Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

“Sometimes you can’t find the truth, have to find another way to achieve peace” says one of Simon Baker’s interviewees in Ivan Sen’s 2023 film, Limbo – a statement which strikes at the core of noir as a storytelling technique. The detective in this film played by Baker is sent to stir up the coldest of cold cases, a murder of an Indigenous girl over 20 years prior in a bleak Australian mining town which has perhaps never seen better days. The overriding futility of such an effort is immediately felt within the film – too little, too late, why bother with the truth when so much time has passed? The case gets solved in its own oblique way, but there is no peace achieved, no satisfaction for sins which have sunk deep into the earth, too deep to be dug up even by the most prodigious of miners.

Limbo’s ambling restless atmosphere is constructed by Sen’s selective distance, most time keeping us far away from having intimacy with any of the characters, his camera always situating them within the chalky hills and caverns of a town reminiscent of Bela Tarr’s apocalyptic Eastern Europe – the dilapidated remnants of colonization and bigotry in Australia never rise above a simmer in Sen’s strict tonal control, remaining the embers of another story which is only half-recalled by the denizens which Simon Baker questions, as if even history itself has thrown Indigenous suffering into the ambient unconscious of daily life.

In such a stark version of noir, the detective’s quest for truth seems not only absurd, but almost a mockery – why bother with retroactive justice for a crime which stands alongside so many other crimes against Aboriginals which laid the foundation for Australia as a Western-style society? I’m reminded of a famous quote from one of G.K. Chesterton’s Father Brown mysteries, a detective remarking upon the logic of criminality:

“Where would a wise man hide a leaf? In the forest. If there were no forest, he would make a forest. And if he wished to hide a dead leaf, he would make a dead forest.”


This is why hate crimes and their perpetrators feel emboldened to continue to do what they do – if one creates a culture of racism and fear, then one may hide individual crimes underneath the aegis of institutional bigotry. The cops in Limbo’s central case, after being late to the scene, went on to abuse and accuse the Aboriginal men of the murder rather than properly examine the evidence itself – the murder of the woman just became another leaf in the forest of a civilization which has normalized the casual death of Indigenous people. The same phenomenon is prolific in Canada, the United States, and Mexico – in the nihilistic logic of those societies, what’s one more native death after all these cities and roads were already built atop the genocide of millions of natives in the past? To the conquering cultures, they view Indigenous individuals and societies as disposable holdovers, remnants which should remain quiet and docile at best, and unfortunately this attitude has proliferated and been systematized all over the Western world, which conveniently decided against genociding native peoples only after they were already rendered passive, converted, or simply made irrelevant to the functioning of the capitalist machinery – annihilation was replaced by disposability.

What then can be the use of the noir detective? What value does truth have when it is turning over one leaf in an entire forest of lies and hatred? There’s the existentialist romance to it, sure – raging against the dying of the light, against the futility of justice, one can understand this impulse. One also doubts it is enough – Limbo’s harsh, almost lunar images of an Outback which has been excavated of every possible resource and valuable trinket belie the fact that the apocalypse already happened to Australia’s Aboriginal people, and that we remain to see its even distribution across the rest of the world – there is no greater truth than the effects of human evil. A detective may uncover one murder, may enact some small form of justice for that one murder – so what? Of what point is detection when you’re inundated in a culture which actively turns a blind eye towards centuries of suffering? You can detect and investigate all you want – the greater monster, the ultimate killer, is staring you right in the face the entire time. It taught you how to breathe, how to subtract, how to pay your taxes – it’s like asking a fish to recognize the water it swims in.

This limit to noir has been recognized in so many other films – the detectives of Blade Runner and Inherent Vice don’t really ‘fix’ anything, their only recourse is simple survival and escape from the system that they discover the horror of. Is that escape even possible in real life? You can drive away, but there is no being ‘saved from the blessings of civilzation’ like in a John Ford film – even the most remote mountains or deserts have satellites peering overhead, or garbage left behind by tourists. That fantasy of closure is denied by Limbo’s ending, where the final drone shot emphasizes that Australia is a country of buried traumas – occasionally, a detective digs one up, maybe there’s a memorial. Maybe. Maybe we can’t do anything but revisit the past in an unsatisfactory piecemeal way, maybe it’s foolish to think you can ‘make up’ for the largest tragedies. If our noir stories are about finding out the truth, that might not be the same thing as achieving peace or wisdom – you have to accept the truth, but it doesn’t mean that it makes the world a better place. 



(Requested by Spykids, a Patreon. Thanks Spy!)

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.