On the Expression of Beauty in The Cinema (Patreon)
Content
What is the relationship between cinema and the notion of Beauty? For the cinema, Beauty is surely one of the many things it may make cinematic, may document for posterity, may transfigure into a new perspective. For Aristotle, Beauty is the harmony of a certain overarching order found in nature; for Hegel, Beauty is the full expression of freedom found within material objects, humanity’s sublation of nature into spirit; for Nietzsche, Beauty is the amoral expression of a person’s individual experience and passions. The cinema can and does maintain such definitions of Beauty. Yet what can we see as distinctly cinematic conceptions of Beauty, conceptions that do not fundamentally originate in philosophy, painting, or theater?
What we must first define as cinematic Beauty must be an extension of the cinema’s individual strengths as a form: Depth and Montage. Depth in the cinema is the transposition of figures and context within a relation of Space (i.e. movement, whether by figures within a frame, or the frame’s own movement towards, alongside, or away from its figures); Montage in the cinema is the invisible unity of depth via the edit, a unity by which one can juxtapose various Depths within Time. Depth is the image with communicates via Time’s passage, and Montage is the non-image which communicates via the inherent interval of Space.
Where then arrives Beauty, and how does it arrive? There are four ways that Beauty may be manifest in the cinematic language: Beauty can be found within the spatial arrangement of Depth, the temporal passage of Depth, the temporal presence of Montage, and the spatial relation of Montage. Some more helpful definitions:
- Spatial Depth is what is where within a frame: why an apple sits on a table instead of a tree, why a woman holds her hands in prayer instead of holding a rifle, why the horizon is at the bottom of the screen instead of the top. This is a three-dimensional outline of the cinematic space, and is the earliest manifestation of composition as-such. Spatial Depth is cinema-as-painting.
- Temporal Depth is how long the frame lasts, and why it does. This is most commonly showcased within so-called ‘slow cinema’, and is concerned with the weight of time and the movement contained within a frame. If Spatial Depth is three-dimensional, then Temporal Depth is fourth-dimensional, and deals with alterations to the figures contained in the cinema: a person walking begins in one spot of the frame and ends up in another corner, the camera moves from the outside of a house and in through the window. Temporal Depth is cinema-as-entropy.
- Temporal Montage is the particular separation of Depths from each other, the metronome beat of comparison and contrast. Whether it’s the borderline incoherence of Tony Scott’s frenzy, the slow-fast-slow wavelength of Woo/Peckinpah, or the glacial clarity of Hou Hsiao-Hsien, Temporal Montage is the pace at which we receive Depths within the edit, and how that acceleration or deceleration provides an effect within the margins of Depths themselves. Temporal Montage is cinema-as-heartbeat.
- Spatial Montage is the way the perspective of Depths can communicate continuity via differing coverage of a frame’s figures and context; no longer 'what is seen?', but 'what CAN or CANNOT be seen?'. The question of Spatial Montage is an ethical one: Why settle for one shot of a large building when two or three shots of the same building in succession can express its totality from different perspectives? This is perhaps the most important and flexible of cinema’s expressions, where choices must be made as to why Spatial Depth should contain this-or-that figure within this-or-that context, and is directly opposed to the aims of Temporal Depth: it is functionally impossible for a space to receive complete perspective via Temporal Depth, as movement inherently forces change upon the image, but the same moment can be captured by at least two cameras and then juxtaposed back-to-back with Spatial Montage, or, two separate moments may be made to seem the same. This opens up a paradoxical number of choices to a prospective filmmaker; those with limited, controlled Spatial Montage are the ascetics of the medium, and those with indulgent, extravagant Spatial Montage are the dark magicians of film, illusionists of the highest order. Spatial Montage is cinema-as-sin.
Each of these expressions finds Beauty not in the balancing of each other, but rather the extremity in which they may be pushed into one direction or another, and the contrast they have between each other’s own extremity. Think of this not as a series of happy mediums, but dials which must be carefully modulated towards high or low: the greatest artists of film are able to do this, to achieve Beauty within artistic extremes, and use that to communicate Truth. Not every director uses the same arrangement of these expressions all the time in the exact same way, but the ones who do achieve such a consistency are usually deemed to be auteurs -- this is the essence of 'style'.
For example, compare Josef von Sternberg’s highly-complex and messy Spatial Depth with Jean-Pierre Melville’s stark, clean Spatial Depth:
Sternberg:
Melville:
Or compare Michael Bay’s careening Temporal Montage with Yasujirō Ozu’s syncopated, symmetrical, and measured Temporal Montage:
Bay: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DsEEf5KT2Kk
Ozu: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6dKP6C7STJA
It is my belief that Beauty within the cinema is not a singular static ideal that has the same constant appearance regardless of the form or style, but rather an object that cinema can only reach by vaulting itself above and beyond the normal means of the human eye. A sunset may be ‘beautiful’ to us, but it isn’t a work of art because there is no limitation to it: it has no boundaries save for human subjectivity itself, and thus has no concept of extremity. Capital-B Beauty is a treasure to be found within art; it is not something immediately apparent, not something inherently historical, not something bound to a certain time or place, but rather is created within Time and Place themselves, immanent to the non-human via art, accessible via perception, and understood by the human being via reasoning.
There is no exact mixture or formula for achieving Beauty in any art form, let alone the cinema; some ‘good’ films don’t have an ounce of Beauty within them, and other ‘bad’ films often have a singular element that strikes us as being incredibly Beautiful and well-done. Beauty, to me, is that which takes on various guises within art, yet is immediately apparent to those with the discernment to see beyond art’s supposed limitations as a document of a singular ‘reality’, and opens up the spirit towards the unity of all realities. Beauty is expressed via subjectivity, but its essence is ‘objective’ in the sense of being eternal, immutable, divine. Humans, who are blessed with possessing the characteristics of mundanity and divinity, can perceive the Beauty within the cinema and thus explore the metaphysical boundaries of our world in all its quantum complexity, and by creating art with Beauty, we may exalt ourselves into a brighter and better place by the process of bringing-forth what is True and immortal from what is momentary and False – to make a couple seconds of someone’s face last a lifetime, to preserve what is spiritual in the material itself.
(Requested by Trevor, a Patron. Thanks Trevor!)
Files
Previews only