Decision to Leave's Technological Leap Forward (Patreon)
Content
One of the failures of modern genre filmmaking has been a refusal to confront the march of available consumer technologies, which of course center around smartphones. If a writer was authoring a screenplay for a detective thriller in the 90s, they wouldn’t have to do much to isolate their protagonist – simply have him make the wrong turn down an alleyway, and suddenly he’s in a heap of trouble. After 2008 or so, it seems unlikely that this detective wouldn’t be in close contact with someone on a smartphone which can be easily traced and tracked, so in theory such emergency situations of immediacy are less exciting because everyone is that much more connected, and humanity is nothing if not a herd animal which can circle the wagons when the need arises – the detective won’t disappear for weeks before being found, and in fact he might be able to briefly livestream his situation to concerned parties. There’s drama there, but it’s hardly the murky world of the 1990s where one could still conceivably go ‘off the grid’ and disappear – you can’t escape that grid now, the grid is the way human society orients its world.
There’s a whole library of ways in which Hollywood films have tried to circumvent this easing of live-or-death stakes – the horror movie being the most obvious victim. How many horror pictures have we seen where there’s some contrived excuse as to why the protagonists can’t simply call for help? No signal, jamming devices, seeing the villains deliberately target and destroy phones before they move in for the kill, having shady organizations ask to collect them before the beginning of a sinister exercise, being hacked into, thrown into ponds and oceans – anything to get rid of the cellular bastards and to reduce the scenario to a primal scene of being pursued by some manner of predator, which is about as high as stakes get.
Park Chan-wook doesn’t use any of those easy outs in his modern classic mystery Decision to Leave – instead, he embraces what a smartphone can do for the savvy 2020s detective such as Hae-jun. Among these handy-dandy benefits are:
1. Writing case notes without having to carry around excess files
2. Recording quality live audio and video of crime scenes, interviews and evidence
3. Translating Korean into Chinese and vice versa
4. Tracking physical behavior through apps like daily step counts
These may all seem obvious, but I’ve rarely seen them deployed as details within modern detective/mystery films – most of them are either period pieces like Kenneth Branagh’s Hercule Poirot trilogy, where the whole point is that there’s no advanced tech to assist the sleuth, or they’re like Daniel Craig’s Benoit Blanc in Knives Out and Glass Onion, which operate by an archaic and stately sensibility even as they take place in the contemporary moment.
But Hae-jun in Decision to Leave is more than all of these: he feels like a lively update to the hardboiled character type, but totally inverted for the digital age. Humphrey Bogart in The Big Sleep or Robert Mitchum in Out of the Past were solipsistic, self-regarded, somewhat paranoid and alienated from their environment as a result of mid-20th century urban isolation and political estrangement. Hae-jun, conversely, is an ultra-sensitive insomniac, a workaholic who really goes above and beyond for his case and becomes scarily compromised by Seo-rae’s careful reticence but emotional availability.
To go alongside that, one can see how smartphones and digital technology make us more porous to the world, not less – instead of processing weather cycles or dusty encyclopedias or animal behavior, the average human being in tech-heavy societies today takes in a gargantuan amount of signals from across the world, a constant stream of news mixed with entertainment mixed with social engagement mixed with dense audio-visual communication. Instead of waiting months to receive a letter, we just send someone a text or an email, and the distance between them and us collapses, and Park Chan-wook does a fantastic job of showing for that excess of signals can turn into noise which can blind us as much as it widens our view – in Decision to Leave’s climax, Hae-jun tragically is unable to find Seo-rae, who has left behind her phone in the car. Hae-jun always used his phone’s translation app to communicate more directly with Seo-rae because her Korean was imperfect and too simple for the information and love she wanted to share with him – by leaving it in the car, she leaves behind the world the two of them could have shared together, and she wanders into the non-digitized physical space of the beach and its deadly waves while Hae-jun cries out for her, almost blinded by his desperation, unable to find Seo-rae without the phone that makes him such an effective detective.
What I deeply enjoy about this is that Park Chan-wook didn’t just incorporate contemporary tech into his genre film, but he used it for a thematic purpose that makes the story that much more interesting and meaningful. A lesser director could have just used the smartphone as a toy or gadget and called it a day, but by linking Hae-jun and Seo-rae with the phone’s ability to translate languages between a Korean man and a Chinese woman, Park Chan-wook is able to create an instant sense of mystery and intimacy – does the app perfectly translate what she means, even if it’s accurate to what she says? The layer of intention isn’t clear to us or to the characters, and the anxiety surrounding that is what powers our desire for Hae-jun to try and continue his relationship with Seo-rae even as it becomes clear that she’s dangerous to him and others. The technology which was supposed to link people together and increase our sense of knowledge actually leads here to distrust and enigmas which cannot be easily solved – the connection between two human hearts is the one puzzle that no amount of processing power can solve. Park Chan-wook is one of the best filmmakers working today because he isn’t afraid to challenge himself as an artist and to shake up our assumptions about the world we think we’ve mapped-out so thoroughly.
(Requested by Fey, a Patron. Thanks Fey!)
Files
Previews only