Second Anniversary Q&A! (Patreon)
Content
(A Provisional Note: I had recorded the audio of my answers to these questions, but I was not satisfied with the extent to which my way of speaking did not provide a sense of cogency for the listener; in short, I was rambling too much. I now render these answers via text for your perusal, hopefully more thought-out and satisfying.)
brice lee:
Q/ “What is the “worst” movie you like?”
A/ According to the statistics of Letterboxd, it's Transformers: the Last Knight, which has an expectedly low average score. To tell you the truth, I've gotten the most questions over the years for my love of Gods of Egypt -- it's the one people tend to arrive at when they're eager to dismiss my opinions on anything, which is their right of course. I enjoy every film I've given 5 stars to -- but in the light of day, perhaps 1988's Cocktail is the most... fleeting, of that number.
Q/ “What is the movie you have done the most dramatic 180 on over time?”
A/ In recent memory, probably Alien: Covenant. I used to really despise that one, seeing it in theaters during the first year of me trying to seriously be a connoisseur of cinema. I wasn't ready for it -- my love for the original Alien was too dogmatic, too inflexible, and nothing short of Ridley Scott going back into that dead-tech analog world would have been acceptable to me at the time.
Now I think Covenant is quite hilarious and fun, certainly keeping apace with Ridley's late misanthropy and contempt for humanity -- it's not difficult to see him as David and Walter as Tony, the analysis writes itself. That he lets David get away at the end when most directors wouldn't dream of it is telling -- he respect craft and genius above morality, just like Kubrick.
Q/ “Snyder vs Bay?”
A/ Snyder. I love Bay and will always defend him at his best, and he has been on quite a hot-streak as of late, but Snyder contains a wider set of skills and is able to deploy them more judiciously -- he's not trapped within the Spielberg Americana that Bay is, Snyder's interested in older forms, he cares about Antique myth and is unafraid to depict the sensible consequences of his insensible subjects. Snyder's the rare artisan of spectacle who has a feeling for internal moods and fugues -- that many of his films have this elegiac or funereal quality places him closer to a John Woo or Jean-Pierre Melville than many of his contemporaries. His politics are not too dissimilar to Eastwood's, but certainly more Randian in scope -- anyway, I love both of my boys, but Snyder's a visionary whereas Bay has never really tried to push himself in any alternate directions from Hollywood formulaics outside of Pain & Gain.
-
francis:
Q/ “What are the best books you’d recommend to someone trying to get into analysing cinema?”
A/ There's a two-volume set assembled by Richard Roud called Cinema: A Critical Dictionary that I picked up on eBay a while back and contains very astute and specialized essays on a wide array of directors circa 1980 -- I think it's quite a gem, worth grabbing if you can.
-
@bartlebooth45:
Q/ “Do you think you have an overarching philosophy which guides your taste and response to movies?”
A/ No, deliberately so. I came to cinema via philosophic studies because I was sick of the dogmatic systems and rhetorical formulas that most philosophers think is the entire purpose of existence -- how X and Y fit into Deleuze's theory of Becoming or whatever, there are dozens upon dozens of philosophic systems and they're all rigid as hell and have basically become objects of cultist reverence, which I hate.
As soon as you start seeing things through one theory, you're tempted to try and fit everything into that theory's tiny box and disregard anything that doesn't fit, which leaves you with a very impoverished world -- what I like about cinema is that it allows multiple perspectives to co-exist within the same space of the screen, and so you're gifted with this inherent pluralism that always resists reduction to the barest denominator. All art does this, of course, but yeah, I don't want to be a propagandist, there is no theory I'm going to structure my viewing through -- I have interests, I do research, but at the end of the day, I'm making my own approach, that's what I'm interested in.
-
@shawngarlic:
Q/ “are there any films you absolutely refuse to ever watch? if so, what are they and why?”
A/ I don't really think I'm ever going to watch anything by Roman Polanski or Woody Allen -- there's just too many other worthwhile things to see, and I honestly don't want to bother with those two fuckers given their reputations.
I also deliberately avoid body horror films, if I can help it -- you won't catch me rewatching Cronenberg's The Fly anytime soon, once was enough for me and my squeamish cowardice.
-
@tomoliver:
Q/ “As someone who takes on a lot of hostility for your film reviews, what are your thoughts on why people take differing opinions on film so personally?”
It's due to the fact that we so often want to build our personalities atop external objects -- you're a Coke person, you're a Pepsi person, these attachments put us at ease, make us feel connected to the world. When I write a review, some people take it that I'm either praising what they hate or damning what they love, so that I must also necessarily be working against them in some capacity, trying to undermine their sense of self -- we all have dealt with this to some extent.
There's also the fact that some people just love a good lolcow and have nothing else better to do with their lives but express hostility towards me on a semi-consistent basis -- whatever floats their boat, I guess, but I'd rather not be someone's punching bad, if I can help it.
-
jack:
Q/ “The influence of even the most basic filmmaker is felt for so many people. Are there filmmakers out there that have avoided developing a connection with you and your studies of cinema? Filmmakers that are popular/ loved/ hated even that haven’t connected with you at all? And why?”
A/ Generally I try not to disregard directors completely until I've seen a wider portion of their work -- that being said, I mostly know what I like and what I don't like at this point. The post-Bresson European school of extremely astringent and mannered filmmaking (Haneke, Von Trier, Straub-Huillet, etc.) isn't something that's ever drawn my eye -- I'm mostly repelled by that sort of thing, the contrived intellectualism of it all, it's quite dull to me, but that's of course just my own limited predilections, so whatever, I don't bother with those artists because I already know it's not for me based on my past experiences.
-
patrick newman:
Q/ “What was the first film you saw that opened your third eye to what cinema is or could be at its highest aspiration?”
A/ Probably The Good, the Bad and the Ugly -- it was the first 'epic' I saw, the first film that I recognized as having ideas and themes it wanted to deliberately express from a specific point-of-view. It changed it all for me -- suddenly I no longer took movies for granted, afterwards I felt like I needed to step-up my thinking to match the thoughts that were going on in the artform.
-
@profundorobbo:
Q/ “As someone with a reputation for negative hot takes, what are your thoughts on engaging with negativity for its own sake (e.g. in the form of a "bottom 100" list)?”
A/ God I really hope I don't have a reputation for negativity -- perhaps I can't help that, which sucks, eh. I don't believe that much productive can come from lingering on what one deeply hates -- you should be spending that energy focusing on what you love instead; obsessive hate in the particular eventually spirals into a sort of universal contempt for any and all parts of existence. I never want to be in that space again.
-
@alexpage:
Q/ “how do you choose which movie you're going to watch next? do you have like a mental priority list of what you're planning to watch in the immediate future, or do you just watch things that sound like the sort of thing you want to watch today?”
A/ Oh it's just totally random, I mean, I have a shortlist of several movies that I'm working through, but I just add them there based on my whims, there's no plan really, it's whatever feels right.
-
@cosmicblaze454:
Q/ “How did you get into cinema and how did you build up your knowledge on cinema?”
A/ I got into it mostly thanks to my father, who put me through watching all of his favorites from the 70s and 80s; his taste is the bedrock of my own, I owe him all of this.
As for knowledge, really it mostly built-up over time, reading online articles, reading books, and simply recognizing the technical aspects of how cinema is made. I'm dense, so I have to learn everything through rigorous process and making mistakes all the time, of forcing myself into an educational routine, watching two films a day, that kind of thing.
-
brian:
Q/ “A bit of an open-ended question, but how do you balance your political and aesthetic beliefs?”
A/ I try to separate them as much as possible and allow each field to dictate its own necessity -- my political beliefs are meager and incoherent at best, the same ideas you can find in the mouths of many other people. My aesthetic principles are from Nietzsche and Walter Pater and the Romantics, English and German -- oh, and Oscar Wilde, of course.
Occasionally one has to let politics override aesthetics -- Birth of a Nation, Triumph of the Will, you can't really make a coherent apology for these films without looking like an asshole for trying, you just have to skirt around them if you can. And sometimes aesthetics must overwhelm politics -- Eastwood and John Ford being two powerful exemplars of that. All-in-all, it's like two ships passing in the night, or King Kong and Godzilla -- there's a possible confrontation, a possible moment of recognition, but I believe that art is essentially good, but amoral, while politics is moral by definition, so they aim for different ends and should not collapse into each other, if they can help it.
-
@no4h_2pt0:
Q/ “Could you talk about your interest in mysticism and how that informs your approach to film and criticism? And related … best movies about Ets/UFOs?”
A/ Best movies about UFOs and aliens: Close Encounters, Fire in the Sky, Communion, The Mothman Prophecies, Earth vs. the Flying Saucers, both Wars of the Worlds, there's quite a few.
Concerning my esoteric interests, they inform me as much as one's religious beliefs might -- it doesn't always come up, but it forms an invisible backdrop by which I can recognize various elements as they emerge into view. Most movies contain some sort of occulted portion, I find, even if it's badly botched -- either way, my esoteric beliefs are more of a private matter that I only wish to talk about when it seems relevant to this or that picture, otherwise it would sound like I'm a raving preacher.
-
toegutter:
Q/ “Top 3 favorite villains in film, or at least just 3 you really like if you don't have specific ones that you'd definitively say are your favorites”
A/
1. Thulsa Doom
2. Dracula (Lugosi, not Lee)
3. Vincent Collateral
-
@alexHD:
Q/ “whats the best german movie”
A/ I've barely seen any German films, so... it's gotta be a Fritz Lang? Let's go for Die Nibelungen, both parts together.
-
luna:
Q/ “I don't know if this has been asked before so I'll ask it here, is there an ideological or aesthetic reason behind your choice to omit capitalization in your writing (and if so could you explain why you format your writing this way)?”
A/ It's just a habit I picked up during my 5 year stint on 4chan -- like riding a bike, I suppose. I avoid it when trying to be professional, like on here, but it's a reflexive thing otherwise, you're the first person I've ever seen bring it up, which is somewhat surprising, all things considered...
-
mona:
Q/ “Any tips on developing a personalized approach to film criticism for novice reviewers?”
A/ I would say the key thing is to copy those whose writing you enjoy, try to emulate them, but then also decide through that emulation what you do or do not want to do with your critique, what directions are possible and which one you wish to go in -- copy, then do your own thing, even if it's weird or messy, and eventually you'll stumble into finding your own voice. I started off by ripping off Matt Lynch, and now I don't write anything like him -- by applying myself to a form, I became aware of what the form was, its limitations and blessings, and so I was able to push it forwards to what I wanted more of from my thinking.
-
@reindeerpizza99:
Q/ “What is your relationship with Tim Burton?”
A/ I think he's a sad case of a man on autopilot, for... most of his career, at this point? It's quite sad to think about -- whatever happened to the passion behind Sleepy Hollow or Bettlejuice? After he did that Dumbo remake, I truly lost all hope -- it's a damn shame to see a man like that, capable of unique visions, being reduced to the level of directing yet-another Disney live-action remake -- I wish someone had the temerity to interview him and ask what the hell went wrong, why he stopped caring. Is he deluded, is he cynical, is he a rebel who went corporate or was he always corporate? I have no clue, but I wish I did...
-
ash:
Q/ “If you could personally direct a film adaptation of any book, what would you like to make?”
A/ We've never really gotten a down-the-middle wide-release Lovecraft adaptation -- either the filmmakers change it beyond recognition, it's a spiritual successor to Howard's work like In The Mouth of Madness, or it's merely using Cthulhu as a clumsy shorthand. Given that all of his work will be public domain within the next decade, why isn't anyone bothering? It really baffles me.
Oh, and I'd love to do a more book-faithful adaptation of Mothman Prophecies; the 2002 film is quite excellent as an abridgement, but it only summarizes the vast weirdness that John Keel experienced in the late 60s, which more resembles an Oliver Stone film than a monster movie, although there are indeed beasties he encounters on the way towards cosmicly-crippling paranoia.
-
@slowdiver2003:
Q/ “what are some of your favorite games and what do u like about them?”
A/ I'm a big fan of stealth games and immersive sims, stuff like Metal Gear, Fallout, Deus Ex, Thief, Tenchu, System Shock, Penumbra, Splinter Cell, I love how they make this quasi-expressionist use of the environment via shadow and light -- especially Tenchu, which should be more known about given how detailed its mechanics are.
I also enjoy adventure games like Myst, The Longest Journey, Life is Strange, or visual novels like Fault Milestone One, where you have these huge considered worlds with well-written characters and fascinating stories that interweave so many concepts together into a unique experience.
The Nier and Drakengard series are also worth mentioning if only to say that Yoko Taro is a singular voice, certainly the equal of someone like Kojima, a true auteur in the videogame space.
-
@liebert:
Q/ “what do you wish your reviews could better express / succeed in conveying?”
A/ I think a problem that I face in my writing is that I have this unresolved tension between my own personal reveries and trying to remain coherent for the person reading it -- I don't always get that balance right and I can feel it slipping past me. Sometimes I feel as if the contents of my brain are either very singular and fixed, or they're spread all over the place like sand on a beach and I can't get them to amount to the shape I want -- really my writing is very dependent on my mood and mental state at the time, which is fine, I like that it reflects a certain temporal position, that makes it more unique, but I wonder if it sometimes gives the impression that I'm a total maniac with bipolar or borderline disorder, where I'll express two diametrically opposed thoughts in two different reviews separated by a couple days -- I don't know if this is a 'real' problem or if it's just my own anxiety inventing something to worry about, but yeah, I feel that I struggle with consistency, perhaps as much as any person does, but it being more acute because my writing serves as a cracked mirror to past versions of my self.
Files
Previews only