Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you so much for the support! You guys and grrls are awesome!

The trying-to-come-up-with-a-page-title me of right now as I'm posting this comic really wishes that writing-the-comic-page-in-the-past me would do better at sticking to a single theme per page. This page goes from explaining the prank from the previous page to computer voice gender preferences to ship AI's of pop-culture to betting to trope-aware arguing. 

You know, the Enterprise-D's computer was just about the perfect kind of advanced computer. It was something resembling an AI, in that it could parse natural speech and extrapolate contextually, (especially when they were talking to it in the holodeck) but it wasn't the sort of computer that was anthropomorphized in any way, and didn't ever seem to have any ambitions of its own. Unless there's an episode I'm not remembering where it went crazy. The closest I can recall was when it created Moriarty, and that was just based on a badly worded request from... Jeordi? It's been a while since I saw it.

Actually, by far the worst kind of computer techno-fear episodes they ever did were all the Holodeck's fault. Every season had an episode where the safety protocols got disengaged and people got trapped. Hey geniuses, maybe make it so the regular holodecks can't have the safeties disengaged under any circumstances. Like the whole thing shuts down if anything goes awry. Have the first thing every single line of code does is check to make sure the squishy meatbags inside can't have their noggins cracked open because the rocks are too hard or whatever. Like how post-Otis elevators can't fall if the cable breaks, because the weight of the carriage pulling on the cable is what holds the emergency brakes open. If the cable snaps, the spring-loaded brake returns to its original shape, jutting out past the carriage to catch on the rails. 

So then I guess maybe you'd want a smaller holodeck that can only be used by the redshirts... er... I guess they were gold in TNG. They shouldn't have muddied those waters by making an unnecessary change. But I suppose that could have happened because the "main" actors didn't want to do a lot of close up shots with their yellow shirt reflecting on their chins, making them look jaundice? Pure speculation on my part. It was probably totally arbitrary. Anyway, at least in that security focused holodeck, you could be reasonably sure that random crew members >cough<Barclay>cough< weren't side loading custom mods or rootkits or whatever.  

Files

Comments

Thomas Dorner

Well, they needed to be able to disable security protocols, otherwise the Borg would have rewritten history (First Contact).

Yin

The exposition continues... also, at least one typo in panel 5 - in the last sentence, "in" should be "is". Also the term "futures bets" seems weird to me but that might just be a language failing on my end...

Justaguy

Though that could have been a captains prerogative. (Or high-enough-ranking officer).

Magraal (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-07 02:00 For some reason Max pulling off the skintight suit here reminded me of the VGCats strip about Spiderman 3...
2026-08-27 11:02 For some reason Max pulling off the skintight suit here reminded me of the Ctrl+Alt+Del strip about Spiderman 3...

For some reason Max pulling off the skintight suit here reminded me of the Ctrl+Alt+Del strip about Spiderman 3...

Ron Jarrell

It was data. He asked for a villain capable of beating him, not Sherlock, so got super moriarty. What I read was one of the show runners was tired of the red shirt hemes and insisted that make command the red color.

Czarzhan

There was an episode of ST-TNG in season 7 where the computer went crazy and had a kid. There was holodeck stuff but it was all for the crew to interact with the non-quite-conscious computer.

Martin Drkoš

The Enterprise-D did have a baby once.

Michael Obert

There's an old rule in screenwriting: tell don't show. I think you got that backwards. Oh, whoops - whoopsie!

Miyaa

I do like we eventually get the grumpy Doctor in Voyager and now, like the Borg, we get a whole “race” of AI-ish people in the maligned Star Trek Academy series?

Martin Drkoš

My headcanon is that the holodeck is acquired alien or future tech that Starfleet engineers don't fully understand. It's usefulness was why it was implemented despite some dangers. Also I think holodecks predicted generative AI in a way. How the NPCs can appear intelligent despite not being considered sentient and how Geordi got an unwanted result from a badly worded prompt.

Skitzman69

My favourite ship AI was The Lexx...

Town Crier

D'aw! The nerds are squabbling. So adorable! This is where I would Devil Advocate for whichever side is losing, just to keep the fun going for the rest of us. I learned this skill back in college. Got some of our best insider quotes from those multiple hour "discussions". "You can't DO that!!!", and "I have free will, because I have free will!", and "Pay me!". Such fun!

Brett Peirce

Last sentence *in second-to-last panel*

TrixieTurner

Stay hot max in that skimpy skin tight suit, it’s the only thing keeping you interesting in this arc.

Madcat6204

Actually no, Dave is correct. Geordi requested it because Doctor Pulaski was being her usual racist self towards Data, insisting he couldn't solve a "real" Sherlock Holmes style mystery that wasn't in the books, and when he did she moved the goalposts insisting it wasn't legit. So Geordi got frustrated with her and told the computer to make an opponent capable of defeating Data.

Ron Jarrell

You know, I can picture the scene with data at the arch saying capable if defeating me. I can hear it. And I went and just looked it up and you’re right, it was Geordi, and I can’t picture that at all. I think I fell through from an alternate universe identical except it was data in that scene.

Madcat6204

There weren't actually that many major holodeck failure episodes compared to the number of times the holodeck was used. I remembered 5, and a bit of googling backs that up, vs 47 episodes where it was used at all. Admittedly, that is a 9.4% major failure rate, which is pretty unacceptable, but I tend to blame that on the writers wanting to do certain stories regardless of how much sense they make. Anyway, the episodes were The Big Goodbye in season 1, where I believe an alien scan somehow caused a power surge trapping Picard and Crusher and Data and some other guy in Picard's Dixon Hill detective program; Elementary My Dear Data in season 2, which is the first Moriarty episode; A Fistful of Datas in season 6, where somehow an experiment with Data's brain somehow causes his memories to "infect" the ship's computer, incidentally trapping Worf, Troi, and Alexander in a wild west holodeck program; Ship in a bottle also in season 6, which is the second Moriarty episode; and then Emergence near the end of season 7, where exposure to a "magnascopic storm" caused the ship to start developing a new intelligence which played out a strange simulation on the holodeck that didn't trap people inside, but did disable the safety protocols again. Now, admittedly, Deep Space Nine had at least one holosuite failure, and Voyager had several as well, I believe, but those are outside the scope of this question.

Scooteroo

my largest issue with the holodeck is not having the power conduits easily accessible and with a quick shut off . Like oh no we are having an issue with it. "Shut it down" We cant captain. What about just pulling a panel off the wall and swing the big red switch that disconnects it? Then boom, all power shuts down. Also why couldn't they just be able to have a device they can place on the doors that hydraulically forces them open? There are so many lacking safety features in the future it's mind boggling

Madcat6204

Often when stuff malfunctioned it would somehow "isolate the power grid" or something along those lines, preventing anyone from powering it down. Also, in the first holodeck malfunction episode Wesley made the absurd claim that shutting it down improperly could "cause the program to abort and everyone inside the holodeck would vanish" somehow including the real people for some reason. Which makes absolutely zero sense based on the technology involved, and was almost certainly a writer just tossing that in to raise tension and/or respond to the why don't they just turn it off question.

Gullindjemprins

Max is channeling a Maybelline commercial there at the end. *hair swoooooosh*

Anton Schleef

The script for First Contact was written over half a decade after the first instance of them disabling the security protocols in an episode.

Anton Schleef

Yeah, they should really leave most of the trope explanations to Sydney, or at least let her ask a question that triggers someone else to do the explanation. It's her main gimmick outside of her Orbs, and a sizable portion of her presence when they aren't needed.

Andrew Diseker

I’ve fallen through alternates every time I can’t find my phone.

Eric Loken

Basil Exposition here! "I guess they were gold in TNG. They shouldn't have muddied those waters by making an unnecessary change. But I suppose that could have happened because the "main" actors didn't want to do a lot of close up shots with their yellow shirt reflecting on their chins, making them look jaundice?" Close, Patrick Stewart looked better in the red, and so the change was made. I doubt Stewart requested it as he was the consummate professional at the time and wouldn't concern himself with the duties of others; he had his job, they had theirs. He had a stick up his ass at the start, but Sirtis said by the end he was the craziest one of them all. " Hey geniuses, maybe make it so the regular holodecks can't have the safeties disengaged under any circumstances" I liked the Strange New Worlds episode with the early prototype Holodeck, at the end Pike suggested the entire idea and everything related to it should be buried in a deep hole. Man talked sense.

Shremedy

No, it's because Sir Patrick looks awful in full-body yellow. If they'd started with DS9-style black with division color only on the yoke, it might have been a different story.

Shremedy

Maxima's disguise is increasingly reminding me of a more durable (much more durable!) version of Empowered's supersuit, especially where she's peeling it off of her shoulders.

eddi_TBH

"Kettle much?" For those my age, it's a streamlined version of "the pot calling the kettle black".

eddi_TBH

Depending on how effed up the system was it could dismantle the real people and return them to the raw material storage. Like a transporter malfunction.