Films Cannot Capture the Unseen, but They Should Still Try (Patreon)
Content
The paranormal has, to put it kindly, a troubled history with the idea of representation and art. In the hey-day of UFO mania from the late-40s to the 1990s, you had thousands of supposed photographs of UFOs, hundreds of bigfoot footprints, bloodless animal corpses apparently drained by the chupacabra or other nocturnal entities, and a whole library’s worth of books written on the subject; all of it was an elaborate dance, so many hands unseen in a dark room trying to feel the outline of an elephant. There was no smoking gun, no process of verification, no way to separate the ‘legitimate’ evidence from the bunkum. And yet, why would we be surprised by that? The way that the traces of evidence do not constitute ‘proof’ is something to examine here; without evidence-based research, there is no way at all to constitute a body of scientific knowledge. If someone’s sighting of a UFO is just as invalid as their photograph of one… then what are we really saying there? If one of the damn things fell out of the sky in front of thousands of people, there would still be skeptics about it, the way that there are always skeptics for anything if you look hard enough. So if we don’t trust any level of evidence in the way that the ‘skeptics’ want us to, which in reality is just them shifting the goal-posts constantly and dogmatically being against anything that breeches the humble boundaries of 19th century scientific materialism, if we aren’t willing to extend ourselves in that way, then the only place that the paranormal has somewhat of a refuge is in art.
But what does it mean, then, for art to depict a set of phenomena that traditionally has evaded the confines of depiction for so long? No photo of bigfoot ‘actually’ captures the intense fear and malaise that experiencers feel when encountering the creature, yet the realm of cinema has always held the paranormal close to its heart within the genres of science-fiction and fantasy. The genre ‘suspends’ our need for believability, and serves as a screen door for audiences to buy into the premise of the paranormal without asking them to take it too seriously; it’s just a movie after all, right? It’s that way that any art, but especially a popular medium like film, gets taken for granted by the public spectacle: the deceptively simple usage of the word ‘just’. It’s just this, just that, merely a fiction, merely a metaphor. And metaphor, that old bastard-child of the Renaissance, one of many; metaphor, symbolic, allegory, all that crap. Nothing wrong with them on their own, but they frequently get attached to the notion of ‘merely metaphor’, ‘actually allegorical’, ‘it’s just symbolic’, the intent by the speaker being this: you think this is one thing, but that’s naive, and it’s really ‘THIS’, or at least supplanted in practical manifestation by ‘THIS’. Back in the 50s they’d see all these wacky UFO sightings and come up with a cornucopia of explanations, all of them possible but increasingly more silly than what the experiencer said that they say: the planet Venus, swamp gas, ball lightning, and so on. Anything and everything said to avoid acknowledging that someone may have had an authentic encounter with something outside of the consensus reality of authorities and their propagandist cronies.
I think this is a central problem that is especially endemic to the speculative fiction sphere of film. An alien isn’t something radically strange and surreal; as a cinematic object within the frame and story it’s ‘just’ an allegory for racism, imperialism, any -isms that seem theoretically viable and that distance ourselves from the implications of engaging with something that does not abide by our assumptions about how the universe functions. It’s why the aliens in Star Trek and Star Wars piss me off so much: most of the time, they’re basically just costumed/CGI dudes with a weird face walking around like it’s a permanent cosplay, the frontier of our existential reality brought into buying food at the grocery store or only being in the film to sell toys. The mundanity of it is so droll and idiotic, where the eerie and bizarre gets reduced to a casual background element, window dressing so that you know you’re in a scifi/fantasy world where things look different. The paranormal gets seen as a brush stroke or a narrative device instead of being thought of as having a mood all on its own; the paranormal is elusive to channel into art because it resists direct representation, so instead, the art lowers the paranormal into a set of aesthetic signifiers and cliches that it can then use as short hand to communicate a general idea to the audience, and hey, sometimes you have to do that to get the ball rolling, but no one’s really cracked the code on how to do this stuff yet, so the failings seem that much more egregious.
Of course, there are films like Penda’s Fen, Dark City, and Nope, which go out of their way to try and capture the divine paranoia that takes you over when you’re in the middle of a paranormal event, but all these films necessary pictorially represent this stuff in pretty certain terms, using iconography to illustrate their subjects in beautiful and haunting ways, but there’s a stasis that creeps in, even at the end of Nope where Jean Jacket unfolds into an Evangelion-esque imago terror. In real paranormal events and magickal experiences, you rarely ever see the literal continuity of what’s going on, but instead it feels like you’re constantly receiving tiny puzzle pieces for a puzzle that’s growing bigger and bigger in scope and size, until it seems like you’re getting closer to unearthing the building blocks of reality itself.
Should movies even try then to deal with the paranormal, if so far it cannot avoid being either distorted into a displaced allegory for something else, or being rendered in a somewhat hyper-literal and conceptual way? I think the attempt is valid and valiant; the paranormal is less a subject to be shown, and more of an implication to be drawn to. When I think of this ideal, perhaps Magnolia’s Fortean frog storm is the closest I can imagine, where it has, at first appearance, almost nothing to do with the rest of the film, but upon further consideration, ends up bracketing the whole story as a totalized portrayal of human existence that also includes the presence of the strange and inexplicable, because the paranormal isn’t the anti-normal, it’s adjacent to it, like two layers stacked on top of each other, mingling and interacting at the desire of some unknown will. That unknown part is the key: the paranormal must always maintain a sense of mystery and incoherence, and any film that wishes to compromise that for the sake of direction or writing really has no business being concerned with these matters.
(Requested by Paul, a Patron. Thanks Paul!)