Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

As someone whose goal is to someday be able to write for a living, I often find myself paradoxically opposed to the writer-directors of the world, and yes, writer-directors as opposed to director-writers. I ask myself, ‘what are we doing here?’, what is actually trying to be accomplished with film, what are its stated aims, its unknown drives, what makes it sing and where must it be silent, where, and for what purpose? All About Eve, to me, is nothing, it constitutes nothing, the barest of qualities are expressed here, and they’re expressed in its writing, not at all in the way it looks, is edited, framed, paced, none of that matters; it remains a succession of non-cinematic moments, but played out within the space of cinema, ostensibly to accomplish the goals of cinema, and fails utterly. As a film fan, it is a contemptuous object, not because it’s even that particularly offensive as a failure, but because it fails without knowing of its failure, it organizes itself atop an anthill of intelligent asides and critical observation, all to no end.

There’s a part of me that feels like I shouldn’t so harsh, because conceptually, this is something I’d easily enjoy, but I cannot abide by how it blatantly has zero memorable imagery or sequencing; I’m struggling to remember most of it as I write this, because it all blurs together into the same conversation about rising and falling actresses, the same theme blundered over and over in dour parties or airless backrooms and hotel suites. This is not a cinema of the stage, even; it has no theatrical bombast like many writerly projects do, no, this is a cinema of anonymous parlors repeated ad nausea because Joseph Mankiewicz cannot conceive of a scene that is not the most efficiently suited to the ends of his script; All About Eve is boring because it tells itself in a boring way, not because of its subject matter. The most interesting shot out of 138 minutes is the last one, in which Eve’s wannabe successor finds herself repeated in an infinite regress of dressing mirrors, all representing the fatalistic inevitability of stardom and the dispensability of women forced to undercut each other to achieve success. Sure, this is a nice shot, concise and illustrative in a blunt fashion, but it’s a punctuation mark, not a sign of quality; the movie builds and builds to this half-nihilistic screech of a scene, when it reality it should have had at least a half dozen images like this before.


It’s so self-satisfied in delivering a contrived climax that it forgets that this is a movie, not a book, and that we actually have to sustain ourselves for the previous two hours almost entirely on actors and dialogue, which is fine, I can handle a movie that’s more centered on performances instead of sweeping vistas or creative juxtapositions, but the whole damn thing is so SHAPELESS. All About Eve lumbers from one scene to the next, characters ironically repeating phrases to each other and talking tough about the entertainment industry and the false illusion of fame, but we never GET that illusion in the first place, it’s undercut from the get-go because Mankiewicz refuses to tolerate us being allowed to participate in the construction of his story, no, instead, we get lectured scene-after-scene by characters who all seem too smart and jaded to have any actual drama happen to them, but because Mankiewicz needs his closed-loop of a plot to happen, he hopes that we won’t notice how empty these sets are without the booming voices of the actors echoing within them. His technique is serviceable, yes, but awful in its mediocrity, beyond reproach because it never tries, never exerts itself beyond comic necessity. When there’s a conversation, characters take up the entire frame by themselves when there’s tension between them, are together in the frame when they’re in harmony, and sometimes, if you’re lucky, you get some light subjectivity with the camera, mainly to show the ladies and gents getting up out of chairs or lounging back into them. When Mankiewicz wants to blah-blah-blah over the passage of time to get to the next part of the script, we’ll get some languid voice over, telling us more than showing anything meaningful, then trailing into conversations of endless medium shot-reverse shot dialectic that serves only to render our actors as isolated vibrations occasionally bouncing into each other, but never taking place outside of their own mouths, because god forbid that an actor’s face can do the work that a thousand words don’t, and when Mankiewicz does err on the side of physicality, he does so out of passivity, cutting between Bette Davis and Anne Baxter only because the simple act of editing will keep his audience from falling asleep as Baxter’s Eve Harrington regales to us her obviously-false childhood that the rest of our world-weary troupe are made stupid enough to believe, their sharp tongues silenced long enough for air to be let in to create actual conflict instead of plastic decadence.

Obviously, I’m being a bit harsh here, but All About Eve really does do a lot of shit that I can’t stand in movies. It’s a film that could just as easily function as a radio play or audio drama, and you wouldn’t miss anything major by converting it into one of those. It’s a film that’s a film because of convenience, but because of necessity; it doesn’t take advantage of the medium in the slightest. There ARE good writer-directors, but those figures take time and care to develop a specifically cinematic vernacular for their words instead of thinking that a film is basically just a recorded stageplay or novel, which is what All About Eve does. There are obviously many people who like this film, and I applaud their enjoyment, because I wish I could find some for myself. I have to ask the question though of what they’re looking for when it comes to film? What do they wish to experience? Because All About Eve is, to me, a bad showcase for the possibilities of what cinema can do. It believes itself to be a triumph of storytelling, when really it just tells its story, and thinks that’s enough. It’s not enough. Mankiewicz’s instrumental approach to his craft bares all the signs of someone who sees cinema as a vehicle for scripts instead of a transformative alchemical admixture that emerges to be something astonishing and more than the sum of its parts, no, not that, instead, All About Eve preens its tail feathers in a locked closet, suspicious of spectacle, mistaking the depth of intellect for the depth of genius. I have no time for this type of film, it is nothing to me, and I wish to forget it at my brain’s nearest convenience.


(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!)

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.