Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Elia Suleiman’s It Must Be Heaven is remarkable to me for two reasons: one, it’s a very amusing oddball comedy, the type of film which I rarely go out of my way to see, and two, it’s a comedy about being a Palestinian filmmaker, which we might gawk at. ‘How could a Palestinian filmmaker direct a comedy? Don’t they have nothing but suffering and trauma to express?’ And what’s amazing is that a character in It Must Be Heaven actually says such a sentiment; when seeking funding in Paris, Elia Suleiman (playing himself) is told this by a French producer:

“This is a film about the Palestinian conflict. We have a certain sympathy for the Palestinian cause. It’s not at all that we want a film that would be too didactic or exotic about Palestine. But we could almost say your film is not Palestinian enough.”

The satire here is obvious: a Westerner would expect a Palestinian film to exist in a certain dire emotional register and to be explicitly about suffering at the hands of Zionist occupation, which is largely what reaches Western media sources that aren’t biased towards Israel to begin with. And the current genocidal assault against Gaza and its people obviously highlights in the most excruciating fashion why this assumption exists: the Palestianian people have been persecuted, displaced, tyrannized, traumatized and murdered by Israel’s forces for decades now, and with such a large amount of suffering, it would be easy to completely define them by that visceral experience, because it is something they have to deal with as an existential threat.

But even in this dark hour of history, Suleiman’s film reminds us that there is more to being Palestinian than simply being trauma sponges or victims – they are a multifaceted people just like anyone else, and Suleiman’s craft in It Must Be Heaven edges far away from standardized definitions of melodrama or even modern ‘comedy’ – his curvy cinemascope framing recalls the comic book vistas and punchy reaction shots of Sergio Leone, while his sense of humor and choice to play himself as a silent chronicler of a strange world reminds one of Buster Keaton. This is not a film made to meet an arbitrary measure of ‘taste’ or acceptable explicitness in regards to political subject matter – here, the oblique and the didactic meet and shake hands.

The way the film handles its politics is the same across every one of its jokes – the most successful being a running gag introduced early on, where Suleiman wakes up and looks out towards the lemon tree in his yard. He’s surprised to see his ‘neighbor’ sitting between the branches of the tree, picking his lemons. The neighbor insists that he is not trespassing or stealing, but merely picking the excess fruits – later, he also insists upon Suleiman in trimming the tree of various branches, and then profusely watering it. Suleiman, fed up with this intrusion, plants a smaller lemon tree next to the one that has been taken from him. Later, as Suleiman returns to his home in Palestine, he discovers that the neighbor has taken it upon himself to water both lemon trees, smiling at Suleiman as he does so.

The metaphor for Israel’s settler program here is unmistakable, and manages to be both politically infuriating and also absurdly hilarious. That’s such a hard balance to strike, and I’ve seen dozens of Hollywood films fuck up similar bits of ‘topical’ humor by being exceedingly broad – yet Suleiman manages to sustain this wry commentary for an entire feature film. I think two techniques assist him: he keeps his camera a strong distance away from any performer which isn’t himself, which abstracts their existence and emotional lives, and he always takes the time to center It Must Be Heaven’s perspective around his own vision, with shot/reverse shots which give us frequent access to his point of view. We see Palestine, Paris and America from where he’s looking, which gives us a physical embodiment of his sight and how he has to juxtapose the horrors and humors of his life together.

The film is absurdist, but not unrealistic – I’ve never been to New York City, I doubt they carry THAT many guns around with them, but Suleiman’s point is clear – his life and the lives of Palestinians have been militarized, but so have been the nations which support Israel’s regime. The techniques of one oppression come home to roost in other places, and everyone deals with it to various degrees. As a resident of Chicago, the police here with their armored trucks and assault rifles and body armor don’t look or act that differently from the Israeli Occupation Forces – both are given license to hurt, kidnap or destroy anyone who is deemed an expendable person. The countries may be different, but the uniforms still designate who the tyrants are. Suleiman’s film does explore his feelings about the world outside Palestine, but it’s clear that he also sees all the reflections of his home in these other places – America is closer to the bloodshed and war than it imagines to be, its hands are washed in the sins of Israel and its apartheid. Suleiman finds dramatic irony in his vacations here, but he does not find that which he does not already know. 

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.