Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey guys,

I made the decision to pull and then re-upload the Pete Buttigieg interview today after a few very small modifications. I will try to be as transparent as possible as to why this happened. As many of you know, my style as a journalist has generally been to be an empathetic, active listener and provide people with a comfortable platform to express themselves in a way that would be impossible to do on most mainstream news outlets. However, interviewing politicians and people in active positions of power is quite a different story. It is necessary, in many situations, to hold their feet to the fire a bit more and there was ONE particular instance in my interview with Pete Buttigieg where I truly felt that I should have immediately pushed back on a false claim that he made but unfortunately, I did not. That instance came at minute 23:29, when Pete reinforced the widely debunked claim that Hamas militants “put babies in ovens” during Oct. 7. These claims were initially published by the U.S. and Israeli government the immediate aftermath of the attacks but were later retracted by the White House after an investigation found the claims to be false. Still CNN and other outlets continue to push the false beheading story to this day, only taking the extra step of attaching a Hamas denial to the end of their reports. As you'll see, in this new draft, I have added what is, essentially, a 'fact check' frame to that establishes the factual inaccuracy of Pete's claim, which will also be featured in the soon-to-be-released YouTube cut. Obviously - if you guys saw the Jubilee jawn that dropped yesterday - I let people speak their minds freely for a living so I don't want to get into the habit of bombing C5 interviews with pretentious 'fact check' slides every time someone makes a false claim, but I just felt that this particular piece of outrageous misinformation needed to be met with some kind of disclaimer, since I didn't think fast enough to offer a solid rebuttal in real time. Additionally, my recent trip to Ireland and some of the connections that I made out there have strengthened my connection to the Palestinian liberation cause and I am currently planning an upcoming trip to the West Bank. For me, making the decision to pull down the original Pete Buttigieg interview wasn't so much a case of 'audience capture' or mob pressure as it was suggested on Reddit, but rather, came from a desire to correct a piece of genuine disinformation before publishing this interview on the main channels to millions of subscribers.

Overall, I am really proud of this piece. I enjoyed talking to Pete and believe that a respectful, sit-down interview with an establishment politician like this will bless C5 with the ability to speak with major players down the line, especially with the midterms coming up. I'll do my part to sharpen the sword in the meantime to ensure that I've got decent rebuttal chops for next round.

Hope you guys enjoy,

AC

Files

Pete Buttigieg Interview

Comments

Adam G

And we're back.

Paul Waltz

Let’s go! Can’t wait for this one.

Matt Brady

GOAT!!!! You’re the best.

Joe

I mean only one fact check is pretty good

Chuck

Respect from Chuck

Azryu

You used the word disinformation. To be clear, you are claiming Pete said this with the intention to lie?

Eric frickson

Andrew with the opportunity to interview him I would imagine youd have questions lined up regarding his controversial time as a mayor of South Bend Indiana i hope in the next conversation you confront those issues or even talk to someone who lived under his leadership

King Harvest

Stoked to see some West Bank content

Catalina Rocha

fact checks aren’t pretentious they are good and sometimes necessary!!!!!

ToastMcGoats

If only this guy actually believed anything, I might actually hear him out, but he's proven to me he's only wearing the skin and veneer of a human. Vapid and and a waste of space. He's probably not even gay, just an angle to garner votes. Edit: Just a reminder: He was transportation secretary when that train crashed in Palestine, Ohio.

Matthew Schembri

Great reason to edit the interview! Keep up the great work and take care in the West Bank! 🍉🇵🇸❤️

jer parker

continuously the realest in the game

Elyse

Keep up the good work!!

Sean Wilson-Leslie

I'm not sure why this claim would take such different steps to other interviews you've done. Surely people say false things in interviews from time to time, this claim seems to be inconsequential. I think you're being too sensitive Andrew. Great job.

mike hansen

I'm not opposed to scrutiny of Democratic leaders, but I feel like worrying about this one note makes it seem like it's as big of a deal as the right side of the government completely tearing down every core value the United States has ever stood for. As much as I didn't like his answer to your question, I don't like what the right wing is doing to this country, and to put so much focus on that as if it is the same level to me is bewildering. I love your journalism; I think what you do is great, but the focus here feels unjust and gives credence to people who are looking at this like a team game.

AlexE

That's why I FW you Andy, I like a MF who takes accountability and always tries to do better. 😤😤

Mike Amorello

Thanks Andrew for this explanation! What the media needs to represent more today, for all people, is accountability like this. It's the most thoughtful and honest way to live, and I believe it will only build more trust from similar people who want to collectively establish a more clear and just understanding of our world. We won't be perfect, but we can own how we show up. Cheers!

C

He dodged your questions about Israel for long, but eventually gave the nuanced answer you were asking for.

The Ders

Thank you for the fact checking. This is especially important when talking to a politician. I've been a Pete fan for a while, but that doesn't make him perfect by any means.

The Ders

Did you not watch the interview? They talked about how dumb it is to "fake being gay" and that if anything, he's proud that he's moved past people attacking him for being gay to people saying he's not gay enough. Get your head out of the dirt and worry about more important things

Vi Tear

Your continued transparency and authenticity are a beacon of hope in a time of extreme misinformation and manipulation. I'm extremely grateful for your fact/data-driven journalism. Thank you, Andrew.

Andrew

Glad you corrected that. Looking forward to your west bank video!

ToastMcGoats

I was being facetious, but he still sucks and should get out of politics. He's bad at it.

Cooper Carrasco

It’s difficult to know when it’s worth it to push back vs when it will just derail the conversation. Haven’t listened yet but if it’s not the main topic of the interview, it could have definitely been a reasonable, albeit unfortunate, choice to overlook it for the sake of the broader interview. In isolation, of course you should push back on it but in context in real time it’s not so easy a choice.

ToastMcGoats

And he enabled the poisoning of Palestine, Ohio.

WetFlapjacks

Your (our) generation is greatly appreciative of your work and journalistic integrity

Jake

Thank you for all you do. Stay safe.

denise em.

Damn, this was hella refreshing. I have so much respect for the way you show up as a journalist; sincere, authentic and accountable. Keep up the necessary and great work! Looking forward to your west bank video as well!

The Ders

Again, did you listen to the interview? That was one of the main things he brought up as a failure of his that he wishes he could have handled differently if he had a do-over. I encourage you to actually listen to the full interview before commenting. No one is going to handle a job like that perfectly

Trev

Appreciate you big dowg. Ireland is gorgeous. Dublin is a fun city. Belfast was very eye opening, and I see why the Irish/northern Irish are so close with the Palestinians. Keep on doing your thing, it’s awesome to see you grow!

ToastMcGoats

Nah :b This guy doesn't get a second chance from me. That was one in a long list of problems I have with the man.

Halfcourt Yeet

This was great to see you change your mind. I want to say, you never followed up sincere coverage on what's going on in DC though I saw you posted it as "Night 1." I'm glad you're meeting with establishment politicians but I want to say, make sure it doesn't go to your head. This was a good sign it isn't but still be careful. I hope you do more stuff with correspondents. There is so much shit that needs coverage!!

Mike Anthony

We are going through a fascist takeover in America. This guy is one of the big players in fighting that. He doesn't need to align perfectly with an IP purity test.

duo max

Thank you for the work you put in

ToastMcGoats

I'm not begging you to see it my way, by the way. I'm immensely frustrated that there isn't a soul who has what it takes to turn this shithole around. If you feel different, good for you. I was just screaming into the void.

324nutz

I think you’re wrong about Trump. I think a lot of people are fed up with Trump and are frustrated the democrats have NO answer for any issues.

Duterte Whitaker

@AC @Channel5, reach out to fellow Patreon: "the Salukie". He regularly travels around the West Bank and would be a great subject and tour guide. Bonus: dude got bars! Also check out Standing Together, a Jewish-Arab grassroots social justice campaign that has been around for a decade but has been working in overdrive over the past two years.

Andrew

This guy still sucks

Ernesto

Explosive Freudian slip @7:09

CathyP

He made it clear in the interview that he was Secretary of Transportation when the East Palestine train derailment happened.

Ernesto

Tucker has it from the CIA that his marriage is a cover because he is a deep state plant

Mike Hughes

Appreciate your transparency as you continue to hone your craft.

ToastMcGoats

If you look at the other convo I had you'll see I'm screaming into the void, but my point in saying that is he ain't got "it". He'll never be president much less an effective one. The only reason he agreed to this interview is because he thinks it'll get him in the running. He's drought of belief or personality. Again just screaming into the void. Believe what you want to believe. Edit: Forgot word :b

Nogahfergi

Great comments, Andrew. appreciate your style and honesty. We all get things wrong in the moment occasionally, but recognizing and accepting mistakes is what makes one credible. Thanks for your work and commitment.

Kyle C

Fuck yeah! Appreciate you putting it back up and providing the context. Comments from people wanting more controversy or contention in your interview is a sad reality of the algorithmic programming mainstream media has bolstered. So appreciate you staying true and C5 for life.

Cassin

Great work recognizing the changes you needed to make to distribute real journalism to the unwashed masses. We are not deserving of your work! Except for us patrons, lol 🙂

Eric Solis

Reflection and self awareness are inextricably linked. Don't sweat it - you're a conduit channeling a voice for the people. Fuck the custers. Keep fighting the good flight.

J

Thanks for being transparent, Andrew. I'm also not the fastest thinker when I'm active listening and respect that, while you didn't catch something in the moment, when it's a big deal, you were transparent about needing to provide some kind of rebuttal. Thank you and the rest of the Channel 5 crew for doing what you do.

burglerian jihad

Appreciate the edit and transparency. I've been a fan of yours to hear from people who don't have the platform or voice, people who are both struggling with and being hassled by late stage capitalism. I think you have a real opportunity to speak to the cruelty and offer solutions in these conversations. I really am having a hard time believing Pete is listening or has seen a lot of what you do. At the end of the day, talking about A.I.'s impact on labor to a career politician seems risky because they can easily pivot to big picture thinking, or vice versa. And then not commit to any real answer. Real working class heroes, these consultants. All he had to do was say "UNIONS". I hope this wasn't just a left wing soft pitch for abundance to people who don't live in mansions. Remember politicians need you more than you need them. f*ck the authority.

ZY

Him and Warren staying in absolutely fucked Bernie.

ZY

Up the rah 🇮🇪

Benjamin Bray

Trump isn't a fascist, and don't worry, he'll be gone in a little over 3 years when he finishes his term. I know he talks about running again but there's basically 0% chance congress actually amends the constitution to allow for that. You'll be fine, and America will be fine.

Cale E

wait what is a fascist to you if it's not currently what is happening? I know that term is kinda loose but what about this admin does not fit almost everyone's definition of it?

Nicholas Bristow

did i get a different video? there was some bad audio in mine and it just ends mid sentence

Vince

Grilling Pete about the Israel/Palestine conflict for damn near 1/3 of the interview seems unecessary because it wasn't a relevant issue for his time as mayor of South Bend, his time as Sec of Transportation, and may not be relevant to whatever office he gets in the future. But I guess this is the omni-issue that's in the psyche of everyone on the far left these days

Andrew

Is the ending supposed to be cut off?

William Caldwell

Still don’t trust Pete, but nice to have some context and hear him speak. Boo on the shout out to Lurie for sure though! He’s a reactionary neo-lib responding to a neo-lib administration. His city revitalization plan relies largely on ill defined “artists,” for which he’s cut funding for by an arm and a leg, and weed cafés. Cool! The engagement bait videos of people experiencing drug addiction or teens doing “the beer run heist” but at places like Sephora haven’t slowed down and living in SF is the same, but worse for anybody making less than 100,000 dollars a year. It’s probably not in the cards, but I’d love an SF follow up video!

e

soyfaced at the shot of Blindboy in the preview of the Ireland episode

Adam

Yo Andrew, thanks for putting it back up! I was one of the people that voiced disappointment that you not being confrontational with him. I felt bad however when you took it down, especially thinking it was because of “audience capture”. I have been a follower since AGNB and really want C5 to succeed, which a bunch of dumbasses like us being opinionated too much at times. I really appreciate the honesty and the edits, and I hope C5 brings good change onto US politics with the authenticity all of you at C5 bring! And I guess with the Israel/Palestine issue, I admit I get in the purity test of asking about if it’s a genocide or not. I honestly think it’s a fatigue of mainstream media where they get establishment people and it honestly goes nowhere except “both sides have done bad”. Maybe I should expect that not to come from C5, but still makes me feel so sad that nobody holds them to the fire on that. One day we are going to hear mainstream media and establishment politicians, just say “yeah it was a genocide, but none of us knew”. That’s just something that is so hard to think about when me and my parents see famine on 6 o’clock news on TV while those same networks avoid calling this a genocide

Jack Duffy

Been asking for the kneecap interview for a minute LFG

Dan De La Ghetto

Buttigieg shmuttigieg. Let’s get Brendan Schaub in here. Would be fascinated to see how Andrew would approach that.

swellpunk

Haven’t watched yet but just read the description. Appreciate your addition for sure and understandable in the moment you don’t have 100% of a wiki database to fact-check stats so all good there brother keep it up. Looking forward to watching

ibesdidit

Love you goat will always support

xoxouno

Just don’t fall for the pressure within.

Conor McGee

Finally someone has pushed Buttigieg on his views on Irish unity.

Rylan May

Is his IQ room temperature? I think not

jamie medley

Fully respect this decision Andrew. Well done.

Miki

Thanks for your honesty and this is why we can trust your content, fully confident in supporting your journalism! And did enjoy the Jubilee’s 1 journo vs 20 conspiracy theorists very much!

Daniel

Please don’t make “fact checks” a repeat occurrence

Rob Dolan

Audience capture is dangerous to journalism

JAGRonin

Why not? So that he can be more easily mislead and spread that misinformation for the upcoming Mid Terms? What is the benefit of not fact checking at least the most egregious of debunked claims specifically when speaking to elected official as opposed to more fringe character?

swellpunk

Agree, when someone preaches some batshit conspiracy I’ve never expected channel 5 to provide some sort of gotcha moment. I come here bc I was drawn to Andrew in a suit nodding along to dudes fucking their cousins in the French quarter. We know you aren’t agreeing with them but it’s how you get people to reveal themselves… You can trust your audience to make the distinction… otherwise the ‘fact check’ slides can be infantilizing in a way

Daniel

Mainly because “fact checks” are almost purely ideological. What Andrew decides to fact check vs not is the problem. Like he says, it’s pretentious and adds more of his takes than needed. He fact checks this one bit of info, but then doesn’t/chooses not to for every other wrong bit of information.

Sam Escolas

The description of the video addresses this - he said he doesn't want to make it a regular thing, but that this particular instance felt it warranted one for a number of reasons that he outlines.

Daniel

We shall see. Especially since he is planning to make more main stream political videos

Meagan McLay

Connecting facts checks to being purely ideological feels ironic. There are journalistic standards and expectations we have, but consumers shouldn’t be reliant on one journalism platform to do the fact checking for them. We watch/read/listen to an opinion to expand the breadth of our understanding on various issues, not to tell us what or how to think. I watch channel 5 for this very reason, and they’re transparent about their bias where and when they recognize it. Fact checking can be picky from the creator/caster/publisher, but it’s still an important tool to expanding the breadth of our understanding. In this case, Andrew uses it as such.

Daniel

It is very ironic isn’t it. Unfortunately, that’s the way it’s devolved over the past years. You especially saw it during presidential debates. And even simple YouTube videos

Liam Kelly

AC the GOAT for REAL dude. on Hollow Moon Lizard God

whiskeyleafa

Oh shit Kneecap sneak peak at the end??

Jon

Appreciate all the transparency as always Andrew, you rock! Keep up the great work man

Catherine Ann

I'm so sick of everything being about I/P as our country is destroyed from within.

Duterte Whitaker

Nothing would make me happier than seeing a C5 deep dive into the Gringo Papi stand-up special

Duterte Whitaker

I was thinking that myself. Mandani was able to skirt the issue in the mayoral debate by saying he wanted to focus on NYC.

Nicholas Ruiz

I really respect your integrity in the decision and transparency around this, Andrew. This was a great piece and I’m wishing you the best in the West Bank

Bob

"We need policies to fix X, Y and Z" "Ok, like what actuall policies?" "Well we need alternatives to X, Y and Z policies. That's what I believe."

Coolie

Don't have an issue with Andrew making edits to the interview. The issue is that Pete isn't saying anything bad but he's not selling his personality like Hunter did. He's grounded but still suit and tie. Zohran and Hunter can flip hard right conservatives because they don't talk in such a media trained way.

Andy Beaudoin

Wtf Pete, don't push the automated driving narrative. If you want less death from cars, you need less driving which means transportation alternatives, not fucking AI. I mean I get that they auto industry is probably paying you, but holy fuck am I tired of car-brain.

Grace

As an Irish person I’m so excited to see what Andrew got up to in Ireland ☘️ Especially now, I’m so proud of my country and how we have spoken up and continue to speak about the genocide in Gaza 🇵🇸 Go n-eiri an bothar leat (good luck) in the West Bank Andrew. I appreciate your work

Psxo

Idk why but its not letting me watch. Its telling me to sign into YouTube but I already am🙁

Adam Rodkey

should be released as a 5cast

savethebaysteve

I do not understand why what you have said is not more widely spoken. I do think a lot of it boils down to AI and electric cars being the "new shiny thing." So instead of investing in alternative transportation, policy makers will just open the tap to the "new and shiny."

Andy Beaudoin

Most Americans don't have alternatives to driving and have spent their whole lives driving, so imagining a world outside of that is very difficult. Pete knows this and is trying to appeal to a base while sounding "innovative" even though it's just more of the same

mfooli

"It's not okay to militarize an American city." I don't disagree, but that should extend to America militarizing the cities of other countries.

Glenn Pogue

Joshua Citarella wants his set back.

Martin Dickler

Just my .02. In the context of what you guys were talking about (broadly - dishonest communication) at the time. I think he was using the babies in the oven as an example of that. Not necessarily saying that it was a fact.

norma brown

Dude is not listening jeeeeezzzz

norma brown

Republicans this republicans that shut upppppp

Sam

I agree, it's fine to give someone a platform but giving someone a platform also comes with responsibility imo. Especially with this subject.

mudpup

Bruh it’s just word vomit ‘we have to listen’ JUST DO SOMETHING

Anna Lam

FYI - you do not need 10 percent down to purchase a house. It’s as low as 3-3.5% but you ideally need a 600+ credit store and consistent income (best if W-2 job). It’s harder if you want a house in a popular neighborhood because then you’d most likely have to compete with those that have more $ down. But also there’s a lot of homebuyers that are going with the most affordable routes.

Hailsssssss

Interview was alright. I think featuring the kirkinator channel 5 AI video is lame. AI is lame and the people behind those videos seem like bigoted chuds. Same account is reposting people saying "fuck Jews". Disappointed to see Andrew reply "🫡" to that account..

Ray Brown

Good interview, Andrew. You covered a lot of ground and, as usual, provided a solid platform for a nuanced and in-depth discussion. I particularly appreciated Buttigieg’s advocacy for and analysis of infrastructure and urban planning based on his experience as Transportation Secretary. This said, there’s 3 areas in particular where some critique/pushback could have challenged his conventional Democratic/centrist/neolib ideology. On the foreign policy front, I think a clear line should’ve been drawn between anti-Zionism and anti-semitism. By skirting this fundamental human rights issue, Buttigieg was able to frame the existence of a colonial ethno-religious state as somehow crucial to the survival of Jews. While promoting a so-called ‘2-state solution’ sounds moderate in the current political environment, the reality is much more complicated and ethnically and religiously intertwined. True security for Jews will never be accomplished through the creation of 2 adjacent ethno-nationalist garrison states. As Edward Said outlined years ago, the only path to true peace and security for Israelis and Palestinians is via a secular state that provides full civil, political and human rights to all citizens. Also re: foreign policy. The notion of the US providing ‘international order’ through the promotion of values of ‘freedom and democracy’ is thoroughly bankrupt. There’s a laundry list of countries from South America through SE Asia and the Middle East where the US has intervened against and/or overthrown democratically-elected governments deemed hostile to American hegemony. While rationalizing blood-stained US foreign policy is standard issue for all pols seeking national office—as an independent journalist, I think it’s incumbent upon you to challenge this ‘freedom and democracy’ narrative. Finally, I’d suggest Buttigieg’s military background and boosterism really puts him in the hip-pocket of the MIC and plays out in all sorts of policy evasions—both foreign and domestic. Understanding and critiquing how the American imperial project is fundamentally unsustainable should be at the center of any discussion with potential aspirants to becoming the ‘commander-in-chief’ or so-called ‘leader of the free world’. At this point in history, there’s underlying questions of planetary human survival linked to the nuclear, climate and biodiversity consequence of the answers.

Carolyn Kwiat

Please try to interview Mamdani!! That would be epic

sdfuy798iujk3

It was a terrible interview with Andrew directly regurgitating Israeli propaganda. The number is not 60k. It is 300,000 OR MORE. There is no "explosion of antisemitism" on the internet and if there is it's being deliberately fomented by Israel themselves! Trash piece. One more like this and my $5 a month will be staying in my wallet.

Mamatha Agrawal

The flow of your interviews is incredibly intelligent and calm. I’m tired of the contentious gotcha type of interviews with just brief talking points from the 24 hours news channels.

Amit Kalia

Mortgage insurance is a huge waste of money.

Anna Lam

Depends on location because you can definitely do 3.5 or 3% with an FHA loan. 20 percent down is a super hot market. Requiring a lot down just isn’t true anymore if you do some research. Paying interest sucks but also paying for someone else mortgage sucks. Mortgage insurance sucks too but you can hope to refinance out of it. Pick your poison! :)

Monica

Why is this shorter version still up here labeled as “full”? There’s almost 25 minutes less than the YouTube version

Rodolfo A

The amount of times that Dems have backed out of a fight The fact Dems (just like reps) are bought by corporate money The fact that Dems are center and won’t dip a toe into leftwing policies I spoke to someone from Ireland recently and he told me that “America’s left wing extremists are Ireland’s center-right” Democratic positioning is pathetic, regardless of whether Pete is the best at it Just speak the truth, talk about Palestine, talk about how you improve things, not just point at it and say “yeah, that needs to get better” about everything

Eli Gaultney

I really appreciated digging into specific policy at the end. It's not so exciting, but that seems really productive. I would love to see more of that. I wasn't aware of all the stuff Pete oversaw as Transportation Sec, but I definitely love the airline changes he worked on.

Alex Cowan

I ran into Pete Buttigieg at my hotel, bought him a drink, and told him how much I liked the Channel 5 interview. (Yes, he was great.)

careb0t

"The world is going to develop along some pattern and some set of values, and a lot is going to depend on who is leading and projecting..." This right here is why America, American politicians, and the American military are fucking psychopathic demons. They just implicitly believe that it is their god given right to force their own perspective onto every other country or group of people in the world. In what ways are Russia or China enforcing their "values" or whatever on the entire world? I don't see fake Chinese and Russian NGOs in every single country trying to propagandize the population to vote for whatever leader will bend the knee to them like the US does. I don't really see Russia or China doing regime change on every single country that refuses to adopt their own values or system of governance/economics. I don't see either of those countries buildings thousands of military bases on every corner of the planet as a means of intimidation. This is uniquely an American thing, nobody else does this to even 1% of the scale that the USA does. What a sick freak.

James

With a conventional mortgage 5% and you can buy out the mortgage insurance generally for 1% the cost of the house. We put 5% down and bought out the premium and don't pay pmi

vampiregal

A lot to say here butttt what ab that Irish piece?? I’d love to watch/read/listen to that - as someone with strong Irish roots who’s always wanted to learn Gaelic!!!

Kevin

"It's not there. But if it is there....." is not a coherent argument pattern. If you think it might be there, you shouldn't have said "It's not there". There is an explosion of antisemitism on the internet. Go onto an incel forum and witness incels complaining about the "jewish chad lobby". If you want to claim that this is being fomented by Israel then you've got to supply proof. Pulling something like that out of your ass without supplying any evidence or proof is worthless.

Kevin

Nonsense. Russia, and the US are both doing that stuff. And China is doing some of it too. Look at what has happened in Ukraine, Georgia, and Moldova in recent years. Russia tries to install flunkies, and if that fails then they launch a military attack. They also have a recent influence push in Africa.