Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

An old critic friend of mine from back in the day has been hyping up Michael as not another bland biopic but something closer to The Social Network or There Will Be Blood, a dark thorny movie about a child molester becoming all-powerful. And not even through some “death of the author” interpretation, but intentionally so by the filmmakers, sneaking it under the radar of the Jackson estate. That reading... uh, let's say it feels like a stretch to me (I love this critic’s work but he’s the type to see Jesus in a piece of toast). To be fair to him though, the Michael Jackson we see in the movie is not… not a child molester. As seen in Michael, Michael Jackson is a man obsessed with toys, Peter Pan and childhood; an eccentric who fills his L.A. mansion with exotic animals he probably shouldn’t have and has friendlier conversations with them than any human being in his life; a person with deep rapport with children, who never once demonstrates romantic attraction to anyone. And this is the sanitized version okayed by the estate. Maybe there’s just no way to depict Michael Jackson, even blandly, where his weirdness does not shine through.

The movie leans heavily on Michael’s music to make us ignore the man’s controversies in life, and the greatness of his catalog might make the public forgiving or forgetful, but it sure doesn’t reinforce his innocence. Michael’s romantic songs are chaste to the point of childishness. His more adult songs show him to be terrified of women with sexual agency. (“Dirty Diana” was one of the MJ songs that recharted after the biopic, and boy, that’s a curious one to be driving up the charts.) He did try to put up a performative display of heterosexuality after the allegations, but I don’t think even diehards really bought it; you gotta be a real stan to hear his albums, or see him and his wife draped naked over each other, and be convinced that this guy was attracted to adult women, or adult men for that matter. At best he was harmlessly asexual, at worst, well, you know.

I say this because I saw an MJ stan on Twitter (which feeds me basically nothing but MJ stan wars and Drake stan wars right now, great site, fantastic) try to argue that anyone who doubted  that Michael had a healthy normal sexuality should listen to Dangerous; an anti-MJ commenter shot back that yeah, a guy who writes “In the Closet” is totally normal. It is true that Dangerous is the most sexually charged, most Prince-ian of his records (he even mentions a girl with a “paisley top” on “She Drives Me Wild”), but I don’t find any of it particularly convincing. There is an exception, though.

“Give in to Me” shows up pretty deep into an album that everyone agrees is too long, and I’ve literally never heard it a single time except when I play it for myself. It was made an official single in 1993, but it was overshadowed as the “rock” song on the album by “Black or White” and overshadowed among MJ singles that year by the Free Willy theme “Will You Be There,” the last big hurrah before being a Michael fan became forever problematic. This is a shame, since “Give in to Me” kills. Michael was not a prolific artist compared to Prince or even Madonna, so he’s not necessarily thought of as having a deep solo catalog, but the guy absolutely rolled deep; the seventh single off his fourth-biggest album stands up with anything off Thriller. “Give in to Me” isn’t just good, though, it’s unique. Michael Jackson had written rock songs before, but “Give in to Me” doesn’t sound like “Beat It,” it doesn’t sound like “Dirty Diana” and it definitely doesn’t sound like “Black or White” despite also having Slash on the record. Slash was fine in “Black or White” but he didn’t really sound like Slash, why bring Slash if he’s not gonna bring the lightning. MJ asked him to save it for this one, apparently.

But the really surprising thing is that Michael Jackson wrote a song where he sounds like a grown man with grown-person feelings about sex. Even before the words, the song begins in a low register, in a late ‘80s/early’ 90s sleaze-rock aesthetic that I associate with softcore porn. Calling it “grown” might be overselling it, but he is at least mature enough in this song to understand the ins and outs of adult relations, the ugly parts especially. MJ’s songs about wanting to love you girl don’t feel especially lustful, even the really good ones, but “Give in to Me” isn’t just about sexual attraction but frustration, which is more complicated. The narrator of the song is in some kind of unsatisfying, unequal relationship where the woman has all the power and uses it cruelly. She makes him cry. He never fights back. Worst of all, he’s left horny and unsatisfied. It is genuinely startling hearing words as harsh – and, arguably, incel-ish – as “Just simply do the things I say” from a guy who was always trying to heal the world. MJ making his “Under My Thumb” is maybe not admirable, but it’s human. Michael sang with extreme sensitivity and vulnerability, even when he was angry; he was uniquely suited for a song about how just once he’d like be to be in charge of the situation and have sex when he wants. He doesn’t just sound whiny and entitled, he sounds genuinely mistreated and hurt, which undercuts whatever accusations of misogyny you might have. I have no idea how this song came about – the writing is co-credited between him and his producer Bill Bottrell, who is also the guy who does the rap on “Black or White” – but it’s the rare MJ song that makes me feel like there might be a normal guy in there. And by normal guy, I don’t even mean “not a pedophile,” just “not the biggest superstar on the planet” and “not a person terrified of the world.”

That’s the thing about Michael Jackson in the ‘90s, both before and after the allegations, he had just fully stopped being relatable in any way. His work became increasingly messianic, and then self-martyring and paranoid, a trend that started before the allegations but definitely accelerated afterwards. I saw the MJ Broadway show out of sheer curiosity – I had to know how they handled a life as controversial as MJ’s, same reason I ended up seeing the movie – and it centers around the opening of the Dangerous tour but they don’t do “Give in to Me.” So much of the rest of his life has a song that perfectly soundtracks it, his downfall years especially, but it’s hard to imagine where “Give in to Me” could possibly fit in the story of his life. (In case it’s not clear, I don’t see any reasonable case for his innocence.) But that’s the tough thing about it; I never had Michael tainted for me since, because of my sheltered childhood, I didn’t know any of his songs until well after ’93. I’ve never known an unproblematic Michael, and I love his songs all the same, that’s just something I have to deal with alone. If he was indeed guilty, there’s no way he would have gotten away with it if not for his legendary charm and talent, and I feel like it’s almost disrespectful to the allegations to pretend otherwise.  

Files

Michael Jackson - Give In To Me (Official Video - Upscaled)

Official Upscaled Video for “Give In To Me” by Michael Jackson Listen to Michael Jackson: https://MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_listenYD Filmed during rehearsals for the Dangerous World Tour, the “Give In To Me” short film features Michael Jackson joined on stage by Slash of Guns N’ Roses, who plays guitar on this hard-driving single. Follow Michael Jackson: Facebook: https://MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_followYS/facebook Twitter: https://MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_followYS/twitter Instagram: https://MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_followYS/instagram Website: https://MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_followYS/websitegeneral Spotify: https://MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_followYS/spotify Chorus: Love is a feeling Give it when I want it 'Cause I'm on fire Quench my desire Give it when I want it Talk to me woman Give in to me Give in to me #MichaelJackson #Dangerous #GiveInToMe #OfficialUpscaledVideo

Comments

David L.

The last paragraph hits on something I've been feeling lately: most of us millennials weren't alive and/or conscious when Thriller came out, so we've only ever experienced a world where Michael was a deeply weird man with troubling allegations against him. Putting aside his talent, I've never known any other version of Jackson than "Wacko Jacko." I think that's why, and I say this without any kind of polling, a lot of our generation are more likely to believe the allegations against him than, say, Gen Z stans doing wars on Twitter who never knew him alive at all.

River Gowan Stone

I'm truly sorry for this non-sequitor, but there's never a good opportunity for me to brag about this*: long after this album dropped and just months after MJ died, Bill Bottrell was a +1 at my wedding. It was a truly chaotic day, and I have very limited memories of the ceremony and reception, so I didn't fully process who I was meeting until much later. I think about the chance meeting from time to time, especially when "Black or White" or Sheryl Crow's first album come up. I have a million questions that I would not have bothered the man with, especially at a wedding, even though I would have desperately wanted to! The marriage might be over (it is lol), but the absurd six degrees of Kevin Bacon** of my friend's +1 -- on one of the strangest days of my life -- remains 🤷🏻 *not claiming this is a "good opportunity" **wherein, I am some rando, and the other person is the Kevin-Bacon-figure connecting me to Michael f'ing Jackson

David Yurch

My problem with Dangerous as an album isn’t even that it’s too long—though I certainly agree that there are cuts that could be made—it’s that the sequencing on it makes absolutely no sense. “Black or White” is an album opener if I’ve ever heard one, and doubly so with the opening skit where the kid putting in the CD; why is it in the middle of the album? And even if you don’t like “Will You Be There” and “Keep the Faith,” those two songs would make perfect sense as the one-two punch that closed the album; instead, the album concludes on the title track, which doesn’t carry nearly the same sense of finality or closure.

Austin F

yeah for me growing up the allegations and weirdness totally overshadowed his music; i didn't know many of his songs until i was well into my teens, but i'd heard 1000 jokes about him being gay or into kids (especially since gay jokes were like 60% of comedians' material back then)

Adequately Sized Dog

As somebody who has researched CSAs (child sexual abusers), I read this song way different. Stop reading now if you don't want it ruined. It's impossible to succinctly summarize the different ways that someone turns out to be a CSA, but I think there's three relevant points here: 1) The stereotypical psychopath who lures children into his van with candy is atypical amongst CSAs. 2) The majority of CSAs think they are in love with their victims because they have trouble relating to adults. 3) Part of the reason that CSAs prefer relations with children is their ability to control them makes them feel secure as opposed to the anxiety from the lack of control when relating to adults. The recurring them of anxiety around women (this, Billie Jean, Dirty Diana), is really hard to ignore. The song as a song kills but knowing what I know about MJ and how absurdly perfectly he lines up with the profile of a typical CSA just gives it the worst after taste if I just allow my brain to turn on for a just a second

ZZZSSS

This is an excellent observation. For me, finding out that MJ was actually black and once considered a sex symbol was probably as uncanny of a revelation as it was in reverse to baby boomers and gen x when he became the pale skinned wacko jacko.

ZZZSSS

Give in to me has always been a deep cut favorite of mine that I had the same reaction to as Todd; where I only heard it due to purposely listening to MJ's full catalog and surprised no one else seemed to really be aware of its existence. On the other point, I feel like the hardest part of talking about MJ's controversies is that everyone acts like there's only one side or the other; pedo or a complete exoneration of any wrong doing. Personally, I don't think he was a pedo, but what he did was still child abuse imo. No adult should be that intimate with a child if they aren't their parent. Sharing a bed and making them call him daddy Michael is fcked. And the parents are just as much to blame for allowing it to happen and trying to profit off of it.

shai

why would he draw the line at sexually abusing a child if he's already, in your own words, doing child abuse, making them share a bed with him and being overly intimate with them? you're saying he just arbitrarily decided that actually physically touching them was a bridge too far, and religiously stuck to that line in the sand over years worth of abuse? come on. In real life abuse usually escalates over time and there's no reasonable argument that his didn't.

ZZZSSS

What? That's not what I'm saying at all. I'm saying I never got the impression his interest was sexual. It's not drawing a line bc that implies he was a pedo but held back. I'm saying it's possible that it could still be child abuse while not being inherently sexual as it's still too intimate and messes with a kid's boundaries.

Tom

This right here is top tier criticism. I actually remember this song. I loved Dangerous even tho I only heard it at my friends house. I literally hadn't heard this since thr 90s when I was like 9 years old and I STILL recognised it! I love that you are brave enough to say yes, he was a paedo and yes, he made some great art. So many of his fans just won't say the obvious truth cos they can't handle loving some music of a guy who did such messed up evil things. We need to be grown up and see the truth of both the abuse and the art.

Tom

So you can watch the Bashir interview and think that is non-sexual? And all the accusers like 5 or 6 of them and different Neverland staff are ALL lying?? Get real man You can still enjoy the music! As Todd says above in regard to the allegations "there is no reasonable case for his innocence". I advise you watch Leaving Neverland.

Jon Heiman

I may or may not be older than you (barely old enough to remember Dangerous coming out), but I do know that MJ stans are a: nothing new (have you *seen* the concert footage of his 80s crowds?) and b: have always been exactly as unhinged as they are now.

Jon Heiman

Yeah, seeing as it was his first album designed for CD--and used *all* of the available space--I would love to see a version of that album trimmed down to vinyl length.

Jon Heiman

As someone "harmlessly asexual" myself, I really, *really* wanted to give MJ the benefit of the doubt... I used to think going to awards shows without a woman and sleeping in beds with children chastely wasn't so bad--and what's so bad about the word "chaste" anyway? But yeah, at some point what is hidden is revealed... And I didn't want to believe it for so long--part of me still doesn't. And like you said, we all need to decide where that line is for us (for me, even before the allegations, there was something deeply unsettling about the main segment of Moonwalker and the "Black of White" video) Also: "Dirty Diana" is either my 1st or 2nd favorite song in his catalog. "Give In to Me" is likely 3rd. :)

Anastasi

I genuinely don’t understand how anyone my age (25) or younger could be a Michael stan. i get liking the music 110 percent, that shit’ s universal, but I don’t get being invested in Michael Jackson the person if you weren’t alive during his golden years. Seeing the reaction to the biopic feels like I’m watching aliens. Like why, why do you care? What possible connection do you have here? These last few months have been bizarre

Joe G

It's weird for me to think back on this album. My parents did not care for any popular music made after 1961 so even though I'm from a musical family, it was all classical and mid-20th century big band music in my house. My exposure to pop music before my teens was mainly the larger mass culture, where Michael Jackson was ubiquitous, and my older cousin who worshipped MJ. Dangerous was one of the first two CDs I ever owned. But even then this song indicated a shift--Guns N' Roses was the new hotness when I started high school in 1990 and less than a year later grunge took over everything. The allegations against Jackson arose shortly after that so it was easy to leave him behind. But "Give In to Me" in particular feels like a bridge between the innocent pop music of my youth enshrined by its avatar Michael Jackson, the guy who rescued children in the Moonwalker video game and film, and the darker rock music of my brooding Gen X adolescence, where Jackson was now a fallen angel who preyed on those he once saved and whose only brief redemption in my eyes came from a nu-metal cover of "Smooth Criminal".

Svitozar

Why are people using that racist nickname for him? I am not going to defend him, absolutely not, he’s most likely actually guilty, but why the racism?

Svitozar

This reminds me of some song from invincible that’s this cute romantic song that gets hard to listen to when you remember man wrote all this after having water balloon fight with children. Why did no one question this?

Svitozar

It’s just a tough pill to swallow for most people. You want to think someone you admire is a good person. So when it turns out it’s not it’s easy to slip into denial.

Svitozar

Okay so I’m about to introduce a volatile argument, but until mid 1990s he was very conventionally attractive. I think this might be important.

Svitozar

Mj honestly artist I probably feel the strangest about. Biopic really made me go into spiral almost. I was a kid when he died and teenager when I heard his music for the first time. They don’t care about us was particularly important to me I remember. Because I heard it for the first time around the time my country had revolution, going against our vile government. It really stuck with me. Having king of pop you heard so much about essentially make anthem for your people in this horrible unjust situation surprised me. It’s actually still my favourite mj song because of it. That’s to say I held him in high regard since I was 12. I didn’t know he had other allegations beyond Leaving Neverland situation that I disregarded because I saw people found problems with the accounts and there was seemingly no physical evidence. I also was still teenager. I now know I was misled about many things as a teenager despite always thinking I was better than that. But with biopic coming out and controversy surrounding it made me actually start looking and reading. I did not like what I found. I’ll leave it at that. Going back to first sentence, it’s not first time I encounter artist I like being bad person. Many artists I was fond of ended up supporting genocide of my people, me. It truly can’t be worse than this. And the approach was typically tear it off and abandon, forgotten to time. But I just can’t do it with mj somehow. His songs found me in wild time in my life. They’re too important to me. So I just do what’s people refer to as death of the author I believe, separating art from the artist? So I still can listen to his songs with meaning I give them and appreciate his impact and art while not glorifying him as person. Yeah. This is very long holy mol y