Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Beyond even the mighty contributions of a singular, talented artist, the best and most fruitful cinematic wonders are frequently to be credited in the collaborative relationship between a director and their  actor: the Johns Ford and Wayne, Tony Scott and Denzel Washington, Carpenter and Kurt Russell, Scorsese and De Niro, Orson Welles and… Orson Welles. There is one of these relationships, however, that stands far above the rest in terms of sheer temporal concentration and high-wire energy: Marlene Dietrich and Josef von Sternberg. For seven films within six years, Sternberg and Dietrich spun a hyper-textual web of sensual exoticism, their work together embodying the feverish mischief of a Hollywood just beginning to adjust to the emergence of sound, and before the Hays Production Code was fully able to intensely regulate the content of these newly-vocal pictures. Works like Morocco, Shanghai Express, and The Scarlet Empress were opulently lavish pageants presented to audiences amidst the worst years of the Great Depression. To call these films ‘escapist’ is an understatement: increasingly with each film, Sternberg and Dietrich’s escalating dynamic of beautification turned these works from achingly romantic melodramas into quasi-mystical fables. Right in the middle of this elaboration is 1933’s Blonde Venus, a scintillating masterwork that simultaneously juggles the demands of a morality play with the sensationalist sexuality of poverty-row pulp magazines.

The central interplay of the film is the poverty-strike life of Dietrich’s cabaret singer-turned-mother having to prostitute herself on stage, and behind it, in order to provide enough money for a cure for her radiation-poisoned scientist husband and to support their somewhat creepy doll-like son Johnny. Her husband, the nebbishly-named Ned, becomes an infuriated cuckold after Dietrich’s Helen drops the cabaret act and elects to be the mistress of Cary Grant’s slick playboy Nick Townsend, and as audience members, we’re caught up in the contradiction that Helen finds herself in. In a blunt statement, Helen says to Nick, comparing him to Ned: “You’re strong, he’s not.” Her husband goes to Europe, is cured of his sickness, and returns to find his house empty and his family sequestered away in Nick’s country home estate. He’s justified in being mad about this, surely? But we see that Nick, outside of being played by an equally-beautiful actor to Helen’s, is ultimately a man of honor, and respects Helen’s loyalty to her husband. Nick’s in love, and he’s not shy about it, but he never tries to do anything but to earnestly support Helen and her son, both of whom he has a genuine affection for. Helen does take what she feels are the necessary actions to save her husband’s life, and all the while doing her cabaret show and never forgetting to take care of her son. Ned leaves her in frustration, tries to take custody of Johnny, and forces her to go on the run throughout the American South, as we see her forced into precariat sex work before an encounter with a detective that Ned hired finally forces her to voluntarily relinquish custody of Johnny, as she’d rather die alone in poverty than see him suffer.

All of that plotting appears on the surface to be fairly contrived just for the sake of pulling on one’s heart strings, but it’s the way that Sternberg brackets the whole damn thing that makes it an irresistible viewing experience. Blonde Venus opens with a primal scene, an encounter with seven young men in Germany’s notorious Black Forest with seven naked young women swimming alluringly within a pond. The romantic flirtations here dissolve promptly into a scene of Dietrich’s son playing in the bathtub as Dietrich’s Helen dotes upon him, a transposing of youthful eroticism into domestic pleasure. Helen and Ned are latter compelled by Johnny’s innocent desire for a bedtime story into telling him again a thinly-disguised version of how his parents met in the beginning scene, with the parents lovingly reflecting on the tale and Helen singing along with a music box to put Johnny to sleep. Later, in the ending of the film, Johnny more or less forces his parents to recount the story again, and Ned finds it in his heart to reconcile with the wounded image of Dietrich singing once more to the child she would sacrifice everything for. The final shot shows Johnny’s chubby fingers reaching out to the spinning wheel of the music box, his grasp seemingly animating the device that has reunited his family.

Is this Sternberg conceding to a certain stasis of the American nuclear family? In all his other collaborations with Dietrich, she’s always a ‘fallen woman’, a seductive succubus who enervates the lives of the men around her, for good or ill. Blonde Venus would seem to run against that current, with its filial reconciliation seeking to ‘redeem’ Dietrich’s actions, but this is far, far from the case. The onus of conflict is (much like in Antonioni’s films) the clash between the legalistic strictures of womanhood held by men and the actual fluidity and existential power held by women. Dietrich’s Helen makes no apologies or compromises in her actions: she accomplishes exactly what she wishes to, everything in Blonde Venus happens according to her terms, and she accepts whatever the consequences may be. Far from the bland, pure archetype of a mother figure, she embodies the multifaceted way that a woman may express her love and affection. She loves Cary Grant’s Nick for what he’s able to do to help her husband and son, but she never subordinates her desire to his sly will, she uses him to save the man she’s married to, even if she must present herself as a hysterical sexual object. In the infamous ‘Hot Voodoo’ music number, the first one that we see in Blonde Venus, Dietrich openly states her lack of middle class moralism:

“Did you ever happen to hear of voodoo? / Hear it and you won’t give a damn what you do / Tom-tom’s put me under a sort of voodoo / And the whole night long I don’t know right from wrong … / Hot voodoo, make me brave / I want to misbehave!”

She sings these bold words right after she emerges from a fucking gorilla suit: this is a woman without shame, without self-pity or self-admonishment. Her role as a loving mother hasn’t ‘tempered’ her fierce animalistic sexual power, but that is rather the image that her husband assumes that she’ll always exist in. Ned sees the debutante innocently swimming in the pond, he sees the mother crooning over the child’s crib, but he refuses to accept the bestial woman on stage, her swaying shoulders and suggestive gaze and glittering bodice. Blonde Venus does not bother trying to apologize for anything on Dietrich’s behalf; if anything, it’s the rest of the world that has to play catch-up with HER. She’s a maternal Babalon, yielding to what she feels is necessary and dealing with the flawed judgments around her without internalizing those attitudes and compromising her own sense of inner virtue. Dietrich never played another mother again in these Sternberg films, but the persona that she cultivated in each of these is equally pliable to any situation that her characters existed in. Like many a great screen icon, it was her persona that molded each film to what it needed to be, her iron-clad perfection as the righteous coquette was what allowed the rest of these films to be as extravagant and delirious as Sternberg needed them to be.

Sternberg, as the apex artist of the camera’s canvas, lingers his vision with purpose throughout the bourgeois clubs and poor hovels of the film. He gives everything here an insanely dense juxtaposition of light and shadow, oftentimes to the point of incoherency or obscuring the object of the frame. People are walking behind the main characters, in front of them, no one is isolated within a clear landscape, everything is moving through this detailed context. His technique, when not curving around the incredible close-ups of Dietrich’s angular cheekbones, shares the detached relaxation of Hou Hsiao-Hsien’s lengthy fixations. But whereas Hou is cool, documentarian, sparse, philosophical, Sternberg is constantly over-heated, his compositions are nonsensically cluttered and never sparse, his world barely feels like it has space for the human being to live in, it’s maximalist without being aggressive, provocative without embracing stupidity. Sternberg elaborates his spaces through layers, not through distance; if anything, his camera doesn’t have a definition of distance or establishing shots, its perspective is fully immersed into this decorative world. His notion of a domestic film’s aesthetic is one in which there’s darkness and glimmer, feather and lace, a silk stocking beneath a modest dress. Pre-Hays code films allowed this luxuriant perversity to last for a short period, and even today it feels risque in a modern landscape of de-sexed movie stars and sanitary scripts.

Blonde Venus is perhaps the most acceptably ‘classic’ of the Sternberg-Dietrich team-ups, but under no circumstances does that make it conventional. It, like its six sister films, is an exemplary clarion-call of feminine iconoclasm, the fecund birth of both glitzy camp and holistic artifice. For Sternberg, it represents his command of the screen even in a non-fantastical narrative, because he’ll make it into one regardless. For Dietrich, her portrayal of a morally-laudable sacred prostitute provides an intense psychological picture of womanhood in a way that some female stars never get to have in their entire careers.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Paul Mirek

Sternberg is regrettably one of my biggest blind spots but this sounds right up my alley.