Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey guys,

There’s been a narrative circulating on X which suggests that in the wake of my decision to make small modifications to the Pete Buttigieg interview and re-upload to Patreon, I did some sort of massive editorial overhaul to take Pete out of context and engineer a ‘gotcha’ moment. Normally, I’d ignore this sort of backlash but I’m trying to build credibility amongst establishment politicians for the upcoming midterms and I need to nip this narrative in the bud before it spreads any further.

So to clarify - aside from the insertion of a single fact checking slide, I did not modify anything about Pete and I’s original conversation regarding Israel-Palestine, nor did I modify or edit any of the conversation to take his words out of context. What I DID do, is trim out certain bits that I felt were slightly off-track, inconsequential to the core of our conversation, or outdated from a news-gathering perspective. Given that we often film things a few weeks prior to release, ‘trimming fat,’ as we call it, is often standard practice for C5 as we go through rounds of edits and prepare for a public YouTube drop.

I genuinely don't believe that any of the trimmed bits from the Mayor Pete interview would have been noticed if not for our transparency in explaining our decision to make a re-upload, but unfortunately, there is now a narrative that our re-edit is somehow drastically different from the original, which is a misrepresentation. So that said, I’ve uploaded all of the ‘trimmed’ bits to a Patreon-exclusive supercut here so that you can see what was chopped, as well as an explanation as to why it was cut.

Trimmed Bit 1: this bit, recorded via zoom from Arizona, focuses on the Jimmy Kimmel firing and broader implications of Trump’s crackdown on late night TV hosts. A day after we recorded this interview, Kimmel was reinstated. Felt like a bit too much of a focus on an expired news item, so I cut this conversation in half for the new cut.

Trimmed Bit 2: this bit focuses on Studebaker’s history in South Bend and Pete’s time as an Indiana mayor. Given that this bit arrived in the midst of our conversation about establishment Dems’ problem with endorsing Zorhan Mamdani, which I ultimately brought us back to after our brief Indiana convo, which really didn't go to deep.

Trimmed Bit 3: this bit is a story about one of Pete's coworkers believing that Chasten, his husband, was actually his 'friend.' This bit arrived in the midst of our conversation about Tucker Carlson's 'fake gay' claims and took things off-track.

Trimmed Bit 4: this bit was about his decision to join the U.S. military, which interrupted our conversation about parallels between the 'War on Terror' in both Israel and the U.S. and the weaponization of language by politicians.

Because these four bits amount to over 15 minutes of cut runtime, I can see how someone might get the impression that I drastically cut important sections of this interview due to woke mind virus. Hopefully this clears all of that up. That said, I am going to re-insert these bits into the final cut when we upload to YouTube as to eliminate whatever room there may be for conspiracy. I really don't like being perceived as a self-righteous spin doctor and I know how quickly things can get out of hand without my direct and specific input during moments of controversy. I hope you guys are having a good day and you can expect the interview to be live on YouTube at 9 A.M. tomorrow.

BEST,

AC.

Files

Pete Buttigieg Interview (Trimmed Bits)

For transparency, here you go.

Comments

Trev

Appreciate you, hope you’re having a good one as well.

Valerio Vota

Well done. Despite everything, transparency is the best course of action

Brian Vansteenkiste

Watching Andrew's trajectory and evolution as a journalist has been inspiring to watch. Keep up the good work AC!

Matheus Bauer

Good on you Andrew. It’s not fair that you and other young journalists have to fight this bullshit constantly to be taken seriously. You and others like Adam Mockler have to hold yourselves to a standard that is miles above the rest of the legacy media cesspool just for the shot of being treated as an equal. The hard work is going to pay off.

Elie Kornfeld

andrew we love you, reppin my c5 beanie today

Vi Tear

Thank you for fighting for the truth 🙏

Pixel-davis

I would rather see the full uncut conversation, personally, and it feels odd that so many other people on your channel over the years have been allowed to say wild unfactual insane things without any sort of fact check slide inserted, but for some reason this is the line. Not sure how I feel about this to be honest.

jer parker

idk, feels like this is a vocal minority situation, though I’m not on X to really know. That said, I mean come on: Andrew’s established such an absurd degree of journalistic integrity over the years of output that idk, I just don’t think it’s worth sweating the trolls. They will literally always be there, especially as the content shifts toward more mainstream politics. Bump ‘em.

Rob

Love the response here. Yeah internet idiots will always exist and they will require you to do things like this.

Kirk

People always trying to start shit.

Andrew Sauter

I think Pete is a charisma Superstar like Bernie Sanders like Obama like Bill Clinton.

Pixel-davis

In my opinion, the path was never to mess with it and just to have left it as it was originally. Hundreds of conspiracy theory nut jobs have been featured on this channel saying outright batshit insane stuff for years and years, and we've all been able to suss out what is and is not true for ourselves. But now we're going to do start doing fact checks? Is this going to be the case across the board anytime someone says something false or is it just a one-time thing or is it just for the specific issue? Seems like a can of worms that was not worth opening.

B

We don’t deserve you

Elijah Meredith

Seems like things get a lot more complicated when you start encroaching on the territory of the wealthy elite and politicians. Power to you Andrew for taking that shit head on for the people. The radical transparency and communicating with your fan base makes all the difference. They might be able to clip you out of context and wave their bullshit wands around a bit but they don’t know how to deal with people who can work fast and speak clearly. They aren’t actually interested in the truth, and one way or another truth always wins.

Roughneck Basidiomycota

Sorry to hear dude. No shame in this. Your editing is appreciated but nobody is taken in good faith these days. Keep it real dude

soph

this

z

do tulsi gabbard next

Chris D'Antonio

I'm immediately reminded of Trump's bogus 60 Minutes lawsuit in which he claimed Harris's interview was edited in a deceitful way - and we all saw how that bullying resulted in some of the plainest acts of corruption to this day. Pressure on journalism and control of the media is not something to be taken lightly - I appreciate the transparency and wish you the best - and the tenacity to keep fighting for independent journalism.

J

Do you acknowledge that there is a difference in the impact of words spoken by a "conspiracy theory nutjob," as you said, verses a former US Secretary of Teansportation and past and potential future Presidnetial nominee? Would you suggest treating both exaclty the same or would you acknowledge that it is beneficial for a journalist ti fact-check the claims of those who hold, or have held, some of the highest ranking offices in the US government?

Pixel-davis

Conspiracy theory nut jobs are running the US government right now, and Andrew has interviewed people who have had immediate influence on those politicians, so I I'm willing to reconsider my stance if every false claim they make in future interviews is fact checked in the same manner. But my preference would be a more confrontational stance during the interview in these cases so that the interviewee has a chance to respond, rather than revising it during the editing process as was done in this case. It feels too selective. The interview should stand on its own

will papsidero

Getting bent out of shape about the edit is such a painfully annoying dork thing to do. You don’t have anything to prove.

Daniel

I wish you the best as you transition to this more “serious” political part of your career

Yeah

Time to hire some fact checkers and PR.

Tom Ryan

I think the trimmed bits are worth it just to see the hotel guy get awkwardly caught in the background at 5:48

Andy

Andrew, I love you. But please work on the spelling in your titles. If you want to establish credibility, you can't be making these mistakes. Keep up the riveting content! You are the only news I care about.

Odie Moses

Glad you uploaded this. Really enjoyed the interview and I’m happy to see more of it!

Kimboleh

Totally understand why you had to do this, but sucks that you needed to. Thanks for being transparent and reputable as always.

jamie medley

More power to you for defending yourself dude. Hoping for Gavin Newsom next!

Leo

He looks like Aesop Rock.

Candelario Calderon

I think there’s a difference between young college kids/leftists and MAGA-pilled conservatives who are mad at the world in their own ways, versus career politicians, my bro

Nina Mcmunn

PLEASE try to platform 3rd parties in the same proportion i dont like him name droping libertarians but peing pro goverment power (when its his party) Quit responding to the liberal cannibals

blip4727

Even if I agree with Andrew's views here I think they got a bit in the way of this interview and it should not have been re-edited.

MulveyMacKenzie

Great interview. Thanks for the clarification too. Ok by me.

Andy K

Andrew knows and acts in a way that shows he knows that a journalist's credibility is almost impossible to regain once lost. Long live C5

Bethany V

It's a shame how people are reacting — Channel 5 has always demonstrated the utmost journalistic integrity. The choices made here do not disrupt the purpose of this interview. Much love to you, Andrew.

HUEYDOESNTEXIST

No third parties are retarded if you vote green you are an unserious person

Kia Nicole Tudor

glad to see you address this and talk specifically about what is different. Clarity is helpful.

Nina Mcmunn

Thats an opinion heres a fact The two party system is not in the best intrest of the poeple.

Sasha Hofman

I fully understand why each of these bits were cut, I think it did help streamline the conversation - however, I still think uncut interviews should be posted to Youtube regardless of where the conversation goes. Your videos are already surpassing 1 hr, we are watching because we take to long-form conversational media. We want to have all the facts laid out and make our own opinions, including on a politician's natural conversational style. We just want all the information and I think uncut interviews are the way to go regardless of what is 'old news' or 'off-topic'.

Juancarlos Martinez

Im with you, I don't care how long it is, I think there's something special about watching an interview in its entirety as it was done.

tro

fuck the haters

Carlos

NGL, don't care what Pete has to say. Homie is far too media trained to sound authentic. Just like the rest of the dems.

sdfuy798iujk3

This was extremely disappointing Andrew. There is no "explosion of antisemitism" on the internet, and if there is, it's being deliberately fomented by Israel itself. Why did you say 60k? That number is a lie ... Are you doing propaganda for Israel now???? Multiple studies have said the number is 300,000 or MORE. Terrible journalism. Been a fan forever but anything like this again and I'm off your patreon

Kai r M

Have you been living in the woods without a phone since this spring? It’s hard to go on any social media platform without seeing countless posts and comments critiquing Israel. And since that sentiment has drifted into semi mainstream ideals, you obviously get thousands of knuckle draggers posting straight up anti semitism. I’m all for valid criticism of Israel but there is anti-semetic (as in hate directed at ethnically Jewish peoples) - in the public discourse right now.

sdfuy798iujk3

Guess what buddy. It's not possible to antisemitic to people who aren't semites. Go climb a tree you psychopathic freak

Alex Ander

Do you cover these studies you’re referring to on your Patreon show? Do you find threats to be an effective tool to get what you want?

sdfuy798iujk3

Yeah this was a weird move same with him trying to be cozy with the NYT. I mean that is the literal enemy. I can see the logic behind it maybe but.. no thanks.

sdfuy798iujk3

"I’m trying to build credibility amongst establishment politicians for the upcoming midterms" .... Why?

Brian Schneider

So the 60k fatality numbers being reported by the Gaza Health Ministry is considered Israeli propaganda now? What source are you citing for the 300k number?

Joshua

Hello Mr Pete Delphi! Love u bro! Ur my fucking idol!

Benjamin Arndt

This is an interesting question that I also had when I read that.

Daniel Bognar

mind blowing this "Video game influence" is a thing in the US and some people actually believe this... at this point any movie, political speech or any song can "influence" you to take out people

Anon69420

Because we literally need a trustworthy outlet to understand what these guys are thinking. We have very few outlets that havent been taken over by conservative billionaires, and Andrew has shown that time and time again he can ensure these interviews actually foster learning that both sides seem to appreciate.

Krankyfox

Definitely has been more antisemitism on instagram. I will see posts criticizing israel which is not inherently antisemitic at all, but there will be comments like „109 countries“ and other crap about jews ruling the world. So while the posts are antizionist and anti israel which is not the same as antisemitic, the comments take it a step further.

who, me

Denying a rise in antisemitism online is completely delusional. As is saying that any such rise is "deliberately fomented by Israel". Attitudes like these, especially by people who probably consider themselves on the "left" which SHOULD and COULD be a bulwark against (obviously among many other things) antisemitism makes me f-ing despair. Why dont you leave that stuff to Nick Fuentes et al -- or just come out already and join him??