RAMBLE ON: "Give in to Me" by Michael Jackson (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
An old critic friend of mine from back in the day has been hyping up Michael as not another bland biopic but something closer to The Social Network or There Will Be Blood, a dark thorny movie about a child molester becoming all-powerful. And not even through some “death of the author” interpretation, but intentionally so by the filmmakers, sneaking it under the radar of the Jackson estate. That reading... uh, let's say it feels like a stretch to me (I love this critic’s work but he’s the type to see Jesus in a piece of toast). To be fair to him though, the Michael Jackson we see in the movie is not… not a child molester. As seen in Michael, Michael Jackson is a man obsessed with toys, Peter Pan and childhood; an eccentric who fills his L.A. mansion with exotic animals he probably shouldn’t have and has friendlier conversations with them than any human being in his life; a person with deep rapport with children, who never once demonstrates romantic attraction to anyone. And this is the sanitized version okayed by the estate. Maybe there’s just no way to depict Michael Jackson, even blandly, where his weirdness does not shine through.
The movie leans heavily on Michael’s music to make us ignore the man’s controversies in life, and the greatness of his catalog might make the public forgiving or forgetful, but it sure doesn’t reinforce his innocence. Michael’s romantic songs are chaste to the point of childishness. His more adult songs show him to be terrified of women with sexual agency. (“Dirty Diana” was one of the MJ songs that recharted after the biopic, and boy, that’s a curious one to be driving up the charts.) He did try to put up a performative display of heterosexuality after the allegations, but I don’t think even diehards really bought it; you gotta be a real stan to hear his albums, or see him and his wife draped naked over each other, and be convinced that this guy was attracted to adult women, or adult men for that matter. At best he was harmlessly asexual, at worst, well, you know.
I say this because I saw an MJ stan on Twitter (which feeds me basically nothing but MJ stan wars and Drake stan wars right now, great site, fantastic) try to argue that anyone who doubted that Michael had a healthy normal sexuality should listen to Dangerous; an anti-MJ commenter shot back that yeah, a guy who writes “In the Closet” is totally normal. It is true that Dangerous is the most sexually charged, most Prince-ian of his records (he even mentions a girl with a “paisley top” on “She Drives Me Wild”), but I don’t find any of it particularly convincing. There is an exception, though.
“Give in to Me” shows up pretty deep into an album that everyone agrees is too long, and I’ve literally never heard it a single time except when I play it for myself. It was made an official single in 1993, but it was overshadowed as the “rock” song on the album by “Black or White” and overshadowed among MJ singles that year by the Free Willy theme “Will You Be There,” the last big hurrah before being a Michael fan became forever problematic. This is a shame, since “Give in to Me” kills. Michael was not a prolific artist compared to Prince or even Madonna, so he’s not necessarily thought of as having a deep solo catalog, but the guy absolutely rolled deep; the seventh single off his fourth-biggest album stands up with anything off Thriller. “Give in to Me” isn’t just good, though, it’s unique. Michael Jackson had written rock songs before, but “Give in to Me” doesn’t sound like “Beat It,” it doesn’t sound like “Dirty Diana” and it definitely doesn’t sound like “Black or White” despite also having Slash on the record. Slash was fine in “Black or White” but he didn’t really sound like Slash, why bring Slash if he’s not gonna bring the lightning. MJ asked him to save it for this one, apparently.
But the really surprising thing is that Michael Jackson wrote a song where he sounds like a grown man with grown-person feelings about sex. Even before the words, the song begins in a low register, in a late ‘80s/early’ 90s sleaze-rock aesthetic that I associate with softcore porn. Calling it “grown” might be overselling it, but he is at least mature enough in this song to understand the ins and outs of adult relations, the ugly parts especially. MJ’s songs about wanting to love you girl don’t feel especially lustful, even the really good ones, but “Give in to Me” isn’t just about sexual attraction but frustration, which is more complicated. The narrator of the song is in some kind of unsatisfying, unequal relationship where the woman has all the power and uses it cruelly. She makes him cry. He never fights back. Worst of all, he’s left horny and unsatisfied. It is genuinely startling hearing words as harsh – and, arguably, incel-ish – as “Just simply do the things I say” from a guy who was always trying to heal the world. MJ making his “Under My Thumb” is maybe not admirable, but it’s human. Michael sang with extreme sensitivity and vulnerability, even when he was angry; he was uniquely suited for a song about how just once he’d like be to be in charge of the situation and have sex when he wants. He doesn’t just sound whiny and entitled, he sounds genuinely mistreated and hurt, which undercuts whatever accusations of misogyny you might have. I have no idea how this song came about – the writing is co-credited between him and his producer Bill Bottrell, who is also the guy who does the rap on “Black or White” – but it’s the rare MJ song that makes me feel like there might be a normal guy in there. And by normal guy, I don’t even mean “not a pedophile,” just “not the biggest superstar on the planet” and “not a person terrified of the world.”
That’s the thing about Michael Jackson in the ‘90s, both before and after the allegations, he had just fully stopped being relatable in any way. His work became increasingly messianic, and then self-martyring and paranoid, a trend that started before the allegations but definitely accelerated afterwards. I saw the MJ Broadway show out of sheer curiosity – I had to know how they handled a life as controversial as MJ’s, same reason I ended up seeing the movie – and it centers around the opening of the Dangerous tour but they don’t do “Give in to Me.” So much of the rest of his life has a song that perfectly soundtracks it, his downfall years especially, but it’s hard to imagine where “Give in to Me” could possibly fit in the story of his life. (In case it’s not clear, I don’t see any reasonable case for his innocence.) But that’s the tough thing about it; I never had Michael tainted for me since, because of my sheltered childhood, I didn’t know any of his songs until well after ’93. I’ve never known an unproblematic Michael, and I love his songs all the same, that’s just something I have to deal with alone. If he was indeed guilty, there’s no way he would have gotten away with it if not for his legendary charm and talent, and I feel like it’s almost disrespectful to the allegations to pretend otherwise.