Jennifer's Mind-Body Problem (Patreon)
Content
What you see in Jennifer’s Body is the waning grasp of gonzo-horror in the American consciousness. That a movie like this failed to critically materialize itself in the way that Wes Craven’s equally-flawed Scream did was a clear signal to all the downbeat fanatics that this was a cult in the making, if not already-manifested in 2009 by the burgeoning social media conglomeration of cinephilia, and who can blame them for the bandwagon? ‘09 was ablaze with unique and interesting horror titles, from Raimi’s Edgar Allen Poe-esque Drag Me To Hell, to Rob Zombie’s Halloween II, Zombieland, Orphan, Triangle; it was a solid year for the genre, especially for focusing on berserk female characters. Looking back, this league of films were not afraid to tick all the boxes: sick gore, crazy twists, emotional complexity, character studies, post-modern kitsch, we had it good in the Hollywood world. What happened to the bygone era of Jennifer’s Body is a story told within the film’s own flaws, which are inseparable from its qualities, a combative struggle to see what would survive in a stratified artistic landscape on the cusp of streaming-service ascendance. A story told in this way shows you the stitches and seams of the post-Scream self-aware horror movie, a post-Columbine desire to deal with real traumatic suffering undercut by a detached ironic superiority to any genuine tenderness. Now we don't even get this combo: it's either trauma-porn or irony-porn, so thank god for this, which has the integrity to be purely pornographic, for our entertainment.

To be precise, Jennifer’s Body's is aggressively dated porn. Coming into my own highschool years, it’s hard not to recall the black-hole singularity that Megan Fox held over pop culture; this was before film critics totally destroyed her reputation as an actor, before her comments about Michael Bay’s on-set fascism, before she settled into her stardom and was still at the behest of a hyper-sexualized media gaze desperate to claim her as the next Angelina Jolie in a post-Brangelina universe. For Fox to lead a horny horror-comedy written by an Academy Award-winning screenwriter seemed like the surest bet to have in-between Transformers sequels; it was her staking her claim as a horror icon, and its success over time cannot be denied, as horror icons are often deemed to be so years after their immediacy has faded into yearly-canonization by Halloween obsessives. Saying that a film like Jennifer’s Body is dated because it has characters say ‘jell-o’ when they mean ‘jeal-ous’ is like saying that Halloween is dated because of Jamie Lee Curtis’ gloriously feathered hair. That isn’t to say that Diablo Cody’s script is what I’d call ‘good’, especially when it’s more or less a constant barrage of tryhard terms like ‘tragedy boner’ which wouldn’t seem out of place on sites like 4chan or out of the mouth of Chunk Wendig, although I do suspect that the trashy obnoxiousness of the dialogue is a large part of what thrills the Jennifer’s Body fandom, that, and the pop-punk scene-kid Fall Out Boy style that the picture plays with serving as a nostalgic tonic for weary millennials with crude taste.
If there’s one part of this that isn’t marked by the passage of time, it’s Karyn Kusama’s classy direction, which is like if Brian de Plama had an eye for women that wasn’t compromised (enhanced?) by his voyeurism. The film elegantly provides you all the visual details you need in the prologue asylum sequence, which makes the narration accompanying it seem even more redundant than narration already is in most films. Kusama brings a virtuosic weight to the gestures of her performers, using the totality of their physiques, catching jokes in the frame that don’t exist on the page, pouring her actor’s eyes into what they look at, leaving us with clenched throats as we suspect that there’s something wounded in Jennifer’s Body’s reality than simply a satanic indie band and an ill-fated succubus. When Amanda Seyfried’s confused Needy stares at Jennifer while the latter flirts with sexually consuming her former friend, we ache with the pain of her being unable to recognize the same soul that once waved to her across the popular kid-nerd divide; she’s so used to seeing herself reflected in those pupils, and now finds that a cold predator leers back at her. This wasn’t the intimate experience she wanted, not this way, not this mechanical. Jennifer’s demonic possession turns her into a mobile wax dummy, a sterile object that devours its onlooker while they have their eyes on the prize. The hollowing out of their friendship hurts not because they were the best of friends, but because they needed each other to validate their existence. Jennifer’s Body excites us with violence, yet it has the most power when glancing at the weightlessness of words, the careless way that we address the people we care about when we take them for granted as being permanent extensions of ourselves.

The film isn’t generous with that philosophy. Outside of Needy and Jennifer herself in the first act, we don’t care about anyone else here because the narrative takes for granted that we’ll respond to certain stimuli like lab-rats; when the mandated murders happen, there’s no joy or regret in what’s occurring, as we are no longer invested in Jennifer’s own subjectivity, and the people she’s killing are stock high school stereotypes. They’re also all men; hence arrives the film’s ‘feminism’, which it engenders by disparaging all genders equally. Not to deny the film’s clear bisexuality, but it’s shallow and callow, thinking that by destroying both objects of Needy’s desire, namely Jennifer and her doofus boyfriend, we’ll sit back and applaud its even-handedness, when actually the ending is a statement in cowardice, wherein Needy miraculously escapes her mental hospital confinement via supernatural means to wreck havoc on the satanic douchebags who victimized Jennifer. If the film played out its own logic to the end, we’d see the numbing of Needy’s personality through tragedy until she herself is broken and erratic, unable to bring herself back into daily life after seeing both her lovers annihilated equally by her actions and passivity. Perhaps she stays this way, and perhaps she becomes a non-demonic monster through this trauma. That Jennifer’s Body instead ends with a tale of future badass vengeance communicates to us that we’re not really meant to take any of this seriously, which is a shame, as it’s more than effective at getting us to see that Needy’s clingy ideal of Jennifer is something so relatably pathetic and human. The film abandons that humanity for a slick certainty; it really shouldn’t.

(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!)