Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

POLL: Pick the next Extended Play Lounge

  • Peter Gabriel - Secret World Live 124
  • Rush - R40 Live 114
  • The Who - Tommy & Quadrophenia Live 33
  • 2025-07-04
  • —2025-07-08
  • 271 votes
{'title': 'POLL: Pick the next Extended Play Lounge', 'choices': [{'text': 'Peter Gabriel - Secret World Live', 'votes': 124}, {'text': 'Rush - R40 Live', 'votes': 114}, {'text': 'The Who - Tommy & Quadrophenia Live', 'votes': 33}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 7, 8, 3, 30, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 7, 4, 21, 24, 53, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 271}

Content

Y'all...it's time to watch a live concert film. I've received many DVDs in the mail, and I've narrowed it down to these three monumental concerts...and I need your help to pick!

Files

Comments

David Kingma

I saw PG’s tour that year and was blown away by a back up singer he had, Paula Cole. WOW. FANTASTIC SHOW!!

Adrian Goodrich

Wow, all three are superb! Gotta go for The Who, though. Wonderful.

Margaret Barnes

Yay!! Peter Gabriel’s Secret World Live is just - sublime, fantastic, wonderful, choose your own superlative!! I suspect it hasn’t the proverbial snowball’s chance next to Rush, though - more’s the pity. 🙁

Laura Fancy

I'm a huge Rush fan, but I voted Peter Gabriel. There's something just so magical about that live performance

KellieE69

No Song Remains the Same huh? 😭

doughelvering

By the way...in the pic, that's a Big Big Train piece of vinyl on the turntable from The Likes of Us.

Ralph Darvill

I've gone with Peter Gabriel...but your should try the Wilco concert DVD "Ashes of American Flags". Captures one of the great current bands at the height of their powers.

Monty Ernst

I went to the R40 concert. Peart and Lifeson were incredible, and Geddy's still a great bass player but he tries too hard to sing high still and ends up sounding screechy.

PETER SALTER

I have gone Gabriel, I saw the tour back in the day and it is still one of the greatest concerts I have ever seen.

Andrew Clark

R40 was my first concert DVD, I would love to see your reaction to it!!!!

Ian Dent

Secret World is well known as one of the greatest feel good concerts ever. I think we all need a bit of 'feel good' at this moment. Also, you get to hear Paula Cole just being the best backing vocalist ever, along with the incredible chemistry, she, and the rest of the band have with Peter. In a good way, this concert always makes me cry.

James

Voted Peter, one of the greatest tours by any band or artist.

Jesstifer

My spouse and I have a saying: "Don't ever miss Pete live." Ironically, this was the one tour we missed. Watch this.

Adie

I voted PG, and sit in confidence that his concert will win. It's not just that it's PG, but that this is the best of all his live DVDs, capturing him at his height of sucess and with a marvellous team of musicians around him. I believe Doug has already seen one track from this concert (In Your Eyes, which is wonderful) but the whole is greater than the parts, and the parts themselves stand out as great performances of the individual songs.

Sid Levy

The Secret World tour is my favorite Peter Gabriel concert of all time. I was so mesmerized and immersed at this show. The DVD does a great job of capturing these moments. I’ve tried to explain portions of the show to people and I just can’t seem to articulate the music, the emotion, and the theatrics with words. It must be experienced.

Claudio Fernandes

Secret World Live is a work of art in visual/musical performance. It's probably my top 10 recorded live DVDs of all time. I know this ever since it was released, and every time I watch it again, it makes me cry.

Dave Clarke

R40 was the best trip i’ve ever been on. Having seen Rush on every tour of the UK since 78. Me and a couple of pals decided we needed to do this. A 12 day six concert road trip from Toronto to Madison Square Gardens was a gift to the 15 year-old me that had loved and obsessed about this band for nearly 40 years. Everything about that tour was immense. The fact they started from the most recent and worked backwards, with the set being deconstructed to max the era was pure Rush genius. An amazing tour, an amazing career and a sensational catalogue of work. Please, do R40