Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The subtle demarcation between guilt and shame is that shame is a socially-induced phenomenon – you are made to feel ashamed by external pressure – while guilt is internally held within your soul, you are made to hold yourself accountable. It is why we are so often resentful of attempts to shame us, “You want me to feel this way about something that I don’t feel that way about? Fuck you.”, we can combat that source of shaming because we hold our selves apart from those who are enforcing that shame. Yet, as every Catholic knows, guilt is the one albatross that you cannot run away from – the only way past it is either forgetting, or confrontation.

Michael Haneke’s Cache illustrates this from a god’s eye perspective; its central characters, the recipients of unknown harassment, are the beneficiaries of a post-colonial political system whose effects are implied in said harassment. We have the ‘objective’ format of the videotapes arriving at their door, the child’s drawings, and are never told the source of these items; it becomes clear by the end that the source does not matter in the slightest, and rather, we are made to linger on the effects that they create upon a man’s conscience. Cache is neo-Dostoyevsky, a Tell-Tale Heart about France’s not-too-distant past as one of the world’s premiere and longest lasting empires, a theme in which we are left with the conclusion that this legacy of imperialist violence and subjugation is far from over.

Instead of lingering on ‘Who?’ sends the tapes, it seems more fruitful to ask why this harassment is in tapes, which ominously record images in and around Georges Laurent’s home a la David Lynch’s Lost Highway. We see that Georges is a famous news broadcaster in France, so his first conclusion is that this is some obsessive fan of his, but again, that source is less important than the medium in which Georges’ guilt is being relayed to him and him specifically. He becomes paranoid about its source and begins to speculate that it has something to do with his actions in negatively affecting Majid, a boy he grew up alongside whose parents were killed in the 1961 Paris Massacre – Georges convinces his parents not to adopt Majid, or at least he blames himself for that non-adoption, and later sees how Majid lives a much different life than Georges’ own bourgeois existence. Yet Majid and his son deny having anything to do with the tapes, and Haneke admits that he’s not really interested in the mystery contrivances of the thriller genre outside of using it to showcase the theme he wishes to explore in Cache – so what’s the deal here?

One, the phenomena is tailored specifically towards Georges – a man who is constantly on television being subject to a camera’s surveillance outside of his job, in addition to drawings and letters which invoke his own personal memories of the stories he made up to refute the possibility of Majid’s adoption. It’s not just the fact of being stalked, but rather that the stalker seems to violate the boundaries of Georges’ sense of self, his memories and existence becoming uncomfortably permeable with who is monitoring him and making him aware of said watching, but also because it doesn’t have an individual source, it feels omnipresent and all-powerful, and disturbs us, as we are used to thinking of our thoughts and feelings as being locked within us as secrets until we choose to express them. This is a very perilous subject matter, because it implies that the separation between past/future and self/non-self is an arbitrary construction – much like how Georges inhabits the homes of his viewers on television, now some abstract presence inhabits his own life, a presence that is of him but also not him, that knows his soul but torments it as well.

This phenomena has several parallels with mystical philosophy, Buddhism, and the paranormal, and it is what intrigues me most about Cache, this lack of answers and a refusal to explain its own conceit. Haneke undercuts this genius though by reducing his film to the intellectualism of pure metaphor; when asked the question of ‘Who?’ sent the tapes, he had this to say:

“I'm not going to give anyone this answer. If you think it's Majid, Pierrot, Georges, the malevolent director, God himself, the human conscience – all these answers are correct. But if you come out wanting to know who sent the tapes, you didn't understand the film. To ask this question is to avoid asking the real question the film raises, which is more: how do we treat our conscience and our guilt and reconcile ourselves to living with our actions? People are only asking, "whodunnit?" because I chose to use the genre, the structure of a thriller, to address the issues of blame and conscience, and these methods of narrative usually demand an answer. But my film isn't a thriller and who am I to presume to give anyone an answer on how they should deal with their own guilty conscience?”

This, to me, is entirely the wrong way to approach this topic, because it lays bare an author’s thematic intent to communicate a theme indirectly, instead of allowing the ambiguity of that indirectness to blossom into a thousand meanings and readings. Haneke makes the film ask an abstract question, but then provides a non-abstract answer: “Cache is a film about a man’s guilty conscience.”, which is more than obvious to us as an audience. Why communicate this theme in an indirect way, then? Why raise the question of who did what? Because Haneke makes a film for his idea, then finds a genre format in which that idea becomes legible to viewers, and by discarding the conventions of that genre, he tells the viewer that the questions they asked during the course of the film are pointless, and that ‘really’ this is a film about one thing instead of many things. This is intellectualism, where the process of experiencing film is reduced to thinking about film as a concept rather than feeling through it intuitively.

It’s unfortunate that Cache leaves one without the questions it is so skilled at raising – there really is something incredible here about how technology makes us always porous to the hidden recesses of the past, how a videotape’s usage in different contexts can illicit both banality and horror. The conclusions that Cache arrives at about colonialism are ones that can be read in a pre-packaged form, devoid of experiential quality, understood solely on a textual basis of summary, but the apparently disposable thriller structure, to me, is what is most interesting about the work, but Haneke is guilty about having to use this structure, so he doesn't lean into its surreal and metaphysical elements, and instead retreats into his thesis statement. It’s a classic case of the form and function being at odds with each other, or at the very least, one being subservient to the other – before a film has any ideas on its mind, it should hold fast to the feelings of its heart. Haneke forfeits this, and thus forfeits his own film.


(Requested by Brice, a Patron. Thanks Brice!)

Comments

No comments found for this post.