Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

One of the most overlooked elements of Western military doctrine is the Commander's Reserve.

In order to understand its true purpose, we need to step back in time. Think about ancient or medieval warfare: during desperate or decisive moments, kings or generals would personally lead a massive, withheld cavalry charge to shatter the enemy's lines and turn the tide of battle. The Commander's Reserve is essentially the modern equivalent of that cavalry unit. It is a dedicated force held back from the initial clash, waiting for the exact, decisive point of battle to strike.

While modern Western forces are not known for making abundant use of massive strategic reserves—generally preferring swift, decisive battles utilizing overwhelming initial force—the Commander's Reserve remains a critical tool held back at the tactical and grand-tactical levels. Interestingly, it adds a unique twist to several core Western Principles of War:

Force Concentration: While Western forces prefer to focus their combat power and rarely hold back manpower unnecessarily, the Commander's Reserve does not participate in the initial fight. It is preserved specifically to inject an overwhelming element of surprise and concentrated violence later in the engagement.

Mission Command: Western militaries largely rely on decentralized, independent decision-making (Mission Command). However, the Commander's Reserve is heavily centralized. It is directly controlled—or even physically led—by the unit commander to ensure it executes his exact, immediate intent.

A Commander's Reserve is not a doctrinal "must-have." Commanders from the platoon up to the division level can freely decide if holding a reserve is necessary. If one is established, it can be deployed with devastating effect in both offensive and defensive operations.

Employment Examples

The Offense: The enemy decides to shift forces to reinforce a crumbling position, inadvertently leaving one of their flanks or sectors below its initial strength. The Commander's Reserve is immediately activated to aggressively penetrate this weakened area and roll up the enemy's flank.

The Defense: The enemy has pushed deep into your main battle area but is suffering severe losses and exhausting their momentum. The exact moment the enemy's assault stalls, the Commander's Reserve is unleashed to conduct a violent counter-attack and push them back out.

For the commander, the most critical skill is identifying the decisive point. Simply plugging a hole to reinforce a failing position is not the primary intent of a reserve. The true intent is to achieve decisive victory through speed, surprise, and violence of action.

The Element of "Surface"

Generally, the larger the force you command, the more likely you are to assemble a reserve. However, the decision ultimately relies on what military science refers to as "surface area" (frontage).

If the enemy exposes a massive, wide surface area, you will most likely benefit from putting all your guns in the fight immediately, as holding forces back would waste potential firepower. If, however, the enemy presents a very narrow surface (like a chokepoint or a dense urban street), you physically cannot employ all your forces at once because the surface area is too small. In this bottlenecked scenario, establishing a strong Commander's Reserve makes the most sense.

The Platoon-Level Dilemma

While the Commander's Reserve is best known for being employed at the Battalion or Division level, it is highly applicable at the Platoon level.

Let's assume our platoon has four rifle squads. Whether in the offense or the defense, every single rifle squad is incredibly valuable for support, assault, or security. However, if you have ever decided to personally spearhead an assault as a Platoon Leader, you have likely noticed the overwhelming benefit of direct control. Your assault plan does not just get fulfilled along your intent; it gets executed precisely to your intent. If there is a sudden situational change, you directly witness it and can instantly redirect your reserve squad to adapt to the battlefield.

The Modern Threat: ISR

Last but not least, it is absolutely crucial that you can actually hide your reserve. In the modern era of persistent ISR (Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance) drones and precision artillery, this task is incredibly difficult.

If the enemy spots your reserve, they will destroy it with indirect fire before it ever influences the battle. Therefore, it is vital to keep your reserve geographically dispersed under heavy cover, but with a highly rehearsed plan to rapidly concentrate them at the exact moment they are needed.

Conclusion

Should you always use a Commander's Reserve? We can't answer that definitively. As the old saying goes: "You don't ask a chess master how to win a game; you ask him for good turns." The Commander's Reserve is just one highly effective turn you can keep in your back pocket.

As always, thanks for your attention.

Files

Comments

No comments found for this post.