A Serious Man: In Praise of the Yes-Sayer (Patreon)
Content
The human experience is a series of apocalypses tumbling over each other in a mad frenzy of insane circumstances; A Serious Man is a document of what that experience feels like for one man to go through what would be an existential crisis for any half-sensible person. Larry Gopnik’s life is a cosmic joke, and he’s the punchline: too enthralled with the stresses of his home and job to give the proper due to the instances of wonder and happiness he has. His son’s ecstatic bar mitzvah, the neglected genius of his brother, the accommodating friendship of his wife’s boyfriend… none of it lingers for too long before we and him are thrust into the shit-storm of futile absurdity that seems to characterize Larry’s hapless existence.
He asks his rabbi, and by proxy G-d, a question: “Why does he give us the question if he won’t provide any answers?”
Asking this after receiving the wisdom of his rabbi regaling to Larry a wonderful story of a man found with a message in Hebrew letters inscribed on the inside of his teeth; what could be more absurd than this? The question, not the story – why, why, why, “Why have you forsaken me?” begs the Christ, but that’s not in the Hebrew Bible. Instead, we have the Book of Job, in which a man begs for death only to receive a series of humiliations, impoverishments, desolation, then to have it restored upon seeing the visage of the Divine rather than hearing His dictates, repent, repent. Why? Job forsakes himself, debases himself, yet finds his faith once more while in the pits of injustice and despair, admitting that he knows not the why of his suffering, but still repents in the face of implacable authority, because the only retreat from the poverty of material existence is through the victory of the soul’s certainty.
“Nobody likes you. Everyone hates you. You’re gonna lose. Smile, you fuck.”

Larry Gopnik takes it all a little too seriously. Middle class values, middle class problems. He doesn’t know why his wife is leaving him, what his children are up to, why his neighbors cut a part of his lawn, whether or not Schrodinger’s cat is dead or alive. Because it has to be one or the other, right? There has to be an effect for every cause, the mathematical logic behind each event, an answer. Why? Why anything, why this, why that, why bother, why ask why? We’re anxious, that’s why. We operate via a certain set of expectations that we rarely ever create, and when those expectations run into conflict with the rest of reality which has no responsibility to realize those expectations, we freak out and think that something’s ‘wrong’, when really it’s us that frustrate ourselves. There’s nothing wrong with desire, with wanting this or that; what’s wrong is thinking that your life depends on this or that bullshit, whatever it is. You sleep on a couch instead of a bed, you miss out on a raise at your job, your partner separates from you; guys like Larry, who is all of us, think that their selves are fixed, and that everything else is in flux, and it’s that flux that’s the problem. Why Hebrew letters in a man’s teeth? Why not? What’s stopping anything from being anything? And who cares? Us? We shouldn’t, because we’d be a lot better off taking it in stride. Your cat dies, you stub your toe, your car gets stolen, you get cancer. Yes, and? What are we to do? What is our task, here on this earth? We’re here for a reason, and it is my reasoning that it is this: your one job here, that one job, is to decide what is or is not within your ability, and then act accordingly.
My man Larry can’t really do anything about most of his problems. But his one failing student who tried to bribe him and latter attempts to sue him? He erases that student’s F grade, and replaces it with a C-. He can do that, and does it, not for extremely memorable or meaningful reasons, but because he makes a choice, an arbitrary choice made in the midst of his whole life falling apart before his eyes.

What did Job do? He made a choice to place his faith in a deity that allowed Job to be put through the wringer, understanding that if Satan was going to make his life into hell, all that Job himself had was spiritual salvation. When faced with the impossible, he assessed what was possible for him and what wasn’t, and made a pragmatic choice, not knowing whether it would pay off or not, but hoping for the best.

That’s faith, isn’t it? But a pragmatic sort of faith that isn’t fussy, isn’t easy, isn’t lovey-dovey holding hands with G-d skipping down Paradise Line. G-d, according to the Hebrew Bible, has a chosen people, the Israelites. Who’s to say this wasn’t also a pragmatic choice for Him? Out of all the various peoples of the planet, He rolled the dice with an enslaved and oppressed tribe to honor his Covenant and to honor them in return. Psychologically, that couldn’t have been easy. There’s no guarantee that anything’s going to work out well, even if you’re the big cheese of the universe. Either that cat in the box is alive or dead when it’s opened, but until it is opened, you don’t know. It’s a work in progress, like anything is, like Larry is; his character, his personhood, his soul.
Why no answers, and only questions? G-d can pose a question, can decide what box to put Schrodinger’s kitty in, but even He doesn’t know how that shit is gonna turn out in the end, because it doesn’t work that way. We get cursed with the responsibility of providing the answers for the impossible questions of the universe, and it’s our choice to own up to that duty or to reject it. You wanna bemoan your life? Absolutely. But you cannot run away from it, you cannot escape your reality, you can only live in bad faith about it. Somebody's gotta pay for all that life you've been living, and it might as well be you. Otherwise, why do anything if it isn't going to be everything we can do?

A Serious Man ends with another apocalypse facing Larry and his son, but we don’t get to see how it plays out. It’s a reflection of our own values and temperament whether we see that ending as a doom to despair over, or as a life-affirming challenge. That’s our choice: accepting the mystery, or not.
(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!)