Joan of Arc, of Herself, of God, and Others (Patreon)
Content
How do we justify our actions? And who or what gives that justification? What is in-side or out-side ourselves? Luc Besson’s film The Messenger, his Joan of Arc saga, is perhaps the most interesting of the post-Braveheart epics, because it’s the only one I know of which leaves us open-towards-questioning the validity of its valorized subject matter, which isn’t surprising, because Joan as a figure is defined by paradox and Milla Jovovich's portrayal delves head-first into this complexity. How did this girl exist in her time, in her place, in her history, in our memory? A teenage girl immolated by the gender binary who literally forced the French nation-state into existence because of her own supernatural experiences; it reads absurd. Unlike the Christ or the Buddha, she hasn’t been completely mythologized yet, she hasn’t been buried under centuries of historiography, hagiography, interpretation, and mis/dis-information. We know she was a real person with documented actions who did things that we can recognize effects of hundreds of years later. But the historical record can never tell us the why of Joan; like Christ, we have to interpret that for ourselves and our time.

The Messenger challenges the ‘purity’ of Joan’s convictions without undermining her innocence in the face of the tyranny she faced, it wonders how this girl thought of herself in her own context, and how she could rationalize both her irrational experiences and her irrational place in the history of the earth’ its conclusions err on the side of a compassionate skepticism. Joan isn’t known as a killer, but she fought in a war, rode on horseback, wearing armor, and mostly certainly engaged with combat at some point with English forces… but we often conceive of her as being above-the-fray, swaying the banner of France and Christ, a beacon above the violence. And that’s just stupid and naive, as the film points out; Joan mostly likely did bash some heads in, and she did it in the name of a God who said “Thou Shalt Not Kill”. This isn’t a new moral dilemma for Christians, as there have been innumerable justifications for two thousand years for inflicting death on behalf of a deathless deity; none of it convincing, in my view, but it’s there, and Joan forces it to make sense, because to her, God showed her several signs that meant that France must have her as its savior. The Messenger points out the self-serving nature of this, but not how that’s necessarily a bad thing… it’s merely a disavowed truth. Joan can’t claim her power and status by her own virtues or desires, she claims it on behalf of a God who commands the ultimate authority over both kings and peasant girls, and thus, miraculously, is able to lead the armies of France. The Messenger’s take-away from this is that, when faced with the death of burning at the stake, Joan must reckon with what her message is as God’s herald, and where that message comes from, and that if she’s honest with herself, she must admit that she wanted to be what she became before she became it; the ‘innocent peasant girl’ shtick is a false modesty, and some part of her knows that.

It seems cruel to say; why condemn Joan for being unable to face her culpability when her entire social apparatus is based on guilt and penance? But the film doesn’t condemn, it only asks the question, and demands honesty, and once that honesty is given, we’re left with an uncomfortable feeling that Joan’s interpretation of her own signs were merely the rhetoric of a self-deluding person, rather than an ‘authentic revelation’ that drove her to have an inspired life. Yet, to me, that’s a false dichotomy; yes, Joan used the religious and political context of her time to place herself into a powerful and socially advantageous position, but the film doesn’t question Joan’s impression that she had an experience in the first place; it wonders if the experience could have been seen otherwise. And maybe it could have, but it wasn’t, and that’s the whole deal – does Joan owe the world a verification of faith? No. We can sneer and put ourselves above Christianity, but that system of belief only exists because people had and still have strange experiences that they need help understanding; it’s equally as possible that Joan’s message from God could have been seen by someone else as an instance of fairy trickery, or like the English thought at the time, demonic possession. It was Joan who took her experience and placed it into her world, used that world to make sense of something that overwhelms the senses. As someone who’s had similar experiences, it cannot be exaggerated how incredibly hard it is to avoid such interpretation. The Messenger flags Joan as being self-deluded, but not dishonest, and we must face the bare quality of what happened – if something like that happened to you, would you do much to the contrary? If you thought that you might be given the task of carrying a special destiny into this world, of communicating a powerful meaning that would change the lives of others for the better, could you still hold yourself as a meager skeptic of your own experience?

Some people do, some people go through the craziest shit that you’ll ever hear and they’ll simply chalk it up to paranoia or drugs or a rogue hallucination. This stuff is more common than we’ll ever know… but you already know that, don’t you? We all do. But that knowing is not enough, that knowing is fodder for personal anecdotes and sometimes ridicule. Joan transformed that knowing into action, into faith, into conviction. She denied her own desire, but did everything to fulfill it anyway, because she did believe that there was a divine message hidden in her existence that must be given to the world. No one can truly judge her, save for herself and her God, because those are the only beings who know her with any familiarity. We talk about her, and she still matters, because she collapsed the distinction between mortal appetite and divine mandate. Maybe there’s no difference between them at all; and if Joan is indeed guilty of fooling herself, may we all be such meaningful fools.

(Requested by Brice, a Patron. Thanks Brice!)