GORILLA WARFARE; or, Kong: Skull Island (2017) (Patreon)
Content

There is no longer such a thing as cinematic mystery. The intricacies of casting, pre-and-post production, filming, intellectual property, profit, failure, and all the other bells and whistles are readily available to the Average Jane via the copious content-farms of pop culture websites, celebrity gossip and box office analysis. The movie mystique, the esoteric quality and appeal of an actor or director, has been more or less vaporized, a romantic relic of the 20th century. Now the cinema is fully transparent to the audience; they know who will be in the film, what the script is about, and how much money it’ll make, all of this is understood to the savvy movie goer the second that they sit down in the theater. In some semblance, all this data about movies is the majorly important product of Hollywood, not necessary the films themselves. The data is the cycle, the leaked rumors of so-and-so being cast as such-and-such character likely generate more online advertising revenue than a movie will ever make from purchased tickets. The mystique, it could be said, was the idea that the film itself was the central object of fascination, the McLuhan-esque hypnotic medium that instructed the teeming public in visual literacy, all those butts in seats bewitched by silver-screen stars and double-feature dates at the drive-in. Now, you likely see most films at home, on your computer, and if you’re smart, you don’t pay for any of it. The theatrical experience is dying, if not dead; you can know everything about a film from its Wikipedia page or sub-Reddit before it even has a release date. Unless you’ve been in a coma for the past 15 years, there’s nothing left for you to experience with a film, only assumptions and expectations to be confirmed while watching, empty boxes on your cinephilic check-list.
When I look back on the nascent stages of this reality I’ve just described, Kong: Skull Island feels like a bellwether of things to come. If you’d ask Average Jane in 2017 if she was interested in another King Kong film, she’d likely shrug in indifference, and already know what she was in for before she ever saw the trailer, and she'd be right. Typical for this epoch of franchise properties, it was only the second film by a Sundance director, Jordan Vogt-Roberts, who was unknown to basically anyone breathing outside of the film festival crowd. He acquits himself amiably with the monster picture: he leans into the heavily green-screened fakery, bringing a slow-mo sequential approach that’s equal parts Zack Snyder and Metal Gear Solid, or equal parts Princess Mononoke and Francis Ford Coppola, or equal parts Evangelion and… some of these parts are more equal than others. Vogt-Roberts overstuffs this with practically every damn fanboyish flourish that you could think of; most of it works, not all of it does. He directs Kong: Skull Island as if it’s the last film that he’s going to ever make, which, in an era of disposable auteurs, is an attitude that I can understand and respect. As a work of popular entertainment, it more than justifies itself with kinetic bravado, and wears its heart on its sleeve as a stitched-together amalgam of things that, individually, you probably enjoy more, but still like seeing Xeroxed into something else.
All of these influences cobbled together makes you wonder if Vogt-Roberts himself has a distinct voice, and in-between the crass visual jokes and first-person camera angles, he finds a propulsive niche that’s just unique enough for this to separate itself from the horde of generic nobodies that usually get tasked with making these flagship franchises. It must be said that this couldn’t be more different from the dour and dreary Gareth Edwards Godzilla film from a few years prior: that film had something to ‘say’, but Kong: Skull Island just SAYS it, whatever that dubious ‘it’ is, and is better off for that stupidity. As said before, the videogame influence is very strong here, trading in broad Vietnam cliché similar to the way that games like Call of Duty: Black Ops use a Vietnam period setting merely as an excuse to have a different weapon arsenal for the player to shoot. Each action sequence here is weighty, punchy, designed to look great rather than necessarily communicate anything. Each character is a smartass know-it-all and a fair number of them bite the bullet in entertaining ways. Every actor might as well be in a videogame cutscene; after the first 20 minutes, none of them feel like they’re in the same room as each other, much less in the remote jungles of Skull Island.
And oh, what an island it is. When comparing this to the original 1933 film and the 2005 Peter Jackson remake, this is pleasantly mythic as opposed to unilaterally horrifying. Those two previous films were epic adventure-horror sagas, behemoths ruled by cutting-edge stop-motion and motion-capture and self-important scale; Skull Island does not wish to reinvent this wheel, so instead Vogt-Roberts and his excellent marshaling of Industrial Light and Magic serve to render the titular isle as a flattened theme park ride rather than as a living ecosystem. The characters waddle around, occasionally encounter a titanic creature, marvel at its glory, then move on to the next one. It’s a film of episodes, fragments of a story, a sketchbook of character and idea, but a pleasing idea nonetheless, an undemanding yet fun tourist trap. If Vogt-Roberts is a director of anything, he is an excellent storyboard artist, because he’s in love with the pure idiocy of image-making. Tom Hiddleston wearing a gas-mask and swinging a katana through toxic fumes and flying reptiles, King Kong facing off against a fleet of helicopters with the halo of a setting sun behind him, a .50 caliber machine gun mounted atop a Triceratops skull in a prehistoric graveyard, all of these short segments more than justify the existence of the movie by themselves.
But what about the elements that don’t work? One only has to look into the (post?) colonial obligations of the film to see what is innately wrong about contemporary blockbusters. All throughout the movie, Vogt-Roberts is constantly bringing our attention to Brie Larson’s intrepid Vietnam photojournalist and her visual documentation of the events occurring. She takes golden-hour photos of the escorting Army unit atop their traveling ship with equal care to photographing the Iwi native peoples who somehow manage to survive in one of Skull Island’s only human settlements, which is thankfully protected by the generous grace of the big ape himself. It would be easy to repeat the mistakes of the past here in regards to this subject, as the 1933 classic Kong has the natives of Skull Island reflect all the most terrible colonizer stereotypes of that time, and the 2005 film makes them into monstrously scary creatures equal in inhumanity to the cold-blooded dinosaurs and insects that stalk the deeper recesses of the locale. Vogt-Roberts, thankfully, doesn’t even begin to approach either of these portrayals; he’s making a kaiju film here, not a monster movie. Kong: Skull Island has more in common with the brightly-colored 60s Toho Studios pictures than the grimy indelicacies of its American forefathers. This leads to the Skull Island natives being the passive anthropological subjects of Brie Larson’s photo reel, barely moving, barely emoting, not saying a word, solely existing in the film because, hey, a King Kong movie has to have ‘savages’ in it, right? No, it doesn’t, but this particular inclusion tells you clearly that the people behind these films care more about repeating people’s expectations of what a franchise film should have in it rather than actually doing anything interesting with those expected aspects. The result of this passive approach is that the Iwi natives are rendered into an inert part of the background of Skull Island, an ‘exotic’ flavoring to accompany the artbook tapestry of monsters that the rest of the runtime cycles though.
We could be generous and see this ‘agnostic’ approach to the natives as ‘better than the alternatives’, but we should honestly expect better, way better. Brie Larson’s photographer ends up creating the vista of American imperialism that sees the ‘Other’ of the East as a cool-looking aesthetic, an object to be conquered and re-contextualized through the taking of the image. In her theoretical travelogue of Skull Island, the diverse subjectivities of American soldiers, Asiatic mountain ranges, native villagers and colossal apes all get painted with the same brush. In the narrative context of the script, she’s an ‘anti-war photographer’, but she fundamentally has no place in the movie other than to be a visual framework for how we’re supposed to perceive things. She’s as ‘neutral’, passive, and ‘objective’ as the satellite photos that lead our main characters to go and seek out Skull Island’s mysteries in the first place. But what results from all that passivity is the death of dozens of people being some place that they absolutely shouldn’t be in, and the future implication that the rest of humanity, particularly America, will see the discovery of Skull Island as a potential resource to be exploited. The potential for a critique of this attitude is within the film, the textual material is there to state something about the post-colonial ease at which every single corner of the globe finds itself rendered in the service of capitalism’s relentless quest to exhaust all of human social relation into the vortex of the profit motive.
Let’s not neglect that Monarch, the film’s fictional organization that researches all of these ‘Titans’, is wanting to travel to Skull Island for the sake of “Resources, medicine, the cure for cancer, geological discoveries.” And the film similarly treats its human characters as an apparatus for seeing a panoply of digital beasts and hearing the most stereotypical 70s needledrops. All of this garnish for the main meal, and yet Kong is, within this work, an objectified advertisement. You don’t need to put him chained-up and on display in New York anymore, he’s not just for the theater seats of Broadway. Kong: Skull Island plays at the idea of sensational mystique, but at the end of the day it’s aware of its own status as a disposable stepping-stone for the dictated future of this ‘cinematic universe’, and that is itself a minor tragedy, as it could have had license to do something more daring with its iconography instead of rehashing the same basic ideas as all the other Kong pictures. You don’t need to have Skull Island’s natives in a King Kong film anymore, because even if you don’t exploit their image, you’ll exploit Kong’s just as well. He’s chained to the successful formula that his producers and shareholders want repeated, as if almost a century of big monkey stories wasn’t enough for an ‘insatiable’ audience. Beauty couldn’t kill this beast if it tried, not as long as people like Vogt-Roberts convince themselves that lightning can, and will, strike twice. Maybe that’s the mystique of the character, the essential illusion that will just not let us go.
Forget the 8th Wonder Of The World; he’s just another special effect.