Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Over the past two years, I’ve really tried to stretch my wings and become more familiar with all kinds of European cinema, which I was largely ignorant of for a long time – mostly because it’s an intimidating subject, and I didn’t really have a reference point for how to evaluate these films. Yet, after becoming fairly knowledgeable about Classic Hollywood production and how many European directors migrated over to that system, I began to understand the ecosystem of international films, which allowed me the context to appreciate the titans of Euro arthouse and genre cinema – Leone looks a lot different to me now that I’ve seen so many of the American westerns that he was referencing in his work, especially John Ford. Before this, Leone was the ‘classic’ version of the western that I grew up with and loved; now, I can see that he’s more of a subversive and iconographic figure, less of a classicist and more of a self-aware film fan who brought an alternative cynical political lens to these types of films. I no longer take him for granted as the definer of the western, but more of the re-definer, and I can love what came before him just as much as he did.

The inverse movement I’ve had towards more European directors has mostly been with the big names – Godard, Bergman, Truffaut, Rohmer, Melville, Russell, Antonioni, etc.. But my love for film has always been with the B-tier directors, the guys and gals who work within certain limited or focused parameters but who still manage to etch out a personal vision within said limitations, of which I can see that Leone definitely belonged to. Jean Rollin and Jess Franco are a part of this ‘tradition’, and I want to see many more of their works in the future – and Dario Argento is perhaps the biggest name among these peers, the first name that I ever heard of when it came to ‘artsy’ continental genre cinema.

As still a newbie to his work, I was sold on him as being the ‘Italian Hitchcock’ who made weirdo thrillers called ‘giallos’ that featured crazy supernatural elements – so it’s my surprise that Deep Red feels like an early trial run for what he would later try to do with Suspiria. The supernatural parts here are small, with a purported ‘scientific psychic’ only serving as a convenient plot device and being the first victim of the film’s mysterious killer, and then all the apparently otherworldly effects of the editing and staging, not to mention the swollen colors, being a form of bold style rather than a feature of something within the narrative itself, a la Suspiria’s witch-house – which is all fine, of course, and Argento directs the hell out of it, with dynamic zooms and showy mobile camera shots which immerse you in the eerie situation. The plot is typical killer-mystery fluff, but in Argento's dexterous hands, it feels smooth, exciting, and huge.

Argento puts David Hemmings in a standard Hitchcockian ‘pathetic male’ investigator role, which also recalls Hemmings other famous sleuthing in Antonioni’s Blow-Up – how do these compare? Well, Hemmings isn’t an ennui-ridden jerk in Deep Red like he is in Blow-Up, but the idea of implicating the investigator within their mystery is present in both films; in Blow-Up, Hemmings is unable to put himself in the symbolic center of his own art, and realizes that the pursuit of the truth ultimately is a fruitless game among the many that he already plays within his life as a fashion photographer – an assassination he accidentally captures is ontologically the same as the women he shoots for his job, so why bother with one over the other?

Such is Antonioni’s existentialism; Argento, on the other hand, makes Deep Red have a more psychological and metatextual detective story, where Hemmings plays a fairly blank surrogate for the audience, as we’re following along with his logic and investigation instead of watching him as a character. While there were no answers in a film like Blow-Up, here we get plenty of answers to the film’s questions, because Argento views narrative the same way he constructs the violent set-pieces – build and build and build tension through denial of visual information, then deliver an explosive payoff which sums up everything which came before in the sequence. It’s a formula that works wonders for guys like Hitchcock, De Palma and Spielberg, and Argento really exploits it well – is exploit the best word here?

No; despite the gruesome kills in Deep Red, I wouldn’t call this exploitation at all, or say that Argento is an exploitation filmmaker in the same way that Jess Franco, Lucio Fulci or Jean Rollin are. The difference seems to me to be a matter of tone – those three directors have a messy and emotional attachment to certain parts of the genres they work within, there isn’t an ironic distance where there’s a consciousness that what’s going on is ‘trash’ or even ‘silly’. Franco and Rollin made actual porn movies in order to pay the bills so that they could be able to make their ‘real’ films about vampires and zombies, there was no irony there, this was their form of expression; Argento, meanwhile, inherits Hitchcock’s English dry humor, with the arm-wrestling scene indicating a contemptuous emasculation for Hemmings, and the contrast between that and the ultra-gore that was available in the 70s thanks to squibs and a lack of censorship means that Deep Red is somewhat operating in parody mode. Not fully, but you get the sense that Argento is somewhat aloof and above what’s happening, angelically swooping his camera around to capture just the right amount of roller coaster thrills for his audience.

The way that it’s edited is really the give away here – compare the kill scenes in Deep Red to ones that Fulci would do in any of his projects. In a Fulci film, you see the full extent of a character’s death in gratuitous detail – he lingers on the violence, loves the way that a zombie eats a person’s flesh, really wants to show you the process of someone being murdered in a stylized fashion, he puts all his cards on the table – the violence is more about the moment, the actual instance of death. Argento in Deep Red doesn’t do that at all – he shows the gore, but only for a precious instant, and cuts around it as needed in order to fit the shots into an escalating sequence – the suspense and shot length starts off slow, then gets quicker and quicker until you have this orgasm of death that provides catharsis for the viewer; he’s less about showing you gore and more interested in the process by which gore can be made into a spectacle. In simple terms, a director like Fulci creates a slow-paced, dreamy horror film by treating death as just a regular thing, as regular as the conversations that his characters have, while Argento creates a high-speed thriller that uses the logic of a nightmare without the lingering dreariness that nightmares themselves leave upon us.

Neither approach is wrong, but when exploring the space of these genre filmmakers, I often end up noticing how they approach similar subjects in very, very different ways – this isn’t even going into how Jean Rollin draws out death in a ridiculous fashion to emphasize the immortal decay, rather than the destruction, of his worlds. That’s the fun thing about genre, to me – because of the shared subject matters and tropes, it really helps to clarify what a director’s individual style is, as they will never approach the same material in identical ways. If you’re looking to analyze style, it’s an easy way to do it!

(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!)

Comments

No comments found for this post.