Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I find myself at an odd crossroads with David Lynch. When confronted with a film like Lost Highway, it seems to check all the necessary boxes of interest for me: a twisty neo-noir story, the protagonist split down the middle between two men who are pieces of a whole person, the dreamy industrial/4AD-influenced score and soundtrack, the occult undertones and an eerie man-in-black. Yet I remain completely mystified by him. Going to try and work some of that out here, see what comes out the other end.

For all of what I just listed, it’s not so much that I reject that material in Lynch’s hands, what he uses that material for, the statements he’s making in Lost Highway. about how human beings can compartmentalize themselves into realities and fantasies and how the boundary between the both of those isn’t quite as clear as we’d like it to be. Nah, all that shit is cool and great and I find it intellectually fascinating. And that’s the problem. Intellectualism in his art, I feel, is what keeps me from loving Lynch. I’ve seen many online critics have this overwhelming emotional response to Twin Peaks, and while I’m glad for them to be able to experience that and enjoy themselves, it’s truly confusing to me. I do not understand what the emotional content of a work like Lost Highway is; if I could hazard a guess, it’s this semi-corny lost yearning for 50s Americana, some notional idea of conscious purity whose unconscious corpse now hangs like a wraith above miles of an outstretched wasteland of souls, the wasteland being Los Angeles, of course. And… is that it? Because I couldn’t tell you Lynch’s worldview outside of that, and that, to me, is not particularly interesting. If Lynch is a filmmaker of American melancholy, it’s a presentation of that which I have no relation to. His characters all feel like half-formed figments who stretch and contort their way through liminal locales, their words either whispered with a pixie’s delicacy or screamed with wild-eyed fascist mania. While I can admire the ‘vibe’ of what’s happening, I cannot tell you why any of it happens, or how Lynch as an artist relates to what he’s portraying.

I could be wrong here, but it feels to me like Lynch deliberately removes scenes of clarification from his narratives in order to create gaps of meaning where the viewer is invited to participate and generate their own meaning of the events, and I do like that very much. He’s a collaborative and open-minded artist who is willing to be abrasive and tender with his stories, treating his audience with the assumption of intelligence and intimacy that his overwrought scenes need in order to play as well as they do. And it’s not exactly ‘cold’ to me in the way that I usually don’t like, but it does come across as very well-managed; Lynch has a lot of control over what he presents, where it’s presented, etc., but because he loosens up everything by refusing to incorporate the slightest bit of expository dialogue or visual table setting, that control feels directionless and circular instead of linear in the classic Hollywood sense of a director like Hitchcock. Lost Highway obviously circles back into itself with the ominous phone call at the beginning and ending, making the whole film into a recursive Ouroboros in a way that does evoke the stoic fatalism of classic noir. The Fred/Pete relationship emerges, collapses, and then will emerge again, their awareness only faintly illuminating a couple steps ahead of where they’re inevitably headed towards, much like the headlights on the nocturnal pavement of the opening credits. It reminded me a lot of Nolan’s Memento, only without the caustic misanthropy that Nolan loves to indulge in. When I watch a Lynch film, I do feel that he’s some strange sort of New Hollywood humanist, wailing against the repetitive behaviors and casual/formal normalities that keep people miserable and alienated from each other, but that’s really about all that I have. Maybe someone could better explain him to me, but I almost feel like to ‘explain’ him in a quasi-academic fashion is to dismiss what he’s going for. Lost Highway, for all its mysteries, seems to me to be a film not so much about pluming those unconscious depths, but about feeling the anxiety that accompanies the experience of not being able to approach those depths, the terrifying sense of drift and unease when you realize that your life only exists on the tenuous rim of a black hole. Fred/Pete cannot overcome their lack of identification with their actions because there’s some grand metaphysical illness that seems to have infected the whole of reality, the film narrative itself, an illness which cannot be cured, but only avoided or accepted. There’s that melancholy again. Maybe I don’t understand Lynch because, when writing pieces like this, I’m trying to comprehend him and his motives. Maybe instead I should just accept what he is, what he does, and that maybe I’ll never quite get as close to that as I want to, and that that’s okay. 

The title of Lost Highway denotes a place of travel and movement that can also be a place of vanishing and forgetfulness, a process that can only be traced by its absence, not its existence. If I had any insight into Lynch, maybe it’s that, that he’s an artist of absence, and the effect that absence has on human beings who have a desperate craving for anything of substance. If this is part of how Lynch sees the world, it's a very bleak view indeed.

(Requested by Paul, a Patron. Thanks Paul!)

Comments

No comments found for this post.