LAUGH AT YOUR TERROR; or, Modern Times (1936) (Patreon)
Content
Rationality is the greatest myth that the Western world was ever sold, even more so than monotheistic morality, more than any individual component of propaganda, more than the efforts of all dictatorships and corporations and governments. Rationality is a self-sustaining myth, the founding sin of contemporary life. Who is to blame for it doesn’t really matter, could be Descartes, Copernicus, Newton, Voltaire, Giordano Bruno, whoever, fuck it, they’re interchangeable, they were just possessed by the same daemonic force; they were men who went forth and conquered the world and continue to conquer the world centuries after their death, they served as microcosmic models for the way of the future, the abolition and sublimation of all previous existences. Rationality gave them their day, and in return, like in every daemonic pact, they surrendered their souls and the souls of the world to the invisible machinery of an egregore, a growing mind-virus that most of us have been infected with since we were born. The human race is the host to a parasite, a parasite known as rationality, it directs us and comforts us and feeds off us and shows us terrible beautiful vistas of code, fantastical digital domains made real by industrial production and exploitation, dark dreams made flesh in ways that are outside of our intention and control. Rationality serves its own interests, fulfills its own goals, and uses us as a means towards an unknown cosmic end-goal that may never be reached. It fucks us and tells us how much we should or shouldn’t like that, rationality is a rapist of the species and nature and its countless criminal actions are only now, at this tangibly fragile point in the history of the world, beginning to be told.

Chaplin’s Modern Times, this is what this film is about. Not a new though, he gets caught in the gears of the machine, so many obvious things to be said, so much written, too much for me to grasp or begin to say something interesting about. It’s not just the beginning portion of the film, set in the gigantic imposing factory of Fordist disciplinary power; Chaplin’s Tramp character, when he’s later employed as waiter in the film at a club, tries to move through a crowd of party-goers dancing to a song in circular motion, has trouble getting to the other side because the motion of the dancers keeps rotating him around in the middle of the crowd, the music stops, he’s able to move freely again, then it starts over and he’s overtaken by the motion again. This is the machinery of rationality, the film parallels this with the Tramp earlier being caught in the spinning gears of the factory, it’s not just a machine. It’s machine logic, it’s the mechanized unity of movement and action and thought and behavior that not only machines are created to possess, but also human beings, the dancers dance in a highly-coordinated fashion and only when the music is playing, they’re fucking automatons devoid of individual will and variance and Chaplin is a fragile soul unable to affect or surpass them, he’s immanently consumed by this rational logic of existence. That dance hall is a place of production just as much as the factory was earlier, it produces a certain standard and expectation of life, of life as a means towards instrument, rationally coordinated, rationally set and blocked. Earlier in Modern Times, Chaplin’s being force-fed by a machine designed to eliminate the externality of workers having to take lunch breaks, lunch breaks that take up oh-so-precious time from further production in the factory. The boss of the factory lets these inventors try out their machine in the Tramp, the idea being that the machine infantilizes the worker into automatic consumption of food while they’re still able to work on the assembly line uninterrupted by human bodily needs of nutrition. The auto-feeder malfunctions, abuses the Tramp in a comical fashion, breaks down and proves to be a fucking terrible idea by any stretch of the imagination. The boss of the factory rejects this machine, but not on the basis that it’s this ugly and malevolent concept that should have never been made in the first place, but because it’s not ‘practical’ to be used as-is, it’s not ‘efficient’ enough, and one gets the feeling that, if it actually worked as described and intended, that the boss would more than welcome its use in his factory.

That kind of thinking disgusts me on a level that I have a difficult time articulating. This is that bullshit, it’s everything I’m against, everything I hate. Chaplin makes fun of it, gives us the space to laugh at the absurdity, but that kind of thinking, that blind rationality that sees the human being only as a means towards production and profit and the re-capitulation of its own logic, it’s hard for me to not become furious with, even as I’m laughing at what Modern Times portrays. It’s almost too real; one could still see this kind of thinking at bat with the Elon Musks and mega-corps of the world of 2022. Their existence is anti-human on a scale that Chaplin would have been paralyzed by, the factory floor of 1936 has become the home and inner-life of modern life, Modern Times is too modern, hyper-modern, the joke is on us and Chaplin for thinking that this is still mostly funny instead of mostly horrific. Billions of human lives only existing for rationality’s take, for the task of number and accounting and manufacture, directing human desires as ‘production for use’, love and art made mundane and repetitive because all that ‘rational’ capitalism can do is re-create the conditions of its own existence. Capitalism enforces what it wants its reality to be, and because reality then ‘works’ that way, capitalism takes on the essential characteristic of a semi-divine and inherent invisibility the way that the Judeo-Christian God used to claim province over.
Chaplin’s a genius for taking that ‘invisible’ world, all those assumptions of the self-fulfilling prophecy of rationality, and then rendering them highly visible and comical, it’s a shock to the system, comedy can allow us to face the harshest of truths in a way that nothing else can because it uses the language of rhetorical distance, suspension of reality, and satire to do so. But it cannot take on a fundamentally revolutionary character; comedy always transcribes into stone the reality that it undercuts, the dimension of comedy places us in a position of absolute awareness and a paralysis of action, because we hear and see the joke and we think that the joke does the work for us. But the joke placates us, it depicts and condemns its subject matter but does not ask us, the experiencers of art, to ever do something. It raises consciousness to new heights without giving consciousness the tools of justice and power; Chaplin gifts us a comical age, he’s a father of the joys in pointing out despair. I wonder if it’s enough, if it’s enough to say that and perform that. He and his similarly-destitute lover walk away from ‘modern life’ at the end of Modern Times, towards the viewer and into a horizon that the audience cannot follow them into, which is ourselves. This is the limit of this comic art, I think. It can mirror a world of tyranny, reveal what it wants to hide, but it cannot move away from it except through absence; Modern Times, with its highly-choreographed and detailed physical setpieces and jokes, is rationality trying to let us in on the joke. I find it to be both incredible and infuriating, it is rationality and its machine-logic becoming self-aware enough to try and invite us to laugh while we cry, it takes comedy to the boundary of absurdism and nihilism, goes to the very end. I celebrate its extremity, because it shows us where we have yet to walk with our civilization, what paths remain unseen and unloved.

(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!)