Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

One can, in fits of naïve exuberance and recklessness, see the art of death, the craft of destruction, a craft to which we are intimately familiar with today’s media landscape to the extent that it becomes invisible. A fish cannot perceive that it lives within an ocean, as it knows no life out of water save for complete destruction; so too follows the civilized man, who, for the past three-hundred and fifty-odd years, has known no culture save for the culture of death itself, a cozy intimacy with death to save us from otherwise being dead.

Edgar G. Ulmer’s The Black Cat is one of the few self-aware instances of a pop culture examination of our thanatotic neurosis. It is the horror of mass slaughter that lies in the background of our film’s first central couplet, as they take their honeymoon by train through the Hungarian countryside. And yet it is not the countryside, it is not simply a background, this context is perhaps more central to The Black Cat than this bland couple, it overdetermines them and threatens to consume them entirely. These two Americans are hopelessly stupid, and they are the future to come, they are every tourist and global citizen who sees places like Hungary’s muddy slopes as the texture to an interpersonal saga, the lifeless mass of a world fit only for photos and architecture, not for life, human or otherwise. The wasteland where nothing happens save for arrivals and departures.

Bela Lugosi’s Dr. Vitus calls this wasteland home. He calls every wasteland home; he’s spent the last 15 years in a Siberian prison camp after The War. He is, of course, the Old Europe, the Europe of Constantine and Charlemagne and Aquinas and Agrippa and Hobbes. The total Europe, and obviously according to his name, the living Europe, or decaying, at this point. Dr. Vitus carries all the menacing baggage of Count Dracula without any of the power, he is a wraith in these newlywed’s train compartment, an unwanted guest who nevertheless must be reckoned and accommodated. The Great War has emptied him, and the prison camp has been killing him. The way he looks at the young wife is as someone who hasn’t seen such beauty in eons. The War destroyed it, and the camp denied it. He’s self-conscious about this, embarrassed of his earnest caressing of her delicate hair. They are passing between each other’s worlds, the old and new, and it entails danger for both of them. Vitus knows this.

Their bus ride crashes, inevitably, during a Dark and Stormy night, and the couple and Doctor pay a visit to Boris Karloff’s Poelzig, a famous Austrian architect. This is the man that the Doctor wishes to see, and it will be the last man he sees. Poelzig offers them succor in his home, and proceeds to plan their ruin immediately. He will dispose of the husband, sacrifice the wife, and play a game with his old friend, just like they did in The War. That game was of survival, and now they play a game of death. And there is the home.

This home of Poelzig’s IS the film, it upstages Karloff and Lugosi and anything else. Built atop the old ruins of Fort Marmorus, to which Poelzig betrayed to the Russian army during The War, lies a clean home, a modern architectural marvel, an Art Deco funeral parlor. Beneath the impossibly-smooth surfaces and steel and plastic is the wound of The War, and Poelzig’s prize: a series of young women, corpses kept in pristine class cabinets of sharp geometric lines, their bodies suspended from the ground as if their spines were pulled up by invisible meat hooks. This is the foundation of Poelzig’s architectural design; the old gothic castles prided themselves on the rising arches, the ornamental gargoyles, the mile-high stained-glass windows that reflected hundreds of glorious biblical colors into the darkened interiors, flying buttresses of Christ’s ascension. Poelzig’s house is similarly vertical, but in the reverse: his modernist home is horizontal on the surface, unassuming, melting into a hill-top squat, and everything else is below, the hell chambers of dead women are kept down, down in the dark halls only given shape by the hum of electric current. Instead of creating an emblem of divinity, he’s settled for a museum of carnage. Poelzig sacrifices these woman in Satanic rituals, then keeps their beauty embalmed for eternity. They aren’t allowed to live, they aren’t allowed to truly die, they’re kept down in his personal curation forever, rendered still and silent, passive objects to be contemplated and gawked at, femininity consumed and regurgitated as parody, a Kantian exhibition of clipped butterflies.

We all know what causes this, why Poelzig and Dr. Vitus need to be played by Karloff and Lugosi. The quaint horrors of Old Europe, the monster in the woods and in the castle and on the margins, cannot hope to compare to the atrocities seen in The War. A monster will destroy you, personally and utterly eviscerate your very being, but it will recognize you, it will have a relation with you, it is an intimate destruction, a romantic conception of the evil as an identifiable cause who generates horrifying effects, a horror borne of Enlightenment philosophy. You will be destroyed by a monster, but the monster is an approximation of a human being, a prevision, but a human nonetheless. Frankenstein’s Monster is, of course, the Promethean image of Man, Dracula was once a noble man, there is a legacy of demihumans in horror fiction that allows these characters a degree of dignity, an anthropocentric lens by which the audience finds the uncanny nestled between the human and non-human.

The Black Cat finds that dialectic to be obsolete. The Whig historian’s notion of human progress has lead to the annihilation of millions for the sake of the European state apparatus, the so-called Enlightenment has, far from banishing the shadows of the past, instead extended them into the depths of the soul itself. Rifles, bombs, planes and gas kill you without you ever having to lay eyes upon the man who made the choice to do so, war on behalf of the nation becomes an excuse to thin-out the population of the working class and reduce the political bargaining power of their labor force. The supposed dignity and rights of man have now been laid to waste by imperial and colonial hegemony, there is no rational man standing astride nature to behold the culmination of his epoch, the human is an incident of history, an accident of biology, an embarrassment to divinity, a superfluous watery excremental side-effect of capitalism’s generation of profit.

Poelzig and Vitus are the distended afterbirth of this systematic, and they know it. They know that the married couple represent a cold and distant future in which the human being occupies a superfluous position, an imaginary body politic dominated by the surface, the image, the rule by consensus, the promise of even further mayhem and madness on a scale that makes The Great War seem like child’s play, the oncoming holocausts giving way to a state of eternal war. Not a world of the human and non-human, but the machine and non-machine. These are the progeny that have been wrought by The War, the 20th century’s Aeon of Horus coming into existence atop a mountain of corpses and bullets. So can it be surprising that Poelzig turns to Satanic practices, that Vitus’ PTSD emerges as soon as he spies a dark feline skulking about this modernist mansion? These are not monsters, they are men, broken men who have been broken and only know how to brake others. The popular notion of Satanic black magick was encouraged later in the century by hucksters and CIA agents as a sort of religious ‘Will to Power’, a corrupted form of Crowley’s spiritual understanding that held one’s self to be the supreme agent in this world. Yet Poelzig doesn’t even have a self any longer, he’s a ghost in his own home, he only becomes animated when his robotic routine of ritual embalming is interrupted by Vitus’ quest for revenge. And what are we to make of Vitus? Clearly equally a broken man, but enlivened by a drive of hatred, which Poelzig ridicules after Vitus pulls a gun on him within the dark halls of his home:

“Come Vitus; are we men or are we children?” he chides, “Of what use are all these melodramatic gestures? You say your soul was killed, that you have been dead all these years. And what of me? Did both of us not die here in Marmorus fifteen years ago? Are we any less victims of war than those bodies turn asunder? Are we not both the living dead? And now you come to me, playing the game of the ‘Avenging Angel’, childishly thirsting for my blood. We understand each other too well. We know too much of life.”

Two un-dead souls who know too much of life? How could those who have experienced the heinous deaths of The War know too much of life, rather than too little? Poelzig refers to their obsolete status, however, as the mortal leftovers of an irrational game, a game that they must play between themselves in order to have any measure of peace. The newlywed couple does escape, yes, thanks to Vitus and his man-servant intervening during the ritual sacrifice of the narcotic and dazed wife. But Vitus and Poelzig are destined to bury themselves in this place, they understand each other too well. They’re both relics of a different world, a world where the human life wasn’t completely seen as a component part of some larger apparatus, a world where the undead were Byronic individuals who stood apart from the social body, rather than a gross product of that society’s ceaseless movement. Frankenstein and Dracula could be noble, they had aspirations and desires and a fully realized articulation of themselves, they had a reason to exist even if it was denied to them. Poelzig and Vitus are shattered zombies shambling pointlessly around Europe, they only exist for the other, only they can understand their own pain at being spat out of the World Soul.

They know too much of life to ever be comfortable with the ambient world of death that the newlyweds exist in. They are undead, but they wish they were dead, and they grant each other that wish at the film’s climax. It was a fait accompli before they even had a choice, and perhaps that is their greatest tragedy: they never were able to have the agency to take on the mantle of monstrosity. It was imposed upon them like it was imposed upon millions of soldiers, the task of wielding the grand gears of warfare on a scale never seen before, the anonymous extermination of mankind, the purest alienation possible. Vitus was a psychiatrist, Poelzig was an architect, and these two men who wanted to construct the inner and outer sanctums of their lives were forced instead to see the apocalyptic obliteration of everything they knew and loved. Vitus activates the explosives wired underneath Poelzig’s house, leaving no trace of the home or the heath it was built upon, but not before he flays the man alive with the knife that Poelzig used to hollow-out the corpse of Vitus’ wife. “It has been a good game.” Vitus opines, then perishes. They were both cursed to finish out this game, but never to be its players. Why did the black cat frighten Vitus? Perhaps it promised too much elan vital, the grace of eight more lives than man could ever hope to live, eight more chances to redeem the irredeemable.



(Requested by Paul Mirek, a Patron. Thank you Paul!)

Comments

Paul Mirek

Thank you for writing so beautifully about this. The stench of death that pervades it feels inseparable from its mournful vision of untapped human potential, which makes the tragedy that much greater. The image that jumps to my mind first whenever I think about it is that of the spiraling stairs leading down into the hall of horrors--it's such a spare shot but chilling, the ultimate descent in both inner and outer space. And in reference to the new consuming the old, I find it hilarious that they took the title of the Edgar Allan Poe short story, kept the cat, and threw out everything else.

Comrade Yui

I love how that spiral staircase seems to coil like a strand of DNA between the above and below portions of the house, inexorably linking them together in a shared heritage!