FEEL THE NOISE; or, Singin' in the Rain (1952) (Patreon)
Content
Hollywood films which are about Hollywood can either be some of the most beloved statements of self-consciousness for cinephiles, or extremely annoying indulgences that make one wonder why you enjoy films in the first place. 1952’s Singin’ in the Rain, thankfully, is of the former sort, and is not merely a nod to, what was at the time, the classic 1920s industry of yesteryear, but also a structural nod to it as well, a highly intelligent mediation on 20s (and then early 30s) cinema that strikes a harmonious beat between lionization and critique.
As an object of fascination, Singin’ in the Rain occupies a developmental territory in Hollywood that it is extremely aware of. It’s a glamorous musical about the emergence of the basic technical capacity that allowed musicals to even exist as a genre, this being the advent of filmic sound, and it is also a beautifully rendered Technicolor extravaganza in its own time in which three-strip Technicolor was in its prime. Over 90 films in 1952 alone were released using three-strip Technicolor, including The Quiet Man, and only a few years later the process would be replaced entirely by Eastmancolor, so just as Singin’ in the Rain documents the painful and messy transition period between two technical formats of popular cinema, it itself is perhaps the highest example of its own particular format of an expensive and lush Technicolor musical that was plenty in vogue in the 1950s.
To wit, as its instrumental historical focus, Singin’ in the Rain places the ‘blame’ of sound cinema’s victory over the 20s Silents squarely upon the shoulders of 1927’s The Jazz Singer, which marked the commercial ascendance of synchronized sound as a way to, above all else, merge the singing of performers with the music of theater into one smooth continuous process. Coincidentally, the same year that Singin’ in the Rain considers the historical importance of The Jazz Singer, a 1952 Technicolor remake of The Jazz Singer is also released; an ouroboros if there ever was one, and one imagines that the producers and writers of Singin’ in the Rain were more than aware of this fact.
Historical precedent aside, and making note of the fact that Singin’ in the Rain is ‘just’ a really entertaining film, fun, very light on its feet (and, rarely for a musical, quite short), what I find most interesting about the film is how it uses its own narrative to elegantly explain why different types of film production pose different challenges and unique effects upon the audience.
To place Silent Cinema against Sound Cinema, one would think that the fundamental disagreement between them, formally, is that one has a focus on the auditory, and one on the non-auditory, but this isn’t true when phenomenologically understood, as silent films were almost always accompanied by a non-synchronized musical score, or a live band, or, as it was in Japanese Silents, a live performer who would give stirring narration to the film and was quite a noted figure in their own right. So silent films were never just ‘pure image’ as such, they were not divorced from sound, but out of step with it, inconsiderate as to what affects that it would have. When a silent film director directed and assembled their film with their editors, they didn’t really give a damn as to what the musical accompaniment was, because why would you? It’s entirely out of your control, your film is distributed and could be played alongside hundreds of different auditory sequences that you don’t always have an influence on, even if you pulled a D.W. Griffith and went on these huge roadshows. Griffith wasn’t a composer, he could select the composer, but that composer, when they composed and played, would play, even slightly, a different soundtrack to the film every time, no two performances are the same. The Silents were thus always with Sound itself, but not ‘of’ Sound, not constituted by it, their language was not bound by the rhythmic beat of music or the tempo of human conversation. Thus, paradoxically, the Silents were actually more ‘literary’ than Sound Cinema, through the constant usage of title cards, description, and dialogue cards; everything that couldn’t be symbolically communicated with the image had to be explicitly stated with language. You can literally read a Silent in the way that’s impossible with a Sound film, it’s an open book.
Think of it like this; if you’re reading a novel, you’re reading the author’s text, yes, the prose that they designed and arranged to be read in a certain order, but what they don’t have control over is you, the reader. You read the book in your own internal voice, you’re in an act of constant translation with the text, you’re converting it from ‘What the Author Wrote’ to ‘What I’m Reading’, and so, if the author had a certain idea for how a character speaks and ‘sounds’, that conception would be completely different from how you interpret that character sounds; thus is the often phenomenon which occurs when fans of a book live to see that book get adapted to film and quibble with certain casting or visual elements, as it literally wasn’t ‘what they had in mind’. Silent cinema is of literature in the sense that it must by necessity have a hard contrast between the abstraction of its image and the explicitness of its words, they are in association, but not strictly bound together; when you are watching a Silent, you are experiencing both photography and literature at the same time. For Sound, this entire distinction collapses.
Singin’ in the Rain’s climax illustrates this beautifully. Debbie Reynolds’ Kathy, a great theater performer who, via Gene Kelly-as-Don Lockwood’s assistance, gets involved in the movie business by dubbing the terrible voice of Silent star Lina Lamont in her latest release which has retroactively become a Sound musical. Kathy obviously has reservations about doing this for her whole career, and wants to be a performer on screen like she is on the stage, but Lina exercises her studio contract to keep Kathy locked in as her vocal replacement, much to Kathy’s chagrin. At the Chinese Theater premiere of their film, The Dancing Cavalier, the audience is absolutely in love with the now-present voice of ‘Lina’, and they beckon that she perform a live song on the stage so they can celebrate her ‘talent’. Kathy sings backstage while Lina lip-syncs to the lyrics of the performance, until Don and the gang contrive to raise the curtain separating them and exposes Lina as not being the one who did the auditory performance that the premiere audience adored. The audience laughs and dismisses the beautiful Silent star Lina, and all the accolades and love is then heaped upon a new potential Sound star, Kathy.
This, then, for Singin’ in the Rain, is the beginning of the truly ‘theatrical’ film, film-as-live-theater, as Kathy is a stage performer who is able to actually do the things on film that she can do in-person, her performance can be, more or less, entirely replicated on screen, thanks to synchronized sound technology. Far from just being Lina’s ‘voice’, Kathy becomes the new type of performer that Hollywood requires going forward, someone who isn’t merely a pure ‘image’, but someone who ‘performs’ with the totality of their self, a fully transparent individual, a figure that the filmmaking apparatus can now quantify and quality beyond the notion of image-as-such.
For a Silent star like Lina, it was enough to be a physical presence, it was enough to be a beauty that an audience member could read their own voice into, it was enough to sometimes be a symbolic character and sometimes be a literal one, but those two types of characters were never exactly the same person, one was an icon, and the other was a work of literature, and the audience was asked to bridge the gap between the two, to impose their own subjectivities in between. But for a Sound star like Kathy, that interpretive act has been rendered unnecessary, what you see is also what you hear, she is ‘objectified’ as a figure who is entirely contained within the film, she is present-at-hand to the viewer and not ‘of’ the viewer’s own access, her theatrical quality is somehow more solid and fixed, Sound generally requires that the image be matched with the appropriate and accompanying sound, so when Kathy speaks or acts, her sound then must follow suit, the relationship of cause-and-effect relays a reality to the viewer that is identifiable with the viewer’s own experience of consensus reality, but still remains at a distance by the inherent nature of the cinematic medium, the viewer participates in watching and hearing the Sound film but no longer participates in being WITHIN the medium as they would with the Silent film. In a strange and disturbing way, Sound film has bridged the gap between one’s own lived experience and the fiction of movies, but this heightens the dissonance that one is able to feel when sound and image are not in accord. The technical complexity of film as an art increases with the advent of synchronized sound in order to maintain the illusion of naturalism, but the potential for contradiction between image and sound also increases. Movies can now feel ‘unreal’, but also ‘realer than reality itself’, reaching towards Platonic Forms, stripping us from the everyday world and generating another parallel world; a world where the colors are brighter, everyone’s singing songs, and there’s always a happy ending.
(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thank you Freddy!
Files
Previews only