Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everybody,

Hope you enjoy this month's bonus video, a review of Richard Lester's 1967 film How I Won the War, featuring John Lennon in his one and only acting role (outside of Beatles films).

I've also give a Patreon/Japan update in the first three minutes!

Let me know what you think of it all in the comments,

Thanks :)

E.

Files

How I Won the War — Review

Chapters 0:00 - Update/Japan 2:52 - How I Won the War 3:40 - Pre-Production 6:19 - Review

Comments

Alex Navas

Fun review, makes me want to watch the movie someday! Hope you guys have a good time in Japan!

Jacob Miller

I have this image in my head of Richard Lester convincing John Lennon to return to acting one last time to be in his reshoots for Superman II. Perhaps replacing Brando as Jor-El. As for How I Won The War? I didn’t have much interest, and this review showed that lack of interest was more or less justified. Have Fun In Japan!

Ethan Hopper

Id be interested to get your take on The Wall movie by Pink Floyd at some point in a future bonus episode. Good video as always Elliot, enjoy your trip to Japan. Well earned.

Alaina

What a great review! And I hope you enjoy Japan. The trip sounds like such a treat. Give yourself a rest—you deserve one!

Elliot Roberts

I talk about The Wall in my Rock Operas video on Patreon!

Marshal Riley

Pleasantly surprised to see my first suggestion for a bonus video selected so soon!! Also dude, you've earned a break, after that Ringo video I was expecting to not see you at least a month hahaha

Oscar H

As a big WW2 nerd when I was a kid who turned into a Beatles nerd as a teenager, this film is like the most "made-for-me" thing of all time lol.

Cate Allison

Great hair, fab review of a movie I wasn't even aware of - and very wise to take a break and hopefully come back refreshed. Looking forward to November.

Davis H

It’s funny you post this today as I just watched Give My Regards To Broad Street for the first time this morning and was thinking of checking this one out next! I hope your trip to Japan is nice, I’ve always wanted to go! And to (kind of, not really) quote George Harrison: “I think your [hair] suits you man”

Яна Уладыка

Thanx for the review! I watched the movie twice: first just myself, and my impression was much like yours, and for the second time with my father, not quite sure if he will like it, but he did. Some context: he served in the Soviet army in its final years (1988-90) - although it coincided with 'wind of change' years in Eastern Europe, the overall atmosphere can be described with a popular proverb 'who served in the army, he doesn't laugh at circus". So my dad - a professional actor, btw, who often irritates mom by constantly criticizing/commenting movies as we watch them - he could both enjoy the performances and the production. He took the plot inconsistency as part of an immersive experience - as he could compare it to his own experience. (E.g., in 1990, he, a trombone player at the time, was brought with the rest of an army orchestra from the western border of the USSR to a rioting Caucass republic for three weeks - to stay in the guard two times, starve with only butter and oranges in abundance, watching the senior ranks looting abandoned shops and thus standing in the helicopter all the way back home because of these 'trophies'. And that's just like the mildest example of what happened in those times.) As a girl, I haven't experienced army in the 21st century, but from the tales I have a feeling it all haven't much changed for the last 35 years - and yes, in Belarus we have a mandatory conscription. Speaking of which, lately I have been positively shocked when reading Many Years From Now. When The Boys of Dungeon Lane were released, I decided to turn to the authorized biography of Paul - finally, and I realized it's not only me who overlooked the book released as far as in 1998, 'cause, for example, the infamous 'Winston Churchill' story was already there, and yet it bombshelled only after the 2018 interview. But, perhaps, reasonably so, cause that's not the most interesting thing in the whole book. What shocked me, being a girl, is a story of a baby boy Paul thinking he has to go to army one day and thus trying to get accustomed to killing - at least an animal. As there was no farm at hand, he went down the Dungeon Lane not just birdwatching, but killing frogs, leaving a gallery of dead bodies on the spikes of a barbwire. Brother Michael stood terrified watching the 'frog chorus' when Paul brought him along to boast. Luckily, they never got to serve as the mandatory practice was cancelled in late 1950s. That's a powerful, multilayered image - I wish such deep stories (perhaps, not as violent, but as meaningful and symbolic) were portrayed in biopics...

Take me for example

hit up as many family marts and lawsons and 7/11s as you can. have a good time. nice review btw.

Brendan King

Fitting how Elliot showed off his haircut in a video talking about John having to cut his hair for HIWTW

HST

Love the new cut my friend, and enjoy Japan!

JorgeFT

Good review. It provides a compelling message that I think a good amount of people share regarding war. But it is a bit of a mess. Go enjoy your time off in Japan! I’m sure it’ll be great! Was there twice recently and really enjoyed my time there!

Jack Almoro

Take all the time you need, Elliot! You more than deserve it. Lastly, the cut looks great!

Craig Hilton

Thank you, Elliot. I saw How I Won The War in the late seventies. It was on TV very late at night, and being a Beatles fan I set the video recorder (Beta, of course) to catch it. I watched it twice. I was glad I’d seen it, for completeness, but I felt no urge to see it again. It’s anti-war message didn’t say anything that hadn’t been said before.

Craig Hilton

I will remain rock-solid as a patron. I’m here for the long haul, because your products are just so darn good.

Judah Quinn

1:04 missed opportunity not saying I’ve been “beatled till I'm blind“

Alyza Alyza

Great video, and nice haircut man! Been a fan of yours for quite some time, and just gotta say, you truly know you're stuff when it comes to the Beatles. Cheers!

Brent

Have a great trip Elliot!

Levi Tomlinson

No Elliot please be joking, your hair was so beautiful, you looked like George so much.

Levi Tomlinson

Top 3 YouTubers and top 5 human you are Elliot

Carolyn Krick

Hi Elliot! 👋 Hope all is well in Japan! Just wanted to say I really appreciated this video! I actually ordered HIWTW on vhs back in the 90s from a video store and paid way too much for a young person back then (I wanna say close to $70!!!) just so I could watch it. 🤪 And unfortunately, my assessment of the film was similar to yours. I even watched it several times because I wanted to see if it made more sense with multiple watches…I recognized Roy Kinnear from Help (+ Charlie & the Chocolate Factory) & Jack MacGowran from The Exorcist…I wasn’t quite aware of Michael Crawford as much back then but I thought he was great and thought they all did the best with what they were given but ultimately it just wasn’t very cohesive enough to be worth the ridiculous amount I spent to own it. Is your haircut a slight nod to the haircut John wore in the film? 😁

Elliot Roberts

Thanks for sharing! And for the record my haircut was purely just to switch things up. The timing was purely a bonus!

Christophine Place

The new hair was definitely a shock, but you look quite sharp! Great video by the way. <3

NanenNanen

Speaking of movies starring musicians, what are your thoughts on Labyrinth?