Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hollywood films rarely deal with death as well as Peter Weir’s Master and Commander does – not ‘death’ as in sheer bodycount, but the messy stupidity and blindness of death, the fickle fate of who happens to live or die based on little but being in the wrong place at the right time to have a 36-pound long-gun cannonball tear through your spine like a sheet of paper, or to expire of thirst after a dry week amidst the still waters of a salty oceanic desert – frankly, it’s a miracle that ANYONE managed to survive a 18th/19th century voyage at sea given the sheer quantity of unknown dangers and constant warfare between various naval powers… not to mention those notorious pyrates, yarrrrr.

But Master & Commander impresses upon you the importance of death to the lives of the HMS Surprise’s crew – the necessity of doing battle in the ocean, the geopolitical realities of the Napoleonic Wars, these things matter less. Like many a sea-tale, such as Melville’s Moby Dick or Edgar Allan Poe’s The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym of Nantucket, the world of landlubbers becomes distant and irrelevant the longer you stay adrift upon the Surprise or one of her rickety sisters. Captain Jack Aubrey stresses the importance of military discipline and chain of command onboard his ship, and despite my own political leanings, it is hard to argue against his philosophy when faced with the sheer existential threat that his crew faces every day on the ocean – before space exploration, the ocean was really the ultimate zone where man Did Not Belong in, and he survives there to this day based upon scientific advancement, strength of artifice and craft, and the sheer ingenuity of he and his peers.

Yet this film also emphasizes the individuality of each crew member, who are drafted into service from every corner of society, except women, of course, who are homosocially excluded from the film entirely. You have young and old, superstitious and rational, noble and commoner – the ocean doesn’t hold any biases, and its penchant for swallowing up intruders makes a good hand into a top priority for any savvy helmsman. Just as the 18th century pirates of Nassau formed their own democratic confederacy of equal partnership in the spoils of sea-crime, we see an egalitarian aspect to life upon the Surprise – every character, no matter their age or social class, seems equally likely to die in the expedition, and the film bares this out in several shocking and surprising ways – not least of which is the opening, in which we see young Midshipman Blakeney get his arm amputated to save him after a pitched battle with the Surprise’s quarry, the French privateer Acheron. Most adventure films, especially those made today, would not dare include a scene of a young boy getting his fucking arm sawed off, yet Master and Commander takes the implications of itself seriously – this can happen, it did happen in real life, and it does happen here. The film doesn’t wallow in Blakeney’s pain, and soon shows him up and about performing his usual tasks in good spirits and health, yet our eyes are drawn to the absence of his arm for the rest of the runtime – the consequences of what happens matter, and this is an exciting adventure that wishes for you to pay attention to the litanies of dead bodies and wounded men after a pitched battle. In the current age of sanitized PG-13 bloodless violence, Master and Commander strikes a good balance of providing entertainment while also being thoughtful enough to emphasize the necessary grit of naval warfare – the psychological and physical turmoil that the Surprise’s crew undergoes makes their hard-won victories that much sweeter, as they’re literally stealing victory from the jaws of otherwise-certain defeat.

The non-fatal tension that the movie also deals with is the burgeoning Enlightenment ideals that the Napoleonic Wars are being fought over – Captain Aubrey rules as an ‘enlightened’ despot aboard the ship, and his charisma and good-natured attitude endear him to the crew as a whole, but in times of disorder and emergency he expects to be listened to at all costs. Meanwhile, the Surprise’s chief surgeon, one Stephen Maturin, is a man of science who would prefer to be performing naturalist studies on tropical animals than hacking the Surprise’s crew to bits in order to keep them breathing. Aubrey and Maturin are old friends and operate in that capacity on equal footing – yet their dispositions push each of them in different directions, and provide a dialectical struggle within the ship’s microcosmic society. To complete the mission to hunt down the Acheron, or to turn back with the crew in safety? To see oceanic travel as a battleground, or to see it as an opportunity for gaining knowledge? To embrace autocracy, or to see a pluralistic view of human affairs?

The Enlightenment as a phenomenon took hold most strongly in France and Germany, and to a lesser extent in America and England – Master and Commander posits that man’s hunger for war and his thirst for wisdom must be seen as a part of the same overall imperial project, and that Maturin and Aubrey represent two equal sides of the British temperament in regards to Enlightenment – this is the film’s Edmund Burkian conservatism of considering Napoleon’s total revolution as ‘too radical’, preferring the 'slow and ready' reforms of British parliamentary politics, and thus represents the French enemy of the Acheron largely as an abstracted faceless assailant rather than a complex and empathized society like the Surprise’s. Indeed, the British Navy began to encourage all its sailors to develop scientific interests and hobbies so that each voyage would feedback into the imperial scientific base; military power thus naturally becomes scientific power, which after the Napoleonic Wars blooms into the Industrial Revolution that takes Britain from being one among equals to becoming the domineering and definitive empire of the 19th century. The steps towards this in Master and Commander are tentative and interpersonal, but they clearly lead towards greater political implications for the entire world – unfortunate ones, yet ones that affect us to this very day.

Master and Commander exists as a rare big-budget gem – a film which is made to reward repeat viewings with its wealth of historical detail and thematic intelligence, while also being a simple story about a group of human beings collectively dealing with threats beyond themselves. The spirit of Howard Hawks and John Ford lives strongly within Peter Weir’s masterpiece – take the military societies of Ford’s Cavalry trilogy, the relaxed ease of Hawks’ hangout spiels, and you have something very close to the singular satisfactions of Master and Commander. Between this and Curse of the Black Pearl, 2003 was a spoiled bounty for epic sea chronicles, blockbusters that still hold up to this very day in terms of craft and masterful filmmaking – what I wouldn’t give to have this kind of cinema back!


(Requested by Brice Lee, a Patreon. Thanks Brice!)

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.