Notes On Mannerism (Patreon)
Content
For some time now I've been contemplating a more coherent rejection to a certain aesthetic move (if not movement) that is all but omnipresent in the current Anglophone cinema -- a move that I would wish to call Mannerism.
I had first considered this description in relationship to Greta Gerwig's Barbie (where I called it 'neo-mannerism' in a typically incoherent fashion) -- as it seemed to be that Barbie represented a type of manifesto of this move that I had sensed before but never was able to articulate, like feeling the tremors of a thunderstorm on a spider's silken web.
The salient features of Barbie -- the self-consciousness, the uniform exaggeration, the flattened semi-symmetrical artifice, the hermetically-sealed thematic space -- these are several central elements of the cinematic Mannerism that I would like to speak of.
Before that, it would help to know how and why I use this term -- in my studies of painting and its history thereof, the sub-sets and various schools, I wondered at what immediately followed the flowering of Renaissance Classicism -- where does one go after the works such a harmoniously perfect group of artists like Raphael, Leonardo, Michelangelo, etc.? Mannerism turned out to be the answer, or at least an answer -- John Shearman codified a term first introduced by Jacob Burckhardt, and I am going to read both of their works on the subject soon so I can gain a detail-oriented understanding of what they mean by the term -- but as far as the Internet tells me, some of the central qualities of Mannerist painting are:
- Referencing sculpture instead of the human body.
- Monolithic backgrounds, often black.
- The Elongation/Distortion of Figures and Elements.
- An Exaggeration of Perspective; the use of Foreshortening to highlight or minimize certain parts of the body or objects in the composition.
- Emphasis on Sfumato, the softening of individual lines to replicate an out-of-focus view.
- Figura serpentinata; the twisting/coiling of the body to increase visual dynamism.
- Compositions which are either extremely dense with Figures or which blot out large sections of an environment to single-out a few Figures
- Painted Frames to compliment and decorate the work itself.
These assembled gestures combine to form an art world that, at its peak, seems scarcely human at all -- the example of Giuseppe Arcimboldo is instructive:

His portraiture takes the human shape of eyes, lips, brow, and duplicates it using a single class of object, being books, vegetables, seasonal nature, or one of the four elements -- Arcimboldo's work is Mannerism taken to its fevered conclusion, a dissection of the human being into shapes which are then presented as artificial elements. Classicism sought to harmonize geometric principles and anatomy into an idealized universalist zone which could accommodate spatial diversity; Mannerism seeks to atomize all particulars of a composition into discrete reflections of a distorted perspective, so that each brushstroke is reflected in all the other strokes, each element is mirrored in its sisters, yet with that mirroring there is a loss of an axial principle, and thus the entire image is ruled by an artificial assemblage of data-points, not a harmony -- muscles heave, limbs elongate, and man may himself be nothing more than a mineral vegetable which is masquerading the shape of an animal -- Classicism believes that the universe is ordered by a logical set of laws which apply evenly and democratically to all, while Mannerism believes in an order which is disordered, a nature which suffocates us in its collective coming-forth, where context dissolves into a nihilistic background of arbitrary equality -- all things being the same in essence, but not in proportion, the Mannerist painter cannot see why one must depict them with the Classicist uniformity, and so we are left with a distended reality, an overgrown greenhouse that is nevertheless chained in its opaque window panes -- as if a chicken grew to its full size while still inside its egg.
As to the place of Mannerism in cinema, I believe one has to look for three features which on the whole hold true:
- The Mannerist cinema does not take its own coherence for granted -- it sets down a charmed circle that each shot and element must exist within, and there is no deviance allowed outside of this circle -- the Mannerist cinema does not believe in an outside, but seeks to contain any possible outside within its own borders. This takes the form of immanent self-critique, self-reference, self-disclosure, self-destruction -- a narcissism of technique, an abolition of difference-as-such as well as a denial of the transcendental frame.
- The Mannerist cinema assumes an over-intellectualized posture in response to the prospect of a possible viewer -- Mannerism re-inscribes its manifesto into every possible scene, compulsively repeating its points with a high-degree of irony, whether situational, verbal or dramatic. As long as the Mannerist filmmaker lets you know that they are 'in' on their own jokes, you are allowed permission to laugh with the film and not at the film; this attitude applies to each camera movement, each staging, each performance.
- The Mannerist cinema juxtaposes the language of cliche and stereotype with the posture of didactic earnestness -- the Mannered character speaks with 'their own voice', but 'their own voice' can only exist in reference to a presupposed position. Feminism in the Mannerist film is unable to speak without using the words of a quasi-universalist patriarchy, and vice-versa -- all opposition in the Mannerist film is shown to be a false one, but the Hegelian synthesis is already assumed to have taken place as the condition for the existence of the Mannerist film itself -- so what the film becomes is a confirmation of its own disingenuous dichotomy, not an exploration or a journey or a positing of a problem; Mannerism is a thesis statement which begs its own questions.
For examples of Mannerist film, what immediately comes to mind are works like Ari Aster's Beau is Afraid, Greta Gerwig's Barbie, Lord and Miller's The Lego Movie, Santos/Powers/Thompson's Across The Spider-Verse, Vaughn's Argyle and Kingsman trilogy -- and before one gets the impression that this Mannerism simply entails 'things that Yui does not like', I must include as Mannerist films such works as Lana Wachowski's Matrix Resurrections, Liman's Edge of Tomorrow, Shyamalan's Glass, or Vogt-Roberts' Kong: Skull Island.
I find it hard to look back at pre-2010s cinema and find much evidence of Mannerism -- there's something about it that seems to have grown up around the internet, around companies like A24, around certain directors. What fascinates me is how Mannerist films present this smooth surface of caricatured images -- as if there are two images, the actual image and its false double, and the Mannerist director chooses to only show the double-image, the duplication. This feeling of duplicity has me suspect that Mannerism is sort of a predecessor to, ahem, 'AI art' -- the way that Midjourney images are always a deliberate amalgam of a hundred or thousand other images correlated with linguistic descriptors which are then used to match a text input by the user. 'AI art' doesn't provide a single image, but rather an 'image of images', a double-triple-quadruple cross-reference which emerges in a single frame -- does this not reflect something of Mannerist painting and cinematic Mannerism? Arcimboldo's Vertumnus is, in a way, the 'AI art' of its time -- an assemblage of curated manners, a disassociation of perspective, a collapse of reality into elements which, through their friction, end up creating an illusion of artificial play, taking the frame of art as a sort of buffet or inventory menu instead of as a holistic network of relations -- the relation of images in their own isolation supersedes the potency of any one image, even if it attempts to be totalizing -- so what you get with 'AI art' and Mannerism is a perception-out-of-joint, a perception of an immobile molecule affixed to the wall of materialism like pinned butterfly wings, which seems somewhat terminal in the case of film given that cinema is literally 'motion pictures'.
In the history of painting, Mannerism is seen as the adolescent bridge between Classicism -- a philosophic art -- and Baroque -- a theatrical art. Classicism emphasized stillness, repose, the moment before or after an event which can be carefully documented by the painter -- Baroque takes its object to be precisely that event, the turmoil of a bird in-flight or the artist within his world.

Diego Velázquez's iconic Las Meninas is able to capture the history of art, the subjects of art, the artist himself, and also do it all within the space of art, yet still containing a refreshing sense of play and openness, the light is allowed into the darkness of the studio space, there is an outside -- so if we are in a Mannerist moment, does that mean there is a Baroque moment to come? Given that cinema has to follow its own path, and that said path is occurring centuries after the full maturity of painting as an artform, we might suspect the answer to be no -- but perhaps Baroque already exists in film, a tendency just like Mannerism. Killers of the Flower Moon or Historie(s) du Cinema come to mind as Baroque works -- the level of ornate detail and insight, the immanence, the sense of grandiosity and excess.
As I explore both cinema and painting, I find both arts to illuminate one another with a shining cheer and curious coincidence -- I have no doubt that I will have more to say on Mannerism in the near future.
Files
Previews only