OUTSIDER LOOKING IN; or, Wichita (1955) (Patreon)
Content
A couple months back when I was first eyeing the long list of narrative films that Hollywood has spun from the Tombstone / Wyatt Earp / Doc Holliday mythos (My Darling Clementine, Warlock, Tombstone, etc.), I somehow missed 1955’s Wichita, directed by Jacques Tourneur. Easily done, as it’s a very liberal (in both senses of the term) interpretation of Wyatt Earp’s saga, sans Tombstone in favor of the titular town, sans the good Doctor, sans… well, almost everything, save for Earp’s status as a legendary lawman. The film’s almost self-aware about how this story has been told over and over again to various degrees of ‘historical accuracy’, when Earp ruminates on his fate midway through the picture:
“I guess I was born under a troublesome star. Bad things are always happening to me.”
In John Ford’s take, Wyatt Earp is immanently mythological, an archetype of a man, but he’s still a man. At the beginning of My Darling Clementine, Earp is rugged, bearded, more than resembling the outlaws he ousts, before donning the iconic mustache and sheriff star as he assumes the mantle that will make him famous. In Tourneur’s Wichita, Earp arrives on the horizon already full-formed, sterling of character, implacably quick on the draw, and his at-first denial to be the town’s protector comes across as false humility, a denial of what’s obvious to everyone. He’s not a man here; Joel McCrea’s performance is steely and stiff, miles away from Henry Fonda’s half-gawky hero. Earp in Tourneur’s film was born to be what he is, and one can imagine him emerging from his mother’s womb, six-shooter and spurs affixed to his infant limbs. He’s unflappable, and when he commits to his crusade of bringing order to the bereaved town, it seems like the planet itself rotates according to his desires.
It’s difficult then to think of how this Wyatt Earp could pal-around with a roguish and disreputable Doc Holiday, and Wichita’s creators obviously know this, exorcising the Doctor entirely from the screenplay. Instead, we get ‘Doc Black’, an antagonistic lout from the very beginning who attempts a traitorous assassination on Earp in the final confrontation. ‘Doc Black’ doesn’t have half the personality of a Holiday, and the film doesn’t want him to; there isn’t room here for grey, only black and white. You’re either on the side of Earp’s perfect embodiment of LAW, or you’re at the receiving end of his pistol. The cattle rustlers who cause drunken anarchy when they arrive in Wichita seem almost like unruly children when Earp arrests them, and quickly acquiesce to his obvious moral and legal authority: they herd the cattle into town, and he herds them into a jail-cell. There’s a pecking order here, an inflexible attitude. Ford’s Wyatt Earp got into the justice business because of personal revenge, but for this Earp? It’s all impersonal: their debauchery caused a child to be accidentally killed by a reckless stray bullet, a bridge too far. Wyatt Earp’s quest in Wichita isn’t something that we can relate to, it’s impersonal and systemic. He’s an agent of some strange cosmic bedrock in the universal scales of order and disorder, or rather…
Apollo and Dionysus. Tourneur frames Earp as arriving and exiting the film according to the setting sun, as if the domain of light sends out an agent to be its herald for the darkness that it cannot itself be a part of. Earp as an angel, and not even an avenging one. In Nietzsche’s Birth of Tragedy, he paints it as thus:
“The images of myth must be the daemonic guardians, omnipresent and unnoticed, which protect the growth of the young mind, and guide man's interpretation of his life and struggles.”
All westerns to one degree or another are mythic, as they deal with America’s idea of its non-colonial origins, manifesting its destiny against a ‘glorious’ future. It’s a question of what one uses myth to say; when Tourneur represents the West as being a struggle between light and dark, pure order and unfettered anarchy, he’s rendering it in Manichean, pseudo-Gnostic terms. His Earp is Tourneur in miniature; it’s a cliché to think that artists always embody themselves in some fashion within their own art, but I do think it’s true. The Western genre already existed before Tourneur made Wichita, and there were already plenty of Wyatt Earp adaptations and evocations. Why tell this story? To grab onto the reigns of retrospective and direct it towards one’s own end.
The film’s only ambiguity comes in with Mr. McCoy, the town’s banker who initially opposes Wyatt’s my-way-or-the-highway approach to enforcing law, as it makes Wichita seem unfriendly to he rowdy-but-essential economic force of the cowboys whose cattle is something that men like McCoy can generate a huge profit from. But after his wife is killed by the renegade aspects of the cowboys, he definitively joins Earp in subduing them. In Ford’s depiction, what I found so striking was that Earp, in seeking vengeance, was using the title of Sheriff for his own ends, but in taking up the job, he found a sense of love and purpose outside of bloodlust. Just as much as Earp ‘tames’ the town of Tombstone in My Darling Clementine, he’s equally tamed by it, civilized into a man who will one day, in revisionist Westerns like Once Upon a Time In The West, be made irrelevant by the world he helped to create.
But Tourneur’s Wyatt Earp in Wichita doesn’t have this psychological reflection of what exists around him. He’s put on this earth to purify it of corruption, and by setting an example to others, even the potentially-ruthless aspects of the town like McCoy are converted to his side. Ford’s story was a man who was shaped by the times; Tourneur’s story is of an eternal force outside of the historical process that redeems and validates the ‘decadence’ of Man. So many other Wyatt Earp stories allow their storytellers to exist alongside their characters, but this one’s got a mission, and he’s a missionary with a gun and he’s aiming to smite; anything to ‘redeem’ the West as an ideal.
(Requested by Paul, a Patron. Thanks Paul!)
Files
Previews only