Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Welp, I didn't get the episode done in time. I guess I don't get paid this month, although at least this time it's not because I forgot to charge. (Although I probably will also forget to charge.)

Anyway, please vote in the Song vs. Song poll, we're doing "Dreams" by Fleetwood Mac vs. "You're So Vain" by Carly Simon. https://www.patreon.com/posts/new-poll-youre-159606896

Files

TRAINWRECKORDS: Lou Reed and Metallica's "Lulu"

Lou Reed loved to annoy critics, and Metallica has been making their fans angry for decades, but somehow they made an album so bad that they made the world angry. Check out "Is There Still a Very Special Place in Hell for Matt Stone and Trey Parker?" and get Nebula for 50% off! https://nebula.tv/videos/lindsayellis-south-park?ref=todd-in-the-shadows Additional writing by: Kevin Anderson https://bsky.app/profile/kbandersonyo.bsky.social Support Todd on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/toddintheshadows

Comments

Tank1319

It’s finally here

Angela

Ha. I was right lol

Epoic1200

The main question that arises for this album will always be who is this for. And the answer to that is me. It is made for me and nobody else.

Machine Gun Philly

GIMME TABLE, GIMME TABLE GIMME TABLE, I DESIRE (TABLE)

Alina

There's some strong static at the very beginning of the video. It doesn't seem to be in the rest of the video (I spot-checked)

tohderix

i knew i spent money on patreon for a REASON 🦅🦅🦅🦅🎉🎉🎉🎉🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳💥💥💥💥💯💯💯💯💯

Justin V

One of the first comments about Lulu I read mentioned that Metallica finally found a way to keep people from stealing their albums.

Russet Burbank

Remember to charge! To remind yourself, leave a note on your TABLE

setalp

14:38. Pandora's Box was directed by GW Pabst, not FW Pabst. The FW belongs to FW Murnau, who directed Nosferatu.

Prideful Xela

The “The End” panel says “Zoot Suit Riot” is owned by Mojo Records (presumably an oversight)

John Seiler

Hell yeah, I finally get to hear where the Botchamania "I Am The Table" bit came from

Quinn

Well the albumn not boring at least tbh

Kevin W.

The end title card is from Cherry Poppin Daddies

Zanish

Starting at about 32:10 the background is too loud and your voice is set to background volume until about 32:36. Great vid!

Flarbu

I personally love this album. I think for me important facts going into it are Lou Reed's proximity to transness. Its a messy history but he was sent to electric shock therapy by his parents for queerness and then as an artist came up in Andy Warhol's factory surrounded by trans people and even has trans partners. Im a transwoman and maybe reading my own experiences a bit too deeply into this record but so much of it feels the forces of self hating internalized transphobia destroying someone. Not to say Lou himself was a secret trans person or anything but this record really speaks a lot to my experiences trying to understand my own identity in this world.

Teddy Haines

It's probably because I've been watching Fate/Strange Fake, but as soon as "Jack" was mentioned, I immediately figured out it must be the Ripper.

R.E. Jasso

You credited Zoot Suit Riot at the end.

SynGirl

Leave it to trans and trans-adjacent people to make the most beautifully messy and unpalatable art imaginable (also very obviously not Todd's wheelhouse, but there is a weird dimension to Lou "my most famous song is about cool trans people" Reed collaborating with noted republican dipshit James Hetfield)

Calvin Philips

Welt, Todd. A German world is called a Welt. Thorough and hilarious look into a moment in music history I'd not heard of; really liked this one!

sconce

At about 32:10 there’s a huge audio issue where the narration is almost completely drowned out by the video - just in case you didn’t catch it!

Kristopher Bluth

Maybe this is the English major in me who owns shelves of poetry books, but dammit, count me as one of Lulu’s defenders. Yes, it’s very weird and no, it’s not remotely for everyone, but it’s sort of like Megalopolis: if I put away my preconceptions and just accept what it’s doing on its own terms, Lulu works for me. I even like all nineteen minutes of “Junior Dad”. I may not play it very often, but I’m glad it exists, and I’ll take this over St. Anger any day. If eighty-year-old me gets to say I told you so when everyone else decides it was pretty good after all, I can live with that. I’ll say what said in the St. Anger comments: I really think this would have gone over better (or at least been not so hated) if random musicians had played on this instead of Metallica. Having them on board skewed Lulu’s expectations in a way that made this even harder for most people to accept. It’s as if they went in to see a John Wick movie and got Last Tango in Paris instead.

Flarbu

I was a bit disappointed that Todd didnt go into Lou's queerness at all, very integral piece of understanding his art but despite all the research breaks that never comes up. I know Todd is an everyman critic so it didnt surprise me it didnt come up but it feels so needed for any analysis of Lou Reed as an artist. Definitely made me feel like the opening line of the video is entirely correct, Todd has no business talking about Lou Reed

Paul Anderson

It's a shame Pat Boone's "In a Metal Mood: No More Mr Nice Guy" doesn't qualify as a Trainwreckord. He was bounced from an evangelical TV show until he disowned the album, but it didn't wreck his career, and was a modest commercial success. But unlike Lou Reed with Metallica, heavy metal big-band Pat Boone is AWESOME despite himself.

RedBedroomRecords

Didn't see this one coming since Metallica already had an episode, but I guess it was one for Reed himself so it kinda counts.

RedBedroomRecords

at least Hetfield never voted for em, in one interview with Playboy James mentioned he didn't vote because you had to go to the city to do it and he preferred to live out in the countryside so he just never bothered voting.

RedBedroomRecords

I'm not surprised, a lot of people didn't know about, I knew about Reed saying some bigoted crap but not about that stuff.

boston hall

Further, the exit card reads "Zoot Suit Riot" is owned by Mojo Records. Might need to update that one! 😁

RedBedroomRecords

Megalopolis it's hard for me not to be disgusted by because of the inherent problem of Coppolla blatantly ignoring what a despicable piece of shit Jon Voight is. I think St Anger would've still been hated if another band did it, but the Metallica name lent it more success on the charts then it frankly deserved.

JasSpy

I've been keeping up an ultimate "Worst Lines of Trainwreckords" list that includes such examples as "peñius colada", "modren man", and most recently, Macklemore & Ryan Lewis (but mostly Macklemore) presenting a baffling term for pooping with “Bathroom door open when she boo boo-ing”. If you are reading this, have the time, have watched this new episode, and think you know what the worst line of lyrics from the covered album is, that is in this episode, I would appreciate leaving a reply with your opinion. I want to get an accurate consensus. I’ve noticed people will give this comment a like but not reply to it. While I appreciate my comments getting a like, a comment is way more helpful, so try to do both. (A little late posting this because I actually went to the theater for once to see Backrooms)

TurquoiseYoshi

noise issue where the background video starts playing too early around 32:20, ending card still says zoot suit ruit

TurquoiseYoshi

loved the video just wanted to note it

RedBedroomRecords

Metallica did do one song about sex very early in their career-Mechanix, which was later turned into "the Four Horseman" and the original version ended up on Megadeth's debut album "Killing is my Business". Also the original lyrics for "Jump in the Fire" were more sexual in nature, but that was changed after Dave got fired.

Andrew Davey

But, then again, Todd did kinda-sorta signal this was coming all the way back in the "St. Anger" Trainwreckords episode. (This is why so many of us were surprised when John Fogerty became the first Double Trainwreckords artist last year!)

Andrew Davey

Thanks for pointing out all of this. Now, more than ever, we need to make sure that queer stories aren't erased from our history records.

Andrew Davey

Ummmmm.... Happy Pride Month, y'all? This is an interesting way to kick off June, but I'm not mad. We knew this would eventually happen, so we might as well revisit this now. (Honestly, I don't hate this. This may not be the most incisive Lou Reed or Metallica album, but it's one I'm glad exists. During a time when bands like Five Finger Death Punch and Shinedown were among the biggest names in rock, at least these folx were still giving us something different.)

Eric Darling

I had no idea this is where "I Am the Table" came from in Botchamania

Gene Younkin

I love the -research break- joke. Gag? Bit? Whatever it is, it becomes funny.

Oisín Harrell

I remember around the time this album dropped, one of the writers at MetalSucks commented that Lou Reed going metal wasn’t doomed to fail – that if he’d partnered up with a band like Om or Sunn O))) or Earth, he might have been able to cook something decent. But we got what we got. I’d say that Soused by Scott Walker and Sunn O))) is the good alternate version of Lulu, and also happened to be the final studio by an alternative legend that Bowie idolized (not counting OSTs). It would never win over a general audience, but as an experimental musical summit: Walker and Sunn pair well together, the lyrics don’t require multiple research breaks and Walker ended his career in much better form than Lou did. Look it up if you want to try something different, or need music to scare off bar patrons and house guests (may not work if they're dressed in black robes and like the sound of bullwhips).

Ryw316

I AM THE TABLE

Anthony Skatz

You’ve made enough pro wrestling references in other videos that I’m sure you’re already aware of this, but for those here who aren’t: There’s a popular pro wrestling series on YouTube called “Botchamania”, which compiles moments in wrestling where things get messed up, or “botched”. One of the more common “botches” is when someone is supposed to get slammed through a table, but the table doesn’t break. And it’s a running joke that, when this happens, James Hetfield screaming “I am the table!” From “The View” plays. It’s become so ubiquitous that fans will sometimes bring signs stating it to shows, and even announcers at smaller shows will reference it as well if such a botch occurs.

Dimetre Alexiou

At the end it says, "Zoot Suit Riot is owned by Mojo Records."

Juhani Aho

"Like a colored man's dick, blood spurting from me" outsells "I AM THE TABLE" in sheer WTF-ness

Juhani Aho

Megalopolis won me over when Shia LaBeouf got two arrows shot up his ass.

S. R.

This is not an error but I'd love if you captioned the lyrics before you comment "that's a book," somewhere around 26:30, because I can't hear it well and missed the joke lol

Austin F

i'm not a cool alternative guy - my favorite musician is taylor swift - so maybe that's the issue, but the lyrics of this album sound like they were written by that guy in your Gen Ed college courses that tries to argue with the professor every single class and puts 4chan memes in his powerpoints 😭

Laura Quin

Your catrd for who owns the music is wrong: it’s about Zoot Suit Riot. You should change that before it goes out to the wider public.

Xela

very fun to watch all my fellow wrestling fans go "oohhh THAT'S where that botchamania thing came from"

Kristopher Bluth

I was actually mildly disappointed by Soused. The teaming of Walker and Sunn O))) promised so much and it wound up sounding like a typical Walker album with just some droning over it. Still good, but I was hoping for something a little more groundbreaking.

Christopher Teuma

Lulu is a masterpiece. Proof Metallica should've gotten someone else write their songs like Aerosmith did. And it should've been Lou Reed all long.

Christopher Teuma

Can't seem to view the video because Youtube thinks I'm a bot.

Erik Danielson

I am the egg man, they are the egg men, I AM THE TABLE

Erik Danielson

We are one step closer to a Trainwreckords on Metal Machine Music and I’m here for it

Harry Harman

Pat Finnerty sighting at 21:52

Jackson S.

I will still defend Lulu as an experiment in the avant garde for both - it's not the most enjoyable listen but it is interesting

Oisín Harrell

I’ll agree that it wasn’t the destroyer of worlds it could have been and that Sunn O))) were more restrained than they’ve been on other collaborative albums. But I still think it was a cool meeting of avant-garde minds and am glad it happened at all.

The Hand Of The People

I don't think it's brought up enough that Metallica's gradual descent in quality may have a lot to do with James sounding more and more like a parody of himself. I'm not saying he became a bad vocalist, but whatever changes he made to his singing after the Black Album really led him on a slippery slope that continued over the next two decades. It resulted in laughable moments like the unhinged "FRAN-TIC-TIC-TOCK", but what really did him in for me was hearing him perform Master Of Puppets at their Hall of Fame induction, and him slipping into a contemporary death metal voice. There became no way to take his singing seriously after a certain point. It's fine when he's doing lyrics he and Lars wrote, but as evidenced here, beyond lethal when forced to sing something more abstract and literary.

Marie Dacy

From 32:10-32:17 the background audio is louder than you. 32:50 I think was supposed to say “ten more minutes of droning” but might have been cut off. The end screen is “Zoot Suit Riot”

avery parkway

I thought it'd never happen.. too weird, too messy, too avant garde... but Todd finds a way

Marcus Lauer

All right, now that we're talking about Lulu I have two things to say: 1. I want to hear Metallica cover Waves of Fear. 2. Apparently Lou Reed had some actual chart success in England. I remember looking that up a while back. Good for England I guess?

Henry Kiley

Metallica is my favorite band. I'll defend Saint Anger and Load/Reload all day. Even I forgot how fucking awful this album was.

Russet Burbank

33:13 edit cuts into the beginning of you saying "Lou Reed should have..." 33:20 "It was supposed to make Metallica..." has a similar late cut

Zach Hubert

I remember a reviewer that said "The only person who gets a pass on this is Robert Trujillo because it's clear he has as much of a say of what goes on in Metallica as I do."

Jimmy M

I have no doubt there's a great story to be told about Lulu, but the music is just so bad. As someone who likes both metal, punk, alt rock, and Broadway, this really doesn't work for any of them.

Herbieguy

How did I never get a notification for this? Damn. Should be an exciting watch.

-

take a walk on the wild ride the lightning

Matthew T.

oh my god THAT’S what the “James blew up for you!” line from the St Anger Trainwreckord is from??

Taylor Abrahamse

All these lyrics are giving Dewey Cox in his Dylan phase. Update: yayy Todd agrees.

Amotrician

Mr Intheshadows, I don't know how tongue-in-cheek was your recurrent despairing at being in over your head but let me say you are not, you are a good music critic/youtuber/podcaster and I found your take on Lou Reed being accessible very insightful. You explained very thoroughly why Lulu did not work. Maybe it was not a pleasant experience for you but as a longtime follower, it was as good of any of your other videos.

Kristopher Bluth

That's fair. Even second-level Scott Walker beats 90% of everything else out there.

Gone

I hadn’t actually heard anything from this album until this video. I think I’ve been consuming niche music YouTube content for too long cause one of my first thoughts upon hearing it was “oh it’s like a heavier Current 93.”

Oisín Harrell

I see it. But also, Current 93 has done heavier stuff that’s way better than anything on Lulu. Check out Aleph at Hallucinatory Mountain if you haven’t heard it. Probably the closest they’ve come to making a stoner rock / doom metal album.

Gone

I haven’t, but I will. I thought about “Lucifer over London” more than once during this video.