Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

The crucial facet of Spike Lee's Do the Right Thing, to me at least, seems to be its insistence on the spatial and temporal continuity of the community it depicts. In a striking resemblance to King Vidor's classic 1931 film Street Scene, we follow the ins and outs of a small section of New York City over the course of a day, we chart the behavioral routines that can take place, the chance encounters, the way small grievances spiral into tragedy, the way individual actions can create collective moments.

Lee's confrontational directness shares a great deal with a director like Vidor, but also seems more immediately connected with Godard's post-1968 radical work like Tout Via Bien, where a desire for illustrating social consciousness collides with a pop-art style, characters often didactically speaking not only to each other but specifically to the audience, a wealth of asides affording us a panoramic insight which is usually denied to our personal viewpoint in day-to-day life -- we can never be in every place at the same time, but Spike Lee's film aspires towards the ideal of 'total cinema', where the camera-eye can show us the impossible within the immediate and necessary -- but instead of seeing this as a form of harmony, Lee uses this ideal to show how racial discord in America is an atmospheric element which finds specific inflections in otherwise mundane events: a visit to a pizza parlor can have dire consequences, internal feelings can quickly boil over the course of a day into a readiness for violence, and the casual discourse, the flippancy that we often treat each other with, always has consequences; the personal becomes political when our social environment leaves us with no other avenue for expression except for a frustrated dream of change.

Lee ends this picture not on the easy climax of Sal's pizzeria burning down in cathartic destruction, but on the day after, when things 'return to normal' and everyone has to pick up the pieces -- Mookie, formerly a pizza courier for Sal, and the man who annihilated his pizzeria rather than see Sal be the target of violence, is now compelled to demand his wages from his ex-employer. They don't come to any sort of profound understanding after this experience -- Mookie's got to find another job to support his wife and kid, and Sal has to start over from scratch after his fifteen year-old business has been taken away from him. They both get to walk away and live another day, but their sacrifice is economic and personal -- their genial father-son relationship will never be that same way again, all because of Sal's casual rudeness to some of his customers, one of whom, Radio Raheem, becomes a victim of NYPD brutality -- Lee lingers in the wake of this devastation because he wants to make a film which considers violence and racism beyond the typical Hollywood dramatic resolution, he shows us that none of what we've seen really 'solved' anything, but was merely another reshuffling of the situation, where prejudices become inflamed and hardened in response to conflict -- yet he also wants us to remember that a small business owner's private property doesn't really compare to the life of a man.

Like Godard, Lee isn't afraid to turn his film into a critique of other films -- the pictures of Al Pacino and Robert De Niro in Sal's pizzeria and the Scorsese-esque needledrops recall films like Mean Streets and The Godfather, which presented one version of what was deemed 'white ethnic' (aka non-protestant/non-anglo-saxon) life -- yet in the world Lee shows, the Italian-Americans don't just exist in relation to other white people: this city belongs to African-Americans, Korean immigrants, Puerto Ricans, and so many others as well, the communities which rarely receive the romanticization that Spike Lee knows directors like Coppola and Scorsese bestowed upon their own ethnicities.

Lee's genius insight is not to battle romanticism with more romanticism, though -- he'd rather see that edifice destroyed, knowing that it wasn't made by African-American artists for their own empowerment, but to facilitate a certain narrative for 'white ethnic' Americans looking to ingratiate their narratives into the larger white American tradition of storytelling.

Do the Right Thing isn't a one-note film -- it's a work of many different instruments conducting in the same symphony, rising and falling in pitch but always attuned to the individuals composing it, not shying away from America's diversity but also running head-on into its divisions, and never pretending to have the 'solution', the secret magick bullet to cure bigotry -- Lee's got a bigger aspiration than that, he wants the film to be unresolved so that there can be action and resolution outside of the cinema due to the film's incisive portrayal of these social contradictions. It's an open question, not a thesis statement, a movement and not a conclusion -- Lee wants a film like this or Bamboozled to create a space for conversation by showing a stark, approachably casual drama that doesn't mince words -- between the shouting and the swearing, the nuance rings louder and harsher, and we cannot avoid the juxtapositions he presents to us, the twin conclusions of Dr. King and Malcolm X, holding enough room for two opposing ideas that speak the truth: violence of speech and action can prevent understanding and progress, yet that violence is often the only way to break out of a deadlock and to reveal concealed problems. We can't abandon either of these truths: the tension between them is a productive tension, and we can either acknowledge them and ride it like a wave, or not, and drown beneath the waves of unconsciousness -- a love of justice is indistinguishable from a hatred of injustice.

Files

Previews only

Comments