Saving Face, and Finding Family (Patreon)
Content
(Warning: this gets a bit personal and messy.)
The relationship between queerness and family is always a tense one, in my personal experience and in Alice Wu’s delightful romcom Saving Face. The people who raise you and surround you at family gatherings are used to thinking of you as a second-class person, someone to be taken care of and managed in the correct way, especially in close-knit families, who typify their experience of who you are before you’re allowed the room to figure out who exactly you really want to be.
In Saving Face, Wil Fang is an up-and-coming surgeon, the model Chinese daughter, but she’s still closeted to her family because of the tight web of gossip and filial piety that links New York’s Chinese-American community together. Much like her mother, Gao, she’s expected to marry a man soon and fulfill a certain range of expectations that no one has ever bothered to ask if she actually wants to. Gao is latter abandoned by her father due to an out-of-wedlock pregnancy, and excommunicated from the household until she marries and ‘makes things right’. But one can see how these different events between mother and daughter are handled in the same way: compliance within a set of social boundaries results in economic assistance and inclusion within the Chinese family unit, and disruption of those boundaries results in banishment or dismissal. When Wil latter comes out to her mother in a desperate moment, Gao replies in disbelief “I am not a bad mother . . . My daughter is not gay.” Her homophobia in this instance is not the bigotry of hatred, but rather the linkage of a child’s homosexuality with a perceived ‘failure’ in the mother’s parenting, that any deviance on Wil’s part reflects badly on Gao’s already-strained status; in a way, Wil’s ‘sins’ thus become Gao’s ‘sins’. This echoes an earlier part in the film where Gao’s father, Wai, says that Gao’s unexpected pregnancy brings more shame on him than it does her, and that this situation discredits him as a parent. Both Gao’s pregnancy and Wil’s sexual orientation are breaks in the moral chain of the patriarchal Chinese family unit, perceived as unstable elements that do not abide by the set expectations, and the responsibility for these things also falls upon the progenitors of said person, so that one is encouraged to keep secrets and hide any deviance – repression thus becomes a matter of course, not the exception.
That Wil is a successful part of the Chinese-American middle class is a result of chance as much as her own personal skill, a chance that can and could be taken from her just like how it was temporarily taken from her mother – women, regardless of sexual orientation, are treated with a ‘moral’ severity that none of the men in Saving Face are seen to suffer through, and this morality directly correlates with the economic structure of the bourgeois ideal of the family unit. Men are the source of essential paid labor, and thus command and reinforce their own power structure, while women are seen as ‘disposable’, regardless of any labor they themselves participate in, especially domestic labor, which isn’t given the same gravity as the men’s because the work that takes place within a home and the work which takes places at the ‘job’ has been divided along gendered lines – the women in these families provide an immense source of time and effort that is taken for granted, so when Gao becomes pregnant in a way that’s outside the protocols set up by this family unit, her father sees the cost in his own labor that it might take to help his widowed daughter raise another child, and chooses instead to belittle and forfeit her, for the sake of ‘saving face’ as much as saving himself that economic imperative.
I detail this relationship in this way because the same exact thing happened to me and my family. My mother’s parents, my grandparents, had been saving up a college fund for me since I was a small child, and when I turned seventeen, they began to tell me all about it and how I can use it for the schools I was expected to apply to. So far, so good. But after I left high school, I began to come out of the closet to everyone that I cared about, because I felt like I could actually do something about it as an adult. I eventually told my grandparents that I was trans, and asked if it was okay that I used some of that college money to begin transitioning while I was at school. In my mind, it would have been like starting a whole new life. They tentatively agreed, but then later, my grandfather, acting on my grandmother’s orders, confronted me during a Christmas shopping trip and said that I should “Really Reconsider” everything I told them before, and that there’s “No cure for AIDS.”, and that I was disappointing everyone by “pretending to be something you’re not”.
I was completely crushed, and honestly scared for my life. I told him that I was serious about this, and he said to me, “Well, there’s going to be some changes then.” I didn’t know what he meant by that at the time, but in retrospect, it should have been obvious. I was completely disposable to them. Soon after, my grandparents took the entire college fund away from me and used it to buy themselves a new car and renovate their house. My mother and I were shocked, and for years my mom tried to convince me to ‘forgive’ them, and I tried to, but they never would apologize for what they did. My grandmother died last year, never saying sorry to anyone, and my grandfather berated me after the funeral for ‘hurting her’.
I never went to college.
I thought a lot about this while watching Saving Face, how our families are based on so many arbitrary assumptions and invisible codes of behavior that you’re not supposed to act outside of. Lucky for Wil and Gao, they were able to survive what they went through and reconcile with themselves and their families, and even as Wil dances with her girlfriend at the end of the film, there are plenty of people who still choose to dance alongside them instead of engaging in homophobia. Saving Face is a really lovely portrait of Chinese-American identity and queer relationships, but at the end of the day it embraces the complicated, yet still idealized version of what a family can be, like so many Hollywood romcoms do. I haven’t had that experience in my life, but that doesn’t make it ‘false’ to me; in a way, it makes me understand how much my own family failed to live up to what could have been a healthier relationship.
Since then, I, like many queer people, have had to come up with an alternate version of what ‘family’ is, and for me, my family are those people who have stuck by me in troubled times, and I would always to the same for them. Family isn’t about blood to me, it’s about having someone there that you can rely on, about being a consistent and generous person. When your house is on fire, when you’re getting married, when you’re in the hospital, who is there to back you up? Whoever that is, that’s the real family, that's what matters.
(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!)