FULL CIRCLE; or, Vertigo (1958) (Patreon)
Content
Time to shake things up a bit. To break out of my pretentious authorial voice that I tend to write these pieces in, and to share more of my raw thought process. These essays are not written from a standpoint of knowledge, where I have some supposedly-special insight into things that no one else does, and I don’t intend them to come across as that; but given a lack of context, even my best intentions can come across as unilateral statements. I don’t know shit, and in not-knowing-shit, my hope with this writing is to grapple with films and, through that struggle, get to a place that I wasn’t at before. That’s all I intend, nothing more, nothing else. So please forgive me for my mixed feelings about an acclaimed and beloved masterpiece.
But Alfred Hitchcock’s Vertigo is a film that I feel is impossible to write about. And I feel the need to write about that impossibility; as to why I currently feel this way, I possess one overriding conclusion: Vertigo is a film designed to be interpreted.
And no, I don’t just mean that it’s capable of sustaining interpretation, as all art and, if we’re being frank, existence, is subject to, no, that’s obvious enough, what I rather mean is that Vertigo, as a film, already contains within itself an interpretive apparatus, it is constructed around its own status as an object to be interpreted by the viewer. When I went into watching this film for the very first time, I made a vow to myself that I would refuse to interpret Vertigo through the lens of amateur psychoanalysis, that I would reject any Freudian, Lacanian or Jungian theoretical baggage and say something else about the film, something hopefully ‘unique’, or at least interesting, say something that wasn’t predicated upon the decades of previous interpretation that Vertigo has already engendered. My first exposure to the film’s existence was via Slavoj Zizek’s indelible psychoanalytic analysis within The Pervert’s Guide to Cinema, and I had heard nothing since then but a mountain of criticism about Hitchcock’s films, his psycho-sexual themes within his work, his obsessions, perversions, complexes, all that bullshit and claptrap, all of it is inextricable for me from his craft, it, to my previous understanding, was layered onto these films so thickly that I found the whole enterprise somewhat ossified and done-to-death, and my general unfamiliarity with Hitchcock is due to this perception that I had.
But seeing Vertigo in its entirety made me see that, no, this wasn’t just a critical veneer that was placed upon Hitchcock, it’s immanent to his work, Vertigo holds neurosis, memory, delusion and phobia as narrative and visual objects, all of that Freudian critique is explicit, not implicit, there’s so many elements in Vertigo that might as well spell it out, from Jimmy Stewart’s infantile masculinity to the double-layer of feminine imagery, it doesn’t take a genius to figure out what’s happening, you just easily put the pieces together and, wham, there’s your essay, mission accomplished.
I didn’t care for that. I didn’t care for how the film itself wanted to guide me into a certain immanent psychology, I had a difficult time even enjoying the pure craft of the film that I, in my obstinate contrarianism, wanted to end up writing about here in lieu of the narrative Vertigo that you’d heard about hundreds of times before. Vertigo is so intricate and rigorous in every moment that I felt breathless, like seeing it was sucking the oxygen out of my apartment, it was driving me mad. In every single scene, Hitchcock directs, with characteristic control, your perspective, drives your perspective, mandates it in masterful panache. In almost every shot, he has a character that he focuses on, and the camera slavishly follows that character’s movement, occasionally even taking on the perspective of that character, every motion is mimicked; when Stewart gets up out of a chair, the camera rises with him, when he’s pensively observing something, the camera also observes that thing, when he follows someone in a car, the camera pans slowly as he enters the center of the frame. There is nothing in this film that has the quality of contingency or coincidence, nor even the appearance of such notions, there is no movement wasted, nothing unmeasured, storytelling functioning like efficient clockwork, tick, tick, tick.
What’s the problem, right? I don’t know. I didn’t have a good time with it, I found the film to be circular, cynical, cold, a work that tries and successfully implicates the viewer’s gaze with the obsessive subjectivity of the framing. Vertigo, to me, does not open up the viewer to any possibility, or any new emotion, other than pure shock and the recapitulation of its own obsessive drive; in its implication, it tangles up the viewer with Stewart’s character’s own misogynistic gaze and myopia, its fatalistic ending is already ordained long before it even happens, it has no room in it for anything else, it is airtight and sealed, it locks the audience up in its perfect puzzlebox and throws away the key, it stipulates how and what happens within it, but also how one can interpret those events; everything about Vertigo is over-determined.
For all of these points, one could say “Yes, that’s the point, and that’s why the film is GOOD!”, and one would be right in doing so, sure, if that’s what floats your boat. And I’m not trying to be anti-Hitchcock or anything, I would have to see so much more of his filmography to even begin to have that opinion, and for the record, I don’t, because I deeply enjoy his Rear Window, also with Stewart. But there’s something that troubles me about Vertigo, something that blocks the usual way that I try to approach films in general. For me, when I watch something new, I can approach it via two paths: I can follow the story of the film, get engrossed in the narrative, the characters, to experience the film in an intuitive way, just letting it wash over me, or, I can take a more careful, detached observation, and try to appreciate the craft, the choice of framing, editing, lighting, music, all the individual components, to take the film as the sum of its parts.
Now, ideally, I’d want to be able to do both for something that I like, to appreciate its surface and its depths, to be able to ride the roller-coaster as well as understand why and how it does what it does, and upon subsequent viewings of a film, I’m usually able to do both. But I watched Vertigo twice in preparation for writing this, because the film is something that I find both utterly transparent, yet obnoxiously dense, and I am still at a loss. I can appreciate the subjectivist technique that Hitchcock uses, but I don’t like what he’s doing with it; I can appreciate the elegance and grace of the story he tells, but the film is too insistent on identifying what it condemns with the film medium itself and with the viewer, to me it comes across as a shallow gesture, the perfect thriller trying to make an anti-thriller statement.
So I arrive at a paradox with Vertigo: do I only judge it purely on form, which it clearly excels at, or do I judge it purely on storytelling, which it is also successful with? But neither of these show what my problem with the film is, my approaches are insufficient to deal with Vertigo. Analyzing form and storytelling can tell you a lot about HOW and WHAT the film is doing, which is great, but they cannot tell me the WHY of a film, why I like or dislike what it’s accomplishing, and why it wishes to strive for that. I can’t write an essay about a film that’s already an essay about itself; Vertigo is a complete artistic work inasmuch as it contains the method and methodology for its own existence and essence, it qualifies the way that one can approach it via its story, but then quantifies the way to approach it via its form. It is very much unlike the works of classic Hollywood directors that Hitchcock is often placed next to, such as John Ford and Howard Hawks. With those two directors, they almost always leave room for the audience, they are not ruthlessly calculated towards a specific end, but rather create a cinematic space for meaning and enjoyment to emerge. But Hitchcock compels enjoyment here, instead of merely allowing for it, his cinema is one of injunction, not of play. With a Ford or Hawks film, you can exist within a world that they create, a world that is a simulation/reflection of our world, their films invite you into a realm of possibility. Hitchcock doesn't design films to be worlds; with Vertigo, it has the character of an efficient machine, oriented towards its own singular point, featuring nothing besides that, all the grace notes and extraneous bits sanded off, rendered smooth and plasticine.
Vertigo is a very strange work to me, because on some level it is a movie that condemns the idea that the viewer can exist outside of what they are viewing. It executes its intentions with a full awareness of the interpretive lens that it explicitly sustains and encourages, it’s a film devoid of subtext, an exercise in pure literalism, a crystal that reflects its own appearance.
I cannot write about Vertigo, because it is redundant; Vertigo is identical with itself, and nothing else.
(Requested by Cheesus, a Patron. Thank you Cheesus!)
Files
Previews only