Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I find it difficult, but worthwhile, to reckon with the quality of a well-crafted capital-R Romance. Unlike in the romantic comedy, it cannot be reduced to a contrivance of the script; unlike in melodrama, it will not blind one’s eyes with sheer intensity and bravado. Pure Romance, as James Grey’s Two Lovers is, rather relies on the subtle intelligence of its camera and performers. The apparent simplicity of Two Lovers is dependent on an elegance of intent, a function over form, something at once strangely earnest as to perhaps be confusing, yet ultimately possessing a power in its insistence upon the unapparent. The Romance here, then, is a love of absence, an adoration and revelation of potentiality, not manifestation. It is this openness that allows Two Lovers to avoid an obstinate cruelty towards the titular couples and, thus, towards the audience as well, swerving instead towards classicism, pleasure, and a tenderness of gesture, if not intent. The intent of the paramours is rendered naive, perhaps innocent, and cannot debase their courtships as anything but the poking and prodding of damaged individuals given the space by Grey to wallow in their own insecurities for a time, then, as they drift closer, to rise out of the muck together, sublimating each of their struggles within an Antonioni-esque sense of mutual alienation. Two Lovers validates without being apologistic for genuine failure, casts judgment not on the lovers, and infuses the film with a genuine grace of spirit.

Grey positions his characters almost exclusively in medium shots, cramping them between walls, affixed to corners, put in the interiors of boxes, rectangles and squares even if they’re in an open environment, all this not for the sake of simple claustrophobia, because Two Lovers remains distant even within this framing, but instead for intimacy itself, collapsing New York City from a geometric grid to a place where people live, a quasi-Mediterranean networked hub where relationships spontaneously gather, emerge, blossom, fade. We see the human beings of Two Lovers as the darkest shadows cast by interior lights, furtive creatures compacted into dense bodies, vessels that carry the current of emotion. Joaquin Phoenix’s character Leonard is still in the beginning, reeling from personal loss and depression, weighed down by rocks, the camera inevitably moves away from centering him as soon as another, more lively person is in the frame. Leonard’s growing attachments to both Sandra, a kind woman foisted on him by his parents, and Michelle, a woman who lives across from his apartment window, free him up from this stasis, sets him on his own course towards channeling the emotions that others direct into him instead of remaining stiff and inert to them. He flows surprisingly well into the lives of complete strangers, erupts into eros, finding it easily reciprocated, if not understood There is more to Leonard than he knows, more that others intuit in him, but he’s smart enough to buy the ticket and take the ride on two concurrent relationships, not out of a desire for polyamory, but out of a sheer restlessness, a daring impulse for improvisation.

When asked about his hobbies and talents, Leonard replies at first, that he takes photos, then admits later to being a photographer, then gets called an artist, a compliment that he lightly rebukes, but internally questions. The photos that he takes at the beginning are deliberately without people in them, pictures of quaint storefronts and urban locales that would belong on Photobucket, pictures that indicate that he’s a tourist in his own life. Later at a nephew’s bar mitzvah, Leonard gets asked to be the official photographer for the family event, and begins to place himself within the world that he depicts, if at somewhat of a remove. He eventually proposes to Michelle that, after a series of dramatic revelations between the two, that they move out together to San Francisco. She accepts, and there are fewer greater moments in narrative art than the fluttering heart caused by the thought of two love struck people willing to forsake everything that each of them knows in order to propel themselves, together, into a wild unknown future, a reckless act of willpower and stupidity, the abyssal free fall embraced by two people with nothing to lose. Within the context of Two Lovers, it can be a bit weird, because this sort of action is usually reserved for the teenage or early 20-somethings of fiction, not the grown adults, but this film’s gaze follows this path anyway, derives so much tension from every step that Leonard takes to secure his new future, his buying of a plane ticket and an engagement ring and packing his bags, an array of objects both personal and practical, an adolescent constellation of desires bundled up into one goal, one silly dream of escape.

But it doesn’t happen. Michelle reneges on their plan once her other lover leaves his wife and child for her, and his foolish love makes Leonard’s foolish love look like the child’s play that it is. She’s sorry for misleading him, but not sorry for loving someone else, just like he shouldn’t be. Leonard isn’t at the stage of his life where sacrifice means anything, his suicide attempts earlier in the film fail because he has nothing left to give up. So he dejectedly waltzes back into his life, takes the ring that he was going to give Michelle, and gives it to Sandra instead. She accepts. What does it mean? That both of his relationships to them are equally interchangeable, that Leonard loves them both equally?

I think not. Rather, Grey holds on the two of them, isolated in their own little emotional bubble as they lounge together on a couch, slowly panning back to show them existing within the context of the rest of their families at a party. The delicacy of the scene is overwhelming in effect; far from Sandra being the ‘leftovers’ of his relationship with Michelle, Leonard is able to understand that Michelle’s other lover had built up a life of his own while also loving Michelle, unlike Leonard’s own floundering. His choice to propose to Sandra then becomes a form of self-affirmation for him; her emotional stability and sensibility more closely matches his own, and thus, he realizes that they’d actually make a much better pair, something that would actually help him develop as a person, instead of continuing his adolescent mindset by doing anything and everything for Michelle, that Michelle was the kind of person who needed someone stable in her life, which Leonard isn’t, and that Leonard needs the same thing. Thus, Michelle’s actions and understanding also become Leonard’s, and he’s able to ease himself into self-consciousness, to act with intent instead of accident, to fathom love’s antinomies in a way that makes him a person worthy of affection and respect, not only from other people, but from himself as well.


(Requested by Pierre-Benoit Gauthier. Thank you Pierre!)

Comments

No comments found for this post.