The Conservatism of Synchronized Sound (Patreon)
Content
As I do preliminary work on my next film project, I am compelled to dwell on the question of sound, which is an element of the cinema that I have grown increasingly uncomfortable with.
There was a time where I played around with the idea that sound itself was inherently a 'mistake', a regression in the filmic medium. Now that I know more about the early days of talkies, I can see that regression has more to do with the Great Depression and the consolidation of technology and talent under the studio systems of America, Germany, etc.. Sound itself was merely an element which fostered this change, but it wasn't at the crux of it -- as Bazin says, it merely added to a film's 'realism' in a way that has never really been replicated, not even with widescreen ratios or 3D or IMAX.
Yet it is this 'realism' that I've begun to seriously take issue with. For one thing, a cinematic image is as 'real' as anything else, subject to the laws of physics, the labor of artists, playing a role in the economies of the world, it is inherently 'realistic' just as a painting is 'realistic' as an object within space and time; it exists, so it is real.
So what does synchronized sound do to create an aura of realism instead of the obvious fact of realism? Well, it implies a spatial extension of what the image is already telling us: if a character in a film drops a bucket, we don't even think about the clanging noise it makes when it hits the ground, we just assume that whatever we see has a matching sound attached to it.
As much as the visual images of cinema have been advanced, we haven't really seen that many interesting uses of sound -- why does the sound image have to directly correspond to the rest of the film's images? The post-MTV era of film, where everything is accompanied by symmetrical needledrops to deepen the intended 'mood' of a moment is just a further literalization of this synch-sound technique -- yet what is more 'artificial' than this? And whence arises Bazin's 'realism'?
Synchronized sound has always been an imposition on cinema since its beginning, it is a direct continuation of the bourgeois novel, academic painting, the assumption that each image has a matching sound image, and that's just good politics if you want an audience to go along with you.
What if we do something different? What if the sound image is allowed its own autonomy, running parallel with the visual part of the film but not synchronized with it? Why not tell one story with the sound, and another story with the images? This could be an even more advanced rendition of Eisenstein's dialectical montage -- the audience is left to either observe the discordance between these two elements, or to invent their own synthesis, having to pay attention separately to two sensory planes, not relying on the expectation that they must reflect on another -- that if a tree falls on the screen, it has to make a sound.
I am also thinking about the 'second-screen' phenomenon created by streaming services, where one is only half paying attention to what one is watching, otherwise looking at one's phone and listening to the audio, expecting the audio to communicate something in absence of their full attention.
What I would like to do is make a film where you couldn't do this 'second-screen' viewing -- if you only listened to the sound, you would have no idea what you're seeing.
This way, I imagine, you would actually force the viewer to engage with the film more directly, the demand is greater on the images BECAUSE the sound is autonomous! So then the image is allowed to be the pure image, and the sound is allowed to be the pure sound -- even silent films, which were of course almost always accompanied by musical scores, lacked this severance.
That's something I want to experiment in this second film: let every element in a film be what it needs to be without the chauvinistic assumption for aesthetic 'realism' or naturalism, without the repetition of elements acting redundantly in relation to one another. If this can be done on a feature-length scale, we can have films of a much greater density and complexity than what we've seen for the past 150 years.
Files
Previews only