"Grace is Dead" -- ramblings on Macbeth (Patreon)
Content
(CONTENT WARNING: discussion of death and grief and suicide. Please take care not to read if that will hurt you,)
I haven’t seen an adaptation or performance of Macbeth since my sister died. I didn’t expect that to be what I felt so strongly after seeing Justin Kurzel’s 2015 adaptation of the Bard’s classic play – maybe I’m just caught in a weird mood – but it dredges up thoughts in me, feelings out of that psychological sewer that we call memory.
Macbeth is obviously about fate, about self-consciousness of one’s role in history and society, about the tragedy of being unable to move against the forces which you are intrinsically a part of. I’ve written about these topics in regards to many other films – I wonder what I can say here that’ll make me seem more interesting, more insightful. I believe in fate. I wrote about it in my last piece here on No Country for Old Men, I write about it all the time, I see it in my life, I can’t un-see it – like Macbeth’s grief in this film, like the forecast of his kingship, every blessing is cursed, every curse is blessed, you can only begin to grasp the faintest conception of what’s actually important when it’s taken away from you – Macbeth here drives himself mad, because after his child dies in the beginning, he wants to be with her. His responsibilities still bind him to this mortal earth, but he’s a warrior, he wants to be brought into a conflict which will destroy him so that he can see her again – which is what he contrives with his crown, it’s the act of a self-destructive man who refuses to place himself at the edge of his own blade – if the world destroys his child, it must do the same to him, and he merely accelerates that process from a potentiality into an actuality.
Morbid stuff. It’s Shakespeare.
The difference between chance and fate. Fate is the destination, chance is all the bullshit which contrives you to get there. We’re all fated to die like Macbeth, and he’s fated to be king, but it’s chance that he kills to be king rather than some other course of action – he made that choice, that’s his will, chance accounts for will. See, that’s what people don’t get about this, and it frustrates me – we’re all free, we all have free will or whatever, but we don’t make the rules which condition our circumstances; you’re not going to change who you are at a moment’s notice, it happens gradually in response to a certain accumulation of events. You can choose to open Door A or Door B, but you still have to open a door – there’s a part of me that doesn’t want to believe this, a stupid ape-like anger at the arbitrary nature of existence. But I’ve seen it in action, and like watching movies, seeing is believing, at least to me.
I’m naive like that.
I think about myself in comparison to movies now more than I ever did. When I see John Wick visit his dying wife at the hospital, I see my sister’s lifeless body barely kept warm by a convoluted set of hospital machines. Macbeth buries his child in the opening minutes of this 2015 adaptation and it all just hits me like a freight train again, the numb heaviness, the cold, I can’t escape it. It’s not everything in movies, not every death. I can still laugh when someone gets knocked on the head in a Buster Keaton film, that hasn’t been made different for me. But some things are different. I didn’t expect them to be, much less face myself crying at the beginning of a Shakespearean film. I’m damaged and it’s not cool and it’s not something interesting and it just hurts so much and the walls between me and the fictional drama violently break down and it’s like I have the thinnest skin in the world and I can’t control when it happens because the world doesn’t work like that and I wonder who am I to even feel this way?
Who indeed. No one else is going to feel it in this exact way, but I know it comes close. I still love movies, still watch them, and have been able to appreciate them better than ever over the last couple years. Actually beginning to know my shit after a long period of being a fake and a phony. It’s nice. Yet I look at Macbeth and say to myself that I would do the exact same thing as he did, because I did, I did try and destroy my life. It was so silly yet I recognize myself in him.
Here’s what I did: from 2014-2016, I committed several attempts on my own life, and each time I though that I would do it in the manner of one of those pharaohs, as ridiculous as that sounds. Before I went out to try to destroy myself, I made sure to clean my apartment, make sure everything was arranged and nice, fed my cats, and I kept buying a bunch of shit. Books, DVDs, manga, videogames, posters, whatever. I was out of high school but I was still acting like a teenager because I had lived a suppressed existence for so many years and now was my chance to splurge before I left this mortal coil. My thought process behind all this was sound in the mind of an extremely depressed and anxious person: how will people know who I am when I’m dead? It was a legitimate question. I didn’t want to be forgotten and I hadn’t done anything with my life so the only recourse I had was consumerism – those who looked into my apartment after I had died would see my book shelf full of continental philosophers, see my wall of anime posters, and then they would know what kind of person that I was, because I didn’t have any friends and there was no one who would recall anything specific about me other than the fact that I liked to read Hegel and Madoka Magica. That was the culmination of my life, that’s what I had built then.
That was my dynasty, just like Macbeth’s short-lived reign as king – both signified nothing, literal nothing, a hollowness at the heart of a person’s life. Macbeth, unlike me, was able to die in battle in the play and in this film – that’s somewhat glorious, I guess, I was just going to throw myself in front of a train and call it sweet goodnight. I talk about these things in a glib way because otherwise I don’t think I’d be able to speak of them at all – I don’t know whether to apologize for myself or be silent. I usually aim for the latter.
I’ve never spoken or said any of this to anyone before, why am I doing it here? I don’t know. Maybe because this is a private venue for me, of a sorts. Maybe because I’m, again, naive. I get paid to write these essays about film and I push myself to do the best that I can in making them but I can’t control how a work of art makes me feel and sometimes things just hit you in a certain way and despite all appearances to the contrary, I must admit that sometimes, I am human, and only that. I hate talking about myself, I hate this narcissism that writing engenders in me, I hate that I don’t have complete control over how and where I feel emotions, yet I also love that, that’s what I watch movies for, I want to feel things that I’m normally unable to, and that’s right and good and I’m conflicted.
I’m a contradiction. I poison everything I write about with my own toxic madness – everyone in my family has had some sort of mental illness, and I come to the conclusion that either the whole world is crazy or that I am a noted product of a specific variant of insanity – everyone in my family has tried to kill themselves in one way or another, and… god, god god, one of them actually managed it, fuck, I can’t even write this, I don’t know what to say, it’s just the fact, that’s all I have, it happened with my sister and that was chance, not fate. I got lucky because I’m too sensitive and I hate feeling pain and that’s chance, not fate.
I’m going to die someday and I feel at peace with that now. I can only feel that peace because I’ve put myself so close to death and have seen what it looks like on my sister. This is horrible to talk about and it makes me feel sick but I’m not going to delete this because I fucking have to speak about what is necessary to say.
I’m mad like this Macbeth, I’m hurt, I’m superstitious. I want to be so many things and I’m on my way towards being some of them and I’m honestly happier than I’ve ever been because I’ve been through some terrible shit and it’s made me actually grow the fuck up. I stopped trying to hurt myself long ago and I literally saw what might have become of me if I had succeeded and I saw how suicide affected my mother and my brother and my father and I hate talking about it but it affected me as well. Macbeth deals with this, so many of Shakespeare’s works deal with these 100% real existential questions that all of us are going to have to ask someday. Macbeth is like Romeo and Juliet, he doesn’t give himself the room to live in a world he doesn’t recognize without that which he loves – god, who could blame him? No one, it’s unbelievable, it staggers the mind, death just hits you and everyone and we like to pretend that we have a controlled expectation of it, but really, none of us have any idea until it happens, no fucking clue. Macbeth is achingly human and he builds himself a kingdom of bullshit so that he can force the world he fought and bled and killed for to annihilate him, that’s his measure of grief, it’s as real as it gets.
It’s not a fable, it’s not a play, it’s not just some movie that gets made, it’s a man coming to terms with having to live in an existence that has a design for him but is also fundamentally outside of his control and his desire. What’s the point of kingship if you’re destined to be king? Fate makes you lazy or nihilistic, either one, the only choice you have is the route towards that fate. I feel like I have a faint awareness of what fate has in store for me, but I’m not rushing to get there, I’m going to take my sweet time because the real importance of life is all the journeying you do on the way towards your conclusion. I really believe this, it matters, we can’t rush our lives in the way that Macbeth does. I tried to do that for a long time, my sister did it, she rushed to the ending of her book, her play, her movie. Maybe she’s okay with that now, maybe she’s not. I don’t know. I don’t know, but I’m fine with not knowing, I have to be, Macbeth has to believe that his child will be fine, that he can still live. It’s irrational, it’s faith, it’s something that can’t be taught except through either chance or experience. If the dying Macbeth knew what it would have taken to get to his fate, I know he would have acted differently, I know it. I have to believe that there’s a quality to living itself, that it means something. Even if it’s fake, even if there’s no real avoiding death, I still believe, I believe in what I must, it’s all that I can do, maybe all that there is in the end. I want to be here and watch movies that make me feel emotions and pain and write for you all and I will continue do it until they pry this keyboard from my skeletal hands. This is the fate that I know.
Files
Previews only