FARE-WEATHER FRIENDS; or, Old Joy (2006) (Patreon)
Content

I wrote this more thematic and textual analysis of Kelly Reichardt’s Old Joy, and sometimes when I write these pieces I get really fed-up with the standard ways you feel like you’re supposed to talk about film or have internalized expectations, writing in a solid way that nevertheless displeases you and remains unsatisfactory, something more’s needed, I don’t know, Old Joy doesn’t feel like it should be ‘read’ or analyzed in the way I was doing it, was trying to, and sometimes you have to accept that your approach isn’t working and that you have to do literally anything else, so I’m going to do exactly that.
Old Joy’s a film about a friendship dying. Simple as that. Not the dramatic way that a friendship dissolves, where you and someone have this loud argument, a battle of egos or unstated desires that were unfulfilled, times where you were wronged, this that and so forth, then you’re no longer on speaking terms, and your heart settles into brittle bitterness for years to come, maybe you make up with them, maybe you don’t, either way, that’s not this movie, not Old Joy, Old Joy’s about two fellas, Mark and Kurt, trying to force themselves to be friends with a camping trip, and it doesn’t work out. They go through the motions of being friends but feel like they live on two different planets, which they do. Mark’s married and about to have a child, Kurt’s something of a disgruntled burnout, and they don’t have much in common anymore. They want to, they want to still see each other as an integral part of the other guy’s life, and it’s just not happening; no matter how much they force it, try to reach a dim catharsis, they’re on different paths now, and no amount of male-bonding in the great outdoors of the Pacific Northwest will put Humpty-Dumpty back together again. After Old Joy’s over, maybe they’ll talk again once or twice, maybe a nice phone call where they pretend that they care about each other in the way that they used to, and that’ll be it. Open and shut, old records and CDs that you haven’t listened to in years for a good reason, the forest road, un-taken.
I wonder why I was asked to write about this specific movie at this specific time, because it addresses subjects that I’ve been ruminating over the course of this year. From 2015 to 2020, I had a pretty consistent group of friends online, people that watched so many films together, hung out, dated, and it felt like this was it, this was the thing that would last forever, despite all odds, that we’d always be at this same level of intimacy and association. I began to realize in 2020, as I became less depressed and more proactive in my life, that I really didn’t have much in common with most of these people, and that it was a particular set of circumstances that allowed us to even be on speaking terms in the first place. Gradually, one by one, we drifted. Some of them moved in together, some of them died, some of them had angry confrontations with me, some of them I just plain ghosted. This year, I grapple with my guilt over all of that and what it meant to me, if anything. When something falls apart in that way, you feel desperate at certain points to re-assert control over that friend group, hoping that your out-sized efforts to bring people together can be the glue that solidifies the crumbling structure. I understood, after a while, that I was trying harder to involve everyone else in my life than they actually wanted to be involved; my attachment to them was a naïve weakness on my part, a childish way of holding onto the past. With every conversation that I imposed, the silences between us grew longer and louder. There was nothing left to say. I haven’t spoken to 98% of those people in over a year. I hope they’re happy and doing well. Paradoxically, I’ve never been better, never been able to actually admit that my life is as good as it has been, despite everything. Strangeness.
It’s hard to let go of anything. Heraclitus discusses how we live in a world of permanent impermanence; nothing lasts forever, not even your lasting memories of something. You’re a different person than you were five minutes ago, much less five years. It’s a fool’s errand to think that you can outrun the change that everyone undergoes at a cellular level, and at an interpersonal level? Forget it. The tighter your grip is, the faster it moves past you. Before that group, I had never had anyone I would call ‘real’ friends, no one that I would die for. That was the only way I could define a true friendship: I’d die for them, take the bullet. I oriented my entire life around the idea of dying for something better than myself, dying for a buddy or a cause or in some kind of apocalyptic scenario. I was obsessed with the end of things but I was so scared that the end would come to something that I didn’t have control over: other people. In those years, what I thought I could control was my once-and-future corpse, and that was supposed to be some kind of purpose, some kind of clarity. It was all I could give to people, I felt, my only worth, at the end of things, finality. Looking back on that, that way of thinking and living… what a joke.

Old Joy’s a hard watch because it rouses all those thoughts and feelings I had, feelings of shame and regret and envy and possessiveness and awkward tumbling into what I thought my life was always going to be and never actually was. The film’s like a cold slap in the face, despite its apparent calmness; life as warmed-over left-overs that you eventually decide to throw away in the garbage. The soft choice, the hardest one to make: to stop seeing things as something they aren’t. To release your own illusions, release that burden of memory even if you feel that it’s all you have left; especially if you feel that it’s all you have left. I don’t know shit about Buddhism, not really, but attachments will kill you, if you let them. Dying for someone is no way to live your life, friendship exists in time and space, and we have to come to terms with that, that it doesn’t last forever and nor should it. Sometimes it’s better to accept that something’s over when it’s over; if you don’t, then it’ll drown you as it sinks along into the ocean of history.
The old dreams were good dreams, and I’m glad that I had them, glad that I still can have new ones. There’s somewhere left to go.
(Requested by Carlos, a Patron. Thanks Carlos!)