Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everybody,

This was an interesting one! Hope you dug my reasons and let me know if any should be higher or lower.

And yes, I'm very excited for the Rubber Soul Special Edition.

Thanks for another month of support!

E.

Files

Tier List of reasons why the Beatles broke up

Comments

Kinsey Bunch

Should Magic Alex get an honorable mention? His bungling of the Apple recording studio definitely seems like a source of contention and added to the business/money woes, and his exploitation of John's friendship may have contributed to some of John's feelings of isolation or depression toward the end of the run (buying an island, etc.).

amanda siegelson

i thought your valuations were very fair, with one exception: allen klein. he actively worked to make paul angry and an outcast to the other three. i still have no idea why he would work against his own future - it just must have been in his nature. but he deserves a higher tier, imho. also - i think i might speak for others: enjoy your trip and don’t worry about those two videos. we’ll survive without them. :)

Christopher Newman

Thank you so much Elliot. I absolutely love your work and it is always a delight to watch your videos. I broadly agree with your categorisations. Specifically, I think Yoko has been dealt a terrible hand by traditional narratives driven by (what seems to be) pure racism and misogyny. If anything, Yoko was a symptom of the disintegration rather than a cause. If I were to try and identify an additional cause, it would simply be '1970'. More than any other phenomenon, the Beatles were creatures of the 1960s. They had set the pattern of album driven rock/pop music and, simply put, their creative contribution was done and the project was finished. Abbey Road was a true ending and it felt like it (but maybe you already covered this in the musical tastes bit so I wouldn't push this too far). I will say, thank the merciful creator that the Beatles didn't become like the Stones (in effect, after Goats Head Soup, the Stones became little more than a tribute band). One final thing, if you haven't read it yet, Kenneth Womack's book "John Lennon: 1980. The Last Days in the Life" is sublime. It is hopeful, because you can really feel the reconciliation and rebuilding of his relationship with Paul. It is also deeply sad, because you can see John coming out of the tunnel and starting to be creative. I felt so angry by the end of it, because of the time and experiences that were stolen from him, Yoko, Sean, Paul and all of us. Apologies for the essay and once again, sincerest thanks, peace and love to you and your partner. Stay well my friend x

Lga

Elliot - we think alike, my friend. I left this comment related to Yoko on r/Beatles just a day or two ago. Though I do believe she was more conniving than you. Changing the framing of the question, changes the answer - especially with relation to Yoko. Rather than, “Did Yoko break up The Beatles?” Ask: “If not for Yoko, would the Beatles have continued?” That answer is invariably yes. Of course a break up would have come some day, but not as soon as it did. I was born long after they broke up, so I carry no scars or reason to “blame” anyone. I don’t think Yoko alone broke up The Beatles, but she was the nail in the coffin. Suggesting she played no part is being either revisionist or an apologist. George didn’t like her and she and Paul’s relationship has always been frosty (bless his heart, Paul still won’t speak bad about her out of respect for John). It’s pretty simple: Paul was making everybody nuts with his unrelenting work ethic. John was drifting from the group, possibly headed toward independence. Yoko arrived and removed all doubt. And she didn’t just lead him away from the boys, she actively disrupted their work to expedite the process for her own benefit. John could claim he wanted her there in the studio all he wants, but let’s not kid ourselves into thinking she didn’t have the social awareness or the agency to say “thanks, John, but I shouldn’t get in the way while you guys are working.” No, she was a star fucker hell bent on fame. Someone in the thread called her a barnacle. That’s right, she attached herself to John so she could draft off of his fame. But that wasn’t enough, she needed it to be John & Yoko to get top billing. Being the girlfriend of one of The Beatles would never put enough of a spotlight on her. The door was open for John to leave on his own, but she came and carried him through the threshold. I also don’t believe Alan Klein takes over if the 4 Beatles are making decisions the way they always had. John and Yoko decided to go with Klein and the others had to choose sides.

Alaina

As a huge fan of Brian I found it really touching how you stressed his importance in the Beatles' lives! I've seen so many people be dismissive of the impact Brian could've had on the Beatles had he lived but you fleshed it out perfectly. Wonderful video as always!

Cole Switzer

Oh I hope and pray you make a Long Long Road review I love that album 🙏🙏🙏

HST

They broke up because Ringo had too much rizz, an overwhelming amount of aura

Peter Melling

Eh, that still sounds like you’re blaming Yoko pretty exclusively.

Davis H

Looking exactly like Paul in Get Back/Let It Be with the hair/yellow jumper combination

Davis H

I pretty much agree with all your rankings here except for Allen Klein, personally I would place him higher but each to their own I guess! Are you planning on making some kind of video for the Rubber Soul super deluxe similar to your Revolver one? I know you’ll be away when it comes so understand it could be tricky for you!

Jacob Miller

Like a lot of things, the break up of The Beatles wasn’t a clean break. But if every little squabble and whatnot was the build up at the end of “A Day In The Life”, then John saying he wants a divorce was that resounding *CHONG*. Also, while I am not in the Patreon tier to actively suggest bonus video ideas, I would absolutely watch a video where you “tourist it up” in Japan.

JorgeFT

Great video! I like that you referenced Lindsey Ellis’ Yoko video when bringing up Yoko Ono’s impact on the Beatles. In the end, yea, John and Paul basically were the two “culprits” of the Beatles’ breakup. But such is life. The band was growing up and coming up with new things to do outside of the band. It just wasn’t the same when the things that kept them together as a unit weren’t there anymore. It stood parallel with all the craziness that was happening throughout the 60s.

James Markin

My girlfriend is Japanese and her name is Yoko. When she meets people they all say to her when they learn her name "Oh like John Lennon's wife" and I get told "Don't let her break up your friendgroup/I bet your friends hate her". It's super annoying to the point that she now just wants to tell people a fake name.

Frederick French-Pounce

Enjoy the record shopping in Japan if you choose to take some time out for it! As much as there’s so many great options here in Melbourne, I feel like a lot of the prices actually end up nicer there in the end.

Debra Cope

Excellent post. It was Lennon’s band, and he broke it up, but I agree very much with your thoughtful breakdown of how Paul McCartney’s press release unfortunately sealed things. I also strongly believe that if John hadn’t had Yoko in his life, it wouldn’t have played out this way. That’s very different from blaming Yoko. It was still John’s choice to give her so much of his energy. (If you can call it a choice; he was undoubtedlydriven by some pretty profound early traumas, and there is a case to be made that this made him very vulnerable to relationships involving intense or hyper attachments.) Brian’s death was certainly a tipping point.

steven anderson

Essentially if yoko had never come into the picture, they would not have split in THAT fashion but who knows what would’ve transpired, we’re into butterfly effect territory. But in this scenario we’re talking about, yoko. They had it correct all those years ago but because they were to some extent driven by xenophobia and misogyny, come say the liberal 90’s people started to overcompensate and turn against the notion. She denied us the overproduced 1983 album full of fairlight synth and a barely functioning ringo replaced with a drum machine, and the 1994 Rick Rubin produced comeback record, with John moonlighting on grand royal making wacky jams with the beastie boys guys…

Pêche aux canards

Thank you for this video, Elliot. I do agree with you, mostly. What I hate the most about the Yoko blaming is the misogyny. John talked about it in an interview, it was always “Yoko influences John” and never the other way around. We could stress how John being seen as the leader of the biggest band in the world gave him power in the relationship and how his behaviour with women at the time may have been hard to deal with for Yoko. I don’t know, I wasn’t there, but I think there’s more to this than the one sided argument people always talk about. Also, I feel like the personal relationship between John and Paul deteriorating was a factor in the breakup. Anyways, thank you for your work

Michael Hartt

Really enjoyed this! I think you’ve got it right. Wondering if you’ve thought about doing anything about The Beatles in Japan or their Japanese records while you’re there? Hope you can check out the Abbey Road bar and the Perfect Circle Beatles Store in Tokyo.

Elliot Roberts

I was considering it but given I’ll now need to make a Rubber Soul video while I’m over there, I think I might leave it at that!

Michael Hartt

When we were there last year, my 6-y-o and I had a bit of a quest to find as many of the UK singles discography with the Japanese picture sleeves as possible. Really fun and not too expensive. Definitely recommend seeing The Parrots at Abbey Road too.

Jacob Witmer

WARNING, this will be a long read again. But if I may, having read the You Never Give Me Your Money book, I'd like to offer up a bit of a defense of Allen Klein and a criticism of Lee and John Eastman: Whilst yes, it did later come to light how much of a shark Allen Klein was, and it was absurd of John Lennon to basically hand him the keys to his life after only ONE meeting with the man; the truth is that for as nasty as his reputation is...he never actually DID anything. At least not whilst the Beatles were a functioning unit. As you said yourself in the video, it was 100% in his best interests that the Beatles stay together, and obviously that would've included trying to appeal to Paul as best as he could. So to that end, his main ambition when taking control of the Beatles' management was primarily to reduce Apple's spending and renegotiate all the band's contracts so they could once again place all their attention on being creatives rather than having to spend their downtime being hassled by all these lawyers and accountants (like we see them being subjected to throughout all of Get Back). The problem was that at every turn, his attempts at implementing these new policies were being undercut by the Eastmans. So for one thing, it should be noted that for as much as Paul McCartney didn't like Allen Klein, you could not find someone who better represented all the people and institutions that John Lennon held a grudge against than Lee Eastman. He was 59 years old in 1969, which put him nearly three decades ahead of both Allen Klein AND Brian Epstein in terms of age. Unlike Klein who already had connections to Pop and R&B artists like the Stones and Sam Cooke; Eastman primarily was a fan of classical symphonies and Broadway musicals. Even in the recent Wings book that came out last year, Linda's sister Laura recollects that their father's reaction to hearing Elvis Presley on the radio for the first time was, "Oh, that'll never last!", thus making Linda's embrace of the rock culture in the '50s and '60s stand as a form of rebellion within her family. So, that sort of more grounded sensibility Lee Eastman had about him was something that was always appealing to Paul (it likely reminded him of his own dad Jim); but suggesting to John Lennon that this kind of conservative character be put in charge of his art and career had to be the equivalent of spraying a cat with water. Of course, not helping matters was that unlike Klein who kept traveling between New York and London to keep meeting with the Beatles in person, Eastman largely sent his son John over to be there in his place, which had to have read to the other three Beatles as a rather disengaged and inconsiderate gesture considering they were the most powerful people in the entertainment world by that point. And all of this to say, just objectively on its face, the idea of Paul suggesting to John, George and Ringo that his new in-laws be put in charge of the band's business affairs when they've already been slowly building up resentment for how much he's been acting like the de facto band manager for the past two years; regardless of who his in-laws were that was gonna be a pretty hard sell for the other three (which Paul himself even admits to in Anthology). BUT, even by February 1969, none of them really wanted this to be the end of the band. So in reality, what happened is the day after the Get Back filming wrapped and the intrusive camera crew had finally gone away, the four Beatles, Allen Klein and John Eastman agreed to a compromise where Klein would be appointed as the Beatles' manager, but the Eastmans could stay on as the Beatles' lawyers and legal advisors. And with this team together, the Beatles could now be freed of all their business hassles and able to fully turn their attention back to polishing off this album they'd just recorded whilst Klein and the Eastmans began negotiations to try and purchase NEMS Enterprises from Brian's family (thus relieving the Beatles from all the contractual obligations they were still under from before Brian died, as well as giving them majority control of the Northern Songs company which controlled the Lennon/McCartney publishing). And this arrangement worked...........for approximately two weeks until John Eastman wrote a letter to Brian's brother Clive calling for a meeting to discuss "the propriety of the negotiations" Brian had made when renegotiating the Beatles' contract with EMI at the end of 1966. And since the word "propriety" is a synonym for "morality" or "decency", Clive Epstein interpreted the letter as John Eastman accusing his late brother of being a crook, and promptly responded by selling his family's share of NEMS to the Triumph Investment Trust. Thus resulting in Dick James smelling blood in the water, starting his own company with his new Lennon/McCartney team (a.k.a. Elton John & Bernie Taupin), and selling off his shares of Northern Songs to ATV. So by now we are in the back half of April 1969; Klein and the Eastmans have been in charge of the Beatles' business for nearly two months and this alleviating of their business pressures has led to the more congenial atmosphere between the band members as the Abbey Road sessions start properly getting underway. In particular, John and Paul are getting along better than they have in a while going off of the lighthearted recording sessions for "The Ballad of John and Yoko" and the vocal overdubs for "You Know My Name (Look Up the Number)". But with Northern Songs now going up for sale, and the band no longer having the NEMS advantage thanks to John Eastman's poorly worded letter, John and Paul now have to be roped back into the business squabbling if they want to retain control of their songwriting catalog. This is also at the height of John Lennon's Bed-ins for Peace, sending acorns to world leaders, recording experimental pieces of musique concrete, and making home movies of his penis so obviously there's a lot of apprehension about what's going to happen when you try to get this temperamental weirdo to appeal his case to a board of chartered accountants about why he should be granted majority control over their highly lucrative publishing company. So it is at this moment when Lee Eastman finally decides to fly in from New York to finally meet the rest of the Beatles in person. Ostensibly, this is to try and make sure these negotiations go off as smoothly as possible, but for John, there's an underlying feeling that Paul's new father-in-law has shown up to put him on a leash. A meeting is held with all involved parties to discuss plans to wrest control of Northern Songs away from ATV, and it collapses into chaos immediately. Klein accuses the Eastmans of sabotaging the deal with NEMS and undermining his powers of negotiation; the Eastmans accuse Klein of being incapable of brokering a deal because of his shady reputation; John Lennon made it all personal, flying into a rage and calling the Eastmans "fucking animals"; leaving Paul stunned and horrified, watching his best friend hurl abuse at his new wife and her family. However, the ultimate bombshell arrives when it's revealed during the meeting that in actuality, John might not even be that crucial of a vote anyways. Having never trusted Klein from the very beginning, the Eastmans have secretly been advising Paul to buy a further amount of shares in the Northern Songs company apart from John since February, thus placing him in a more powerful and profitable position than John within the company. From Paul's perspective, this was meant to function as a safeguard against any potential meddling from Klein in their earnings, but from John's perspective a move like this completely flew in the face of the agreement they had held in place since they were teenagers that they would split all the benefits from their partnership 50-50. For John, and by extension George and Ringo, this all effectively served as a confirmation that at this point in time, Paul and the Eastmans were now making decisions which sought to place him ahead of the rest of the band. A few days later, John, George and Ringo would quickly send off a letter to Lee and John Eastman terminating them from their position as the Beatles' official legal counsel. Three weeks after that, the Abbey Road sessions would be brought to a halt after the three Beatles gave Allen Klein full control over Apple, overruling Paul and resulting in the "Now or Never" argument he recounts in Anthology. When the Abbey Road sessions resumed a month later in July, John Lennon would be largely absent, recuperating at home after crashing his car while on vacation with Yoko, Julian and Kyoko in Scotland. In August, Paul would form MPL Productions with the help of the Eastmans thus further cementing his separation from the Beatles. On September 19th, Northern Songs would officially be sold to ATV, meaning John and Paul no longer held any ownership over the songwriting catalog that had been their life's work since they were teenagers in Liverpool. The next day, John told the other Beatles he wanted a divorce. Now, the main reason I bring all this up is not to absolve Klein or John for that matter for the role they both played in the breakup of the Beatles. Obviously, the two of them made some incredibly stupid and divisive moves which did not work in their favor. Klein made the first mistake right from the beginning of giving John a preferential treatment over Paul and choosing to woo him over specifically instead of approaching them as a pair which at the very least might've helped Paul believe that he was treating them like a proper team. And that's to say nothing about how poorly John Lennon handled all of these things. Again, the fact that he went head over heels for this guy after LITERALLY ONE MEETING was hopelessly naive; and the childish way he turned a business conflict into a personal one by acting like the Eastmans' misgivings about Klein represented a personal attack against his new father figure undoubtedly led to the disintegration of his relationship with Paul since he treated Paul's defense of his new family as a personal betrayal of Paul's own loyalty to him. Hence why the Beatles' breakup got as nasty as it did when it didn't really need to be that way. In any other world, the four of them could've just taken some time off like they did after the disastrous 1966 World Tour to recollect themselves and come back together recharged and renewed. But instead these disagreements over financial decisions led to John Lennon treating it like this kind of Romeo and Juliet war of the feuding families where you either showed John how much you loved him by just letting Allen Klein do whatever he wanted, or you expressed your misgivings about what Klein might be up to and run the risk of John accusing you of being a traitor. And ultimately, Paul's misgivings were proven to be well-founded. By the end of the following year, the Rolling Stones would discover that Klein's sneaky handling of their contracts led to him losing the rights to all the music they had made up to that point, leading them to flee to the South of France to live as tax exiles. The year after that, Klein's failure to register the Concert for Bangladesh as a UNICEF charity event led to hefty portions of the money meant to aid the refugees ending up being swallowed by tax (as well as some side pocketing off the record sales by ABKCO). The year after that John and Yoko felt let down by him after his lack of support for the Some Time in New York City album. Then after being let go from the Apple organization, he ended up becoming a key voice in the opposition against John and George in their subsequent plagiarism lawsuits over “Come Together” and “My Sweet Lord” respectively. But again, all those things came AFTER the Beatles had already broken up. So in the end, what did Klein REALLY do to the Beatles while he was their manager? Was it his fault that the NEMS deal fell apart after John Eastman sent off a poorly-worded letter that offended the Epsteins? Was it his fault that the Triumph shareholders didn’t want to sell their portion of Northern Songs to Apple because they were getting conflicting reports about who was running the negotiations from both John’s team AND Paul’s team? Yeah, he fired a lot of people at Apple from their original positions…but like…he kind of needed to? When the Beatles were running Apple themselves they were throwing piles of money away on projects that failed like the Apple Boutique or Apple Electronics (I always think of that one guy in Get Back who shows up in the Apple offices during the rooftop concert and just walks up to the front desk shouting, “Where’s me money?!?!”). If his job was to cut back their spending, he needed to get rid of all the money pits at Apple, and Apple had a LOT of money pits. So then what does that leave us with in terms of nefarious things he did to the Beatles? Well…he put together the Red and Blue albums…are we mad at him for that? And look, obviously there is an equally valid argument to be made in favor of the Eastmans. If you want to get sentimental about it, you can say that their constant undercutting of Klein and their encouragement of Paul to make some business decisions which were more in his favor than the others was their way of looking out for their daughter and her new husband. And the evidence is also there that they were very good at what they did. We all know that with the Eastmans’ help, Paul became and continues to be the wealthiest Beatle of them all. The success is self-evident, and you can’t argue with the success, right? But at the same time, I think they also made the crucial mistake Klein did of treating their client as a separate entity away from the other three. Klein gave too much favoritism to John, but by that same token the Eastmans gave too much favoritism to Paul. Encouraging him to buy more shares in the publishing company than John, helping him set up MPL whilst the Beatles were still a working unit and before John’s divorce meeting, these are not the pieces of advice you give to someone who’s trying to keep a band together; these are the pieces of advice you give to your special client to help protect him in case his unruly bandmates make any more stupid decisions he doesn’t like. It’s that kind of separatism and favoritism which Brian Epstein would’ve never allowed within the Beatles’ orbit because he knew how crucially important it was for the four of them to be treated as a unified collective rather than an individual hierarchy. And to be fair to Paul, I believe he knew that too; but in Brian’s absence, his push to keep the Beatles working made it look to the other three like he was keeping them around to act as vessels for his ideas. Klein saw that and tried to reset the power balance by treating John like he was the bandleader. The Eastmans countered by acting like Paul should be treated as the bandleader. And when that infighting led to John and Paul’s songwriting being ripped away from them, I think it just finally solidified it for John that it was all over. And with Paul’s natural response to grief being to put all his frustrations into work, it led to him deciding to ram on ahead with Linda, spreading his wings, and not looking back. The same way the Beatles was built upon the foundation of the partnership between John and Paul being 50-50; I think the blame for its unravelling also has to land equally upon the pair of them and the different people they chose to be their advisors. 50-50.

ovidiomedes

im very much of the belief ppl over-correct when talking about yoko. like yeah she wasn’t the sole reason they broke up but it’s a bit silly to think she had absolutely nothing to do with it. she did! and even if it was mostly john using her i still think it’s important to understand why that was the case

Erin Uy

I do think that the beatles' interpersonal relationships could've been a reason, specifically the triad dynamic of John Paul and George (and of course the John and Paul of it all) but those relationships are too long to summarize and they were influenced by topics covered here already, so fair game!! and I think you handled the Yoko part of it all very well. its definitely a balanced and nuanced look and doesn't lean into over-correction or inane hatred slightly out of topic, but if we're talking beatles books, I would like to recommend "the beatles and the historians" book by erin torkelson weber - great book that explores how the beatles' stories and narratives have evolved over the years via their depictions in these books and newspapers. another one would be "a women's history of the beatles" by christine feldman-barret. it has really fun interviews and anecdotes from their fans and explores all sorts of topics that are really rare in beatle works (specifically topics related to their effects on women fans, their music pushing women bands etc)

Elliot Roberts

I own and have read both books! I particularly love The Beatles and the Historians :)

Kathryn Coffey

Just got around to watching this, and I agree with most of your rankings. I would've placed Brian's death and the money problems in A Tier. John asking for a divorce from the band definitely deserved it's spot on the S-Tier. I finished reading a Beatles-related book called Beatles Blackouts: Trips Around the World in Search of Beatles Monuments by Jack Marriott. It's about some guy visiting various Beatles statues and Beatles-related locations around the world under the guise of working for the BBC for a documentary or some crap. It's a wild ride, and I recommend it. It even talks about some of the Beatles-themed bars in Japan (at least at the time of the book's publication)