Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

From 4x10 “If a Tree Falls in the Forest...” Full Length Reaction (Patreon)

Published:
2026-09-17 22:50:36
Imported:
2026-09

Videos

  • 747187727.mp4

Downloads

Content

The story comes to an end...FOR NOW! Can't believe we made it to this point. An unhinged episode along with an unhinged way to end this season leading into season 5. Woo I need season 5 immediately. Thank you to everyone who stuck along with us to this journey and to everyone who had requested this show in the first place.

Let us know if you would like a FROM dedicated chat either here on patreon or Discord.

Boyd's quest to lead the residents home reaches a terrifying crossroads, and nothing will ever be the same again.

Files

Comments

Tay

I can’t even cry in peace and here come Sophia frolicking through the flowers 😭 omg

Christina

I ship Jade and Tabitha and I'm not sorry about it lol. Tabitha finding the skull that belonged to her and Jade's daughter broke my heart. A lot of things broke my heart in this episode and that cliff hanger is criminal lol.

Jackson Potluck

Can we please refer to her as Fatimonster from here on out?

Jess K

What a great, yet INFURIATING finale lol! This show reminds me of Lost so much with all the little mysteries/theories/cliffhangers. Y’all would love that show! Maybe put that on the list for your guys next longer show to react to😉😉

Jess K

There’s a Wayward Pines show! Yall should watch it on here!

Pam Ellis

Me too. Some may say that they don't really have that type of relationship but I choose to believe that he is basing his words on the memories he recovered when he remembered plus what he knows in this time that they have interacted Loll

Love10 ❤️

Cody im so serious we all were screaming this smh HOW DOES NO ONE NOTICE SOPHIA?!?!? LIKE WTF

kaine

i think cody is right, we need to go back in time to see how things happened. there probably IS more context that would be genuinely helpful!

Carlie

It was so much fun to rewatch this show with y'all on your From journey. So bummed that we all have to collectively wait for the final season now. Maybe y'all could do a video with your theories on how it will all end and the main questions you want answered in the interim!

Love10 ❤️

Cody silence at the end was me and my husband. Like wtf smh

Misfit

I hate this show!!!!! 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

Sab

I just fucking knew jade and tab were gonna get stuck in the tunnels it just screamed it. IM SO SICK OF SOPHIA I HOPE THAT BAG CLARA GAVE YOU WAS JUST A BAG OF BORING ROCKS I’m hopeful but Clara seems like a total simp to Sophia Ethan is breaking my heart, Henry is breaking my heart, and Victor Also, why the fuck are we not listening to the man that has been here since this place was even able to come up with a fucking riddle like omfg 😭😭 but it gives ✨drama✨ Rip to my lesbians like fuck, had me ruined I refer to dick as Richard like yall, and the way he just killed her and walked out like he didn’t just do that was wild

Sab

I’m leaving another comment because Why I ship Sophia and cl- *GUNSHOT*

Sarah Rose

When y’all said “hopefully it’s not one of those where they’re dead the whole time and it’s purgatory…” I’m thinking… wait… wasn’t this by the same writers as LOST? 😬 I think I remember seeing someone said too that the writers said all the answers were actually in season one. I could be wrong, but it definitely has me itching to go back and rewatch again. I’m glad y’all liked it and can’t wait for season 5! 🥰✌🏻

Sarah Rose

Everytime she came on screen I’d go from 😃 to 🙄 real quick.

Claire Dactyl

In a much earlier episode, Fatima said, “I’m not going to let this place scare the life out of me.” That line really haunts me after this episode. Low-key hope she eats Clara next season 👀

Sarah Rose

I honestly thought Sarah would have caught onto that hoe. I was VERY disappointed in her this season. 🙄

Love10 ❤️

Omg absolutely, I was so annoyed. Missed opportunity. Maybe she'll pick up on it next season but with them living together I thought she would

Michayla

Congratulations to getting to this point! You guys honestly pieced things together so early on that I never caught onto until it was revealed in the show lol. Fatima's fate is so devastating because she was such a beacon of hope but at least she was able to save the people that she loved before completely losing herself to the monster taking over. That leads me to a theory that I've been holding onto till you guys got caught up. I found it in the wild blue yonder of Facebook From theories lol. It's actually an awesome theory even if it winds up being something completely different. This theory helped me to understand the storyline better and just makes sense to me. Here's the theory, it's a long one: I genuinely think *From* is pulling a full-on *Silent Hill*-style psychological horror thing, and the more I think about it, the more everything actually connects. Like… what if the town isn’t a normal place at all? What if the entire town was created by the Anghkooey children? Not in a literal “they built it” way. I mean their trauma created it. Their fear, suffering, grief, abandonment, whatever happened to them… it became this living nightmare world. A place that runs on emotions, memories, symbols, and story logic instead of real-world physics. And honestly? That would explain almost EVERYTHING. Think about it: • the roads loop endlessly • the forest changes • the trees move • time feels broken • symbols have power • monsters follow weird rules • people get trapped in repeating cycles • reality acts more like a dream than an actual town. That’s EXACTLY how *Silent Hill* works. Trauma manifests physically. The town in *From* feels less like a location and more like a psychological realm built from children’s fears and distorted memories. And Ethan is probably one of the biggest clues. Adults in the show always try to solve the town logically. Maps, radios, engineering, survival plans, etc. But Ethan understands the place through STORIES. And the town itself behaves like a story: • quests • sacrifices • rules • symbols • chosen people • monsters with conditions • magical safe spaces • repeating archetypes. It’s almost like narrative belief literally shapes reality there. Which also explains the talismans. I don’t think the talismans are “magic” in the traditional sense. I think they work because the town obeys symbolic belief. Like a child believing “this keeps monsters out,” so the realm makes it true. Because if this world was born from children’s emotional logic, belief itself becomes law. Even the monsters fit this. They don’t act like normal creatures. They act like distorted versions of adults from a child’s nightmare: • smiling strangers • fake kindness • manipulative “safe” people • predators pretending to be welcoming. That’s why they always try to get invited inside instead of just attacking directly. It feels symbolic. Personal. Almost social. And I honestly think they WERE human once… or they’re manifestations created from corrupted people over multiple cycles. Fatima’s pregnancy made me think this even more. That whole thing basically suggests the town reproduces itself THROUGH people. Like despair and trauma slowly turn humans into part of the system. The town corrupts hope itself and creates new monsters from broken people. Which is DARK AS HELL but also fits perfectly. The Boy in White also makes way more sense through this lens. I think he’s either: • one of the original children • or the last innocent part of the town that still wants to help people. He can guide people, but he can’t fully stop the cycle. He feels more like memory or hope fighting against the nightmare. And the moving trees? I don’t think the forest is physically real at all. I think it’s emotional geography. The realm reshapes itself based on fear, belief, trauma, and where people are in the “story.” The faraway trees are basically dream-logic portals connecting different emotional layers of the town.

RebalBuoy

I am absolutely going to need a theory discussion time

Alfie Fulton

Cody’s face, Sergio’s immediate “I hate this” encapsulates the ending

Elesia

Thanks for the book recommendation 💛 As for the chat, I don't mind where it takes place, but I need to share my theories now 💜 •First, I think the one responsible for all this might be a Lovecraftian Outer God (or at least the series interpretation of one), more likely Nyarlathotep, who can take on hundreds of different forms or avatars (which might be where the idea for the Man in Yellow came from) to walk among humanity with the goal of deceiving, manipulating, and driving as many people as possible to madness🖤 •Regarding the Boy in White, I'm not so sure, but he could be Nodens (another Lovecraftian deity). He is an enemy of Nyarlathotep and shows a certain benevolence toward humanity, not out of goodness, but because of his hatred for the Outer Gods🤍 •And finally, I think the ending will be Boyd and the rest of the group managing to stop the ritual and killing the Man in Yellow (well, just the avatar), which I believe would kill the creatures (but not Fatima because the ritual would return them to the age they are supposed to be, so the other creatures would die instantly) and get everyone home🩷 •After that, I picture an emotional scene—perhaps at the hospital where Tabitha was—where the whole group says goodbye to each other and agrees to keep in touch because after all of this they’ve become a family...And just as the episode seems to be ending, an image of Nyarlathotep appears (sparking theories about what he is/what will happen next...). To me, that would be a way of saying that even though the ritual has ended and our group is "happy," that evil is still out there💚

Tay

No because same!!

ClaryTehSage

I thought of the king in yellow just tonight when I was pondering the man in yellow.

ariel mermaid

Great reaction can’t wait for season 5 💕 You’ll are the only reactors to remember that lady with the burnt face had anxiety so that probably why she freaked out so bad even i forgot I’ve seen that episode several times lol

Chaunte Dotson

Please make Lost your next reaction. Trying to figure out the mystery of that show will be a lot of fun. It'll be a great replacement to this

Rowan Dawson

So, loose ends: Fatima's golem thing, the doll people, the creepy poles that killed the dolls, and however the bones get them home. I do think that the creatures are freaked that the bones are found and Sophia is getting desperate. I also highly doubt that Sophia's deal is what she says it is

Elisa

There are some villains that you want to just slap through the screen and Sophia is definitely one of those villains

draeonic 🪼

trying to tap into what the audience wants based on public discussion seems like the worst possible thing for a writer to do 😂 I hope they have a plan and they stick to it

draeonic 🪼

Prediction: Dick will have a change of heart and be the key that ends the Town and lets people go home. (Not Boyd though.)

Elesia

Yess! I’d like that option too, and the town could be a version of Carcosa. (･w⁠･⁠)⁠つ⁠⊂⁠(⁠･w⁠･⁠)

MissTaken Gamer

I hope next season we get to see Julie go back in time to try and save her dad because she was there when her dad died. Also the actress shared on her Instagram that they let her cut her hair so no more wig. Apparently they wouldn't let her in case they needed to do reshoots.

Samantha

Have you guys ever watched Gotham the tv show. It’s so good I think reactions would be great

Natalie Halveston

Hey guys. I started typing this last night but the comments got deleted. Gutted. Great reaction. I've been holding on to my personal theories for soooooo long. So bottom line CELTIC FAE LORE The first thing I noticed then looked into more was the Talisman. There are 8 symbols that represent, I think children. 8 children were meant to be sacrificed for the ritual to worl properly. Only 7 were. Two people - Jade and Tabitha. Sun and the moon semi circles - balancing of the dark and light. Sun being something that can banish Fae Folk back to the underground. Moon being the celestial being that thins the veils between the human and other world allowing Fae Folk to venture out on top. This is also reminiscent of the German Fairy tale The Seven Ravens. I saw this story first on Netflix a few years back with my daughter. The Dark Grimm. But it was swallows instead of ravens. The story goes A man has seven sons and finally has a baby girl. The baby is very weak, so the father sends his sons to fetch water for a quick baptism. The boys drop their pitchers into the well and dare not go back. The angry father wishes they would turn into ravens, and his wish comes true instantly. The girl grows up not knowing she had brothers until she hears the secret. She leaves home to search for them at the edge of the world. She visits the sun, the moon, and the morning star for help. She loses a key to the glass mountain and cuts off her own little finger to use as a key. A friendly dwarf lets her wait inside her brothers' castle. She tastes food from their plates and drops her parents' ring into the last cup. The ravens return, find the ring, and wish for their sister. The spell breaks when she steps out, turning the ravens back into men. Sounds very similar with the little girl being the one that was Jade and Tabithas daughter. And the bone/s being crucial to them being "saved" Talking about Fairytales. The first ever episode was a Grandmother (or wolf dressed up in Grannys clothing) eating Meghan and Mother. Reminds me so much of Little Red Riding Hood. I wonder how many other Fairytales can be found within the show. Teeth. The MIY collects teeth. In Fae Folklore, collection of teeth is shown through much of Celtic History. Teeth and bones are used as magical transactions of power. Faes are known for looking for humans to make bargains with. When the bargain is made, they take the human from the human world and take it to its lair, kingdom, place. There are actual historical stories of people going missing across Scotland and Ireland and people swearing it was the Fae. Time, weather and landscape can change completely different in the Fae realm. I was listening to an Audiobook called The Deverey Cycle and it's subsequent sequels. In one we learned about The Seelie and The Unseelie Courts. The Seelie Courts being one of Good and Light. Fae that help humans if being a little mischievous too. And the Unseelie being cruel and murderous. Here are some of the legends that are the Unseelie. Redcap: A malicious goblin from Scottish border folklore that dyes his cap red with the blood of his human victims. [1] Baobhan Sith: A Scottish vampire-like fairy woman who lures travelers into the woods to drain them of their blood. Each Uisce: A dangerous water-horse shapeshifter from Celtic traditions that tricks riders onto its back before plunging into the depths to drown and devour them. Slua Sidhe: The "fairy host" or army of the dead and malicious spirits that sweep through the night air to abduct or strike down mortals. Why the Fae Are Feared Cruel Bargains: Fae deals follow literal wording rather than intent, twisting promises to trap or ruin mortals. Child Stealing: Traditional stories warn of changelings, where the Fae steal human infants and leave sickly doubles behind. Vengeance: Minor slights—like cutting a fairy ring or disrespecting a sacred tree—can result in severe curses, madness, or death. There is soooooo much more but honestly I got so excited as I've literallt got a whole noted section dedicated to research that I wanted to share with you guys once you got to this episode. I don't know if it is Fae. But I definitely think the writers have taken inspiration from it. Also there in a selection of shorts stories under the name of The King In Yellow by the Author Robert Chambers. This book inspired August Derleth to write more about it. Calling TKIY a manifestion or avatar of a cosmic being called Hastur. He was a disciple of H. P. Lovecraft. So we never get to know more about TKIY or where he is from in the short stories. But TKIY was a play (in the story) and anyone that read the play turned mad. Crazy. They went insane and either killed themselves or others. Carcosa with it's two moons and weird time warping abilities was the place Hastur and it's monsters/being were from. Anyway. Sorry that was such a long comment.

Dana (Dah-Nah)

i wonder if this is the type of show to have them all go home but show us them having ptsd from Fromville or if it'll be a happily ever after

Erik

Agreed. I am praying they are not gonna turn From into Lost :P

Laura❤️

The fact that she was able to skate through the ENTIRE SEASON without a single person even having a slight suspicion of her is insane.

Zombies_Are_Real

Me back when this episode aired: My boy Kenny is back in! I have a season 5 theory of what I think the entire season will be. Ethan brought up the Lake of Tears since the pilot. Sara brought up that she thinks the fears of everyone who dies ends up in the forest. Where would they bring the bones now that they have them? Fromville has no more talismen. And they have to address the Cherkov's Giant Spider that's been hinted since season 1. I think they have to take the bones through all the horrors in the forest to get to the Lake of Tears. Then put the bones in the lake. It's definitely a dangerous quest, and quests have been a theme throughout the show. Leaving wouldn't be an easy task, so it makes sense to me. But who knows!

Laura❤️

Fucking Patty. I would honestly probably be her in this scenario but watching from the safety of my own home SHUT THE FUCK UP AND GET A GRIP🤣

Natalie Halveston

Wayward Pines is a great show btw guys. It got cancelled but its still.worth the watch

Bethany

i unfortunately had marielle’s death spoiled for me a few weeks ago by someone on twitter not using any spoiler tags so i’ve been waiting for it to happen every week… man i was NOT prepared to actually see it play out 😔

The Horror Bandwagon

Maybe, I disagree to some extent. As we said, it seems to not have worked out for other shows who aren't at least self aware. So maybe it's time to do something different. 😂 But yeah hope they do have some idea of what they wanna do.

Rob Bace

If they do catch her, she'll probably just kill them or worse. Look at Elgin, he caught on and nothing good came of it.

Kris

I'm so glad you all were frustrated like I was. I personally hated the Sophia storyline because all it taught me was how unobservant everyone in this town is. No one people watches or just picks up on people's energy??!! I just know I would have been like nah something is off with that girl and would have been peeping some things. Gotta say, Kristi's performance in this episode with that death was great - that was a great cry. May sound weird but Mari also gave a good performance dying and it was realistic. Her just saying I love you and wanting one last kiss goodbye was 🤌🏾.

Natalie Halveston

I've listened to The King In Yellow audiobooks and love consequential the stories of Hastur and Carcosa. I think the writers may have taking inspo from a lot of stuff. Including Fae Folklore and Fairytales

Michayla

I just realized it cut off the rest of the theory: Same with the music. Music keeps showing up during visions, memories, transitions, weird moments, etc. I think songs act like emotional anchors or subconscious triggers because the entire realm was built from emotional trauma. Even Julie’s storyline suddenly makes more sense if you look at it this way. She is a storywalker. Someone who can move between layers of the narrative itself: • timelines • emotional echoes • dream states • repeating cycles. Not time travel exactly… more like navigating the structure of the nightmare world. And the reason people die whenever they get close to escaping? Because the town is self-preserving. Leaving the town means escaping the narrative cycle, and the system resists that. So people get redirected, punished, manipulated, or killed whenever they get too close to truth or escape. Which is why Tabitha escaping was SUCH a huge clue. Because she DID leave. But she got pulled back because: • her role in the story wasn’t finished • the cycle wasn’t complete • or the town itself chose to reclaim her. That feels VERY *Silent Hill* to me. Even the crows fit symbolically: • watchers • messengers • omens • manifestations of the town’s awareness. They always appear when boundaries are crossed or truths are getting close. So yeah… my full theory is basically this: The town isn’t a simulation, alien experiment, or regular haunting. It’s a living psychological myth-world created from the suffering of children. A place where: • belief becomes reality • stories become physical law • trauma reshapes the environment • and people get trapped inside repeating emotional narratives. And honestly… the more the show reveals, the more this interpretation actually explains almost every weird thing happening there. Other notes: - it makes sense now why the creatures only come out at night… children are frightened by the dark and the monsters in it. - and also, it would explain why the intro song has children’s paintings and also the perspective of a child singing a song about what his mother used to say (que sera sera)

Megan H.

I've used yall as my 3 rewatch for the show & I caught a lot i missed on the first 2 watches. Mostly stuff from S1 & S2 that meant nothing at the time, but stand out as interest now. ... 1. Like looking back at the OG scenes when Julie was storywalking, but we didn't know about it yet. I find it interesting that Boyd's wedding rings appears when Julie storywalked. 2. Clara, Sophia (in the 70s photo) & Kenny's mom (for her funeral) all wear the same dress. 3. Ethan mentions to his mom in S1 that "Victor's pictures have giant spiders, boogeymen and scarecrows so this is a definitely a quest" and the later mentions putting Victor's pictures in order to figure out the story. 3. I think the Man In Yellow & Boy In White are God's that created this world, but unlike Abraham religious lore, they are more like Greek Gods that aren't always separated into Good vs Bad. 4. The crows only appear when there is danger ahead, so maybe they are helping by giving warnings? We saw rats eating a crow in the tunnels during S2. Maybe that means something? 5. Everyone who is still alive & had a partner is now a widow .Kenny's dad, Jim, Mari, Fatima & Abby. I'm worried for S5 because Henry doesn't have final girl energy and I can't see the town allowing Boyd make it out alive with Ellis.

Megan H.

The writers originally wrote the episode with Patty successfully ending her life, but changed it because it was too heavy. (I guess they mean to show the death screen bc they showed the aftermath of a guy hanging before)... it made me feel bad for wanting Boyd to push her out the door.

Desiree Mclaughlin

I've been waiting for this reaction. Thoughts and theories time! MIY/Sophia/???: I think we will get a MIY flashback/personal history episode at some point in Season 5, and I think we'll learn that Sophia isn't the only person the MIY has masqueraded as. I think Tillie was also the Man in Yellow. Hear me out. From the very first moment she arrived I got a weird feeling about her character. She didn't seem to add much of anything to the proceedings except covertly causing chaos. She goes to the clinic to give her morphine to Kristi and it just so happens that Marielle is dealing with a relapse into addiction. This ends up causing conflict between Kristi and Marielle after Kristi finds out Marielle took some of the morphine for herself. So whether or not Kristi finds out like she did or she doesn't and Marielle keeps using, chaos. There's also a scene she has with Jim early in Season 2 where he's asking her about her past and she evades the question by saying, "My, you ask a lot of questions." It's not exactly the same but it reminded me of when Jim is killed and the MIY taunts him by saying, You always tried so hard. You carried so much." Then there is everything that happens with Elgin and Fatima. She reveals that Fatima is pregnant, saying that she can always tell. She says it in front of Elgin and this seems to trigger his memories of the dream/vision he had on the bus. While Julie, Randall, and Marielle are in their sleep paralysis episodes, Tillie leads a prayer circle and recites Psalm 23. We've also seen Sophia/MIY asking people to pray with them and they have obvious knowledge of different verses. She is in the waking visions that Elgin has a couple of different times of the kimono woman, and way too involved with Fatima's monster pregnancy for my liking. She comes across her eating rotting food, tells her that it's totally fine and that she used to lick the inside of eggshells. She is the one who initiates the tarot reading with Fatima that is interrupted by a crow flying through the window. Even her "death" happens in a way that facilitates the third act of Fatima's arc in Season Three. It is because she stabs Tillie (with a pair of shears with a YELLOW handle...just saying 😂) that she runs away. Tillie actually tells her to run, which seems strange considering she'd just been stabbed. But because Fatima runs away and isolates herself, Elgin is able to get to her and kidnap her. I don't think the MIY worries about dying. After all, when he became Sophia, he engineers a car accident that could've taken off his head. So who knows what happened after Tillie "died"? I don't have an answer for that, but this is a supernatural horror show. I'm sure they can come up with something 😅

Sabrina Bookert

Finally! Okay so here is my theory THE BIW SENT VICTOR AND TABITHA DOWN TO THE PART PF THE TUNNELS THAT HAVE THE RITUAL THEY NEED TO GO HOME ON THE DAMN WALLS!!!! And to the entrance to the lake of tears!! They just didn’t have the other answers yet to make it make sense which is why the BIW keeps saying I have already helped you! And why he pushed Tabitha out into the world because the only way for her to remember was to see the drawings Miranda made OMG!!! Okay so follow me guys… The BIW survived the ritual by hiding. By the time the MIY found him the ritual worked but it kept them alive and trapped there forever so the boy made a deal to stay alive (which is why he had the tools for Victor) to get the last parents back to save him and the children. MIY agreed but clearly there were rules…also fuck Clara ass and damnit Elgin you idiot!

Desiree Mclaughlin

Fatima: Her story is so tragic. As I rewatched this with you guys, there are so many lines of dialogue that seem to foreshadow the turn her story will take. I started taking notes every time I noticed something that struck me as prescient. 1. The very first time Ellis and Boyd talk on screen, Boyd refers to Fatima and says, "She doesn't change, does she?" 2. When Fatima takes Julie to the Brundles, she tells her the story of her father's death, saying, "The point is, there are always going to be monsters in the world. It doesn't matter where you are. I promised myself I would never let them scare the life out of me." 3. At the end of Season One as they're trying to get the radio tower set up, Ellis and Fatima are talking about what they are going to do after they get out of Fromville. Fatima has conflicting emotions, saying she's almost as scared that the plan *will* work as she is that it won't. Then she says, " How do we go back now? After everything we've seen, some of the things we've done...how do we just...and even if we can go back how do...I'm not sure we can ever really go home. We're not the same people anymore." 👀 4. In Season Two Ellis says (I think to Boyd) that the people who make it in Fromville are the ones who are able to hold onto a piece of themselves. I wonder if Fatima will somehow be able to do the same. 5. On their wedding day, Fatima's vows include some words of wisdom her father imparted on her: "Life is a journey through the unknown, and though your eyes and mind may sometimes deceive you, your heart will never lie." 👀😭 I'm hoping that somehow Fatima will be able to hold on to her humanity. Maybe the golem has something to do with it, I have no idea. I also think Ellis might end up dying because he does something stupid (understandable, but ultimately stupid) to try to save Fatima.

Desiree Mclaughlin

Okay, last comment. Random half-baked theory: What if it's not actually supposed to be called the Lake of Tears (rhymes with fears), but instead the Lake of Tears (rhymes with bears) as in tears in the fabric of reality/space/time? After all, we only know about it because of a creepy children's book. It's totally possible they were misreading the word. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Megan H.

I think you are right @1:22 about it ends with From being wiped from reality because of S1 E1 Tabitha tells Ethan that "Norman can't be dead because monsters aren't real" when he is upset Julie killed his toy. Creators said that how it ends is in S1

Megan H.

Meaning Jim or anyone else killed by a monster is still alive.

Megan H.

AGREE! Those cave drawings what looked like a map and showed people leaving a boat

Sabrina Bookert

EXACTLY!!! they have to go back in the tunnels

Megan H.

AND now that I think about it, it could be what Ethan talks about in S1. He says "This is like the lonely Dragons cavern where you find the map of rainbow sky and that's how we get home"..... Or maybe that's too obvious?

pamysue

I love Donna. But why why why would you tell a clearly disturbed man where the gun is for the bullets in his hand and then send him to WHERE THE GUN IS???⁉️⁉️ Did that lightening (or whatever) come from the whole the tree was in or from the dead bones hole? I have looked at it over and over and still not sure⁉️⁉️ Horror show got Emmys this year! Widow's Bay took home 5 and set a record!🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆✌️💖

pamysue

They have to do a better ending than Lost. If they fuck up another Harold Perrineau show, I'm going to have to stop watching everything he does! I've been obsessed with him since Oz.

pamysue

👹🤣

pamysue

I think that is amazing. I'm old from when you talked about a show with a couple people in real life and that was it. Seeing what people on the internet come up with is awesome! I just watch and wonder to myself kind of as they hand it to me.

Sabrina Bookert

Omg your right! I don’t think that’s too obvious. They have said over and over the answers to the end are at the beginning… time for another season 1 rewatch lol

draeonic 🪼

I'd say we fully disagree but having slept on it, I'm going to choose to enjoy my weekend instead of ruminating on ways to convince you that I am Obviously Correct. :') Have a good one, keep doing what you enjoy, hope you do Attack on Titan someday 💙

Jeune!!

This is so true, its like one second I'm tearing up and she shows up right after an incident and i just roll my eyes and wipe my tears 😭

Andrew

I really hope they do Lost one day. It would be so fun!

Andrew

in the comedy categories lol

Fern

Okay now you guys should do the series Dark! It is very much a mystery box show and very very cool!

Tabitha M. Guin

I watched the last season with yall, and my son is gonna be pissed because I was supposed to be watching with him… oops 😬 As a Tabitha it’s “spooky” hearing people saying my name hahahaha can’t wait for the final season

Coco W

I have enjoyed watching this show with you guys so much!the last two seasons I was able to experience with you guys for my first time. So that was fun! the season ended on a tragic but exciting note. Can’t wait til next season. Question have u guys seen game of thrones. If not id def recommend for the channel. Not strictly horror. But does have supernatural elements. And great drama plus action.

Coco W

Oh also by the way yes the books are great. But there is also in fact a tv adaptation of wayward pines. I think it’s available on Hulu. I would love for you guys to react to that. Especially since Cody enjoyed the books. Dark matter is another good show that was adapted from a Blake crouch book. Oh and 11/22/63 is an awesome Stephen king adaptation that’s only one season!

Jbug

This episode was heartbreaking 😭 Kristi's cry was something so realistic & painful. What an incredible actress. Fatima turning into the creature was fantastic. That last scene was unexpected with the boy in white, I always wondered if they were aware of each other. I need season 5 ASAP! thank you both for taking on this very complex show.

Coralie

I personally feel like Fatima became the golem she was building. She protected Kenny from Smiley (aka "Dick") and transformed into the monster so that everyone could safely get away from the tunnels.

Dr. J

Now that you all have completed all four seasons, I encourage you to look up what the creators of the show have said, as far as what is not the case for what From is; ppl are not dead, in a dream etc. Also, loved the Wayward Pines reference, it was short lived but I enjoyed that series and I def thought of it when I started watching this show!

Usani

Sobbing my ass off, thinking about if this was me or my girlfriend then BOOM Sophia and her four eyed fire crotch ass!

PiscesMoon

Whew this season finale tore my nerves up! Marielle's death really hit me harder than any other death. They way she immediately asked for Christy bcuz she knew she was dying. Now on to Sophia. Sergio screaming why no one sees her doing sneaky shit is hilarious 🤣🤣. I can't stand her but the character is a great bad guy. This show is giving an evil entity and a good entity battling for humans souls. Sophia talking about the Bible, picking the priest as a way into the town and praying makes me feel like she's mocking God in a way. The force of good or good entities cant help but maybe they drop advise to people, show certain people things to help. Who knows I could be waaayyyy off lol. Great reaction guys, can't wait for season 5. Oh and I did read that the writers know how this is gonna end and have known since day 1. I don't think they're gonna give us some crap Ending.

notra

i love jade & tabitha so much the chemistry the tension is chef's kiss 🤌🏻

Anxious Em

From the very first episode, I immediately thought the monsters were fae--happy to see someone else with that idea!

Natalie Halveston

Yessss you're the only other person I've seen that holds that belief. If we see them react to Iron in Season 5 then that'll be our answer 🤣

john lawson

She did not say this is when it starts period she never said that . She said i think this is when it happened talking about her dad's death.

Em_bits_n_bobs

I honestly think and HOPE Fatima can switch the monster on and off..