Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

No better illustration of the reality of fate than the coin toss.
 

Anton Chigurh knows what kind of creature he is, what is his nature. No one else can seemingly figure it out; always speaking some naive variant of ‘Do you know how crazy you sound?’, that he “Doesn’t have to do this.”

No one has to do anything.

Everyone must do something, according to his or her nature.

Chigurh’s nature is to destroy in the proper way and survive to destroy again. He is a blunt instrument of causality – hired to do a job, he does it. No questions, no compromise, no apparent ‘humanity’, save for his coin toss, when he indulges himself and others as to whether they’re really as in control of their lives as they think they are.

They aren’t.

So many Coens characters believe they’re the smartest guy/gal in the room, that they’re able to outwit everyone else – everyone except for the simpletons, the Chigurhs of the world who wreck shop and don’t give a sub-atomic fuck as to what the best laid plans sound like in the mouths of those who think they can outwit death’s emissary. Chigurh survives precisely because he is willing to endanger himself in every moment of his life and face death with a bemused smirk – how can you stop a man who is willing to take any reasonable risk to mess up your precious preconceptions of how things are supposed to work? Chigurh has no ego, no bullshit, no bluster. He does what he says he will do – this is his code.

Some code.

Cormarc McCarthy writes about men with codes and men who disregard codes – both fated to decay and die, one on their own terms, one on someone else’s – if you have no structure to your behavior, you’re a deer in the headlights in McCarthy’s view. If a deplorable assassin like Chigurh gets to live slightly longer than his prey, it’s because he has no tether to this world. He cannot be bribed or reasoned with, he cannot be seduced, he is a man in a world of animals and those animals cannot understand him, because if they were to, they would no longer be animals, and they would become Chigurhs.

No Country for Old Men and The Counselor are both stories about fish swimming in a sea of sharks – the Coens’ film questions whether a God can exist in McCarthy’s dire world, Ridley Scott’s film questions whether the God who made this world intended it to be as imperfect as it is – a difference of intention, like Chigurh himself. He intends, and through his own competency and his prey’s incompetency, he accomplishes said intention. The Coens channel the evil of this world into a singular man, Chigurh; Ridley disperses it into a hazy system of sin, where the details slowly stack up over time and lock you into an invisible cage which you cannot escape from. In No Country, a man can bargain for his fate via Chigurh’s coin toss – if he dies, he can be aware that he will die, and can decide accordingly to absolve himself to this fate or to rail against it. In The Counselor, there is no bargain to be struck, no choice made to affirm your fate – your destiny was determined long ago by a successive sliding into the position you’re at now, and now that you’re here, you are forced to reckon with the destruction of the world which you have created. Comparing the two, Chigurh’s coin almost seems saintly – forget the almost, it is.

What’s the difference between a fate you can choose and a fate you reckon with? It’s hard not to answer ‘everything’ – the coin toss offers the real possibility of continued survival, but also the total inevitability of death itself – if Chigurh doesn’t kill you in that moment, you’d better believe that something or someone else will… in a way, he’s offering absolution to his victims, a psychopathic absolution: take your life and death into your own hands, or allow me to do what I was born to do. Contrasting, The Counselor’s system of sin is a means of purification – is there a moment where you can realize that the grace you denied yourself and others is exactly what will make your life meaningful in the face of personal extinction? It’s not a question of avoiding death or not – there is no Chigurh here to make that arbitration, the arbitration must come from a willingness to face the hard truths of one’s actions, which is a task that few of us would actually be able to do without suffering a complete breakdown of the self – which might as well be the equivalent to being dead, as the world which you have built no longer has the creator or the care to sustain its already-tenuous existence.

McCarthy stands at the crossroads of morality, and the Coens and Ridley offer two variants on his myopic worldview – if a man like Chigurh can exist, can embody the twisted virtue of honor in his own disgusting profession, then perhaps God can exist, perhaps the dream of the pure and forgotten age has left behind the traces of its passage, its soldiers fighting on in an invisible war without winners or losers, merely survivors. A man someday may be able to govern over the peace of man without carrying a gun – but this man might yet carry the weight of some more terrible and destructive virtue, a purity which blinds in its insistence and presence. Chigurh kills almost everyone he comes into contact with – he leaves behind a world which is hollower, taking the shirt of an innocent child to start this entire cycle over again within the guise of a man with nothing to lose. If he approximates one of this deity’s angels, one would hate to see what the devil looked like – knowing the God of No Country might be worse than his non-existence.

Ridley asks an equally dark, yet just as humorous question: assuming that McCarthy’s world was created by a creator, has that creator reckoned with the sins he’s given birth to in the way that The Counselor is compelled to? Is he even aware of these sins? Could God be a blind idiot, an uncaring tyrant, or, perhaps worst of all… could God be as ignorant of the consequences of his actions as much as we are of ours? If the mountain moves, it moves quietly – maybe it moves without purpose, maybe it moves instinctively, as gravity pulls the apple towards the earth and birds soar into the sky. 

No Country is Old Testament no-nonsense dualism – God contains the capacity for evil in his absolute goodness, which by necessity must include its opposite – he cannot let there be light without the darkness of the waters which surrounds all that is bright and pure, and Chigurh finds a morality in his amoral life.


The Counselor is cosmic horror – God might be just as stupid and narcissistic as we are, but on an inconceivably larger scale. If he makes the world in his image, he makes quite an interesting image indeed – if we do not understand ourselves, it is because the world might be impossible to understand – and without that understanding, every choice is a sin which indulges our appetite for illusion and madness – the grace we may find is the grace of the jester, who, balancing atop the cliff’s edge, wonders wistfully at the beauty of a balletic spiral into innocence and non-existence.

The coin toss alleviates our responsibility, as God intervenes.

What if each choice is a coin toss? What if sin was the tails, and virtue the heads? Were any of us ever in control? The game of life was never our creation; it was hubris to think otherwise.


(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!)

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.