Hamaguchi's Cinema of Healing (Patreon)
Content
The most striking facet of Ryusuke Hamaguchi’s Drive My Car, in addition to his films Wheel of Fortune and Fantasy and Asako I & II, is how un-striking they are – there are no bravura camera moves here, no instances of intellectual montage. Hamaguchi instead brings his crystalline clarity to what lies within his frame – especially what seems otherwise invisible within it, the lingering atmosphere that emotions can create. He’s a director of melodrama, but not the high intensity Götterdämmerungs of a Douglas Sirk or Paul Thomas Anderson – Hamaguchi rather prefers the mellow-drama, or melody drama, the power that comes from unspoken restraint, as in Ozu or Rohmer, a drama which seeks to unearth the unapparent or unsayable and bring it forth into cinematic manifestation.
This is the reason for his harmonious un-striking style – to impose excess via the form would be to exercise force against his reticent characters, thus not allowing them the space to speak or act. It’s not quite slow cinema, as Hamaguchi values the brisk reaction and also occasions visual jokes, such as a character stating to someone on the phone that they’re in one location, while the camera cuts to show that they are very much not there. Hamaguchi’s cinema is one that deals in disassociation between feelings and actions, time and place, past and present, as memories bubble up in inopportune moments, casual conversations, or especially within the realm of art itself – such is the central conceit of Drive My Car.
I will readily admit to being unfamiliar with Anton Chekhov’s play Uncle Vanya, and being unfamiliar with stagecraft as a whole – there was a time where I could have gone down the road of being a theatre kid, and instead I chose the cinema. Regardless, Drive My Car’s usage of the play seems less invested in the particulars of the drama or characters and places priority on how the ritualized work life of the arts allows for a unique emotional resonance between its creators and their own personal lives.
Yūsuke Kafuku, the director of this troupe, recites the play alongside a recording of his deceased wife while in his car, which becomes a way for Misaki Watari, his new driver, to understand and have access to the idiosyncrasies of his trauma, which then allows for Misaki to work through her own past of losing her mother to a landslide. Both Yūsuke and Misaki are able to achieve something like closure through the space that art creates which allows there to be a narrative to the suffering that one undergoes – and through that narrative, a processing of emotions which can’t be directly said, but which can be indirectly stated through the dramaturgy of the play.
I feel like, at least in the West, there’s a lot of hand-wringing about what ‘the point’ or ‘the purpose’ of art is – no other question could be so crass, but it’s something that’s especially pertinent to cinema, which has primarily been a hyper-commercialized medium since its very inception – in other words, what the real question becomes is ‘what’s the point of doing anything in film unless it’s designed to make money?’
What Drive My Car gets at is that art may have a healing function outside of the instrumentalist notion of generating a profit – that the participants in art, whether being the creators/performers or the audience, are able to work through their own personal issues by engaging with the work of art. That word is key, I think – art is a ‘work’, as in an object, but it is also ‘work’, as in labor, a process. The narrow definitions of Hollywood cinema that bind film to the task of ‘entertaining’ refuse to grasp that the real essence of art isn’t to placate its viewers or give them slight bouts of pleasure – sometimes art is fucking hard, sometimes it hurts you, sometimes it’s not fun and games. Art isn’t a game, it’s not a speculative medium, but a definitive object with porous boundaries and borders – yet Western culture, especially Anglo-American, is insistent on the infantilization of art, as if all a painting or a movie amounts to is a slightly more sophisticated jingling of the keys in front of a baby.
Hamaguchi understands this, and I think is tactfully working against it – Drive My Car is a patient 3 hour drama which requires you to pay attention at every second, it’s art which is invested in working with the viewer to achieve catharsis, which was Aristotle’s basic tenet of aesthetics.
Sometimes, in my more despondent moments, I wonder whether or not there’s any point to trying to convince anyone to see this type of art – that maybe it’s a ‘you either get it, or you don’t’ type of thing. And maybe my anxiety in regards to that is a feeling that the type of art which Hamaguchi practices is always kept on the margins, barely recognized by the general populace. Maybe that’s absurd, given the movie’s Oscar nominations, but I always feel this insecure impulse, this idea that if everyone were able to get onto Drive My Car’s wavelength, maybe they could experience some of the healing that’s in the film, then help others seek that out, and we’d be better off as a species.
Yet such a viewpoint betrays a desire to enforce catharsis, which by definition cannot be forced unless you’re willing to receive it. Acceptance of such finitude is a major piece of what Drive My Car is saying – that perhaps art is the work we do to make ourselves feel human, of which cannot be taught other than through example. When we see ourselves on screen, on stage, we become something more than what our own worst thoughts convince us we have to be.

(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thanks Freddy!)
Files
Previews only