Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everybody,

Got this one finished just a couple hours behind schedule. I'm very curious to see what you all think of these criticisms and if they align with yours. But also, what have I missed? Let me know in the comments to this post.

On with Ringo!

E.

Files

Elliot's least favourite qualities of each Beatle

Chapters 0:00 - Intro 1:33 - Beatles Anthology announcement 2:54 - Disclaimer 4:38 - John Lennon 11:05 - Paul McCartney 17:07 - George Harrison 25:38 - Ringo Starr 30:22 - Channel Update

Comments

James Markin

My first bonus after join woohoo. Really rocking that Christian Bale look friendo lol

Angie

i need to know what products u use for your hair

Jaymcgray

This is such a good video idea

Ryley Taylor

Very good points on Paul. I've always thought something to be off about his modern persona in public appearances. But could never put into as good of words as this. Very nice. Id love to get some more ernestness and new stories from him. But he's the PR king lol

Scott Whiting

I love George to death, but his take on Elton John’s music was just not it. He described it as formulaic and made with, I’m not even kidding, four chords. There’s a lot of ways to describe Elton’s music, but four chords ain’t one of them. He has a lot of interesting chord progressions in his biggest hits. To me, it doesn’t just ring as narrow-minded, but just…wrong. Again, I love George and his music, but that won’t prevent me from seeing his imperfections and taking issue with him as a person. Of course, he became acquainted with the Rocket Man later in life, so it’s not all bad, but I find that quote so fascinating

ovidiomedes

paul being a fake bitch is one of my favorite things about him 😭 it’s so funnily endearing but i can absolutelyyyy see why it would piss people in his periphery off. like as a fan of him im endeared by it but if he’s someone you know and talk to on a regular basis im not at all surprised that people would find it off putting

Kathryn Coffey

In terms of what I don't like about each Beatle, I can't add anything that you hadn't said already. If anything, Paul doesn't drop enough F-bombs (then again, if he did drop lots of F-bombs, it might get old after a while). But when talking about "George's favorites (guitars, ukes, and F1)," I can't believe you forgot about the gardening. In all seriousness, if Bob Dylan told George Harrison to jump, the latter would ask how high, but I don't see that as a big issue. I can be like that, too. I once got into Arkells just to impress a guy I liked, and that opened up a new world for me. While I see merit in some modern music, I still have my favorites. I like guitars, ukes, and especially F1, too. Besides, there are worse ideas/materials that could've been listed as George's favorite things he wouldn't shut up about. (Now, I might be a George apologist here, but that quote about Bowie, though, major yikes!)

Gen's Portfolio

Great idea for a video and I agree with all of the things you brought up, though I wish you had taken the time to mention the infidelities of all four of them. They were all known to cheat on their women, especially George. One additional quality of Paul that I’m iffy on is his handling of his relationship with Jane. I don’t like the idea of him whining about her not wanting to put her career on hold to be a housewife for him (I’m probably over-simplifying it), but admittedly we got some really good songs out of it.

Gen's Portfolio

Just watched the last couple minutes of the video, I see that you mentioned that, I’ll redact that part of my comment 😅

Jaymcgray

I completely adore your take on Paul. Paul is one of my favorite people to ever live, and is easily my favorite Beatle.

Peter C

Paul is my absolute favorite Beatle and favorite musician. That being said, I don’t want to say I *hate* it but it’s super interesting how Paul will lie about stuff (like in the lyrics about when he was with Jane/Linda) when we all know he’s lying. Like you said, King of PR. With the cheating, yeah, and also how he was very controlling with Linda and how he still believed in that Women should have certain roles. If Linda wanted to do something, he had to be there for it. I’m a bit surprised Paul’s coldness wasn’t mentioned more. I think with their Beatlemania Hard Day’s Night personas, people still to this day perceive Paul as the cute sweet beatle. I was reminded of this in Ian Leslie’s ‘McLennon’ book, where he reminds us a few times that Paul could be just as mean as John, they would both shut people out, ‘A LOOK WOULD PASS BETWEEN THEM AND AFTERWARDS IT WAS AS IF YOU DIDN’T EXIST.” Paul not great at communicating his feelings (but with his father and childhood, who can blame him?) People saying Paul could be rather spacey, using Brian’s sexuality to his advantage, Brian saying he’d always get upset more with Paul than anyone, there’s a quote too about john saying he’d send Paul sometimes to do the hard stuff (?) I think especially right now, on Beatles social media (generally Twitter) people can get so mad when you critique them, especially Paul, because people still believe in that John the smart one Paul the cute one etc etc. So interesting those personas still carry so much weight. Paul is either a controlling manipulative dictator or a caring creative genius, but he can’t be both!

Peter C

Such a long rant, but so glad there’s beatles fans out there who can point out their flaws and wrongdoings. ALSO! Post 70s when people would bring up John’s sexuality and insist he was bisexual or gay and Paul each time is very jokey about it, very insistent that John his best friend couldn’t possibly be gay! Not a bad quality, just something super funny to me. I always think it’s hilarious that paul is super open and supportive of everyone but when it comes to his band mates (or even him, but that’s …. Moving on) it’s NO THIS CANT BE!!! Anyway, Great video! So so excited for Ringo, you’ve put so much hard work into it!!!!

Andrew Galvin

It would be good to ask George how a song called Ding Dong Ding Dong gets you closer to God...

amanda siegelson

after revisiting those 80s/90s interviews with ringo - i am even more baffled by the fact that paul used to get railed for dyeing his hair and ringo never gets called on the same. i wish he would let it go - paul has seen that it’s ok to be gray - come on rings! you can too! fantastic video, btw. really enjoyable.

Luke Hall

Great video (as always), agree with all the points raised, in terms of Paul you alluded to it but (here me out here) he is kind of similar to Mike love in the sense that I think Paul as a working class child from Liverpool he knows what it’s like to have not have much money growing up and being tight on money, but that’s a quality despite being a billionaire Paul never lost, (obviously Mike loves reasoning is very different and he went from a middle class family to have nothing but I think both are money conscious despite not needing to be at this point though Paul is obviously a much bigger risk taker than Mike not to mention just an actually likeable person. Unrelated notes: loved you got in a Kennedy Davenport reference into a Beatles video 😂 & you might already be aware but Al Jardine and the pet sounds band (Brian Wilson’s band) are going to Australia at the end of the year and their performing nearly the entire love you album live as well as a version of ding dang with new lyrics by Al. I don’t know if seeing that would interest you but I just thought I’d mention it in case you weren’t aware.

Harvey

my opinions on the beatles are so out of whack compared to my fellow Gen-Zers, George is actually my least favourite Beatle even though he is the most common choice these days, Paul is by far my favourite Beatle both personally and musically and it's funny because a lot of the complaints people have about Paul are exactly what I have about George (mostly hackney'd songwriting outside of Beatles + ATMP, very emotionally cold, a bit arrogant) and i've heard a lot of people mention George's clear love of music as to why they love him but like you pointed out, it was only to genres he deemed important to him, i totally buy it more from Paul who always sounds like he's having a blast recording while by the mid 70s George sounds like he would rather be anywhere else than in a recording studio, i definitely think who a lot of people call "fake" should be switched from Paul to George, but hey that's just my opinion!

Keelan Bellard

I couldn’t agree with your take on John hating the past music he made especially with the Beatles more. It’s soo infuriating to hear something as revolutionary as Strawberry Fields Forever or Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds and John to just say oh no “that’s shit” or “I wish I could redo it”.

Lavender

Love this video - I always think it's really interesting listening to people reckoning with the problematic and uncomfortable aspects of people they admire. Beyond just the infidelity, a big problem I have with all four in their youth was their pervasive misogyny. I understand it was normal for the culture they were in, but it really seemed like they all treated women as total props in their lives and showed very little respect for their partners' own ambitions and wishes and that's always troubled me. Something I really respect about John in his later years is how seriously he took Yoko and her art, even things like him taking her last name were pretty progressive for the time and it's heartening to have undergone that kind of personal growth in his short life.

Davis H

Elliot, you’ve nailed it! I was thinking about my least favourite qualities of all of them and you mentioned literally every single thought I had! I’m very excited for the Ringo video and I am also seeing Oasis on November 4th! Please make sure you get there early to see Ball Park Music as support, they are one of my favourite bands, very 60s and Beatles-esque at times, I recommend their album Weirder & Weirder if you’re interested. Thanks again for another excellent video!

Elliot Roberts

I saw Ball Park Music live in Melbourne in 2016! 😁

Davis H

Oh wow! Had no idea you were a fan!

Þorgeir Tryggvason

Excellent! I think your Paul-Analysis is very good, in that you spot the flaws, although they don't get to you because of the love you feel for the guy. Which is fair enough. The George bit is just perfect. PS: Love the look.

Sam

Even John liked the punk scene and the 80s music because to him it was 50s music with new sounds

Brendan J. Smith

I’m sure John would’ve taken back A LOT of the negative things he said about The Beatles’ music if he had lived longer. As you briefly touched on in the video, nearly all of the negative comments he made were from the early ‘70s when not only was the breakup still fresh, but John was also in his primal scream therapy phase. He was basically lashing out at everyone and everything he’d ever loved. Even throwing uncalled for insults at his heroes like Elvis and kindred spirits like Mick Jagger. By the dawn of the 1980s, John was a much happier man who had defeated his worst characteristics and was ready to dive back into making music and reform broken bonds. The ‘80s would’ve been the happiest decade of John’s life if he had been allowed to live through it.

Zach Antle

Regarding John, I’ve seen some people suggesting he had ADD or autism (as someone with both I can def see it) all the way to borderline personality disorder, and having known several people who do or probably do have it, I can also see it 😅

Rael74

I recently saw this interview excerpt from the early 90s of Ringo naming his favorite contemporary artists, including Nirvana and the Sugarcubes. It stood out precisely for the reason you mentioned that he rarely seems to express interest in other music! https://youtube.com/shorts/cOy1v-uVoXA?si=zFfqXVUe5E5avIqZ

Morgan Smith

Hey so Paul obviously cheated on Jane a lot obviously but I don't think in the lyrics he was actually lying about their not being any significant crossover with Jane and Linda, the date people point to as the day Jane broke up with him was just her announcing the break up. We don't have an exact date but apparently they'd been broken up for months before and just didn't announce it to the press until then.

wroamm

ELLOT I just wanna say YOU LOOK SOOO GOOD with the longer hair and I think your beard suits you, man

Nick Huynh

I say Ringo in interviews was very entertaining (the interview with George for example) but that got watered down. Was that the alcohol withdrawal or he got older?

Lene Fauske

Thank you, Elliot, for another very interesting video! I LOVE your videos on Paul, George and Johns solo career. Like you, Paul is my definitive favourite. And your Paul video is amazing.

Brendan J. Smith

This made me realize how hilarious a “Least Favorite Qualities of Each Beach Boy” video would be!

Mike Griffith

Hey Elliot, this is great. I agree: When it came to women, all 4 of them could be chauvinists if not downright misogynists. FWIW, I always felt that John could be withering, Paul could be pretentious, George could be bitter, and Ringo could be aloof. Thanks for the great analysis.

Byron Davis

As much as I love him, a quality in Paul that always rubs me the wrong way is how much of a condescending jerk he tended to be at times. Especially to George Harrison and you can see it not just in Get Back but in endless interviews where he just talks about him very unseriously, like an ambitious little sibling

Tsukidoki

Thanks for making this video. I really can’t stand fans who over-idolise their favs, putting them on a pedestal as if they’re some divine being, free of flaws. George is my favourite Beatle because I really connect with his pursuit of spirituality and a deeper meaning of life, along with his honesty about the internal struggles he faced between his spiritual purists and his attachments to earthly pleasures. I think it also ties into me being a double Scorpio, with both my Sun and Mercury in Scorpio. My mercury in Scorpio is actually conjunct George’s Moon in Scorpio energy, so I totally get why he can be so black-and-white about certain things. For people with strong Scorpio energy, everything feels like it’s either 0 or 100, with no in-between. We are known for being incredibly consistent and stubborn, sometimes to the point of narrow-mindedness because Scorpio is a fixed sign. But over time, I’ve loosened up a bit and learned to add more balance to my life. Like George, I used to be a big moaner too, but I’ve also learned not to dwell too much on what I hate and instead focus my energy on manifesting the life I want. After all, there’s no point in wasting energy on things or people that drain me. As for George and Paul, I don’t think George held any real grudge against him, especially later in life. I love what he George said in a 2001 Yahoo live chat when asked about their relationship: “We are both pretty damn cute.”

HST

God I am so hyped for the Ringo Ranking

dwq

I pretty agree with everything you said. Two things I do wanna add. 1. Ringo comes off as full of himself. The main example of this at the Concert for George, the two songs he performed were a song from HIS solo career (grant it, one that he and George wrote together) and the Carl Perkins song HE sung on Beatles for Sale. Like... he could've at least sung Everybody's Trying to Be My Baby. 2. Paul controlling nature. Yes, I know you touched upon this and you brought up a good point about how HE seemed to be only one keeping the unit together. But there does get to a point where you can be a bit much. Like, there's a reason why people reference that clip of George being like "FINE I'll play it how ever you want!!"

Teri Olsen

I love George if only for Cosmic Empire, but did he have to be so grumpy? At times he seemed to forget how very fortunate he was. Your hair reminds me of Cal Berkeley in the early 70s! I was there and the look, far out then looks great on you now, Elliot.

Jenny Harris

Great video! I think we hold the Beatles, especially their 60s incarnations, to pretty high standards overall considering how much pressure they were under and how incredibly public almost all aspects of their lives were. I can’t truly blame post-60s George for being grumpy or not enjoying interviews much or even for not bothering getting into newer music (lots of his generation didn’t, as you said) — though I agree it is certainly a contrast with 60s-George’s openmindedness and constant desire for new sounds. One example of the Beatles bringing out the best in each other, arguably. I do think all of them had/have fairly generation-typical attitudes to women generally, in addition to the infidelity/‘free love’ aspects, and George may be the worst culprit here though I haven’t looked into the others enough to call it definitively. Also Derek Taylor has implied that Paul had a bit of a mean streak/didn’t always treat Apple staff very well in the late 60s. Ringo’s awful taste (MS paint art!!) is mainly funny, and I think it’s wrong to say he isn’t intelligent, though he certainly missed a massive amount of education due to illness. Can’t wait for the Ringo video to drop!!

Andriy Griffin

Won’t lie, I was most excited for your Harrison segment. As much as I admire him, he definitely is the most detached from reality then the other three. I think being so young when the Beatles became big did stunt his maturity growth that he tried to catch up to for the rest of his life.

Justin Guadagno

Love the hair & beard combo. Also, definitely a vote for a more thorough Oasis video if you're looking for stuff to do after the Ringo video! Just saw them in NJ & had the time of my life!

Steven

Had "Inside Out" from the Wilburys Vol. 3 album playing earlier (love that song btw) and upon actually dissecting the albums front cover I noticed so awesome for the first time Bob Dylan with his backwards cap on and made that immediate connection as to why, very cool! Assuming also that the still you used at 23:25 is from that same artwork shoot?

Marty

To be fair, the fact that George didn’t like Punk, or hip hop I wouldn’t say it’s a bad quality of him, it’s just taste, he was very open minded about other stuff, he loved reggae and soulful music, and what he said specifically is that why he understood why punk was born and what they were trying to do, he didn’t agree with the way they were going about things, because he was of the mindset that we should fight hate with love, and not with more hate, While also the punk movement wasn’t offering any concrete solutions. And i think it’s perfectly valid just not liking something and be vocal about it if you’re asked. But he also liked some new music, he said he liked Blur and others. So I wouldn’t say he just didn’t like anything.

Marty

He also wasn’t as grumpy as people make him out to be, there’s so many great stories people shared (fans and friends of George) who said how sweet and caring of a guy he was. He was a real person, not a 1 dimensional character, so he’s allowed to be grumpy at times, but that wasn’t all he was at all times, this narrative has been pushed since the dawn of times mostly because of his rbf.

Lisamarie LiGreci-Newton

This was really interesting and it made me realize something about myself, which is that I am probably drawn to the Beatles that share my flaws. Growing up in the 80s/90s, I definitely went through my 'John' phase, but then cooled off on him a bit as I realized he definitely was a bit of a pretentious, snarky ass (and later recognizing some of his horrible actions towards his previous lovers). And yet to this day his music is still the music that resonates the most with me. I've certainly come to realize and appreciate as you have that he was a person aware of his flaws and I do think sincerely trying to atone, and some of my favorite work of his has both a visceral anger and an extremely vulnerable tenderness. But what I realized as I was watching this is that in some ways I'm the same, and that's probably why both John and George appeal to me. I'm not a physically violent person, but despite my own religious/spiritual beliefs, I know I struggle with anger, irritation, snarky comments, rage, etc. It's not a part of myself that I like but I guess I can really relate to John's quote about the dichotomy within himself. And likewise, with George (as a person of faith) I absolutely know that can turn into preachiness, inconsistency/hypocracy or judgmentalness. Even John's comments ragging the Beatles just to me felt really familiar in things I've said about my own past work or accomplishments. But as it pertains to George, yeah, I do roll my eyes a bit at some of his spiritual preaching when he himself did still have a pretty lavish, wordly life (although again, I relate to the struggle) but you make a good point about how he came into all his fame so early. In fact, the way you describe his curmudgeonliness makes me wonder if he was a tad on the spectrum (maybe not in a clinically significant way) because I'm recognizing that trait ALSO reminds me of qualities I see in myself and others I am close to, which is that initial negative first reaction to any new thing, as well as getting REALLY INTO the thing you found, getting obsessed with it, to the point where nothing else is worthy. Like (similarly to Ringo I suppose) sometimes you just like what you like. As for Paul, I'll just say that while it had positive aspects, I do think he could be a bit controlling (and dismissive of others', especially George's) ideas and maybe a bit TOO invested in the Beatles as part of his identity. That's maybe not a 'bad' thing per se - especially as it kept the band together, but just a quality that probably did start to conflict with the others' as they wanted to move on. But I have really come to realize that he DID have a huge appreciation for all forms of music as an art form and branched out creatively in so many ways, and evolved with the times in a way that seemed like genuine joy, not just trying to capitalize on shifting trends.

Jevin

Bob Dylan liking N.W.A is something I needed to hear

Tyler Piper

I just feel like as much as I love his music and some of his ideas, George did not sound like the most fun person in terms of how cranky he was and honestly close-minded about a number of things he tended to be. I appreciate that he is so honest especially in some ways compared to how rehearsed and careful Paul and Ringo tend to be these days (or always for Paul), but he just seemed to really exhibit some typical angry boomer tendencies. I liked this video a lot and thought it was refreshing to see someone who loves the beatles so much be so honest and willing to admit flaws about these four people, as so often when in fandoms where people tend to really have a deep respect and love for an artist, there can be a tendency to put them up in some immaculate pedestal and get defensive whenever flaws get brought up (though I totally know you're not that kind of fan). I think the key is to remember that they are human and have positives and negatives like everyone, even if they're the most famous and beloved musicians we've perhaps ever seen. Great job!

Pork Lumps

What gets me with George is how many people I see online claiming that he was not only on the level of John and Paul, but above them. Don't get me wrong, I get and love his Indian stuff, his psychedelic stuff, his spiritual stuff...but the sourpuss was churning out mediocre tracks like Old Brown Shoe and For You Blue while Paul was crafting Let It Be, I've Got a Feeling, etc. and John was writing Across the Universe and Don't Let Me Down. George was great, but John and Paul were legends.

fitzroy

All four were very sexist in the 60s, I recall a quote of Paul saying he was amazed that a girl tried to get into his house with a ladder because he didn’t think women could climb ladders! I also think he and Lennon were so closely connected musically that they didn’t realise how left out George was feeling. Obviously the sexism was very much of its time, and they definitely improved a lot, but it still astounds me with some of the stuff they were saying.

Star Star

paul can come across as cold, but i think he lowkey just dissociated. like when brian died, when john died, when the beatles broke up ect, i think he just wanted to be a rock for everyone around him so for their and his benefit he'd just put up a front.

Prometheus

The sheer audacity of calling Old Brown Shoe mediocre that’s one of his best songs!

Debra Cope

You’d have to know what their qualities were to begin with. None of them stand out to me as individuals.

Earth's Mightiest Nerds

Year on from this video just wanted to mention one thing. During the start of Apple, Paul could get really nasty to some of the employees. I've wracked my brain as someone who loves and respects McCartney as to why, but nothing seems to come up. What really gets me is something he said to Derek Taylor as quoted in Taylor's book from '71 "Don’t forget, you’re not very good, any of you, you know that, don’t you?" Just not a good moment maybe, the good absolutely outweighs the fleeting moments

TheMr.L01

Love Paul, but I've got a couple criticisms I can share. One is that he was opposed to the idea of him, John, and George having an equal number of songs. This was something John proposed sometime after Abbey Road but before he quit the band, but Paul thought it was "too democratic" and admitted to disliking George's pre-Abbey Road songs. Another is him taking all the royalties for the massive McCartney–Laine single "Mull of Kintyre", only giving Denny Laine a flat fee. I know this one's a bit more business-y, but it's still an unfair move that soured Paul and Denny's relationship.

Elizabeth Salvemini

Oh my God, I thought I was the only one who theorized this!

Ghost Disco

I approve of Ringo's statements. I don't like much music after 1970 either.