Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 733886409.mp4

Downloads

Content

hey guys,

This is a prime interview we shot with Marcant, who was one of our primary sources out in Germany covering AfD stuff last week. Figured I'd drop it here.

AC

Files

Comments

Jan Detlefsen

Wow nice to see. He is doing a heck of a job to expose the German right for the idiots they are.

The Ders

Love this. Didn't think we'd ever get this crossover

Christian WASDF

Marcant and Channel5 cooperation is something I haven’t had on my bingocard. A very pleasant surprise regardless

Poisonous Purple

This crossover made my year, both of my favourite journalists talking for almost an hour! So happy to see <3

Tony S

Another right wing (explainer) subject. If alternative journalism continually shows us society's pathologies and almost never its functioning alternatives, it can accidentally teach the audience that the pathology is where history is happening.

Mar F Gold

Man to us germans Marcant is a true hero. He is like Hasan Piker for Germany. I saw you guys having an Interview on one of his clips and I was so happy to see my two favourites connecting! ❤️

Sharon Liscinski

I just got back from Auschwitz- Birkenau. 1 million German and Polish Jews died there. However there were groups of Israeli teens who draped themselves in the Israeli flag during the tour which was so disorienting because the message went over their heads.

holly

Also thanks for your coverage on this :)

Mar F Gold

You would not say, if you really knew his work. He shows both sides and gives solutions. Plus thanks to the world wide phenomenon of normalizing faschism and racism,everything is pretty shitty right now.

jw

How anyone could miss the irony is baffling. I wonder what they'd say to someone draped in a Palestinian flag.

Ray

Always thinking in the best ways. Keep kicking ass channel 5

M Like Mike

Channel 5 keeps blowing my mind - thanks for everything @ Andrew & team

Wiley H

I love how he starts most answers in English and then goes "my English isn't good enough, fuck it" and switches to German

Ryder Currier

Was in Germany three years ago and they were playing a WW2 documentary. It was a small town bar but still everyone was joking about how it was a shame they had lost the war. Interesting what you say with media aligning, I noticed other parts of the economy, like fashion, aligning too.

Floodo1

tiktok comments WOW actual cespool

Oscar Leitner

What the actual fuck, I did not expect that, Love marcant and channel 5!!!!

Hans Wurst

Liebe geht raus an Marc! All love no brakes, Andrew!

Mr.Psychotronic

Nice. We saw in one of your videos that you are in Germany right now, showing one of your documentaries in Berlin and covering this election. I already had my hopes up that you guys somehow meet on the streets somewhere during that time. I didn't know you would do a whole interview. Amazing! Thank you so much. The whole of Germany is holding its breath right now. Some people are already moving away from east Germany. I hope for a wide spread coverage. The media in Germany isn't doing a good job, we need people like Marcant and you to educate. So again, I can only hand I out my sincere thanks to everyone involved.

Johannes Dato

I had the same reaction this morning. Love it!

djdeutschebahn

Does andrew is able to understand german? Sometimes he nods in response

Raphael Rose

I'm German and I disagree with marcant. Andrew raises really good questions but marcant gives really one sided answers. It's not that black and white. There is a real immigration problem and that is driving many voters to the afd which would normally just vote conservative (CDU) or even slightly left (SPD), but these parties haven't recognized this issue for a long time. Their doing it now though, which proves the point that there is a real issue. Not 30% of Germans are Nazis but the AFD could get 30% in the next election. That doesn't mean that the AFD isn't bad or that there aren't a lot of nazis in it but marcant just gives a too one sided answer. It's just as objective as it would be to interview an AFD politician about the whole thing and only show his perspective. I hope that in future videos, the broad public will have the chance to speak, so that everyone here can understand that there are many reasonable people who do think that Angela shouldn't have let them all in. As marcant says, it's very important to not let parallel society's emerge. Well, that already happened because there were just too many people for our slow bureaucratic system and some didn't even want to adopt our values.

Kami

THIS IS CRAZY FOR ME AS A GERMAN 😭🙏

pas moi

Speak for yourself. I dont think his work is particularly helpfull and the quality of his questions is much worse than Andrews and not designed to find any common sense. Hes nothing like Hasan Piker because he essentially is not anti system. He makes fun of uneducated radicalized poor people for a liberal audience imo. Something that fristly helps the established parties which are responsible for the questionable demography and migration policies that led to the raise of the AfD in the first place. The honest question should be to which extent a nation state with shitty demographic can keep its identity when using mass migration to solve this issue. The following honset question should be if you are a Nazi if you not feel comfortable with mass migration that will change your countrys ethnoculutral identity. The CDU is mostly to blame for all of this shit. Their abysmally preparations for a mass influx of migrants created a terrible situation for those who arrive as well as for the natives. https://www.morgenpost.de/politik/article408791356/messerverbotszone-im-u-bahnhof-das-ist-doch-augenwischerei.html

Jonas

Im a german too and disagree somewhat with marcant but comparing him to an afd politician seems a little farfetched to me. Not 30% of germans are nazis, but you cant deny that germans are somewhat prone to racism and xenophobia and the problem surely isnt the immigration crisis in 2015. And the question is: are the immigrants the problem or is it our slow bureaucratic system?

Jonas

Nice to see you cover things in Germany, Andrew!! However, marcant does a great job as a political online persona, i like him and appreciate his work, but i think you could have interviewed someone more knowlegable and eloquently. Marc forgot to mention important things such as differences between east and west germany and how they came to be. He didnt mention social identity problems within the youth of germany. He didnt mention foreign interference in german elections. And really important too: you didnt really touch on german economics, which is a central reason for people to turn to a facist party like Afd.

Kami

Sorry but what do YOU do to stop a 2029 fascist government? The infighting between socdems and further left is the primary reason the AfD will win the 2029 elections. Even a status quo with a “centrist” government would be more favorable than a fascist leadership in this nation.

pas moi

Cant help it, but i dont like Marcant. I dont think his work is helpful. The Nazis were much worse than the AfD. The antimigrant sentiment is not the same as industrialized genocide on people deemed inferior. Most of the AfDs nationalistic positions that are deemed far rigth now, were part of the big conservative CDU party until Merkel took over the CDU (check Hans Jürgen Irmer or Alfred Dregger). I do not agree with the AfD and I think the parties popularity stems from its unjustified image as an antiestablishment party (while being led by a former Goldmann Sachs emplyee kek...) Using mass migration to fix the economy and the job market while claming that the motivations for taking in so many people were purely humasitic is a real political issue that should by honestly and seriously discussed as it has led to significant security issues in some places (we have no weapon zones in public places like train stations now, which is crazy). Those issues are played down by the established media as far right panic. Criticizing the established media used to be a far left anti system thing but was handed to the rightoids (to delegitimize the critic all together imo - check Lügenpresse). Our current governemnt of the big two old parties is currently abolishing the german version of freedom of information act, because in the past those FOU laws have uncovered corruption within the governing parties. The party who criticizes this most vocally is of course the AfD. The AfD is also the only party in parliament who calls for a full disclosure on all corona policies as well as a reform of the public braodcast. I know a lot of countrieside boomers who only vote AfD for those two reasons and because they are fed up with the establishment

pas moi

Ill give it five to ten years and the AfD will govern in coalition with the CDU. Im not a fan of them but as Volker Pispers said: are you trying to sell shit in diffrent flavor. Our centrists are already very cozy with Palantir and the oligarchic establishment. But sure vote for them to prevent the fascist goldmann sachs lesbina

Looca

Loved this interview!

Mar F Gold

You are exactly the problem. Demographic problems I give you. But migration problems and leftist streamers are suppose to be reason for the rise of the AfD in the first place? You must be eather not be from Germany to say that or you lost your common sense. Do you feel the need to defend Andrew and Hasan of a unworthy comparisson, in your opinion? You even use the great replacement theory. What the Merkel administration did in 2015 with the migrants from Syria was noble in was as good prepared, as possible, because everything happend so fast! Fact: Almost 70% of Syrien men, that have the capibility to work, do work! So no! The migrants did cost us at the beginning, but it was an investment, that payed off already!

Tani

As a German. I appreciate this a lot because my us girlfriend could watch this content now and learn a lot about German politics

Max H

There is such a big difference between the interviewing and questioning-style of C5 and Marcant. It seems like Marcant is looking for the opportunity to make these people look dump. Of course there are Nazis supporting AfD but by far not everyone can be labeled as a straight Nazi. And in my opinion Marcant is missing this when he is talking to and with the people at these rallys. In contrast it seems as Andrew and his team is not hated by the people with different opinions or worldviews because of the way C5 is talking to them. C5 seems more interested in the dialogue and understanding instead of „educating people from above“ like Marcant is doing in his videos. Marcant is doing a brave job in joining these rallys but I would love to see a different approach when talking to people with a different ideology

Mar F Gold

No! All wrong! You pay close attention to all kinds of similarities in Andrews videos: not the failed policies of past parties (Biden), not an uncontrolable wave of migrants (great replacement theory, fearmongering), social and economic instability that follows, when you „Let them all in“. Every play in the book has been used before. I bet you can see it happening in the U.S. So why do you close your eyes in this case. Its Propaganda! Its gaslighting the uneducated and give all the racists a platform, even if they are just a bit racist. So, all the old parties did horrible jobs according to you. What will the AfD do, that will make Germany a better place for the ppl that are struggling?

Denuii

lmaoo whaaaat :O

pas moi

Im anti economical growth. I got red pilled by Gerog Schramm 20 years ago. The great Replacement is a stupid conspiracy and not the same as what linkrel describes: https://www.un.org/development/desa/pd/sites/www.un.org.development.desa.pd/files/unpd-egm_200010_un_2001_replacementmigration.pdf Solving the issue of agening and declining population with migration will simply change a country. Thats neither a conspiracy theory nor factually wrong. Conservative people will be opposed to that. Im not a conservative and I dont mind migration but its incredibly dishonest to not admit that behind the AfD is a real political issue that is not treated seriously. Instead the establishment calles it, ehat ypu accused me off. Why does a conservative sentiment that is considered normal in most european countries only find a place in the far right party here? The CDU didnt use its 16 years governing period to create infrastructure for a mass influx of migrants and also wasnt honest about the motivation to let so many people in (member Sarazin? Member Frank Schurrmachers bestselling book "the metusalem komplot". I even leanred in school that our demography was fucked up in the early 2000s and despite this no political action took place till 2015 . The CDU of course did this because a big portion of their voters would have opposed such mass immigration. And here is the german heritage I identify with: (...) GOTT VERSAH UNS MIT ZWEI HÄNDEN DASS WUR DOPPELT GUTES SPENDEN NICHT UM DOPPELT ZUZUGREIFEN UND DIE BEUTE AUFZUHÄUFEN IN DEN GROBEN EISENTRHUN WIE GEWISSE LEUTE TUN IHRE NAMEN AUSZUSPRECHEN DÜRFEN WIR UNS NICHT ERFRECHEN HÄNGEM WÜRDEN WIR SIE GERN DOCH ES SIND SO GROBE HERRN PHILANTHROPEN, EHRENMÄNNER MANCHE SIND AUCH UNSRE GÖNNER UND MAN MACHT AUS DEUTSCHEN EICHEN KEINE GALGEN FÜR DIE REICHEN (...) R Heine

pas moi

Und Händy Legastheniker bin ick ooch

Mar F Gold

You need to break out off your bubble. You are on the wrong side of facts. What really shocks me ist that you pay for an honest reporter like Andrew, but completely fall for disengenious politicians and propaganda. Let me guess - you get your informations from Nius or Ben unframed?

Michael

I'm from Germany, and I don't like Marcant. I think C5 is great because somehow Andrew has this ability to come across as non-threatening, so people are just open with him. Marcant does not have this ability, nor does he try to conduct objective interviews. His style extremely condescending and only fishes for some gotcha moment he can upload to tiktok. Last but not least, Marcant only affiliates with people from either Die Grünen or Die Linke and frequently frames their talking points as definitive answers.

Nik

Appreciate your coverage of this and really enjoyed your conversation with Marcant. Thanks Andrew

pas moi

No. I usually use Ground News as I think the german media landscape is not very usefull. I regularly check Nachdenkseiten, Overton Magazin, Multipolar Magazin. Let me guess, you read Taz? I hate RTL2, I hate Springer. I hate self declared youtube influencer who sell wurköder to RTL2 Germans. And again. Im not anti migration. Im paying 120€ of schoolmoney per year for the education of a random guys child from Kenia. I met this guy lost on a train. Hes was a preacher in Kenia (dont ask him about his stance on LGBTQ). I helped a family of Yesides in Berlin. All of them expected Germany to be way more weatlhy and to offer way better opportunities than it does. I help two Syrian guys to find their way in the Berlin S-Bahn who paid 15k each to come here from northern Syria and when I told them, that 3000€ per month netto was considered a high salary here, they reufsed to believe it. They were unironically thinking, that a honest hard working person could own a house and a car in 5 years when working a factory job in car manufactering. Im not a chud in denail. I just think the AfD is a perfect divide and conquer tool for our dishonorable elites.

Mar F Gold

Multipolar? My friend your lost. You are using ground news wrong. Its not suppose to confirm your conspiracies and believes. I don‘t whatch cable tv. Zeteo, the Guardian, official indepedent organisations like Dr. Without Borders. Btw: You did not answer the question: What will the AfD improve? If you see in the AfD a culture division tool, why would you not tackle it and yes, also ridicule the whole party and its members? They lie directly into the microphone and leftist can‘t make a joke out of it?

Dawid Wieczorek

Marcant's answer when asked to address the Polish hate-crime statistics is downright xenophobic. Andrew rightly points out to false correlations: Polish immigration law has become restrictive mostly due to Poland taking in millions of Ukrainans after 2022. but this law is EU-compliant and was written with EU's Parliament support. there's a right wing resurgence almost everywhere, including Poland. and Poland in particular struggles a lot with being open to foregin cultures (being homogenized culturally by first the Nazis and later kept isolated from the wider world by the Soviets). but that doesn't mean foreigners are openly hated here! of course there are incidents, more recently more against the Ukrainians than anyone else, really. and that is a complex problem on its own, Moscow's hybrid war and misinformation campgains nothwithstanding. racism in Poland extreme? sorry, but we have nothing on the scale of AfD: our most far right parties are no more than 10-12%. that is way too much still, but talking about extreme racism in Poland while discussing the AfD issue in light of otherwise accepting and egalitatarian German society is shortsighted. he's eager to point out that media in Germany are biased in presenting the problem, yet he virtually condemned the Poles because he heard stories from his friends? that is not a valid data sample, unfortunately.

pas moi

Dass du mir die Fähigkeit zum Selbstdenken anscheinend nicht zugestehst, pisst mich richtig an. Würdest du unsere Positionen gerne in einem persönlichen Gespräch abstecken? Ich schicke dir gerne meinen Discord Kontakt.

# Tjark

i've found this interview a good introduction to the severity of the situation in germany as of right now, yet it was a frustration watch all the same. while i believe markants youth reachout work is well intended and working and i'm thankful and i hope for him to continue it, i've found his answers shortsighted at moments. maybe this stems from his lackluster knowledge of english, but especially with andrew as an interview partner there would've been so many topics to open up, since the political movements in germany and the us are so more aligned and share so mich more croassover than it would seem. anyways i'm still very grateful and happy to see andrew in germany, maybe next time he'll make it to hamburg, after going to frankfurt for markants sake. the intersection between german qnd american youth should be a lever we whould not underestimate for global change and i truly wish to see a channel 5 europe subsection one day, since there is so much eneless possibilities of amazing topics and coverage for the world to see 5 is the best number best -tjark

Ethan Dueber

I’m curious how Andrew is translating Marcant’s German to English? Are they cutting away when a human translator relays what he said, or does he have some kind of real-time translation device type thing?

magrathean

As a German thanks for this interview both to Andrew and Marc. I've seen some videos and lots of people I value like Marc but I wasn't sure what his opinions really were. Now I feel like I know much better and I like what I'm hearing

D B

I agree with you, but I also think that the AfD governing a state, or worse, the country, would severely worsen or threaten the lives of many people living in Germany. It would also harm the economy with their neoliberal/libertarian policies. So, doing something to prevent them from gaining majorities in parliament is a net positive.

Gear

People immediately shit on Marcant, but like to forget (or ignore) that he only at it for ~1,5 years, while also being what - 23-24 years old or smth? I dont agree with everything Marcant says or does as well - but in general his work is extremely important to offer a counterweight to right wing social media (which is way waaay more skewed and ignorant than anything he has ever produced)... He is regularly reaching youths who were falling into the right wing - nazism spiral and that is super important.

Mar F Gold

I do not have Discord. That fact, that a random guy, that critics you directly pisses you off, is an issue you need to work on brother. Everybody can think for themselfs, that does not make everybody right. I do not suggest: You use ground news, but your conclusions are simply wrong = you are not using it, as intended. 30% of germans vote for the AfD but not all voters are Nazis. Its the same 2nd grader logic, Ulrich Siegmund uses. And still no answer to my questions.

pas moi

Which question exactly didnt I answer? All I really got was the accusation of being a missled AfD apologist who is falling for missinformation paired with your assumption that im consuming shit media like Nius. I dont deny the Neonazis within the AfD but I doubt that Green politicians will be killed in SA basements by paramilitaries once the AfD takes office in Niedersachsen. I doubt that they will built concentration camps. Unlike the 80s CDU the AfD doesnt even want to reconquer Silesia or Pommeria. You just dont like that 30% to 50% of german voters feel the way they feel about mass immigration and are voting accordingly. Its beyond me how one can deny the connection between mass immigration and the rise of far right movements all over europe. What media would you suggest to me? Spiegel? Süddeutsche? ZEIT? Der Dunkle Parabelritter?

pas moi

I dont vote for them and I agree: they will kill off the welfare state and economically screw over their own voters once in office. But as long as they are eternal opposition they will just grow due to the justified resentment toward the establishment.

Margaret Nelson

I’m an American now going to university in Baden-Württemberg to get a bachelors degree in anthropology and education studies. I can attest…it’s really scary to see another side of Germany not valuing the importance of education and knowing your own history. It’s crazy to think that I potentially know more about German history than most of my German friends because I had to know the history to learn the language.

Dustin

On the one hand they have to maintain that authentic German heritage, like currywurst, falafels, and doner, but on the other keeping your bloodline pure didn't work out so well for the Habsburgs...

DL

Maybe it’s a similar situation to the liberals in the U.S. who spend all of their time ridiculing MAGA people, rather than politicians with ridiculous ideas. Seems naive to pretend we can all go back to normal when a whole group of people has been primed to be radicaoized (and was radicalized) because they were left behind.

Asatas

hey C5, you should have Marcant's team proofread the subtitles, sometimes they're gobbledygook

Matt Dawson

Does Andrew just like, know German?? Is he following the conversation? if so, super impressive

Grant Oberle

I assume someone else translated for Andrew after Marcant spoke and it wasn't shown in the cut

Luis Perez

Wow. What a video. I an so blind

Иноагент

I don't give a shit about immigration, I like it actually. I don't like walled garden societies and I'm not precious about demography or "preserving culture" these are irrelevant to my values and I'm not going to be manipulated into acting like they're legitimate concerns I should waste energy engaging with

Duterte Whitaker

3:00 the protestor is talking about a gay Palestinian...the translation wasn't very clear. Could one of the Germans in the comments interpret his point? Bitte

Jordi Brennan

The power that bots have in comments is disgusting

dougeatdoug

I have never heard of Mercant but this interview was fascinating. Peace and love!

orangestarfish

Appreciate your comment pas moi, I think you are right that we do ourselves a disservice when we only bat away AfD as a bunch of crazed Nazis, as if without them we could just get on with making things better for everyone - this is, after all, exactly how they feel, only their enemy is immigrants and jews, whereas ours is nazis. I do think Andrew tries to make this point when he shares his theories about why people become radicalised i.e. loss of community, economic security, need for belonging. But this gets lost in the comfort of believing the enemy is weak and uneducated, when the truth is that we have a lot in common with people who support AfD, and the enemy is staggeringly powerful; the establishment, which has lost touch with its responsibility to the majority and is instead beholden to the interests of those who can afford to have its ear. It benefits them that we remain divided. How could we unite? On what basis?

Janek

You Identify the issues correctly but instead of denying people safety we need to integrate them better. Some are in Germany for years and don't get work permits, they need to work ASAP ( I'm not saying this from an economic perspective but from a social perspective). One of the worst things for a society are bored young men without a perspective no matter what origin.

Yann Uhlrich

A “true hero” who produces sensationalist “slam dunk” content, capitalizing on misdirect fear-driven anger? Anmaßend von “us Germans” zu reden

Mar F Gold

So lets deflect from the positives: He talked sense into almost 600 people, that were on a dark path and changed their lifes. Education. Teach to take a stand for all mankind, animals, global environments in need. He even teaches basic economy~ because he also makes money? A carpenter - A classic nature hater, that takes advantage of poor people in need of furniture! If he would work for the AfD, then its taking advantage of feared, misdirected people, because they created the fear and they are liers. Millionaires destroy environments, enslave people, cost global financial crash‘s, rape and traffic kids - this are the kind of individuals, whom I don‘t want to be succesfull. The guys making a living fighting all that, deserve even more money!

pas moi

I live on the countryside where many people vote AfD. They like to vent out all their missguided hate and justified frustration while drinking copious amouns of beer. I often join them, inviting myself to their tables and start to hate on the whole banking industry and on the wastefullness of capitalism and how back in the good old days people would rather darn their socks instead of just buying new ones. I hate on the superrich and then I mock the AfD as a party of the superrich while emphasizing that we as the pleb (and any pleb for this matter, also african and arabic pleb) should fight against our oligarchic overlords. I never tell them what to vote and what not to vote. I often talk about Lugig who is unknown here. Cant tell if any of this changes any mind or voting behavior but most of them respect and like me for being honest, respectfull and constructive instead of hating on them or falling for the 'you cant talk to those people'. But I aslo live in the west - we dont really have the hardcore skinhead Nazi here that marcsnt usually interviews. Young rightoids in the west rather fall for the viking aesthetic here.

Avicenna

Became a member just for this insane crossup

Ben

What a crossover! Thank you for doing this interview.

Bussell bender

We got the smoking fajitas in here🔥🔥🔥

brdbth15678

So many double agent far right psy-ops in this comment section saying this guy isn't doing good work. Don't listen it's copaganda.

Thxrexsh

1 year ago I posted a comment on marcants channel he needs to talk to channel 5. Now I see this. THANK YOU guys fr !

Thxrexsh

he needs to learn from andrew...

Sprout

Can someone confirm if I could download all these videos DRM Free so I can watch this Offline? Thank you! (I'm new to patreon and this is my first real subscription)

Paul

No one is “too old” to change. No one is too anything to change. Shut that notion down before it spreads. Anyone can change. Anyone can come out of the darkness. As soon as we give up on each other we have lost.

jon50250

Fantastic jawn

Merlin

this is so cringe.

Merlin

marcant is cringe guck 99zueins read gegenstandpunkt aber mach keine werbung für marcant digga

Jake

Wild

Max Goisser

Strong disagree. I think he does a fairly good job of approaching people differently depending on what stance they are showing. For rather undecided people and "Protestwähler" that very apparently never read the AfD's proposed policies he takes a much more open stance than with people that just spew hate. Yes, he is often taking a stance of "educating people from above", but interestingly so are many of his "opponents" (be it politicians or recurring characters at those protests) - I think that's just a much more typical German attribute. The goals are also quite different from what C5 is trying to accomplish. With someone like Marcant that primarily visits right wing protests, taking a more passive interview style like Andrew does, they would either turn into bad uncommented platforming of right wing sentiment (which the German mainstream media already does too much of), or incredibly boring (as protests are much more organized compared to the US, and nobody would talk to Marcant). I do agree with other commenters here, that would like too see more broad criticism across the German party landscape (e.g. about structural problems at the SPD and how they are complicit in cooperating in the current dysfunctional administration) that you see in the US from a Hasan Piker, but I think his main channel content is exactly one of the things Germany needs right now.

Max H

Fair points! I guess my point is that his videos rather add to the polarization that is happening in Germany instead of trying to find a base where you can have a discussion about the true Problems of the people that result in their views regarding AfD and Germany in general. I would love to see more of that instead of talking about each other.

Alana Jordan

who won the channel five correspondent documentary contest? this is bothering me so much the more time passes

Chance Rogers

In keeping up with Nick Shirley, i saw he recently took a trip to Ceuta, Spain where he posted a video fear mongering over the mass immigration of Moroccans to the city. I tried to do as much research as i could around what led to this, but it almost seems as if nobody has a clear answer. Moroccan parliament recently increased relations with Israel. the U.S has close ties to Morocco, as it was the first country to ever recognize the United states as a sovereign country. Yet, thousands of Moroccans fled to Spain under economic hardship, claiming there was no work and no life to be had in Morocco. Is this true? Or is this an underground invasion by the US/Israel against Spain since Spain has has a target on her back after recognizing Palestinian sovereignty? Too many questions and not enough answers. Would love to see some coverage either on the ground or by experts covered by C5. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS MATTER.

Jannes Petereit

Hey Andrew Great to see you're setting up HQ in Germany! As a local, I’d love to share some direct insights or pass along reliable sources/data to help your team get an accurate picture of the current situation. Let me know if you're open to connecting or if I should send a few notes over. Best, Jannes

Duterte Whitaker

Unironic and by design. There are plenty of teen trips to Israel which will first spend time in Poland. Realizing the attempts to parallel what's happening in Gaza, West Bank to what happened in Eastern Europe 80 years ago, however, this comparison diminishes the vast horrors of the Holocaust. It also kinda lets the current Israeli leadership off the hook as the comparison is hyperbolic and therefore dismissed. Both firmly in the category of "shitty bad things" but not an apples-to-apples comparison.

Duterte Whitaker

"You know, with Hitler, the more I learn about that guy, the more I don't care for him!" -Norm MacDonald

Yes-Man

This meeting was not on my card. You visited my home town (Magdeburg) and I missed it :/

Garrett

Wonder if you have heard of Brother Ali, Andrew! He would be an interesting guy to interview

m0rt

It can happen a lot faster than you think, way less than 5-10 years. And when they start to REALLY take from you, not like right now, as popular and powerful as they seem; you'll realize there really is no getting back --any time soon. If this video is any indication, Germany rn is in the height of its "fuck around" phase, when y'all find out, you'll always remember what role you played in it all. I think you underestimate how good things still are for you, and how fast that can actually change

H34Dlez

my 2 favourite journalists... what!?🥹

R K

Sounding like an afd tard btw. the situation in Germany right now reminds me of the late stages of Weimar Republic

Connor Willie

Poldi in a channel 5 video - crazy work I love this world

Chris D'Antonio

Great interview, super interesting to see the parallels with American society. Marcant seems like quite the controversial figure, from the video and the comments, and I'm wondering who any analogous Americans would be for perspective... somebody mentioned Hasan? But it feels like Marcant does a lot more fieldwork...? Looking forward to the Berlin video!

supa

Marcant does not need to make fun them. They are doing it themselves. And they don't want to be educated (except the younger audience like he said). It's in plain sight to see in his content.

pas moi

Here is the main issue. Compared to Andrew or Hassan, Marcant is considered to be system conserving not anti-system. Andrew talks about media concentration in a corrupt system run by shady rich people and tries to find common ground on this bases even with manosphere assholes, proud boys and grandmas for Trump. He points out the economical situation of January 6th protesters as a likely reason for their radicalization. Such opinions and stances would be considered to be Schwurbelei (unserious conspiracy talk) by the majority of german established media and associated with the AfD by manufactured consent. Critic of the system was given to the AfD, so if you criticize the system (even for very didfrent reasons than the AfD) you must also be a crazy and dangerous Nazi. Easy divide and conquer just like in the USA.

pas moi

I dont know Marcants heart and his motivations but compared to Andrew he just doesnt do the hard system critic I'd need to see when dealing with the rise of right wing populism. I dont oppose his effort to convince missguided idiots by talking to them. But he has to know that they preceive him as an Agent of the Lügenpresse while proudboys or manospehre assholes seem to feel that Andrew gives them a fair unbiased oportunity to present themselves. I dont think the people getting interviewed by marcant ever feel this way.

pas moi

No offense but compared to late stage Weimar, we still live in peacefull stable times tbh. I also feel like "the New Nazis are around the corner Narrative" is very questionable: >1929 economical crisis so bad that people literally starved on the streets >1930 till 1933 german governments ruled without the parliament >1932 Chancellor von Schleicher coup detats the pro republican SPD let prussian government for no apparent reason >Judges, the high officials and 99% of the military opposed democracy and hoped to restore the german Monarchy >de facto civil war between Nazi (SA) and communist (Rotfront) paramilitaries who both want to destroy the Weimar republic >Hitler opposed democracy and wanted to abolish it ≠ Afd runs on a platform to allegedly save democracy, freedom of speech and law&order (im Wahlkampf wird natürlich nie gelogen) >Hitler thought that germans were the masterace, chosen by natures destiny to advance humanity aka aryans by killing or enslaving the 'inferior races'. Starts a war to do so, commits industrialized genocide (his ideas were no secret but published in his book Mein Kampf in the 20ies ≠ Ausländer raus >weimer germany was a fully independent nation state surrounded at best by rivals and at worst by arch enemies ≠ modern germany is part of many suprenational organizations and surrounded by friends >other european right wing populists took office and nothing even remotely similar to 1933 happened. Even Trumps ICE raids are a joke compared to the murder and torture that occurred right after the Ermächtigung

Alton Jack

The rise of Nazis feels like a depression indicator. People are struggling and looking for something to blame. Meanwhile, Elon Musk is a trillionaire.

Mar F Gold

Well thats a good point, but the comparisson cannot be drawn like that. Andrew is a full blown, all out, pure honest and highly appreciated journalist. Marcant is a full blown, all out, pure honest and highly appreciated streamer and content creator. Why I appreciate them both and mention them in one sentence ,is on the positive effect for the population and opressed minorities, that their own, but similar work result into.

Mar F Gold

I am not even going to debunk all this. Everybody that knows WW2 history, knows that it is a desperate attempt to ignore the similarities to the NSDAP, with made up conclussions about the facts. Present this nonsense to any renown historian and he/she would laugh their ass off. And btw: still no answers to my questions…

Phil Sch.

It doesn't make any more sense in German...

Vlad Loenko

keep fighting the good fight and showing up to the rallies! So grateful to be a part of this community

Lukas Lauber

well done. Danke Marc für deinen Einsatz

Kia Nicole Tudor

"I also wonder what German values even are today... other than being on time." Had me rolling

pas moi

Again which of your questions didnt I allegedly answer? And please enlighten me about the mistakes in my historical comparison. Wanna talk about the Nazis social politics? The socialist part of their politics thats are quite the opposite of the libertarian / market radical stance of the AfD? And you also wanted to tell me which media you consum Sag mal bist du eigentluch genuin oder ein Bot?

Jet Jaguar

the amount of digging into german/prussian history that this inspired for me was truly rewarding, thank you man

Jet Jaguar

also, curious to see if marcant would find benefit in approaching minds he hopes to convert by creating a perception of MAGA that would appeal to AfD supporters & the like, but then showing them accounts of people admitting regret in supporting MAGA

Waylon Cortez

This needs to be released worldwide

Mar F Gold

1st: Will you vote for the AfD? 2nd: What policies of the AfD actually benefit the working class or will be positiv bye any means? No man, I don‘t debate your nuances of politics, when there is no base to stand on. NSDAP was the peak of fascism and evil. The Antitheses to democracy. Everybody, that tries to make even the slightest comparisson is a stupid moron! No I am not a bot.

Kris

Nobody mentions HOW GERMANY GOT HERE ... again. Corrupt politians facing no accountability when caught. 17+ years smooching billionaires and israel, anti voter but pro oil/gas/electricity lobby politics that killed economic growth. and on top of that a multi millionaire chancellor with zero intellect, social skills and morals that calls them lazy and spoiled.

Lee Caroma

Thats an excellent way to phrase it. Cult of responsibility. To do better than humanity did in the past. Ive been trying to explain to people I know, I wasnt born when people were slaves, but I dont want that to happen again. I dont feel bad, I just try to treat everyone with respect. The mention of slavery, of history, to certain people triggers that "You're assaulting me for being X race!" Which is simply not even the issue man.

Guillermo A Calvillo

Did you watch the video? The ethnic identity of East Germany is quite strong since their population of Muslims is ~ >1%. The right is throwing up shadow monsters on the wall(AFD, MAGA, same ol shit) to get you to vote against your own benefit, for the capitalist class who bought all the East German factories for pennies on the dollar. You want change, vote further left, and force the CDU into the correct policy platform.

pas moi

1. No I will not vote the AfD and I never did. I usually voted Die Linke in germany and Martin Sonneborn on a EU Level. I have sympathy for some BSW talking points such as Lifestyle lefty. 2. The AfD is a marekt radical party who will serve the hyper rich just like the others do. Their narratives are obviously designed to distract the enraged pleb from the social issue and the shitiness of capitalism. To which extend anything they say can be trusted is very opaque. Anything could be a merketing strategy. My point again. The CDU is the fuckin worst and mainly to blame. The political question of mass immigration and to which extent which kind of ethno nationalistic points should be legit within a normal european conservative party should not be a taboo that only serves the AfD. Fuckin Merz called the AfDs remigration 'ethnic cleansing' in parlaiment while his EVP led european commission prepares mass deporatations through hubs in Albania which is basically what the AfD wants. I cant stand the whole fuckin machiavellian shitshow. WELTENLAUF WER VIEL HAT, DER SOLL VIEL MEHR NOCH BEKOMMEN WER WENIG HAT, DEM WIRD NOCH DAS WENIGE GENOMMEN WENN DU ABER GAR NICHT HAST, ACH SO LASSE DICH BEGRABEN DENN EIN RECHT ZU LEBEN LUMP, HABEN NUR DIE ETWAS HABEN >Peter Thiel

Mar F Gold

We agree. Merz did a very very bad job. He abondoned his principles very quickly and that led to a disbelieve in politics in general. Where we don‘t agree is that we have a mass migration problem. Its made up to fuel fear into the population. We need even more migration and those migrants need to be welcomed and treated equaly. You need to realize that world wide conservative parties are not what they used to be. How did Orban got into power: by saying the same points - Migrants are the problem and slowly changing all the policies to be allowed to bully, opresse and ultimately get rid off the opposition and stay forever in power - they all know that there is no mass migration problem or a replacement. Thats the reason, why we cannot allow that discusion to happen. To use the racism within people and ignite that into hate, with flat out lies is not something that politicians should be discussing, as the LBGTQ community and Islam is no threat to anybody. Remigration is ethnic opression at the very least. Its Verfassungswidrig and disgusting. That we even have that discussion, weather remigration is ok or not, IS WRONG! P.s. Quoting Peter Thiel is bad brother. Ppl like Thiel, Musk, Durshowitz are evil.

jw

Can you clarify what state / what shitty demographic? You make some good points about shit policies leading to afd rise and more victories, but I'm not clear on some of your argument. "The honest question should be to which extent a nation state with shitty demographic can keep its identity when using mass migration to solve this issue."

jw

Also not clear on this "The following honset question should be if you are a Nazi if you not feel comfortable with mass migration that will change your countrys ethnoculutral identity." because I think of course a Nazi will not feel comfortable with immigrants changing Germany, right?

Jonas Le Loup

I was gonna write the something similar. Me, as an older German, love the dedication this guy has, but don't watch his videos, because they still have a kind of low professionalism, at least for my taste. But this interview again reminded myself of how young this guy still is (he mentions it: 24y) and he actually hasn't been doing this kind of journalism for very long. He will gain experience (and probably also will learn how to speak better English ;)). Nevertheless, the work he does is valuable and important. He offers a message to all Germans: To start taking the AFD voter serious , just talk to them and stop with falling into this condescending tone, because this is what will rise tensions even more.

Manolo

I love it when Marcant is talking about German values and they show Bernd das Brot LOL

pas moi

>shitty demographics Germany had a reproduction rate of 1,6 children per familiy for almost three decades. Mainly because of cost of living factors and a two person households where both partners wanted to work full time. Germany has a generational financed retirement system, so my grandmas retirement money is financed by the whole current german workforce. This system needs to crash once there are way more retired than working people. Id argue that this issue is supposed to be solved by immigration >ethnocultural idendity Till the late 90ies the CDU used to have a very diffrent profil when it comes to migration and idendity policies. The idea of conserving a national idendity used to have an obvious ethnical component at its core which was considered normal within the moderate right wing but is now almost considered a nazi pov within the german establishment. The CDU obviously was never openly racist but in their old mans club a real german would have to be white and have a german name and german as mothertongue. Foreigners could of course integrate but would always be foreign to some extent. Such Positions were considered moderate right wing in the day but are now seen as far right and the CDU acts as if they were alsways open and progressive.