Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey all!

Here's the bonus video for April. I retitled it slightly from the topic suggestion but I think you'll dig this. It's my hypothesis for the next album the Beatles created together if they never broke up.

Would love to hear your thoughts behind my rationale and eventual tracklist/sequencing.And feel free to include your own in the comments!

Thanks for another month of support.

E.

Files

Let's make a 1971 Beatles album

Chapters 0:00 - Intro 1:00 - The Black Album 2:38 - Hypothesis Structure 3:53 - "The Beatles" in 1970 8:27 - The Beatles regroup in 1971 9:37 - Shortlist of Songs 16:54 - Meet The Beatles... Again 20:24 - Sequencing 22:53 - Conclusion

Comments

James Markin

Well I got something fun to watch when cooking spaghetti tonight.

adrifatw

i was watching old patreon posts and this popped up; i had a feeling lol

Ryley Taylor

Aaannndd...putting everything down and casting this to the TV

Maxwell Dziabis

Yay, I suggested this one at some point! Can’t wait to watch this one later

Andrew Kuder

I actually came up with my own tracklist a while back, though it doesn't account for the maximum length of a vinyl disc: 1. Imagine 2. My Sweet Lord 3. Another Day 4. Isolation 5. It Don’t Come Easy 6. Maybe I'm Amazed 7. Mother 8. Isn't It A Pity 9. Gimme Some Truth 10. What Is Life 11. Junk 12. Jealous Guy 13. Art of Dying 14. Teddy Boy 15. All Things Must Pass 16. The Back Seat of My Car

Phil Pagett

Posting this before I watch so I’m not influenced, but here’s mine: SIDE ONE: 1. Too Many People 2. Instant Karma 3. Wah Wah 4. Jealous Guy 5. Uncle Albert 6. All Things Must Pass 7. Photograph SIDE TWO 1. Mother 2. My Sweet Lord 3. Eat at Home 4. Monkberry Moon Delight 5. What is Life 6. How? 7. Maybe I’m Amazed

ovidiomedes

really fun video! the concept of photograph being the lead single is soo cute just imagining that alternate universe is putting a grin on my face

Jacob Witmer

WARNING LONG READ This was a fun video! I think your rationales were very well thought-out and the sequencing was pretty sturdy. Personally, I've always thought it kinda telling that even though people make such a big deal on how much the Beatles' career paths diverged once they split, they all kept playing together on each other's records throughout the early '70s (with the exception of Paul who waited until the '80s to invite Ringo onto one of his albums). In actuality, putting together these hypothetical post-1970 Beatles albums has been a hobby I've been working and reworking since I was a teenager in the early 2010s. By this point, I've made so many of them I've basically put together an entire parallel timeline which brings us right up to the present day (the '90s record they make with Jeff Lynne featuring songs from Flaming Pie, Brainwashed, Vertical Man and the Anthology reunion singles is always a fun listen). But the one that I always struggled with the most was the 1970/71 album. Mainly because for the longest time I was trying to make a single album that would've attempted to blend the bare-bones McCartney and Plastic Ono Band albums with the Wall of Sound grandeur of All Things Must Pass and also trying to shoehorn Ringo in there somewhere as well. The songs never flowed quite right and there'd be too much good stuff left on the cutting room floor. So instead, what I decided to do after Get Back came out in 2021 was I chose A.) To forgo trying to make it a single album since Get Back made it clear John, Paul and George all had stockpiled enough songs in January 1969 to last them the next three years; and B.) Tried to draw upon material which was all recorded around the same general timeframe of Mid 1970-Early 1971 which in Paul's case meant pivoting away from McCartney and pushing more toward Ram as a kind of bridge between George's lushly produced songs and John's raw minimalist songs. In the hypothetical timeline I've constructed here, the group comes near to breaking up at the end of 1969, but more concentrated and sympathetic discussions lead to John and Paul deciding that whilst they may like to keep Klein and the Eastmans on as their own respective personal lawyers, putting either party in charge of the Beatles' contracts is driving too deep a wedge between them and so both parties are pushed aside. Through Ringo's friendship with Peter Sellers, Dennis O'Brien is brought in to help get Apple's finances back together and help remove the strain being put on the band's relationships due to their worries about the business (the band will later sour on O'Brien as well though this will not occur until the '80s). It's around this same time that the Let It Be film comes out, and the four Beatles confronted with documentary footage of themselves in the midst of a creatively frustrating time realize that before they begin work on their next project they first have to address the pressures they've been putting on each other for the past two years. It's at this point when John and Yoko happen upon Primal Scream Therapy and offer it up as a suggestion that might help the Beatles work out the tensions between each other, a la George's attempts at getting the band into Meditation with the trip to Rishikesh back in 1968. The other three hesitantly agree initially, though they peace out of Janov's center in L.A. even quicker than they did Maharishi's retreat in India, leaving John and Yoko on their own to work out their inner demons. Paul goes off to Scotland where he'll record the first McCartney album and start gathering material for the next Beatles album. George devotes himself even further to his spirituality and will produce albums for The Radna Krishna Temple, Doris Troy, Billy Preston, and even puts out another experimental album of he and Eric Clapton jamming together with a bunch of rounded up backing musicians called Apple Jam. Ringo spends his downtime much like he already does in 1970, trying to get his acting career off the ground, starting his furniture company with Robin Cruikshank, and putting out two solo albums of his own Sentimental Journey and Beaucoups of Blues. Thus, by the time John and Yoko return to England in September 1970, the four members have had enough time away from concentrated Beatles activity to come back into the fold fresh and renewed. But this time apart has also done interesting things to their creative output. As John, Paul, George (and even Ringo) begin trading off songs to each other, it becomes increasingly clear to all four of them that they've all written their new material about what's happened to their relationships with each other over the past two years, and how distant that's left each of them feeling from each other. Instead of having their group therapy sessions behind closed doors, they've poured all of it into the songs. Their fears, their resentments, their anger, but also their love, their hopes, and their aspirations for their futures together and apart. It may not have come easy, but perhaps these acknowledgements of the difficulties life throws at you are what might be called for as the flower power dreams of the '60s appear to be over. Over the course of the next six months they begin a marathon of recording sessions at EMI Studio Two for what will end up being their final recording sessions as a quartet within that space. George Martin is not brought back into the fold as he has little interest in the new material the band have written, and the band members themselves are looking to make a break from the sound of previous albums like Sgt. Pepper and Abbey Road (though he does end up providing orchestral arrangements on a handful of songs). Instead, at the insistence of John and George, Phil Spector is brought in to help produce the sessions, though he largely ends up having his role reduced to simply voicing his opinions on what might be the best songs to include on the album as he ends up being absent from most of the sessions (largely due to his frequent artistic disagreements with Paul). However, by February of 1971 the band have recorded enough strong material to comprise what ends up becoming the first triple album by a single act in pop music (the only other triple album preceding it being the soundtrack to Woodstock). And as a sign of George's new status as a songwriting equal on par with Lennon and McCartney, this also becomes the first Beatles album named after a Harrison composition: All Things Must Pass. The final tracklisting goes as follows: Side 1 [24 Minutes]: 1. Mother (the opening funeral bells immediately telling us this is a complete 180 from Abbey Road) 2. My Sweet Lord (selected by Phil Spector as the most commercial song on the album) 3. It Don't Come Easy (Ringo's strongest songwriting contribution to the band so far) 4. Ram On (Paul's opening statement encapsulating the ethos of his songs on the album) 5. Working Class Hero (John's indictment of the class system) 6. I'd Have You Anytime (George's calming and welcoming riposte to John's seething anger) 7. Hold On (John allows himself a moment to take a breath and relax) Side 2 [24 Minutes]: 1. Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey (Paul's mini-suite masterwork, a callback to the medley on Abbey Road) 2. What Is Life (George's jubilant song of love) 3. Another Day (Another pop classic from Paul) 4. Love (John's hushed vulnerable affirmation of the themes of Paul and George's songs) 5. Monkberry Moon Delight (Whacky Macca Madness) 6. Heart of the Country (A tribute to the place where Paul has found his happiness during these times of trouble) Side 3 [22 Minutes]: 1. Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp (Let It Roll) [Carrying on from Paul's ode to the countryside, George follows in turn with his own song about his home and his garden] 2. Early 1970 (Ringo reflects on the hard times the Beatles have just went through) 3. I Found Out (Spurred on by Ringo's laments, John claps back by ruminating over the bitterness he has towards the fans, his parents and the other band members) 4. Too Many People (In response, Paul claps back at John for acting like he has all the answers whilst slinging daggers at everyone else from his high horse) 5. Wah-Wah (Being put out by John and Paul's petty bickering, George claps back at the pair of them for letting their egos run away with each other and never bothering to acknowledge the hurt feelings that get left behind in their wake) 6. Isolation (Taken aback by George's angry outburst, John concedes that he's flawed and maybe isn't cut out to be the leader he wants to be.) Side 4 [23 Minutes]: 1. Power to the People (Having now admitted that the Beatles are flawed leaders, John encourages the audience to lead themselves) 2. If Not for You (With another argument having been abated, George takes the time to pay tribute to Bob Dylan) 3. Eat at Home (Paul moves on from that with this ode to breakfast and lovin' in bed) 4. Look at Me (Now feeling regretful about his earlier outburst, John begins questioning his own identity and sense of self) 5. Behind That Locked Door (Not wanting the bitterness to go on, George offers up this encouraging ode of companionship) 6. Smile Away (Meanwhile, Paul decides to just let loose on this heavy blues number) 7. Run of the Mill (Though wanting to move on, George reflects on if this constant up/down cycle is what the Beatles' friendships have ultimately amounted to and questions how things have now reached this point) Side 5 [23 Minutes]: 1. Remember (In answer to George's questions, John picks at the roots of the systemic abuses which would've formed the Beatles' earliest ways of looking at the world) 2. Beware of Darkness (In agreement with John's sentiments, George warns the listener of the evil forces out there which seek to impede one's personal and spiritual growth) 3. 3 Legs (Put off by George and John's austerity, Paul undercuts the moment by taking some jabs at the moments he felt let down by the other three Beatles) 4. Awaiting On You All (Ignoring Paul's comments, George offers up the suggestion that higher faith in God is the true answer to their problems) 5. Dear Boy (Having heard this lecture before, Paul takes the stance that the other Beatles need to better appreciate the things that they already have) 6. Isn't It a Pity [Version One] (Thinking that this all might be a lost cause, George offers this melancholic rumination on mankind's frequent habit of causing each other pain) Side 6 [25 Minutes]: 1. Apple Scruffs (Towards the tail end of the record, George takes a moment to let the fans know that they truly are appreciated) 2. Well Well Well (Meanwhile, John turns his attention to the one earthly thing bringing him pleasure through all of this: his lust for Yoko) 3. Loser's Lounge (Unable to come up with a proper solution which will make everybody happy, Ringo instead offers up this ditty about downbeat people just looking for ways to stay resilient) 4. Ram On (Reprise) [A circling back moment to the beginning of the record and Paul's determination to keep ramming on) 5. The Back Seat of My Car (Ultimately, the only resolution Paul can come up with is running off with your sweetheart and consummating your love with you're teenagers all over again) 6. God (However, before the record ends John chooses to rip away all the veils and disavow himself of all the false idols and false promises which ultimately amount to nothing, including the Beatles within that list) 7. All Things Must Pass (Which leaves George to offer up the final words of comfort and solace to the listener, assuring them that even in these moments when it seems like nothing really matters and all hope is lost, "It's not always going to be this grey; All Things Must Pass away") At least, that for me is what ended up being MY 1971 Beatles album. Of all the post-1970 hypothetical Beatles albums I've made, this one is the one which I'd dare to say is strong enough to be held up there with any of the proper Beatles classic albums from the late '60s. But that's just one person's interpretation. Sorry for the long read, really liked the video!

BestDavidBowieSongOf1985?

I like how you mostly included tracks they would actually choose rather than just the best songs from their solo careers. Also love the idea of Ringo's song being the lead single! P.S. I took your advice from the Man On The Run video and made the cartoon of Paul smoking weed my PFP!

Sam Alcumbrac

I think there comes a time for every Beatles fan where they put some of the solo tracks together but I’ve honestly never gone as deep into logical choices as this. It sounds like a good playlist, I’ll have to listen to it later!!

Яна Уладыка

Actually, Gimme Some Truth is almost 'another Lennon-McCartney song' - as far as we can see from the Get Back footage. So, fair enough to include! (As well as On the Road to Marrakesh, aka Jealous Guy and the Back Seat of My Car). All Things Must Pass lyrics also include a contribution from John - but I can see why it rather be a solo release than not. P.S. Thanks for another profound video, it's always a pleasure to watch! And I wish a great time in Japan to you and your partner - the idea sounds fab! As a devoted follower I'm really glad to know you have all the resources - time, money, good spirits - to afford this trip! Hugs from Eastern Europe!:)

Elliot Roberts

I have noticed and I greatly appreciate it! Looks good on you!

Eric Cheung

The coda at the end of the Ringo showed the albums Imagine, McCartney II, George Harrison, and Ringo's Rotogravure arranged in one big square, a bit like the Let it Be cover, so I kind of guessed that 2027 video might be something like this one. I kind of knew pretty soon after that it wouldn't be that, but it's cool that we got this one! I'm listening to the playlist now (I've added the tracks that didn't make the final cut as bonus tracks, as if I'm listening to like a 55th Anniversary Remastered release or something. Fun!

Bec Tries

Have an amazing time in Japan! September to December is such a great time to go as well. If you find yourself in Koenji, definitely check out a vinyl store called Be-In Records. It was amazing...and I may have dropped about $300 AUD on Beatles and solo records >_>

Beatles Fan

You should read the lost album of the Beatles by Daniel Rachel it’s a brilliant book

DeniRose

If you head to Hiroshima during your next adventure, here is an okay cafe (foodwise) but great for the amount of Beatles stuff from 1964 onwards. The owner is a huge fan and has a great collection. Definitely worth a visit. It even has a smoking room !?! https://maps.app.goo.gl/dQoGAKzJ9L2Rn1we6

wallaceprower

Really interesting thought exercise! Would love a playlist for this line up but regardless such a fun watch. Excited to hear about your 3 month trip in japan, maybe instead of a Bonus Patreon video, you could do a little vlog one month?

Edward Rhodes

Great stuff, Elliott. I did this myself a while ago and my album - titled Isolation - would have the following tracklist: Instant Karma! (We All Shine On) Smile Away All Things Must Pass Uncle Albert / Admiral Halsey Back Off Boogaloo Gimme Some Truth Let It Down Love It Don’t Come Easy The Back Seat Of My Car My Sweet Lord Isolation Wah-Wah Maybe I’m Amazed Unlike you, I didn’t really take into consideration the fact that they may have released solo albums/singles in between Let It Be and this hypothetical album, so it’s slightly inaccurate when you look at it like that, but I still think it’s got a cohesive sound.

Matt Tregortha

Great song selection! Your Japan trip sounds amazing. Super jealous - I really wanna go back! Amazing vid as always 👍

Cate Allison

What a joy to watch! If only this happened... Thanks so much!

Andrew Kuder

UPDATE: After watching your video, I made another tracklist as a double album SIDE 1: 1. Mother 2. My Sweet Lord 3. Another Day 4. Photograph 5. Isn't It A Pity SIDE 2: 6. It Don't Come Easy 7. Maybe I'm Amazed 8. Jealous Guy 9. Apple Scruffs 10. Gimme Some Truth 11. Junk 12. Art of Dying SIDE 3: 13. Imagine 14. Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey 15. Mind Games 16. Every Night SIDE 4: 17. What Is Life 18. Teddy Boy 19. Love 20. All Things Must Pass 21. The Back Seat of My Car

noremac

YES i can finally share my own beatles album with the world. in my version of the timeline, they wouldn’t put out an album until 1973 when their legal stuff was settling down (also they had a ton of songs collected that were unable to be released on solo projects because of aforementioned legal stuff). so here is my track listing for Photograph (1973): Side A 1. My Sweet Lord 2. Crippled Inside (raw mix) 3. Photograph 4. Every Night 5. Isn’t It a Pity (Version 2) 6. Maybe I’m Amazed Side B 1. Give Me Love 2. Single Pigeon 3. Oh My Love (raw mix) 4. Smile Away 5. Gimme Some Truth 6. You and Me (Babe) it took me a couple years to get that track listing figured out, i also have a potential album from 2006 but that’s getting in the weeds a bit

Luke Collins

Here is my attempt at the album using the songs you chose but in a different order: 1. Love (A sentiment reflected on in many Beatles songs and a vulnerable way to start off the album) 2. Give Me Love, Give Me Peace On Earth (Reiterating the message of the previous song but also injecting spiritual elements into it) 3. Maybe I'm Amazed (Paul's introduction to the album is raw, honest, grandiose and about a love that is found in darkness) 4. Apple Scruffs (Coming down from the theme slightly to thank the fans) 5. Smile Away (A delightful 50s rocker) 6. Gimme Some Truth (An embellishing critique of contemporary politics allowing for Lennon to let out some raw honesty on a Beatles album) 7. Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey (An epic to close disc 1 and the hand across the water part would be great to lead onto the next disc similar to I Want You She's So Heavy) Side Two 8. Photograph (Ringo introducing the next side and showing his flourishing songwriting with a spectacle which all of the Fab Four contribute to) 9. Jealous Guy (Ringo's delight has allowed John to come out of his shell and be vulnerable and admit his failings) 10. What Is Life (More upbeat than the previous song but also questioning aspects of living with self-analysis and the ultimate philosophical meandering by George) 11. Awaiting On You All (George further touches on his spirituality as his last song even if it may question John's Give Peace A Chance) 12. Long Haired Lady (Paul nod to Linda and an expression of the greatness of true love with maybe John singing Linda's parts) 13. Mind Games (I know I'm closing on an album opener but John's Mind Games answers the questions this album has posed by stating 'love is the answer, yes is the answer', a great way I believe to close this hypothetical album)

VirtuaColin

I have a playlist of an imaginary Beatles reunion album that would’ve released around 1980 or ‘81 that I titled “Starting Over.” The track list goes as follows: Side 1 - (Just Like) Starting Over, Coming Up, Blood From a Clone, Private Property, Darkroom, I’m Losing You, Unconsciousness Rules, Watching the Wheels. Side 2 - I’m Stepping Out, Bogey Music, Wrack my Brain, Temporary Secretary, Woman, Save the World, One of These Days, and finally Beautiful Boy (Darling Boy).

steven anderson

I’m going to come up with a banging scenario here I think but mostly I’m trying to get baby don’t run away in there 😆

Lisamarie LiGreci-Newton

Wow, this was a fun experiment. And yet I can't help but think, "But this means we never get Too Many People/How Do You Sleep!" Like, what do those songs even mean in a non-post-Beatles breakup world? This is actually a really fun subject for me because several years ago - I am pretty sure it was around 2018 because I specifically remember studying for my Javascript certification at work while listening - I stumbled on a YouTube playlist that was called 'the black album' (it was NOT the Boyhood one) that was basically this concept - a post 70s Beatles album that was a bunch of their solo tracks from the early 70s. I really had only listened to John's first two albums and new a few of Paul/George's hits (or the Anthology demos) but it was a huge introduction for me to a bunch of great songs and part of what got me more interested in the first place. One day it disappeared/got content claimed and I'm still so sad I could never find it again as I really want to recreate that playlist. If I recall it started with Give Me Love and then I think Instant Karma was the next song. I have a lot of memories listening to at work while going through a career change so it's kind of a formative thing for me. :) And some of the songs saw me through some rough times as well. I do really appreciate that you tried to also pick songs that would thematically fit together and fit a general album concept, not just 'these are the big hits/my favorite songs from these albums'. I totally agree Imagine would have been John/Yoko's thing, and also agree Plastic Ono Band (probably my favorite solo Beatles album, or at least the one that is most formative for me) would have been released as John's catharsis mostly untouched. I was actually thinking Uncle Albert would be the closer as it's got that 'Day in the Life' feel to it to me but I definitely see how Back Seat of My Car makes a great conclusion. But of course the real dream is...what NEW music would they have made together? I'm sure some of those songs would have been polished in the context of the group, but then they would have done some new stuff too. Of course that also means we would have lost some great music. Speaking of, I'm pretty pumped for both Paul and Ringo's new releases and it's actually been a really fun experience going through the album leadup after having watched the deep dives because I have a whole new context/appreciation for where there work has been (I actually kind of love this the most for Ringo as it seems like he's found a good lane). You will definitely have to add where they come into your rankings!!!!

steven anderson

The Great Retcon… Communication thaws throughout 72-73; following meetings before Christmas 1973, the now Klein less fabs convene to discuss possible project in 1974; to McCartney’s surprise, Lennon – aware that Yoko is going to be doing her own projects in the following year – is keen to find a way for them to connect live again, something George following the Bangladesh concert is convinced they can now do – everyone is energised about the idea of doing the post 66 material never performed live – March/April is a planned residency at Earls Court in London, whilst June/July will see them decamp to New York for concluding shows at Madison Square in New York – these high energy performances are a roaring success, sets generally closing with an explosive Hey Jude, the wild card encore can be anything from John & Paul sharing a mic on Baby’s in Black to an almost proto punk reading of It Won’t Be Long – come the autumn all 4 Beatles decide to start recording new material at Abbey Road… Alt time line discography… JL: Plastic Ono Band – Imagine – Some Time in New York City PM: McCartney – Ram – Wild Life – Red Rose Speedway – McCartney tours Europe throughout 73 & hence no other full album, though the ambitious Band on the Run & Jet tracks are released as stand alone 45 singles (album tracks other than LMRI used b sides etc) GH: All Things Must Pass – Living in the Material World RS: Beaucoups of Blues – Ringo The album… Beatles 75 Side one: 01) Steel & Glass (George on a more vicious bottleneck guitar, Macca on high harmony and answer/call on certain lines) 02) Helen Wheels (John on lead electric) 03) Meat City (John & Paul adlibbing over the end) 04) Not Guilty (John on electric piano, Macca providing a signature smoky bass groove) 05) Out the Blue (Macca on lead piano) 06) Letting Go (John & Paul trading licks on electric, George providing both sultry lead solo and idea for full soul brass arrangement, all 3 providing harmonies) 07) Woman Don’t You Cry for Me (George’s Innervisions inspired funk tune with Macca providing clavinet & high harmony, Lennon on organ) Side two: 08) 9 Dream (George on signature bottleneck, Macca providing accompanying harmonies & electric piano) 09) Let Me Roll It (George on organ, Paul & John twin playing the main circular riff) 10) Junior’s Farm (John on lead electric & chorus backing vocals) 11) It Don’t Come Easy (Macca on piano, George on guitar, John on bass) 12) Bring on the Lucie (Paul & George on BV’s, George on dobro) 13) Warm & Beautiful (George on backing guitar) 14) Circles (phased BV’s from John & Paul, at the end you hear the opening acoustic strum of Steel & Glass, suggesting the album is on a continuous loop, emphasising the theme) I need a lie down…

Mike S

Bro, as someone who studies Japanese and was beyond overjoyed to spend two weeks in Japan, I am BEYOND JEALOUS of getting to live there for THREE MONTHS!! Have a ton of a fun!

Mortimer Q. Forbush

I'll never not be impressed with how thoughtful Elliot's analysis is on the Beatles. Combining solo tracks onto playlists and/or "albums" is an exercise LOTS of Beatles fans do, and I have long been curious about Elliot's take on the matter and am so happy to hear his process. I've gone through this process myself, focusing instead on compiling playlists based on unifying themes that I hoped would unify the songs from four increasingly divergent careers. Complete with custom artwork, I call this series John Paul Ringo: Fabricated and if anyone is curious, you can see and hear them at https://johnpaulgeorgeringo-fabricated.com/fabrications

Mortimer Q. Forbush

Question to Elliot: what is the non-album B-side to Photograph? ;-)

Archy

Hi Elliot great video. I was just wondering if you have any Beatles book recommendations ?

Patrick Wilson

Hi Elliot, I'm excited for you on your Japan trip! I recall you've mentioned on multiple times Japanese musicians like YMO and Hosono. I've dabbled a little bit with some 60s - 80s Japanese artists, but was hoping to get more into the genre. I was wondering if you had any artist/album recommendations? Thank ya!!!

Kathryn Coffey

I love the timeline you made! It's plausible, and the hypothetical of the other three insisting on making Ringo's "Photograph" the lead single is just...chef's kiss! All the same, I'm also kind of glad things played out the way they did. There's so much great solo material that came from such a somewhat turbulent time. As for my own playlist, I still need to stew on it a little and may share it via Discord later. PS, I have never been to Japan, so I'm both envious and glad you're going to stay there for three months!

Byron Davis

Not sure anybody else is asking for it but a short something about Ringo’s latest on the Patreon would be a nice vid ! Exciting to hear about the trip and I hope you both have a great time :)

LAUGHING CLOWN Ltd

With the recent release of “Home to Us” just dropping, an excellent Idea for a short Pateron exclusive video could be to do a break-down of every Start/McCartney colaboration through the ideas from Six ‘Clock through Anthology to Beautiful Night & Really love you, going into La de, da, walk with me, Grow old with me, Now & Then, Feeling the sunlight & now This! On top of the occasional live stage performances as recent as last year! Could touch on how it was when the other band member were alive or how they write and perform in the context of eachother as solo Artists and could really get into the root of there friendship as the two surviving Beatles with a great respect for legacy La De Da! Elliot! You could even do a ranking of them! Just an idea!

Jack Almoro

Late to this one (realized I hadn’t consumed my monthly Elliot Roberts Patreon video) BUT another great video! I made my own Beatles ‘71 album in 2023 that was very All Things Must Pass centric. It was my George era and so this was a very pro-George album but I did do a 4/4/4/2 split. I think mine was largely similar to yours: Gimme Some Truth What Is Life Another Day My Sweet Lord Jealous Guy Maybe I’m Amazed It Don’t Come Easy Dear Boy Imagine Isn’t It A Pity Give Peace A Chance Photograph The Backseat of My Car All Things Must Pass I guess my background here would be that they don’t go off and do their own albums first so I think I wanted to capture a sense of division. One song I will champion for as a Beatles song is Dear Boy; the boys would do an amazing job in those harmonies (although I adore Paul & Linda on the actual). Anyways, thanks again Elliot, excited for you and your Japan trip!

Cassy Turner

Have you watched any of Fathom on YouTube? She has a very similar video hypothesizing a 1971 Beatles album and it’s very good! I just watched it recently and it’s cool to see the differences in opinion

Davis H

Man one day Elliot’s Dream Setlist for each beatle in a solo setting will win and I cannot wait till the day it does

Jo

Anyone make a playlist from Elliot’s album?

Jonas Arumainayagam

McCartney look so much like Andor on that back cover of McCartney 😭😭😭

Livia

First video ever that I watch here, yay let's go! BTW the doggo 🤩❤️

JorgeFT

Really cool experiment on a “what-if” scenario. I think we all would’ve wanted the Beatles to have had that one more go together in making an LP post-1969. Even then, it’s cool to see them grow up together and then continue that growth even after they broke up. Also, have a fun time living in Japan for a few months! That should be fun!

Allan Massie

Another strong video that made me consider songs I knew in a new light and also gave me a bit of homework in the form of new songs to check out. Thanks as always! The Japan trip sounds like a blast. If you are inclined I recommend trying to learn a bit of spoken Japanese. It is a difficult language for English speakers but immensely fascinating and satisfying. I have tried a lot of ways to learn language and I have found Pimsleur's to be the best of commercially available packages (although I don't know their Japanese course). I also recommend going all-in on eating Japanese food. When I was living there I ate nothing else. I lost weight and felt great, although I did miss strong flavors now and then (it was an hour's drive from my small town to the nearest Indian restaurant).

Elliot Roberts

I do speak a bit of Japanese! I’ve been learning with my partner (who’s almost fluent), but I’ll definitely have learnt enough to get through standard conversations.

Morgan Michalko

Finally had the time to sit down and watch this, your timeline actually made me a bit emotional.. all of the “what could have been” conversations that surround the Beatles’ legacy always fascinate me, knowing a full reunion of some sort genuinely COULD have happened in some other reality, but they just weren’t able to get it together in time in this one :( Thanks for putting this together so cleverly and for giving us something to imagine.

HST

My tracklist: Side 1: 1) The No-No Song 2)The No-No Song 3)The No-No Song 4)The No-No Song 5)The No-No Song 6)Two Virgins: Side Two 7)The No-No Song Side 2: 1) The No-No Song 2)The No-No Song 3)The No-No Song 4)The No-No Song 5)Movement III: Musica 6)The No-No Song 7)The No-No Song

Craig Edmonds

Awesome dude! I'm soon to create my own Dec 1970 album using their first four solo efforts (and Ringo's first two). Also LOVED the colour matching on the names to the Sgt Pepper colours too... niiiiice!

The DC3cast

This was a lot of fun, and i think it's funny a few of your choices would've been the first I'd have purged when making my own version. The biggest note I have is that George would've quit again had he been forced to play on Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey. Plus, that song feels redundant when sharing a LP side with a better/more Beatle-y epic in Backseat of My Car. I think, as you said, most of Ram is too Linda-coded, so he's only getting one Ram song on there. 2 I also think that Love would get groans from George for being so simplistic and childlike. If a Plastic Ono Band song would make the cut, I think Isolation fits much better. I'd also include "Hold On" and as a tip of the hat to his fellow Beatles, do verses with at least Ringo's name if not all their names. As for George, Isn't it a Pity already cribs from Hey Jude, so that's a fun allusion to include in a new Beatles LP, though the length of that track might cause an issue. Plus, it shows that, like John with Hold On, that he's willing to forgive and grow with his brothers. Also, 14 is the traditional Beatle record length, so I think 2 Ringo songs make sense in this context. My version (also, god damn this is hard to sequence): It Don't Come Easy Every Night Hold On Beware of Darkness Gimme Some Truth Maybe I'm Amazed Isn't it a Pity What is Life Isolation Junk Apple Scruffs Photograph Jealous Guy Backseat of My Car My first attempt at a tracklisting was too "one side upbeat, one side downbeat," so I tried to mix it up a bit. This is easily the most George-heavy album not just because of his songs, but he also co-wrote both Ringo songs. I like this album a lot.

Elliot Roberts

Nice list! I considered ‘Isn’t It a Pity’ but John and Paul already rejected it in 1966.

ThoughtfulPug1

Well, glad I got the subscription. If I were doing this kind of project in your stead, I probably would have ruled against the idea of the various solo albums being cut down to allow for certain tracks to make it onto a Beatles record. I mean, maybe I can see Apple Scruffs being held off of AtmP because Harrison realizes that'd make a better inclusion for the next Beatles album; on the other hand , it's really stretching in places to ask John to hold Love off of Plastic Ono Band. Also doesn't help that it arguably weakens said solo albums, unless they replace those tracks with outtakes. I think if a 1971 Beatles album happened, it probably wouldn't be a classic with all four members firing on all cylinders. Maybe Photograph gets finished and put on the album. But I get the feeling the other three beatles would be hesitant to put their best work on the album rather than hold them off for their own solo albums. And let's not forget the change in the power dynamic with George's rise in prominence as a songwriter with his solo debut under his belt. If the Beatles kept on going to this stage, unless every issue they have is resolved (let's say, they realize Allen Klein's a huckster and oust him early on), I can imagine these hypothetical 1971 sessions will be contentious and awkward. Maybe we see lines being drawn in the sand; maybe John and Paul renew their friendship only to fall out with George, and the trio fight over Ringo in the divorce. Of course, this video is about an ideal situation where all four beatles put aside their differences to make the best music they can. And I see that. But I think it'd make for a fun alternate history book to see how this divergent timeline can play out and how their relationships change over time. Idk, "What if the Beatles never broke up" scenarios are interesting to discuss.

Jackson Wade

On paper this album flows nicely, will have to try it out.