Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

(Warning: this piece contains discussion of self-harm and suicidal idealization.)

The collapse of a civilization is not elegant, it is not simple, it is not cathartic. What initially seems like the small typical fractures we’ve grown used to eventually pile up into a silent apocalypse, an apocalypse in which a short absence of order and system opens a vacuum of power that is quickly filled by a new system before anyone can really assess the revolutionary potential of the old system’s destruction.

I once quietly yearned for many years for something to ‘happen’, for the dream-collapse, for the event horizon of social existence, the end-framing that would be a fitting capstone on the story of the human race. My biggest nightmare was that Francis Fukuyama was right, that we were at the ‘end of history’, that nothing truly novel or interesting would ever happen in the course of human affairs, that neoliberal capitalism had won out over all its alternatives and that we would be forever stuck in a static recursion of global empire until the sun evaporated the surface of the planet Earth.

In my years of depression, I thought that the only exit I could have for my own life, without destroying said life myself, was that the entire structure of society had to destroyed instead – and as I had no faith that communism could be achieved in my lifetime, I instead opted for the more ‘realistic’ desire for the world to end. I didn’t care how it happened; an asteroid hitting the earth, a plague, killer AI, any number of ready-baked sci-fi scenarios would please me. And if I was unlucky enough to be one of the survivors afterwards, at least the task of bare survival would motivate me much more than my previous life did. This was the kind of loser I was, the stupid, lazy depths that I sunk to in order to keep myself from thoughts of suicide – why kill myself when I could ‘hope’ that something catastrophic would do it?

I kept waiting, waiting for America to collapse, waiting for something to happen, anything to happen, an event that would release me from the ‘burden’ of having to live my own life.

Then, when I stopped waiting for it and started to live, it did happen.

No litigation of the COVID pandemic is necessary right now, as you’ve lived through it as much as I have. But it was surreal to experience – suddenly, after I stopped wanting it, all the signs of apocalypse began to happen. This was a real global threat that went on to kill millions of people and disrupt basically every part of life for every person on the planet – in the age of globalization, no one was really exempt from this, it was a collective experience on a scale that I can’t imagine was felt since World War 2. The Hollywood thriller trope of a deadly virus which almost destroys the world actually happened – and we just dealt with it.

Perhaps ‘dealt’ is a strong word, maybe ‘ignored’ is more accurate, at least for Americans. We had about a year or so of everyone trying to stem the tide, then no one really gave a shit. Come 2023, and it’s basically ‘over’, even though people are still dying. We just decided that we were though with experiencing an apocalyptic scenario, and that was that.

Which then made me realize that me, as a dumb teenager/early 20-something, never figured that the history of the human species is nothing but a series of apocalypses that were experienced, ignored, and sometimes forgotten entirely. There’s no big revelation at the end of it; real life is not like the movies where the audience expects to have a tidy bow wrapped around in the third act, no, the real apocalypse is just things slowly falling apart and then maybe someone notices that, and maybe not.

America is slowly collapsing from within into a scattered series of gated urban fiefdoms and dilapidated rural wastelands, and no one gives a shit, and no one knows what to do. We had gigantic riots against police brutality in 2020, and everyone’s mostly forgotten them as much as they forgot things like the Occupy Movement. There is no revolution because there are no revolutionaries because there is no revolutionary circumstance. But there is no end, either. America will continue to wither and decay for the next century or two, and will keep acting as if it isn’t, and the qualify of life will continue to lower until we are living like rats, squatting in squalid buildings and pining for the days of suburban hell-holes and poisonous food. The nuclear missile silos will rust and be scrapped; the tanks, after they are done rolling over protesters, will run out of fuel and be abandoned on street corners; the cops will become hired mercenaries for corporate neo-feudal lords, and none of this will seem interesting to the people of the future. American flags will eventually be sold as kitsch items in the same way that Confederate flags are, nostalgia for LARPers who get tired of Ancient Rome. Like the Soviet Union, one day America will just cease to hold any sway over its own parts, and will gradually become a myth like any other ridiculous national identity does. The catharsis I once desired will never happen, not for me or for people of the future. There is no catharsis in history, no final victory over the forces of evil, no clarification of who wins or loses, no Whiggish grand advancement from cavemen to spacemen – there is only more history, more memories, more forgetting, more experience. The history of the human species is a history of perpetual decay and rebirth, and none of us will understand the point of any of it, or our place within it. Destiny has no use for our understanding, only our existence.

I write all this because Werckmeister Harmonies replaces the Western obsession with apocalypse with a realization that every supposed ‘end’ is merely an eclipse – a darkness which obscures our perception and comprehension, then fades, and we’re left wondering what happened. The collapse of the Soviet Union hangs heavy over the film – not only is the failing system blamed by the rioters of Harmonies, but the dissidents opposing said system are beaten as well. Anything associated with causing the oncoming ‘finality’ is blamed, and in the end all that is left is the bloated carcass of an entity far astray from its home – is this not the ultimate failure of the 20thcentury socialist imagination? The naive idea that the system of power was meant to go on forever, the calcification of oppression and bureaucracy to stem the tide of revolutionary fervor? The workers party which transforms a revolutionary scenario into a reformist question is equally as absurd as a whale being dragged across a land-locked European country.

Bela Tarr circles this story with circumspection and tact – his rotating camera is constantly being eclipsed by the characters, and also eclipsing them from obtaining a full awareness of what is going on. The camera is organized by the principles of Copernican astronomy, and is an object which must maintain its motion at all times – the minute that it maintains a stillness, the film ends, because it must, the orbital movement is the raison d’etre of Werckmeister Harmonies – and a critique of its own form, its own history. If there is no end to history, but only a series of eclipses which are sustained and then survived – then there really is no point to any of this, surely? Surely it’s all ridiculous, surely the human being is a sad joke of an animal, a creature whose fading orbit drags down everything which it touches – no, not down, it’s not a question of height here. Tarr’s camera isn’t privileging one perspective over another, isn’t contrasting high vs. low, good vs. evil, it’s a flat mirror which circles around the sun of its subjects, a de-centered gaze, a gaze which reflects the light of being. The camera’s viewpoint eclipses by the nature of its gaze, it eclipses the characters, surrounding them like a confessor, but we as an audience are also participating in said eclipse, our gaze is shared with Tarr’s camera, so we as observers create an anti-historical presence which privileges the distinct moment at the expense of grander context – a context that, we know, is largely irrelevant and incorrect, yet seemingly necessary for sanity in our civilization.

Does Bela Tarr then want us to show how every observation is in-itself a sort of eclipse event, an apocalypse which conceals its own finality? What does this mean for cinema? Is every shot the creation and duration of its own universe? Is this what is meant by the ‘ethics of camera movement’?

The long-take in Werckmeister’s case then becomes a positive ethical stance, not a nihilistic one, despite it portraying dissolution and destruction – the long-take here says: “Let us undertake a journey within this space and this space alone, let us inhabit a moment for as long as we are allowed to, let us take sanctuary from the burden of history, let us make a world which is not absurd, but which discloses itself in its individual perfection, let us experience the eclipse without reference to an apocalypse – there is love within the tenderness of experience, because it asks of nothing save for one to Be There, to be present-at-hand for the unfolding of occurrence at all. Let us not ask for why or what next, but for the here and now – we can achieve eternity in a second, if that second is regarded with care. The camera’s purpose is to care; to care about the world.”

I think that’s why I stopped being depressed, why I stopped wanting the world to end – I started to care about what I was experiencing, I stopped wanting to destroy something that I did not even truly see. There doesn’t have to be annihilation in order for there to be salvation – the hours of the day beckon us to see what is within them with the same grace as Bela Tarr’s camera, to caress the world with our eyes, to take care of what is in front of us. We cannot impose abstract ideas on reality – we have to begin with what’s right in front of us, the material and spiritual qualities, and build atop those. There is no historical beginning or end – but there is ascension, a flight towards love and wholeness.

I wanted either oblivion or communism to win – what I did not realize in my youth was that communism does not ‘save’ the world, it is a process of bringing the world where it needs to be, of recognizing the worth and value in everything under the sun – yes, even the eclipse which blinds us.


(Requested by Avalyn, a Patron. Thanks Av!)

Comments

No comments found for this post.