Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

I find film at its most compelling when it functions as an illustration of process. The idea being that, differing from almost any other artform, film’s abridging of time and space into a two-dimensional repeating frame allows for the density of change to be portrayed in a fascinating, emotionally-charged way. Film documents the heft of one state transforming into another, of the basic physical formulation of the way that things are made apparent to us, the emergence of emergence, coming-to-be in a way that is not usually possible for the human experience. Within the space of two hours or so, a film’s depiction of its world can radically shift while also maintaining a sense of direct continuity; a person performing a task can soon see it done in a detailed way that is difficult for us to understand otherwise without first attempting the task ourselves. Film can be a phenomenological experience of placing ourselves in a privileged position of being able to focus on particular instances of importance without the dull tedium of weighty repetition. When a process is performed for us on film, ideally, it is illustrated using only the necessary and beautiful elements that allow us a second-hand satisfaction by way of a malleable abridgment of said process. This is the cinema of expertise, and it is something I have an intense admiration for.

It may seem ridiculous, in some way, to call Portrait of a Lady on Fire an example of this cinema of expertise; in a romantic sense, we may look at a film focused on painting-as-relationship to place more importance on the intimacy of the relationship than the nuances of painting as an artform, that the painting, being a process, is used exclusively for an endpoint, which is the emotional heights of the love shown; the titular Portrait may seem to collapse itself for the sake of its lady aflame, its subject matter, but I am of the opinion that this film is deeply in love with love-as-process, love as a nebulous zone explored by its two participants and brought to full and bittersweet realization by them and them alone; not as an instrumental desire, but one that exceeds the remainder of its production.

The romance between Marianne, the painter, and Heloise, the painted, begins within the logic of exploitation, with Heloise not wanting to be painted, and Marianne being tasked with stealthily accomplishing her art despite this, a relationship based on subterfuge. Marianne slowly over the course of a week begins to sketch Heloise in bits and pieces, her ears, her eyes, her hands, the way light falls across her cheek, everything accumulated into a greater unity, but not conceived as a unity. Heloise, when faced with this unwanted depiction of her, confronts it as “A presence made of fleeting facts.”, moments of her life carefully selected and drawn without a semblance of all those fragments being immediately apparent in front of Marianne herself. It’s a patchwork presence, something static and Franksteinian, an artist trying to create a person without that person’s existence or acknowledgment.


But as the film progresses, and Marianne and Heloise become closer, Heloise becomes a willing subject of Marianne’s painting, and examines her illustrator with an equal eye for detail and framing even as she is herself made the object of the artistic engagement. Their romance, then, is only to be found as a fully-realized process containing room for both of their subjectivities; the painter is painting out of a love for the whole person, and the painted is being painted while in full-view of her painter’s enraptured and loving gaze. It’s an effect achieved with sublime directness and matter-of-fact construction, and as a showing of process, we see Marianne’s early sketches develop into something much more intimate, then powerful, each brushstroke filling out an awakening for both her, Heloise, and us as the audience. Heloise awakens to her capacity to be courted without societal pressure, Marianne awakens to the contradictory beauty of a life gifted to her in vital lust, and we awaken to the film’s message of how the juxtaposition of the cinematic sequence is an intensity that compels us to be raw, to face the iotas of yearning pain and the returned erotic gaze which brings one into an artistic dialogue with love itself.

I find the film’s most powerful moment to be when Heloise challenges Marianne on the basis of this process itself. Heloise points out, when speaking of Marianne’s sketch that she made of Heloise, wanting to keep her own depiction of her lover, that “You can reproduce that image into infinity. And after a while, you’ll see her when you think of me.”, and now Heloise herself, not being an artist, won’t have a similar replica of Marianne to think of in the long years that they will be separated. Marianne responds with what I think is an overwhelmingly romantic and intimate answer: that she will illustrate herself in one of Heloise’s books, then taking a mirror, Heloise taking it and strategically placing it over her own crotch, and watching Marianne as Marianne sketches her own naked body in the reflection, the reflection itself framed by Heloise’s body, then the sketch framed in her book, on page 28. This scene, for me, is pure process, pure adoration, pure generosity, the swooning idea of gifting yourself to someone you love, but only being able to do this by capturing your own existence within the context of theirs; the notion that Marianne can, perhaps for the first time, draw herself in the careful fashion that she does on behalf of so many other people, but only when Heloise, in her charity, can give Marianne the ability to gift herself to another person, for them to keep and hold close that image for all their life. 

But then something remarkable happens; later, after Marianne and Heloise have been separated for years, Marianne spots a painting that someone else has done of Heloise; and yet, even in this othered image, authored by another artist, with Heloise gone and past her time with Marianne, Heloise deliberately includes a symbol in her painting's hand: the page 28 that holds Marianne's sketch within it, a reference that only Marianne will ever understand as she sifts through a sea of others who have observed the painting; a private, esoteric gift between these women, the usage of their art as a blossoming of their time together, something they were both able to dream into being.

As a show of process, it gets into what I find process really, truly is about: that to do something, to experience an event, it changes you, alters you in a way; that we do not simply act upon an indifferent, isolated world, but that we ourselves become something new, something more, through an engagement with art. This, to me, is the gift of love.

Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.