Opinion: Why The Tactical Community Needs A Reset (Patreon)
Content
We have continuously joked about the nonsense of "kit shakedown" videos and the absolutely confused three-hour monologues they inevitably produce. While the tactical community is currently at a promising turning point—where human performance, doctrine, and tactics are taking precedence over gear—I still believe this space needs a fundamental reset.
The Line Between Professional and Enthusiast
The first step, which is thankfully already underway, is separating the enthusiasts from the professional users. I don’t associate professionalism with how you earn your paycheck; I associate it with intent and focus. Preparedness, readiness, and performance-driven training are what define a professional. A professional will only look for tools that enhance those specific attributes. For the tactical enthusiast, however, a "professional need" is often just a convenient excuse to buy more kit.
Fortunately, we are seeing companies pivot more toward competitive shooting, tactical games, and the fitness space. This is the best thing to happen to the industry in recent years. Seeing influencers like Lucas Botkin shoot matches instead of LARPing accomplishes three vital things:
Increases the focus on high performers as a core customer base.
Inspires as many new people as possible to become high performers themselves.
Alienates the crowd whose sole interest is purchasing more gear.
Sticking with the Botkin example, I've heard people claim that he "abandoned the prepared citizen" or turned his platform into a "sports page." This couldn't be further from the truth. By engaging in activities you can actually replicate regularly as a prepared citizen, you are building the best version of yourself. The same applies to MIL/LE members looking to train off the clock. You can, of course, assemble a "Minuteman IAR" and a recce rig to remain a weird loner in your basement, but the broader community is changing for the better.
The Content Mill and Made-Up Kit
Regarding gear, the horse has been thoroughly beaten to death. When this page started, we created numerous packing plans and kit setups, specifically focused on light infantry and recon work—topics that simply weren't discussed much five years ago. Eventually, we stopped for a simple reason: it had been done to death.
There is no reason to provide more kit setups unless our goal is pure clickbait. Publishing more in-depth gear discussions would be dishonest because true innovation in this sector is slow. We would either be copy-pasting old content or, worse, making things up. Why are there so many jokes about the "Minuteman Aquatic IAR Gunner Rig"? Because that’s exactly what is happening right now: kit-centric pages are forced to invent absurd concepts just to maintain their engagement.
The Pseudo-Science of Specs
This desperation for content also plagues discussions around NVGs, optronics, calibers, and gun parts. If you watch closely, these conversations have devolved into pseudo-scientific debates about MOA, grain weights, and FOM, completely devoid of real-world application.
A great example was our take on SIG's Fury cartridge solving an issue that doesn’t exist. The backlash we received was entirely math-based, defending the cartridge for its "good values." The metrics might be perfect, but they don't give the rifle a practical purpose. You don't need to know the exact formula for FOM to effectively run night vision, and you don't need to memorize the load data of your cartridge to shoot accurately. What matters is the anecdotal experience of actually putting rounds downrange.
Hyper-fixating on specs and numbers is a glaring symptom of people not actually running their kit. Hearing, "The device has a crisp image, and I could flawlessly shoot fast both inside and outside a building," tells me significantly more than any technical specification you can project.
Daily Fundamentals over High-Fantasy Classes
Finally, the community must recognize the difference between pretending to train (taking one to three fantasy tactics classes a year) and actually training consistently. "Go out and train" is the standard battle cry of most content creators. Yet, most of their followers don't do that, because rural recce and urban entry are not skills you can practice on a regular Tuesday. If anything, they drop thousands on an expensive weekend class with a shady training company, only to forget the material a few weeks later.
For us, the goal has always been providing realistic opportunities to train while encouraging people to master daily fundamentals: shooting, martial arts, running, and strength training. Luckily, we see a massive portion of the community moving in this direction as well.
The tactical community must emphasize what is possible to train daily, instead of complaining about what it can't.
What the community needs is a definitive shift away from high-fantasy scenarios and gear-nerdism toward practical application. Yes, a lot of people will get left behind because they can no longer hide behind "what if" excuses, but shedding that dead weight is entirely worth it.
As always, thanks for your attention.