Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

1. Youth subcultures. A huge part of Japanese media (at least what I have been exposed to) prominently features the interesting phenomenon of what would be called ‘fandoms’ in the West, subcultures which propagate themselves around an obsession with a certain hobby or lifestyle or media, and Kamikaze Girls shows us the particularly Japanese forms of lolita culture and sukeban culture, of whose current status I cannot really vouch for as I have never encountered any Japanese person who is a part of theses specific scenes. But in anime and films they’re very prominent and often used as stereotypical shorthands for types of personalities – yet Kamikaze Girls spends so much time lingering on non-stereotypical aspects of them: a member of a girl-gang who is a blabbermouth liar, a Rococo maniac who has a withdrawn and minimalist personality. I think in cinephiliac culture, there’s such a wide variety of tastes and interests that don’t get acknowledged and instead we have the ‘filmbro’ or ‘A24fan’ or ‘vulgar auteurist’ as stereotypes which don’t really cover as much as they purport to.

Something that I figure that everyone can relate to is that, as a kid, you often become very fixated on a specific topic for months or years, and because you have all the time in the world to research and absorb information in regards to that topic, it can resemble a childish monomania; this is why kids tend to know the names of every single dinosaur or Barbie doll or character from their favorite book, but cannot easily remember what they just learned in math class a year ago – they have a selective embrace of whatever makes an impression on their impressionable minds. I know that I was obsessed with dinos, with all types of paranormal creatures, with Godzilla monsters – I remember going on the same kaiju fanpages and websites every single day, having them all bookmarked, refreshing them again and again for the latest news or article pertaining to anything having to do with giant monsters. The two main characters in Kamikaze Girls have fully immersed themselves into the peculiar mindsets of Rococo fashion and girl-gangs, and because the film takes place during summer, there really isn’t anything to get in the way of these kids engaging in a fervent deep-dive into these sub-cultures which structure their identity in profound ways. I think children and young adults often use their taste and knowledge of various things as the cornerstones of their personality, and they can use these sub-cultures as a bulwark against a world which wants them to fit into a standardized model of what an average person is supposed to be – wearing 18thcentury lolita fashion makes you separate from the rest of society, and can easily make up for the fact that your sense of self is somewhat underdeveloped and neglected, which ideally changes with time.

I know for myself that my taste in movies since I was a teenager has massively changed in some ways, and not so much in others – I still like Arnold Schwarzenegger films, but I no longer think that Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World is the coolest and bestest thing ever!!1!!1! This is not to say that my earlier taste was ‘invalid’ – it was what I had at the time, and it served as a foundation for exploring different things in the future, which I am grateful for. Still, who among us has not looked back at these early years with a certain degree of reticence at our own naivete? I think it would be impossible to do otherwise – there are things that one does as a child, and no one does as an adult, but then there are things that prove to be integral parts of ourselves and that structure our realities forever afterwards. I have a dear friend who has worn almost nothing but pink clothes and pink hair since she was a teenager – she’s not too dissimilar from the Momoko character here in her love of fancy dresses and sumptuous aesthetics. She was able to lock onto that part of herself and really hasn’t let go of it, nor does she intend to, and I think that’s great – Kamikaze Girls is a story of these self-important teenagers trying to use easy ready-made identities to make themselves feel at home, and we all do that to some extent. I still hang out in graveyards, I still like to go for long walks, I’m still a voracious reader, and I still like movies. We all deserved to have a time to experiment with who we are, and there’s no shame in experiencing the solipsistic world that Momoko and Ichigo do, because by testing ourselves within these spaces, we give ourselves permission to understand that our identities are more fluid than is generally accepted by mass culture. That, to me, is the value of subcultures – they are a safe space where one can discover new interests and passions, whether that’s sewing, biking, reading, and so on. We all need places like those to learn and grow as human beings, no matter how ridiculous those scenes might look to outsiders.

2. The perils of adapting a novel. I’ve actually had the book of Kamikaze Girls sitting on one of my shells for almost a decade at this point, always with the intention of reading it and then seeing the film, because I encountered the interesting premise of the movie a long time ago and wanted to experience it ‘properly’, which doesn’t mean much to me now. And… I never read that shit, it just sat on my shelf collecting dust until I sold it a few months ago to make space for things I actually did read.

My awareness, then, of this as a novel adaptation make the construction of the film make a lot more sense – there’s not really much rhyme or reason to what happens, events and scenes are massively compressed and butt up against each other with an irregular facility, and the beginning of the film has a much more anarchic, almost cartoonish tone that the second half completely drops in favor of a relatively normal drama. These might sound like criticisms, and I suppose they are, but they aren’t ones that really bother me that much, I still really enjoyed the film – but they did make me think about why novels are always hard to make into movies.

I think it ultimately comes down to structure. A novel, as tight as it might be, is essentially composed of digressions and description and conversation which don’t necessarily focus all the time on a singular idea as much as they present a panoply of different threads which interweave and bounce off each other – if you look at the adaptations of Harry Potter or American Psycho, you see that the majority of that material found within the book isn’t adapted at all, but either merely hinted at, compressed into a different context, or straight-up eliminated altogether, because they mostly consist of digressions into this environmental detail or this scene at a dinner table or merely the psychological state of a singular character, all of which are competing for screen time with the bare-bones assemblage of ‘plot’.

A novel, in the tradition of Cervantes or Balzac, is supposed to capture several episodes of the world it creates, and the short story usually sticks to the space of what would normally be considered one chapter of a novel, which is why I am inclined to believe that movies based off of short stories tend to work better for films as a medium – the average short story furnishes more than enough material for a 90 minute film, and you don’t have to cut much out, you’re often more adding things into it if any changes are made, which leaves more room open for directors and screenwriters.

Kamikaze Girls has several ‘dead-end’ bits that stick out even on a first-watch – all the stuff with Momoko’s parents feels anemic and broad, and there’s really no main story, just a succession of different bits which explore this or that facet of these girls and their lives – but what makes for a poor structure can still be entertaining. Sure, the ‘My Rifle, My Pony, and Me’ song that’s sung in the middle of Rio Bravo technically doesn’t ‘advance the plot’ in any significant way, but it adds texture and grace and humanity to the characters. Sometimes it’s okay to linger on the divergent qualities of a story, because those are often the most memorable to us – Kamikaze Girls is an unwieldy film, but it owns its awkwardness, it’s an awkward film about awkward teenagers, so it all sings together even if some of the individual notes fall flat.


(Requested by SpyKids3D, a Patreon. Thanks Spy!)

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.