Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

How do you even begin to write about your favorite film of all-time? How does this happen? There are two kinds of favorite films, in my experience: foundational texts for your personal taste, and accumulated appreciations. The former often emerge in youth, when there is still a taste to be shaped, and the latter builds up as one becomes familiar with the greater spectrum of the cinematic experience. In the decade-plus since I’ve first watched Marry Harron’s American Psycho, I’ve thought of it to be one of the cornerstones of my pre-cinephilic experience; it was the first movie I saw that made me stop considering films as ‘mere’ entertainment, and begin to regard them as artistic statements with merits outside of the American blockbuster model. I’ve seen it at least sixty times at this point, and I’ve likely thought about it more than any other single film since then.

My difficulty in writing about it then seems idiotic, and mostly stems from my desire to branch out and develop a broader taste, and also my cowardice in avoiding the memeified status that this film has achieved in recent years; the things one does to not be considered a shallow ‘filmbro’. Yet the time has come to move beyond this, and finally put my feelings together in a more concrete expression.

Perhaps it’s easiest to begin with the psychology of it all, or lack thereof. The insidious brilliance of the film (and the novel as well, perhaps the only Bret Easton Ellis text that truly justifies his excesses) is that Patrick Bateman is a negating rebuttal to all the ideological gunk that’s built up around serial killer mythology: the medical diagnoses, the narrativized traumatic childhood, the paced fury of murders, the dispensability of the victims, the cult of personality attained afterwards. Patrick Bateman is a fucking loser; we never understand the motives behind his desire to kill, we never gain any true insight into his soul, we are never allowed to fetishize him in a way that would make what he does look ‘cool’. The book accomplishes this by assaulting the reader with the sheer shallow stupidity of his inner-monologue, the repetitive madness of his catalog-cum-eviscera descriptions that make a man eating someone’s brains into a half-boring routine, while the movie takes the cliches of 80s cinema (the Tom Cruise yuppie, the consumerist montage, the erotic thriller) and sucks all the visceral MTV slickness out of them, leaving only a Bateman who talks exclusively in references to pop music, movies, celebrities, and buying this or that with money that he barely earns. He sucks, he’s dull, he’s not an interesting person; the man has no depth, he’s a pure surface, which makes him a perfect cinematic object, of course. “There is only an idea of a Patrick Bateman.” he intones while glaring into the camera, his skin glistening with anxiety at the notion of his own existential folly.

The film’s refusal to give Patrick any interiority is its greatest strength; even at the climax, in which he flails wildly at the lack of consequences to his actions, the way that the world denies him any catharsis for his transgressions, we still do not get the sense that he has arrived at a deeper level of insight about himself or his place in the world. “This confession has meant nothing.” – this is not a character study of a man, but a satire of an attitude and its implications. Bateman lives in such a disposable corporate reality that it ultimately does not matter in the slightest whether or not he murders sex workers and homeless people – his Wall Street buddies do that by proxy every single day, merely in a more indirect fashion than he does. Bateman’s absurdity is that he’s a literalized reflection of Americanism; the guy thinks that he’ll somehow obtain transcendence from his debased circumstance if he pushes hard enough, if he commits enough sins. Paul Schrader is a key to this film; American Gigolo was one of the first MTV-styled sex thrillers that placed an emphasis on conspicuous consumption, with a Bressonian detached protagonist suspected of being a murderer. Schrader’s film has a spiritual core, where Richard Gere’s sex worker is brought into relief by forming a connection with one of his clients, a person who breaches the boundaries of his hermetically-sealed life and shows him that there is something beyond himself. Bateman comes close to this with his secretary, Jean; she’s the only person he invites to his apartment that he doesn’t kill, but why? Only because his specified way of murder-by-nailgun is interrupted by a message from his faux-girlfriend Evelyn on his answering machine; the flow of his murder-fantasy is interrupted, the erotic charge diminished, and he lets Jean go thinking that he’s merely rebuffed her to save face with said girlfriend. There is zero realism here, no psychology; whereas Schrader dialetically challenges the limitations of his lonely men, Harron reaffirms Bateman’s cursed monomania, where even the disruption in the suspense results in a flaccid diffusion instead of an explosive dramatic realization.

I’ve very obsessed with this fatalism, and American Psycho is likely the first film I experienced that holds fast against the American cinema’s tendency towards declarations of free will and happy endings.  No matter what Bateman does, no matter who he kills or hurts, he cannot run away from the emptiness inside him, and the world reflects his actions, not in a causal way, but in a cruel logic that highlights a truth that few are willing to consider the implications of: it doesn’t matter to society at large if a rich guy kills sex workers, if he has a couple of decapitated heads in his freezer, if he runs around his apartment with a chainsaw. Ace Rothstein in Martin Scorsese’s Casino puts it perfectly: “Money is like a morality car-wash.” These things happen all the time: the rich kill us all, slowly by degrees or quickly, and they’re allowed to get away with it because the reality they’ve constructed allows them to do so. Bateman is the beneficiary of a job given to him by his dad, so of course his lawyer doesn’t believe him when he says that he killed all these people; in real life, why would he? The film posits all of this in a surreal ending, but it’s very much a non-surreal topic – it’s as real as it gets.

Bateman is interchangeable with all his shitty yuppie colleagues, the Paul Allens and McDermotts of the world, because what does it matter who they are? They’re not accountable for their sins in any capacity beyond their own sense of right-and-wrong, which ceases to mean anything when you can easily obtain anything you want without accounting for serious repercussions. There likely are real Patrick Batemans of our world, almost certainly, but we don’t know about the vast majority of them; their sins are absorbed as a silent ‘necessary’ externality of capitalism. Which is why the ‘This Is Not An Exit’ scene remains so incredible powerful: even Bateman is a prisoner of this system, even his humanity, as evil as it is, is made into an everyday banality. Transgression is impossible when your existence itself is an automated transgression; free will ceases to matter without the ability to imagine the truly impossible. Wall Street is already a club of murderers and criminals; to them, Bateman isn’t anything exceptional. He’s just another face behind a desk, behind a dinner table, behind a limousine window, but behind that face, behind the surface, behind all qualities and events, behind the business card?

“I simply am not there.”


(Requested by Brice, a Patron. Thanks Brice!)

Comments

No comments found for this post.