Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey folks!

Here's September's bonus video for you all.My usual channel update at the end of the video has been moved to the beginning due to some exciting news regarding an upcoming YouTube video!

Hope you enjoy. It's going to be a fun month ahead!

Elliot

Files

Are legacy acts still worth seeing in 2025?

• Chapters • 0:00 - Intro & Ringo Update 3:16 - Initial Topic Discussion 5:28 - 1. Know who you're seeing 7:25 - 2. Can they still perform? 13:12 - 3. Is this their final tour? 17:13 - 4. The Cost

Comments

Carlo Davies

Man seeing your Patreon videos uploaded somewhere else’s must make you feel really mistrusting, sorry that happened Elliot

Ethan Ng

Great video, love the Al Jardine show mention, seems that the shows are being moved to June at this rate. As someone who didn't get the chance to see Brian live I'm really holding out that these shows still happen 🤞

Jacob Witmer

To your point about "Is this their final tour?" something that honestly made me really reasses how I treated seeing legacy acts in concert was in 2017 when I saw Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers live on their 40th Anniversary Tour. At the time I was in college and was starting to get pretty disinterested in seeing legacy acts in big arena shows in favor of seeing local up and coming bands in smaller club venues which to my mind had such an intimacy and immediacy to them that I found I was having more fun at those kinds of shows than spending hundreds of dollars to go watch a legacy act from a distant seat in an arena (which let's be honest normally amounted to watching the big tv screen behind them rather than the actual band). But Tom Petty was one of my family's favorite artists and I knew that he and the Heartbreakers would be able to pull off a fantastic show so I went to go see him live and genuinely it was one of the best shows I'd ever seen. Every song was a classic (including some personal favorite deep cuts he threw into the set), the band was on fire, Tom's voice was in as pristine a condition as it ever had been, it was the only time where I'd ever seen a legacy act in concert and thought "Man, if he ever rolls back into town I gotta see him again" (and I've seen McCartney, Dylan, the Stones and the Who live on different occasions). And then only a few months later, Tom was dead, and suddenly that gig I'd seen him at was now one of the last performances of his entire career. And from that point on, my attitude has been "If it's someone I'm gonna regret missing the chance to see perform live once they're gone, then I'm gonna try to see them when I can. Because you never know when you'll lose that opportunity forever."

Jack Almoro

I am warning you all with peace & love, no more Elliot leaks!

Jenny Harris

My dad also saw Wings in the 70s and I also think that is extremely cool. And I splurged (a bit more than I reasonably ought to have done) to see Bob Dylan in November because what if he never comes to the UK again?! I’ve never been that fussed to see him live before but for whatever reason this year feels urgent, and I am really excited to drive an hour and a half to Coventry for it. Can’t wait to not recognise any of the songs and generally have a weird time in the same room as Bob Dylan! Also, incredibly excited for the Ringo video.

Keelan Bellard

This is exactly how I envisioned the video when I first suggested the topic so thank you!! As someone who is going to see Bob Dylan in November and seen numerous times online complaints about his voice, stage presence etc, I think your thoughts here have given me some new found appreciation for acts like him. I honestly cannot wait to see him now. One day Macca, one day 🙏

Kinsey Bunch

What's the etiquette on standing vs sitting at these shows? I saw Ringo at an amphitheater this summer and stood basically the whole time because... it's Ringo, but others were mostly seated. I'm guessing Paul will be a slightly different vibe in a huge arena. In my opinion, if I'm watching a Beatle perform, I'm going to be on my feet. However, I am substantially younger than a lot of other concert-goers, so do I look like a dick? Is it just my social anxiety at play? Ahhhhhh

Kendy Parchman

Very funny this topic got chosen when it did, the other week I went to Riot Fest in Chicago, and “the Beach Boys” were playing and had John Stamos of Full House as a part of the band. Decided to check out a bit of their set out of morbid curiosity. While they were playing they were showing a ton of old beach boys footage on the screen from their earlier touring years, and it really hit me then that the band that was on the screen was completely different from the band on stage. Really makes a huge difference when not a single Wilson brother or Al is there. I then promptly left and went to see dropkick Murphys, who were incredible!

Eric Cheung

My wife saw Dave Brubeck 19 years ago and loved it. Yeah, the factors you cite have definitely been in my thoughts. We have definitely been seeing a few shows a year, and sometimes try to mix it up in terms of how old the acts are. Honestly, though, my main period for discovering new music was the aughts, since that was when I was in college, then my stand-up years in Boston, listening to WFNX, then living in Los Angeles, listening to Indie 103.1. We discovered Sparks when Edgar Wright's documentary came out, and we've seen them twice since. Russell's still hitting the high notes, in part because Ronald is uncompromising with his songwriting and insists upon it. It was a great show both times and they're still ridiculously prolific. This week, we're also seeing B-52s and Devo on Thursday and David Byrne on Friday which might be a bit new for your category of legacy bands, but both band have got members that have died and have previously announced farewell tours, so they still fit. I suppose we'll see. David Byrne is still making new music and sounds good. It'll be our second time seeing him (we saw him do American Utopia before it went to Broadway). We're finally SEEING Macca in November, after merely listening to him outside of Fenway in 2009 and 2022. Yeah, his voice isn't what it was, but he's still got insane energy and even standing outside of Fenway, I could see it was still an epic show. Looking at the recently released set list, I was curious if he'd be teasing some of the new material for next year's album, but I don't think that's the case. I do wonder if he'll be playing "Michelle," since he'll be in francophone city Montreal for our particular show. It is cruel what's happening to Frankie Valli. The closest I came to seeing a show like that was when I saw Micky Dolenz and Mike Nesmith, just a month before he died, in Medford, Massachusetts, in October, 2021. But Mike was still quite cogent. He had a stool out there and sat on it the whole show. He left for a couple of songs to cede the stage to Micky, but they still both sang. Neither of them played instruments, though Micky did play timpani on "Randy Scouse Git," which was pretty cool. I actually saw Micky a few years earlier, at a screening of Head. I had him sign my copy of Headquarters. I was wearing Roger McGuinn-style sunglasses and a light-colored blazer, similar to his, so he asked me where I got them. It was fun. I'd go see Micky again, because he's still definitely got it. What's interesting is that maybe this video and your Ringo ranking video might actually make a case for me to go check him out live. I haven't been as interested in seeing him as Paul, but you do make a good point about how he's still got his voice and he's kept on top of his drumming all these years.

Eric Cheung

My thinking is usually if I'm blocking someone then I'll stay seated, but if I'm being blocked by the row in front of me standing, then I'll stand up, too. I guess I'm saying "peer pressure?" I saw Sparks a few weeks ago and this one young woman was standing for most of the show, because she must have been a massive superfan. There were sections of the audience that stood up for much of the second half of the show, to the point where Russell commented on how into it the balcony seemed. No one seemed to mind.

ovidiomedes

what u were saying abt australia is soooo real. i live in mexico and while we do get artists coming here frequently its also not as frequent as it is for people living in the states. paul came in 2023 and i didnt go bc i wasnt as insane abt the beatles as i am now. and its really hard to not feel regretful over it ;_; i would absolutely die to see him live at least once

JackJack_1479

One band for sure I’ll tell someone not to go see is Motley Crüe. I saw them in 2022 they did a huge tour with Joan Jett, Poison, and Def Leppard. Out of all of those bands they were the worst 😭 I couldn’t understand what Vince Neil was singing and he sounded out of breath the entire time.

Jacob Miller

The only legacy acts I’ve seen in concert are Lynyrd Skynyrd and Journey both about over a decade ago. In retrospect, while Journey was a lot of fun and put on a great show even without Steve Perry, Skynyrd had a bit of that “Beach Boys” syndrome. (Real Talk, if you’re gonna listen to Lynyrd Skynyrd, stop after “Street Survivors”) That Said, there are still a bunch of legacy acts I would LOVE to see live. Macca and Ringo, of course. Heart’s always been a bucket list act, as is “Weird Al” Yankovic. And after this video, Al Jardine is on my radar. Yeah, safe to say this video gave me something to chew on.

Jesse Hart

Didn't think I would ever get to see Stevie Wonder live and then did a surprise tour last October. Jumped on that real fast and was probably the best legacy act I've seen. May not have the energetic movement but still has a great voice and feel for any instrument he plays.

Euan Mangan

We’ve had brat summer. Get ready for Ringoween

Davis H

This had me dying 🤣

Davis H

I saw Paul McCartney back in 2023 and still think it’s one of the best shows I’ve been to, not just because of it being Paul I was seeing but also because of the atmosphere. It was such a cool experience and I would give anything to do it again! I’m so hyped to see Oasis on November 4th!

Davis H

The hype for the Ringo video is getting real. This will be the first Elliot ranking that has been released since I became a fan (and patron) so I’m super excited!

Mike Griffith

Great video as always. I used to imagine what would happen when some of my heroes would get too old to rock and roll. I believe it's important to remember that when one gets as old as them, the aging process becomes more rapid. There's a noticable difference in Paul from even 3 years ago. I say see them while you can. I heard that Frankie Valli possibly has a condition that caused some of the muscles in his face to freeze. He can't blink, which must be uncomfortable. I'd love to think that performing keeps him feeling alive. We're all going to get old. There's only one other alternative.

Trey Niño

i’m seeing Paul McCartney live for the first time on October 22nd! As a native Oklahoman i couldn’t believe Paul was coming to my state as Oklahoma is not a popular state by any means 😂 but he’ll be here and I’m going, literally can’t wait! I’m very excited to see the long awaited Ringo video too. October is going to be a good month 😄

JOSHUA

Great video Elliot. If anything this just proves why Paul McCartney is leagues above everyone else with his 3 hour performances. Also I wondered if you'd ever listened to Paolo Nutini? He's quite big in the UK. I recommend Iron sky or Candy as a first listen if your interested. You may like him!

Toupee Reno

Saw Dylan 4 times this year, 12th show overall since 2021 lol. He's just the best. 2 ok shows (mostly the venue/my seats) and 12 unforgettable ones. Most I've paid has been like $110 for really good seats. Have even paid like 65 for really good seats to Dylan. And when he's not doing outlaw shows he's almost exclusively playing in mid-sizes beatiful historic theaters. He could definitely sell bigger spaces but I'm glad he doesn't because they're the PERFECT environment to see him in. Old Dylan is best Dylan.

KathyT

I saw Paul and Wings in Chicago in 1976. I am probably older than your dad. 🙀 I have seen Paul several times since then. He is definitely worth seeing, cracked voice or not!

Kinsey Bunch

Paolo Nutini mention in the year of our lord 2025 was unexpected but delightful

Kathryn Coffey

Ooh, Ringo vid's coming out just in time for my birth month! Also, saw Paul live in 2017 with my family, and that was awesome! Those 3 hours flew by. We're (we being me and my family) seeing him again this November when he's at the United Center. I can hardly wait!

Andrew Doran

"Uncanny Frankie Valli" 😂

Mike Selinker

When I saw Dylan last year in Seattle, he played nearly all of Rough and Rowdy Ways, When I Paint My Masterpiece, and other non-Top 40 songs. The most well known was Gotta Serve Somebody. It was phenomenal. But the couple next to me was grousing the whole way through, saying "We flew all the way up from LA for this?" They came to hoot along to Rainy Day Women. That show was not forthcoming. So, yeah, not only know who you're seeing but who you *want* them to be, and act accordingly.

Marius8767

Wonderful video. I love seeing legacy acts live, though it’s always a bit of a gamble on the artists’ condition. I recently saw Mavis Staples, and at 86 her voice and stage presence are still incredible. The love coming from the audience was genuinely moving. Guitarists like Santana and Sérgio Dias (of Os Mutantes), which I also saw live, still play as brilliantly as ever. As a European, I really understand how precious these legacy acts feel, especially since fewer American artists can afford overseas tours these days. And like you I really enjoy hearing older generations talk about the legends they saw live. I still can’t believe my grandparents got to see Ella Fitzgerald and Oscar Peterson in the 50s.

Eric Cheung

So, I went to see B-52s, Devo, and David Byrne last week. I was going to see Lene Lovich open for B-52s and Devo, but it took too long to get to my seat and she only had a 6 song set. For Devo, the crowd was seated the whole time (though I thought their set was actually better than the B-52s. For the B-52s, the entire audience was on their feet the whole time. Both of these were at an outdoor venue. For David Byrne, he did his own charmingly awkward pre-show announcement. It was at a theatre. The best seats were actually in the balcony, since you could see the immersive projections that spanned the floor and all the walls of the stage (it was an incredible visual, along with the choreographed movements of the entire band--it's amazing what can be done with wireless instruments nowadays). The degree to which people would stand was really dependent on where you were in the audience and which song it was. If it was a big Talking Heads song, then more people stood up. There was one couple that stood in front of Mary Beth and me, so we stood up at least when they did, but the people behind us didn't always stand up as often. So, once, when we were up, and the people behind us weren't up, I apologized to the people behind us, and they said, "It's fine." I think they expect that sometimes people will be standing in front of them.

Kinsey Bunch

That sounds like an incredible show!

Paul McCartney’s real wife

I’m seeing Dylan next month! Got lowest expectations for it and hoping that way it won’t disappoint… but it seems he’s been doing a few more bigger hits recently??? Hopefully…

Paul Knox

Great video. A few comments… I have been told by a few people who know about these things that at the London Olympics no sound checks were possible which may explain Macca’s dodgy vocals. I have seen him three times since and no complaints. I saw the last date of the Beach Boys Reunion Tour. I suspect by that time Mike Love had informed others of his plans to do his own thing again. Without knowing that at the time, i did feel there was some tension between Mike and Brian. It was not a concert i greatly enjoyed. On the other hand, i saw Brian Wilsons band many times and they were always joyous concerts. Give me Brian any day. I last saw Franki Valli in London in 2018. He was still brilliant then .. seven years on not so sure. I think your assessment is right. However, sometimes it will be one last chance to see somebody. I saw James Brown shortly before his death . Not the James Brown of the 60s and 70s but it was still James Brown and I treasure the memory.

Lisamarie LiGreci-Newton

I saw Paul back in 2011 and it was incredible (way better than expected), and a few years ago he came to my town, so I took my kids. He wasn't quite as good that time - could have been partially due to the sound but I could also tell his voice just wasn't as smooth. But honestly, giving my kids the chance to see a live Beatle was important to me (my son is a third generation Beatles fan) and part of it is just being with all the other fans of ALL ages, walks of life, etc. It was a blast to be there and celebrate a catalog spanning over 50 years! I'm not sure if I would see him again if he came here - it was quite expensive...but I also don't know if I could resist the chance! But I agree the stamina of the shows he puts on is amazing.

Lisamarie LiGreci-Newton

Heh - Weird Al is also on my bucket list, I've seen him probably 10 times by now. :) I will say this past concert I just went to was maybe the first where I thought, 'yeah, I can see his age a bit' but he still puts on a wildly energetic show. I am lucky enough to have seen both Paul and Ringo. Sadly never got to see George and one of my other regrets is never getting a chance to see Tom Petty. I also missed Paul Simon when he came to Milwaukee recently, but the logistics would have been a bit tricky for me.

Lisamarie LiGreci-Newton

Oh, I did see Ringo live way back when I was in high school (in 2000, heh)! So at least I've seen two Beatles. I do marginally regret missing Paul Simon when he came to Milwaukee (I'm in WI and not too far from there) - the logistics just wouldn't really have worked out given the timing, but Paul Simon (and Garfunkel) has been crucial to my formative years (and if anything, his songs just feel more poignant as I age) and I would have loved to see him. Maybe I should have prioritized it more but I also kinda told myself that he wouldn't really sound the same anyway...but still...if he comes this way again I will definitely go.

Lisamarie LiGreci-Newton

It's funny you mention Tom Petty because that is definitely one of my 'man, never got to see them' regrets (along with George Harrison). I've seen Paul twice, and the second time I definitely could tell a bit of a decline but...I think if I could afford it I'd probably still go if he came to my town! I mean, it's more than just the performance itself at this point. That said his tickets tend to be pretty expensive, and I HAVE seen him and had an amazing time so I do feel that itch is fairly well scratched. I do actually try to see Weird Al whenever I can, especially as I recognize he probably is also heading towards the end of his touring window (although he recently has said he plans on continuing!)

Jacob Witmer

I used to be friends with someone who once saw Weird Al live and they told me it was one of the most spectacular live shows they’d ever seen considering all the costume changes and things that went along with it. As for Paul, I saw him live during the Out There tour in 2014 and I enjoyed it, but at the same time I felt like my hyper-obsessive fandom with his career actually hampered my enjoyment of the show because nothing he did actually surprised me. It was basically the exact same show you can hear on the Good Evening New York City record (though he did play a little bit of “Yellow Submarine” since it was Ringo’s birthday when I saw him)

Þorgeir Tryggvason

Just got home from a trip to London to see Patti Smith celebrate the 50th anniversary of Horses. It was simply magnificent. The lady in excellent voice, and full of attitude mixed with funny self-deprecation. A room full of rock'n'love.

Silver Birch Bitch

oh god the Frankie Valli footage actually made me sad.

Jason Ardler

I saw McCartney in Sydney in 2017 and assumed that would be his last Australian tour. I saw him twice in 2023 and now assume that will be the last time! If he does come back I will have no hesitation to see him again, even if the set list is getting a bit tired. I was lucky enough to see Ringo in 2013, and can’t imagine him returning to Australia again. Seeing him with Gregg Rolie singing early Santana hits was a bonus. Speaking of, I saw Santana and Doobie Bros together a few years ago. Both were great but DB was such a fun high energy show - definitely exceeded my expectations. I haven’t always been so lucky. I bought tickets to see ELO a while ago not realising that Jeff Lynne wasn’t going to be there and that the majority of the set would be post-Lynne era songs. So yep, it’s important to be sure what you’re buying tickets to before handing over your hard earned…!

Magda A.

I have tickets to go see Paul in none other than COLUMBUS OHIO. Never in my stars would I imagine 1: seeing Paul McCartney in the human flesh and 2: seeing Paul McCartney in Ohio of all places. I guess my only complaint would have to be the price. For example I went to go see Stray Kids (Kpop group) this past June and 2 VIP tickets were $500 each. Yes, expensive but not too bad for Vip Tickets. Grandpa Paul on the other hand....$1,300 EACH! AND MORE IF YOU WANTED TO BUY VIP. All the basic cheaper seats were already sold out and I had no choice but to buy 2 seats near the floor. Don't get me wrong I had the money available, I was going to see Paul no matter what, but $1,300 for a ticket, no matter what the issue is, is way too expensive AND I HAD TO BUY 2 CAUSE IM DRAGGING MY LITTLE SISTER WITH ME. But still I'm super excited to see my Grandpa Paul and I can't wait to see him. Oh if only 9 year old me can see me now

Pork Lumps

I saw Paul in Vegas, and turns out The Beach Boys were also playing there the night before, so I picked up tickets to see them too (a fraction of the cost for nearly front row seats)--even though these artists aren't in their prime, it was still a transcendent experience experiencing tracks like Good Vibrations and Hey Jude live.

Robert Wilkinson

Ive seen mikes band 3 times, they put on a good show and tickets are cheap. Not getting to see Brian Wilson is a great regret of mine

João Belo

I watch Iron Maiden every year Live, they just keep getting better it seems

Grace Marie

I took the risk and bought Brian Wilson tickets in 2022, they were for a local Theatre near me and they were crummy back balcony seats and I figured it would be fun to be in the room regardless of whether or not I would be able to see. When I got to the venue though, they asked me if I’d like to take a seat in the orchestra section (since they didn’t sell that many i guess) and I got 5th row from the stage, which was a stroke of amazing luck. Easily one of the best shows and my least regrettable financial risk in retrospect.