Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello everyone!

Here's the latest YouTube video uploaded exclusively to Patreon a few days early and ad-free.

Would love to hear your opinions on the Beatles Biopics cast and crew! And let me know what you think about my own thoughts on the matter.

As usual, feel free to point out any errors before it's released publicly in a few days, but otherwise, enjoy!

Thanks!

E.

Files

My case for the Beatles Biopics

Get an exclusive 15% discount on Saily data plans! Use code ELLIOTROBERTS at checkout. Download Saily app or go to https://saily.com/elliotroberts Sam Mendes' Beatles Biopics will be released in April 2028 and in the lead up to these four films, I'm going to voice my opinion on the casting, the writers, the cinematographer, and the whole idea around the four-film premise. Here's why I think Harris Dickinson, Paul Mescal, Joseph Quinn, and Barry Keoghan may just live up to the massive challenge that lies ahead of them. Chapters 0:00 - Intro 1:09 - Saily 2:26 - Casting 3:01 - John Lennon/Harris Dickinson 6:15 - Paul McCartney/Paul Mescal 10:52 - George Harrison/Joseph Quinn 14:20 - Ringo Starr/Barry Keoghan 16:44 - Accent & Voice 19:18 - Casting Unknowns 20:29 - De-aging Technology 22:18 - Supporting Cast 25:22 - Writing & Aesthetic 29:20 - The Four-Film Structure Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/elliotroberts Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotroberts Twitter: https://twitter.com/ElliotRoberts5 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliot.roberts Letterboxd: https://letterboxd.com/elliotroberts

Comments

Sarahhh

really enjoyed this! I think these will be well crafted films with a lot of love put into them, but I hope they won’t end up as 4 quite bog standard (read: dull) biopics. I also really agree re: lack of female writers (or producers, or directors or in general…) it’s disappointing though not all too surprising. And YES all the speculation about the films focusing on one era each has driven me crazyyy - it would be so unsatisfying to go into a biopic and not get their whole perspective. I am excited to see what parts they choose to delve more into with each individual (ie Paul & Sgt pepper, George & spiritualism, Ringo packing his beans for the India trip etc etc)

Sarahhh

oo also on the list of ‘people cannot be normal about these biopics’: the lack of common sense about how filming production works (ie “they’re filming ringo’s film first!”) is quite…something

BestDavidBowieSongOf1985?

Great video as always! Very refreshing to see a good take on these biopics, insane how many people have written them off when we know nothing about them other than the people working on them. I am a bit worried about Jack Thorne on the writing team given the Cursed Child's lack of respect or consistency for its source material, but I'm definitely keeping hope that these will be great!

Shea Donlin

Great work Elliot. Happy you made another video commenting on the Beatles biopic. I’m sure we’ll get another the closer we get to release date. Crazy we still have 2 years before the releases. My hope for the films is that the writers stay focused on what made the Beatles.. their ability to create music. Unlike other biopics that focus more on the deterioration of a person/group rather than the music, I’m hoping we great to see their process and spark captured. And I believe this cast can deliver!

Lucas Lieu

The people needed more Elliot talking about Beatles biopics!!!

Jack M.

Really enjoyed this! My biggest hope is that these movies are actually…funny. The Beatles’ humor is a crucial part of their success, and prestige biopics are often kind of humorless.

ovidiomedes

hamnet , aftersun and the iron claw made me want to die. they were so fucking sad and devastating i really got a great glimpse into harris and mescals acting abilities something ive been saying since mescal in particular got casted is that these are, in fact, award winning actors. they are GOOD at what they do and i think that matters a lot more than appearance (though some estrogen for mescal couldnt hurt XD)

steven anderson

Personally when I first saw the killing of a sacred deer I thought Barry keoghan had a certain allure 🤔😉😆. Seriously though, beauty is in the eye of the beholder, there’s gorgeous movie star types that don’t move me that way at all, then you’ll see someone walking down the street or at work and you think about them all day. In fact all of the Beatles stood in contrast the bland good looks of stars on both sides of the pond pre 1963, my friend Neil who died a few years back was 11 when he first saw the Beatles on UK TV in January 1963, and used to say they were his spiritual & sexual awakening, they were amazing BUT crucially looked like lads you might see in the street. Heh, just thought this all needed a gay perspective, you’re welcome 😉😂

steven anderson

Btw Elliot, check out James Norton in the sensational UK 3 season drama Happy Valley, don’t know where it would be available in your neck of woods but it was an astonishingly good drama series set in northern England and Norton plays a truly reprehensible character and is scary as all hell. How that’ll translate into George Martin who knows but he’s a superb actor with I’m sure à no doubt fabulous range.

Elliot Roberts

James Norton’s playing Brian! I think that’s probably what you meant, and thanks for the tip!

steven anderson

Oh yeah, I did! My right thumb often works faster than my brain sadly. Bless him, Brian deserved so much more than Midas man. A film not good enough to be worth watching and not spectacularly awful enough to be a camp classic. It’s just… boring. And George’s wig, holy shit, I’m speechless.

Mason Peery

Thankyou Elliot for helping restore some faith in the Beatles community for these movies☮️✌️

DeniRose

I don't care about how they look but I really hope the script is good enough for them to really get the personalities right and tell a good story. Fingers crossed. Thanks Elliot ... love your work.

Þorgeir Tryggvason

That Barry Keoghan performance in Sacred Deer made my an instant fan.

Lisamarie LiGreci-Newton

The Eternals is hardly what I would call a standout movie, but Barry Keoghan had a (small-ish) role and let me tell you - something about him just captivated me and it's the thing I remember the most from that movie. I have yet to actually see any of his other movies (even though I want to) but he definitely has an energy and I'm excited to see what he brings to it. I didn't realize Joseph Quinn was getting hate. I primarily know him from Stranger Things (I was very much an Eddie fan) and if anything, we at least know he CAN play a younger character. So I don't have too much concern over that.

Allison

Excellent video! I'm excited- I loved Joseph Quinn in Stranger Things.

Todd Costa Rica

I have seen Harry Lloyd (who'll be George Martin) in a Doctor Who two-part episode Human Nature and the Family of Blood (great episodes btw). Speaking of Doctor Who, Arthur Darvill (Derek Taylor) played one of the Doctor's companions Rory Williams. As for the movies itself, I'm really looking forward to seeing them and I'm also a little bit nervous myself. But I'm sure it'll hopefully be great.

maddie daniel

erik singer cameooo. also had no idea jack thorne wrote some early skins that's actually so reassuring